Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What will happen if I don’t attend?

207 replies

Happy988 · 11/03/2024 13:12

I was in a car accident almost 2 years ago. My insurance put it down as no fault and then I was paid out the value of my car. As my car was written off my insurance put me in touch with legal company who offered a private hire vehicle till I was paid out

Third party are disputing the hire car costs. For months now I have been sending the solicitors evidence, forms, etc.

They want me to attend court and give evidence. I have anxiety and don’t do well with crowds, new people and speaking to a group. I’m a single parent and have no childcare to get there . Really panicking about this. The solicitors asked the court if the hearing could be made online but they have only just made the decision this morning that I need to attend in person. They said my medical evidence of anxiety isn’t enough to warrant it being made online.

The court they want me to attend is a 60 mile round trip from where I live. I have a no vehicle currently as it’s in for repair, I have no funds for taxis for a journey that long, no childcare available. I just don’t know what to do. what happens if I don’t attend? Will I be liable for the costs? I feel as though im going to have some kind of panic attack about this

OP posts:
Happy988 · 11/03/2024 18:08

Still trying to find someone for childcare as apparently the court have flat out refused for me to bring my DC

OP posts:
Happy988 · 11/03/2024 18:04

LemonRoll · 11/03/2024 17:57

I don't think it's going to be about the actual accident is it? It's going to be about the hire car. When you got it, how long you had it, why it cost twelve thousand pounds.

This is what’s confused me too but my case handler says I need to give evidence about what happened at the accident, as well as why I needed the hire car. Even though my insurance agreed I wasn’t at fault and my no claims bonus wasn’t effected at all

OP posts:
Happy988 · 11/03/2024 18:02

TwoBlueFish · 11/03/2024 17:55

I’ve just had the exact same thing, I went to court about a week ago.

i had no idea that I was supposed to find the cheapest car hire possible and just went where my insurance company told me to go. In my case the other driver was at fault and admitted that straight away.

I tried to get out of going to court but was told that as it was me who the car agreement was with then I would be liable for the costs if I didn’t go and defend the case.

i was very nervous but it wasn’t too bad in the end. Basically I had to prove that I needed a car and quickly. It came down to timings in the end, the other party’s insurance had texted me and called offering me a cheaper car via them, apparently they are not allowed to cold call and the text could have been mistaken as a scam. The letter they sent arrived after I had collected the hire car and as I needed a car quickly (disabilities) it was found in my favour.

Thank you.

Same here, I wasn’t told to find the cheapest one. Just that one would be provided as a like for a like. They didn’t even let me know what car it would be before I picked it up. I just received a text saying car is ready for pick up, arrived at Enterprise to pick it up and they said it was the only one they had available for me

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 11/03/2024 18:02

I think you need to accept that you have to attend and stop focusing on why that is difficult for you. Sorry that comes across unsympathetic and I’m not unsympathetic but I am a realist and you do need to attend in person.

LemonRoll · 11/03/2024 17:57

Happy988 · 11/03/2024 17:54

I’m the only person who will be in the room that was actually there at the accident

I don't think it's going to be about the actual accident is it? It's going to be about the hire car. When you got it, how long you had it, why it cost twelve thousand pounds.

TwoBlueFish · 11/03/2024 17:55

I’ve just had the exact same thing, I went to court about a week ago.

i had no idea that I was supposed to find the cheapest car hire possible and just went where my insurance company told me to go. In my case the other driver was at fault and admitted that straight away.

I tried to get out of going to court but was told that as it was me who the car agreement was with then I would be liable for the costs if I didn’t go and defend the case.

i was very nervous but it wasn’t too bad in the end. Basically I had to prove that I needed a car and quickly. It came down to timings in the end, the other party’s insurance had texted me and called offering me a cheaper car via them, apparently they are not allowed to cold call and the text could have been mistaken as a scam. The letter they sent arrived after I had collected the hire car and as I needed a car quickly (disabilities) it was found in my favour.

