Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who move from job to job but are never happy. What causes it?

88 replies

peashootsalad · 11/03/2024 13:12

I have had a friend for 2 years. During the time I’ve known her she has persistently changed jobs and I think has had at least 5 (I’ve lost count). The jobs have been in different fields but the issues she’s had are similar. She starts off happy for a few weeks, then starts to complain about how things are run, how incompetent everyone is, she’s the only one who’s any good etc. She gets quite obsessive about it and rants on about how awful it is to anyone who’ll listen. Anyone else know anyone like this? It intrigues me.

OP posts:
UpsideLeft · 11/03/2024 19:50

Shitty nasty managers

misssunshine4040 · 11/03/2024 19:48

@Freckles81 we had the same childhood and I too job hop and struggle to stay in one home and one job.

I am learning slowly that it pays off to just stick and tough it out. I don't have roots or a "home town " but I feel I'm getting there and I'm currently in a role I've been in for a long time now and I like it.

I am always on indeed looking for more though.....

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 11/03/2024 19:48

@OnTheFerry could you look at what your transferable skillset it?

Are there any parts of the job you like at all and could thry be used in other industries etc?

OnTheFerry · 11/03/2024 19:45

@cakewitch bless you, that sounds awful.

I got made redundant from my dream job right out of uni (before retraining) and I think that has impacted my confidence hugely, I'm always expecting the worse so perhaps it's self-sabotage leaving before I can be made redundant

OnTheFerry · 11/03/2024 19:43

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 11/03/2024 18:47

I think there's a few different types of people who job hop regularly.

1 - those who genuinely just like change, low boredom threshold

2- those who chase every salary increase - some with good reason, others who just always think they are worth more. I've seen people more for a worse overall package just for a minimum increase is salary & most likely will be eroded by the increased travel cost

3 - those who really cannot stand taking instructions cannot get on with anyone

4 - the over promoted - we had a senior manager once who was shit- goes on PIP and moves, it keeps happening- he has a great cv but it's not good enough at the job and everyone keeps managing him out when they find out

Edited

For me it's none of those - it's because of a mix of imposter syndrome, feeling like I've chosen completely the wrong career, and reaching burn out very quickly which then leads to looking for new jobs and leaving. My job is very niche, took a long time to train for but has ended up in reality being completely different to my training, which ends up making me feel completely inept. I have worked with such wonderful teams (and usually stay in touch with at least one person from each job), the pay is really good, on paper it is very interesting, however I find it intensely challenging and out of my comfort zone all.the.time. The nerves and anxiety I felt when newly qualified have never ever gone away (and I've been qualified 10+ years). However I'm so stuck now I don't know what else I can do!!

Sorry to go on, I obviously need to talk about it 😂. Don't mean to hijack. I guess I'm just saying it's not always about chasing promotions or not being able to get on with others or follow instructions. I can do all of that, it's my own internal struggles which lead to me leaving.

cakewitch · 11/03/2024 19:27

Immemorialelms · 11/03/2024 15:32

Sometimes it can be a cycle - I know someone who moved jobs loads, in the first couple she really did have some toxic managers. In the next few, they weren't, but she was so twitchy and traumatised she saw problems where there aren't any and became a bit victimy. Then, in the same way that nasty abusers prey on vulnerable people, toxic workplaces can hire vulnerable employees, because they don't notice the red flags at interview.

So it is possible that someone has genuine problems in every job. But also that they may well be very moany by that point...

'Twitchy and traumatised' .. well that just sums me up completely. Was in a job that I absolutely loved and i was very good at.It was perfect. But management were absolutely awful. Bullies, Threatened by me. The people above them couldn't act because they'd been with the company too long it very nearly broke me. I had to leave a job I loved. And now I trust nobody. I can't stay in a job for any length of time. As soon as it starts to be less than perfect, I'm off looking for the next thing. I hate it. But I cant be any different now. Hard work doesn't pay off, that's a complete fallacy.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 11/03/2024 18:47

I think there's a few different types of people who job hop regularly.

1 - those who genuinely just like change, low boredom threshold

2- those who chase every salary increase - some with good reason, others who just always think they are worth more. I've seen people more for a worse overall package just for a minimum increase is salary & most likely will be eroded by the increased travel cost

3 - those who really cannot stand taking instructions cannot get on with anyone

4 - the over promoted - we had a senior manager once who was shit- goes on PIP and moves, it keeps happening- he has a great cv but it's not good enough at the job and everyone keeps managing him out when they find out

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 11/03/2024 18:30

Am I your friend? Perhaps she just finds it harder to accept mediocrity (or worse) than others..

SecondHandFurniture · 11/03/2024 17:22

But I think the issue comes when some people look at what they want from "the right fit". If it's (like my ex colleague who recently left) to feel never stressed but also sufficiently challenged, to have entirely supportive and friendly colleagues, exactly the right amount of hours, great pay, benefits and opportunity for progression, either a short commute or no commute if you want WFH, plenty of holiday, and bonuses - it's really hard to find in one place.