Happy988 · 11/03/2024 17:54

I’m the only person who will be in the room that was actually there at the accident

OP posts:
Happy988 · 11/03/2024 17:52

Ophy83 · 11/03/2024 17:47

A small claims trial is the least formal sort of trial. Sometimes it will be in a court room, sometimes in the judge's office. It will just be the judge, your lawyer, the other side's lawyer, you and maybe the other driver depending on whether they dispute who was at fault for the accident, or are just disputing the amount claimed. So max 5 people in the room. No one will be horrible to you. If the issue is hire they usually just have some questions about why you needed to hire/if you could have afforded to repair or replace the vehicle earlier etc.

I would go. If you don't turn up the claim will be dismissed so the other side won't have to pay anything. Your hire contract will say you are personally liable for the hire charges plus you will have legal costs and may struggle to get insurance again.

If there's no liability dispute it should be possible to settle. Ask your solicitor if any offers have been made

Thank you for the information.

I think I’m making it bigger in my head than it will be. I’ll just have to get there however it may be

The driver of the other vehicle apparently is not available for the hearing. It was a company vehicle he was driving. He no longer works for the company so they’ve said he won’t be attending. His ex boss (the company owner) will be attending. He wasn’t actually at the scene of the accident so is going off his ex employees word

OP posts:
Ophy83 · 11/03/2024 17:47

A small claims trial is the least formal sort of trial. Sometimes it will be in a court room, sometimes in the judge's office. It will just be the judge, your lawyer, the other side's lawyer, you and maybe the other driver depending on whether they dispute who was at fault for the accident, or are just disputing the amount claimed. So max 5 people in the room. No one will be horrible to you. If the issue is hire they usually just have some questions about why you needed to hire/if you could have afforded to repair or replace the vehicle earlier etc.

I would go. If you don't turn up the claim will be dismissed so the other side won't have to pay anything. Your hire contract will say you are personally liable for the hire charges plus you will have legal costs and may struggle to get insurance again.

If there's no liability dispute it should be possible to settle. Ask your solicitor if any offers have been made

SmudgeButt · 11/03/2024 17:23

Likely you'll go to a lot of trouble only to have no one else there as they've assumed you wouldn't show. Whatever happens I'd be sending them an invoice for my travel expense, refreshments and extra for the inconvnience.

Allthegoodusernamesweretaken · 11/03/2024 16:55

OP small babies & toddlers aren’t a problem in a short hearing. Pop her in a buggy and keep her with you. It happens more often than you think. It’s not your fault you couldn’t arrange childcare and don’t have anyone to go with you to wait outside with her.
Hope it goes well for you

Allthegoodusernamesweretaken · 11/03/2024 16:45

Dontforgetthesalamander · 11/03/2024 16:31

Just noticed it's tomorrow - get on the phone to them and tell them to settle it.

Not happening at 16.30, not least because the court office shuts at 16.00. Too late to get an application/consent order in before tomorrow’s hearing. In any case, Solicitors will need instructions from respective clients; defendant (or any) insurers won’t pay a penny more in hire charges than they have to. Hire company will dig its heels in to make maximum profit and OP is stuck between them. All she can do is tell the truth.

Allthegoodusernamesweretaken · 11/03/2024 16:44

Happy988 · 11/03/2024 16:23

Thank you. There was talk of the being striked out. Think that was the term used.

They have told me that there will be nobody at the court who can look after my daughter during the hearing so have said I am unable to bring her. All family are at work and can’t get the time off

i will have to go and somehow find a way

It’s entirely possible that one side will ask for the claim to be struck out, as a preliminary application to the court before the main hearing on the issues. But in this scenario it’s more likely that it’ll come from the Defendant, seeking to strike all or part of your hire costs on the grounds that they’ve been unreasonably incurred. After all, you (the hire company in your name) are claiming against the Defendant but it doesn’t look like they’re claiming against you.
*Try not to panic

  • Organise yourself to get to court tomorrow, ideally at least 30 minutes before your hearing is due to start *Put the court’s phone number in your phone now *Go to court tomorrow with your DC and if you’re running late for any reason, call and ask to speak to the Listing Officer to explain and give them an eta. *Be guided by what your barrister says. *Ask the barrister to explain exactly 1) what’s going on and 2) whether you have any personal responsibility for the costs or hire charges (very doubtful)
Dontforgetthesalamander · 11/03/2024 16:31

Just noticed it's tomorrow - get on the phone to them and tell them to settle it.

Allthegoodusernamesweretaken · 11/03/2024 16:30

Zyq · 11/03/2024 16:20

Today is the day before the hearing.

@Zyq all well and good but a lot of unnecessary scare-
mongering about having to pay the insurers back. The insurers don’t look to have any contractual interest in the car hire claim. The case is done as far as they’re concerned. And the witness summons boat has long sailed. It’s far too late when the hearing’s tomorrow. No one wants to summons their own client; it screams communication breakdown unless there’s a really good reason, eg witness’s employer wants it so that pay can given for time off.

Dontforgetthesalamander · 11/03/2024 16:26

If you don't go, the case will be awarded in favour of the defendant and you might be held liable for the cost of the hire. You signed the agreement, they'll expect you to attend court as part of you cooperating in order to not be pursued for costs. I've worked in motor insurance for 20 years and credit hire is the biggest legal scam going and a huge part of the reason why everyone's insurance is rocketing. Hire can very quickly outstrip the value of a written off car by thousands.

I would go back to the hire co and show them the evidence that you tried to hand the car back and that it wasn't a like for like - you tried to mitigate your losses, and they wouldn't let you. If you told the judge that, it wouldn't go well for the credit hire company! Tell the hire co you want settlement reached before the hearing. They can absolutely negotiate with the other side before it gets to the court hearing. If they don't settle, and you tell the judge the hire co has inflated the costs, they could lose the case entirely. So it's in their interests to settle as well.

Happy988 · 11/03/2024 16:23

Abeona · 11/03/2024 16:19

A few years ago now, but a woman drove into me and then insisted it was my fault and claimed for whiplash and miscarriage. I had plenty of evidence that she had been in the wrong lane at traffic lights and had turned left into me while she was in a straight-ahead lane. Despite the CCTV footage and the witness testimony I was called to attend a court 250 miles from where I lived (in the area where she lived) for a 10am start on 23 December. There was snow and ice on the ground and I ended up travelling up there overnight, staying in a Premier Inn and turning up the next day — only to find that her legal team had accepted the evidence and cancelled the day before.

OP, you can't just bury your head in the sand and hope this will go away. Turn up with your child to court and say whatever you need to say to sort this out. Getting all defensive about having to travel 30 miles to sorth this out just looks petulant. Surely you have family, friends, work colleagues or even a neighbour who will help you out?

Thank you. There was talk of the being striked out. Think that was the term used.

They have told me that there will be nobody at the court who can look after my daughter during the hearing so have said I am unable to bring her. All family are at work and can’t get the time off

i will have to go and somehow find a way

OP posts:
Allthegoodusernamesweretaken · 11/03/2024 16:20

Far too late to issue a witness summons.
Also, lots of confusion on this thread about the small claims regime and costs generally.
As OP’s insurers weren’t a party to the hire care contract, they don’t have any interest in this aspect of the claim. It sounds like the hire company is fronting it and possibly have a no win no fee arrangement in place (ref: the ‘fund’ that will pay out if Defendant doesn’t). Definitely check your paperwork and ask questions tomorrow OP.

Zyq · 11/03/2024 16:20

honeylulu · 11/03/2024 15:22

Have you a actually received a Witness Summons from the Court? If so you must attend or you potentially face imprisonment for being in contempt of court. The good thing about a summons though is that it has to offer to reimburse your reasonable costs of attending (travel etc).

If no summons you can refuse BUT there are possible repercussions from your insurers. In the small print of your policy will be a "cooperation clause" which says you will have to give all reasonable assistance to the insurer in an action to recover their outlay. If you refuse the insurer can void the claim and demand you repay ALL the outlay they incurred (repair costs, hire car etc). This is very rarely enforced but could mean you'll never be able to get car insurance again as you'll be seen as a bad risk. (I'm an insurance solicitor. )

So you really must attend but tell the insurers lawyer that you need to be summonsed and have your expenses paid. If you can't get childcare take your daughter. The court and your lawyer won't be delighted but you will have complied with your duties as a witness.