I work for a small family company with the perfect part time hours, 15 minutes away, but the tradeoff is that the pay is average and there are no bonuses.

OnTheFerry · 11/03/2024 17:15

Just wanted to add here that it's not always because the person thinks they're better than everyone else, ego thing etc.

If you saw my resume you'd think the same - the longest I've ever been in a job is 21 months and most I've averaged about 1 year-18 months, but it really really gets me down. To the point where I'm currently really struggling with my MH because yet again I've started a new job and yet again it doesn't feel like a good fit because of my own doubts about myself and my confidence, so I'm off sick waiting for a GP appointment to try and get to the bottom of why I find it so difficult to stay.

I've had CBT, talking therapy, art therapy, all to no avail. It is completely paralysing feeling like your job isn't right (or you're not right for the job) and going round and round in circles trying to find the right fit.

Sorry to be such a Debbie Downer but it's not always as clear cut just from looking at CVs.

LutonBeds · 11/03/2024 16:43

Some people just don’t like working. It’s just an unfortunate fact that we have to, to be able to live.

There was a thread on here a few weeks ago asking what job people would do if money didn’t matter. IIRC, me and lots of others would like to work in a bookshop. Or be a dog walker, however there’s so many dog walkers my way, it would be very, very difficult to make a living at it. Not many bookshops, apart from the wonderful one in a nearby town, that never seems to have vacancies 😢.

I always wanted to do beauty therapy, but that wouldn’t have done for my parents; I was ‘clever’ (not really, just went to a shit school and looked brilliant next to most, had 6 A-C GCSEs) and so would go to sixth form and do A-levels. They weren’t for me, can’t do the work, tried since when older and still can’t do it. I do now have an OU diploma though.

Left sixth form and went to a more vocational college. Again, wanted beauty but was told by their course adviser that I’d be better doing hair & beauty which I didn’t want to as I’m crap at doing hair. I was persuaded into media studies and left after a year. Couldn’t afford uni, parents wouldn’t have been able to pay anything, although on paper they could.

DH offered to buy me a shop if I wanted to still do beauty a few years ago when we were both made redundant. However, it would’ve taken me at least 2 years to qualify and there are so many beauticians/nail shops near me, I’ve missed the boat sadly.

I’d love to work for myself but I don’t have a skill to sell. The other ideal would be working PT, but those roles seem very hard to come by too if you’re applying ‘off the street’ as it were.

varyblue · 11/03/2024 16:31

I had a friend like this. Each job also involved her raising a grievance, getting union involved. As a pp said, she never recognised the common denominator .

Freckles81 · 11/03/2024 16:27

Same with a friend of mind who is an excellent and committed teacher: she prefers to do supply teaching due to the appalling way she has been treated in more long term roles by management and the kids...

@Startingagainandagain
This I feel deep in my marrow. I will only do supply in UK schools. It is like a war zone in some schools

Freckles81 · 11/03/2024 16:23

I unfortunately see myself in this post.

I grew up in a very unstable home, Dad was in the army, so we moved every 6 months to 2 years...he was also violent and I remember us leaving in the night to get away, then again with another of my mum's unsuitable boyfriends later on.

I went to 12 different schools. I am sure I am repeating childhood patterns, and often wonder why I can't just do what everyone else around me does. It eats away at me, but most jobs feel soul destroying, and I dream of quitting....then I do, eventually; every time.

Despite this, at one point in my life, I was doing very well in my career (promoted, worked abroad, lots of money as an international teacher for two stints of three years). I am very academic and managed to get a First Class BA, MA and PGCE all off my own back, with no help. I seemed to have gotten over my issues and was doing well.

After I had emergency surgery in late 2015, (ectopic pregnancy) and as a result was left infertile, I have not been able to last in any one job, and am deeply ashamed at this fact.

I just walked out of a long term supply post last week, after having books thrown at me, and students wreck the room I was in, as well as shout/swear/leave the room/call me names/refuse to follow instructions. I was waking up shaking in the night and had panic attacks. I got signed off sick and then quit the post. I hate myself again for this :(

Since 2015/16 I can't seem to cope in any job, nor do I make effort with friends etc. I drive myself mad.

However, I can cope with free lance work, where I dictate how much work I do, or which jobs to take or turn down. I am back in the UK now, btw. Skint, obviously.

I plan to go abroad and teach internationally again but I worry I won't be able to due to lack of a long term teaching position and references (most schools abroad want a solid two year stint in a school with references as most recent post).

I am considering CBT or hypnosis as I am mid 40s now and sick to death of quitting everything.

I think I lack the necessary resiliance maybe? The ability to put up with the repetitive nature of jobs and the mundanity of the routine of work??

TinkerTiger · 11/03/2024 15:48

I know someone like this too. Job is always good for the first month, then the complaints start. To me, they're part of working with people, we're all different and there will always be personalities that we don't gel with.

Im able to put it aside and do my job, but I guess not every one is able to.

I think it must be exhausting though, this particular person can go ages without finding another job, and they talk about how stressed they are about money. But the cycle goes on.