It is highly likely the defendant will fold and settle the claim before the day. This happens all the time, annoyingly right up until the day before. The fact that they have no witness and you (the claimant) is attending as witness is strongly in your favour. Only 3% of litigated cases actually reach final hearing though many get very close with each side waiting for the other to "blink first" i.e. the defendant to pay the claim or the claimant to drop the claim or accept a low offer.

Today is the day before the hearing.

Abeona · 11/03/2024 16:19

A few years ago now, but a woman drove into me and then insisted it was my fault and claimed for whiplash and miscarriage. I had plenty of evidence that she had been in the wrong lane at traffic lights and had turned left into me while she was in a straight-ahead lane. Despite the CCTV footage and the witness testimony I was called to attend a court 250 miles from where I lived (in the area where she lived) for a 10am start on 23 December. There was snow and ice on the ground and I ended up travelling up there overnight, staying in a Premier Inn and turning up the next day — only to find that her legal team had accepted the evidence and cancelled the day before.

OP, you can't just bury your head in the sand and hope this will go away. Turn up with your child to court and say whatever you need to say to sort this out. Getting all defensive about having to travel 30 miles to sorth this out just looks petulant. Surely you have family, friends, work colleagues or even a neighbour who will help you out?

Happy988 · 11/03/2024 16:17

Allthegoodusernamesweretaken · 11/03/2024 16:11

How long did you continue to hire after your insurers paid you out? The defendant’s insurer will be attacking (1) the length of hire, especially if it went beyond the payment date for your car, (2) the weekly or daily rate and (3) whether you ‘mitigated’ your loss, ie kept it to a minimum of what you needed in terms of the hiring period, the rate and type of hire vehicle (eg. it’s unreasonable to hire a new Mercedes SL500 when your car was a 15 year rust bucket)
Evidence about the hire period is factual, given by you and backed up by the hire documents.Your barrister will deal with rates and mitigation issues. You’ll be questioned by the other side; be truthful. Good luck

It went back the day after I was paid out.I tried to give it back even earlier than that as I knew it was racking up costs but they said hold on to it. I didn’t get a choice in the car, just got told it would be like for like and I turned up and it wasn’t at all

OP posts:
Zyq · 11/03/2024 16:13

OneMoreTimeBaby · 11/03/2024 13:58

Please don't worry!

Your insurance can deal with this if they want to. I have recent experience of attending court for a traffic accident claim. Your witness statement can be read out by the barrister who is representing your insurance company, the barrister can also send your apologies for non attendance due to lack of childcare at short notice. This is why we pay insurance. If the judge in charge is that bothered they can call you. Trust me, they won't be.

Please ignore this. It's dangerous advice.

Happy988 · 11/03/2024 16:12

Zyq · 11/03/2024 16:10

Your contract with the insurer will say that you have to co-operate with them in trying to recover from the other driver. You can't just take their money and say "Thanks, but now I'm happy for you to take the loss because I don't fancy helping".

I understand that but it’s not that I don’t fancy helping. I have been in contact with them for months sending all kinds of evidence. It’s just the change to a 60 mile trip To a different court with 24 hour notice and already under a lot of stress and having to sort childcare and costs

OP posts:
Allthegoodusernamesweretaken · 11/03/2024 16:11

How long did you continue to hire after your insurers paid you out? The defendant’s insurer will be attacking (1) the length of hire, especially if it went beyond the payment date for your car, (2) the weekly or daily rate and (3) whether you ‘mitigated’ your loss, ie kept it to a minimum of what you needed in terms of the hiring period, the rate and type of hire vehicle (eg. it’s unreasonable to hire a new Mercedes SL500 when your car was a 15 year rust bucket)
Evidence about the hire period is factual, given by you and backed up by the hire documents.Your barrister will deal with rates and mitigation issues. You’ll be questioned by the other side; be truthful. Good luck

Zyq · 11/03/2024 16:10

Happy988 · 11/03/2024 13:35

@fedupandstuck this is what I don’t understand. I didn’t ask to pursue it. The solicitors just wanted loads of information from me and said they just needed my assistance in the matter as the third party were disputing it and the solicitors wanted their costs back

Your contract with the insurer will say that you have to co-operate with them in trying to recover from the other driver. You can't just take their money and say "Thanks, but now I'm happy for you to take the loss because I don't fancy helping".