Immemorialelms · 11/03/2024 15:32

Sometimes it can be a cycle - I know someone who moved jobs loads, in the first couple she really did have some toxic managers. In the next few, they weren't, but she was so twitchy and traumatised she saw problems where there aren't any and became a bit victimy. Then, in the same way that nasty abusers prey on vulnerable people, toxic workplaces can hire vulnerable employees, because they don't notice the red flags at interview.

So it is possible that someone has genuine problems in every job. But also that they may well be very moany by that point...

Startingagainandagain · 11/03/2024 15:32

It really depends on the sector.

I work for charities and the staff turnover is incredibly high because of poor pay and shit management.

The organisation I am with as the worst staff turnover I have ever seen. It employs about 50 staff in total and we seem to be losing 5 people a month. New starters don't stay long and now long term employees are leaving too.

Very common in the sector for people to move every 2 year due to poor conditions and lack of opportunity to progress/be paid better.

This has been the case in every charity I have worked for in the past 20 years. I have also seen countless examples of bullying and bad management/governance.

I am job-hunting again because I was lied to at interview when it comes to flexible working, pay is not keeping with the cost of living and I am expected to cover several roles but have just been refused an upgrade in my job title to reflect this.

Same with a friend of mind who is an excellent and committed teacher: she prefers to do supply teaching due to the appalling way she has been treated in more long term roles by management and the kids...

So yes your friend might be flaky but equally these days there is little loyalty from staff towards employers and vice versa.

Sometime you have to change jobs to get a better deal and life is to short to putting up with employers who don't do anything for their staff.

Nannyfannybanny · 11/03/2024 15:29

I know a couple of people like this. They also keep moving house, never satisfied never happy. You can't move or change jobs and leave your problems, personality behind, but they can't see that. If you can't have what you like,you need to like what you have

TheFretfulPorpentine · 11/03/2024 15:27

Some people take a while to find the right job. And some people don't really want to work at all.

Laiste · 11/03/2024 15:25

Well - your mate sounds a bit of a tit (with the face book update), but, in principal, and if you can afford to, i think there's nothing wrong with persevering to look for the right job if you're able. Why stay where you're unhappy if you can go?

One of my mid 20 somethings went through about 8 jobs in 3 years, slightly different fields, but each time she left them wanting her not to go, and trying hard to keep her. Each time she went to a new employer with honesty about why she'd left the last place and still flew through the interview processes.

She hates stupid, inefficient, illogical and unproductive (management) set-ups and just can't tolerate working under idiots. Unfortunately it would take a couple of months for it to show up - and she'd be off. She finally has settled down and been in a job for 3 years now where she's happy and climbing up the management pole herself. But she did change departments VERY near the beginning of working for even this company because her direct manager was a prat 😂

Rosesanddaisies1 · 11/03/2024 15:25

Unrealistic expectations, and a lack of perspective. I just go in, do my job well, leave and forget about it. And as long as I am generally OK with work, that's all I expect.

SecondHandFurniture · 11/03/2024 15:16

I know one (met him in retail - I was PT while at uni, he was full time) who has crippling social anxiety which makes him rude, yet persists in applying for customer service supervisor or assistant manager jobs because he won't take an entry-level salary to retrain. He always hates the next person up (store manager) because he thinks he's better.

I'm the opposite - I was at my last place 12 years, although worked in 2 totally different areas.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 11/03/2024 15:10

My XH was like this. He'd change jobs every couple of years - it only took about six months for 'everyone else to become an arsehole.' He HATED being told what to do - which is a bit of a disadvantage in any job really, unless you are the CEO (which he wasn't).

But then, I am ADHD and hate changing jobs. But then I've always had jobs where there's been an element of random every day, which is probably why I stay.

EmpressSoleil · 11/03/2024 15:06

But novelty is needed to hold attention so lots of ADHDers change jobs frequently

This is me and I didn't know why until I was diagnosed. I could manage a year or so, two at the absolute most, before becoming bored with a role. Luckily, I joined an organisation that has a lot of varied roles within it and have done nearly all of them! I've been in my current role longer, just because it's wfh and it suits me.

But I come across people who have worked in the same role/office for 20 or 30 years and I just can't imagine. That would be my idea of hell.

Guttedme · 11/03/2024 14:46

Over positive. Always wishing it was better.

The only job held down in my 30's for nearly 5 years throughout a credit crunch - fear kept me there. It was actually the sort of place I use to dread going back into after holidays etc, had depression episodes. Crazy.

When faced with bad news, us job-hoppers cope. I've even been told off for my 'bad CV' by the Jobcentre before now (couldn't make it up) but I've never known them complain as I don't stay out of work long.

Then I think about some of the s*itshows I've escaped that normally end in beautiful redundancy only, after I've left!

My colleague couldn't cope doing 2 days on their own last week, kept going on about it, I didn't retaliate and neither did I do the same when on my own for 3+ weeks. Then I see emails trying to stich me up and think I'm best of out of it. I'm rather proud I got a job back in January to start next month calm and controlled, that's some achievement for me. A whole years contract, gulp.

Swipe left for the next trending thread