Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that drinking in small sips is not necessarily better

31 replies

HolidayAtNight · 11/03/2024 12:45

Bit of a weird one, but I think about this often as I tend to find myself drinking whole glasses of water a few times a day instead of sipping at my desk.

The advice always seems to be to sip water throughout the day to not "overload" the kidneys, but if you think about it, when we were hunter-gatherers we would likely have drunk water where we could get it, or would have stopped every so often and drunk, which would have also been the case when we were on our feet more either in or out of the home. Sipping all day every day is only easy if you're sitting at a desk, which is a pretty recent development.

Similarly with animals - I've had pet cats and dogs, and they drink a lot in one go, a few times a day. Wild animals seem to do likewise, and visit the "watering hole" or other water source specifically to drink. This doesn't seem to overload their systems.

AIBU to think it's fine to down a glass of water a few times a day rather than trying to spread it out, and that our kidneys will manage?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OneFrenchEgg · 11/03/2024 22:32

I thought sipping was for illness and dehydration. Not general day to day stuff.

Sundaygettingreadyfortheweek · 11/03/2024 22:20

HolidayAtNight · 11/03/2024 12:51

If you google "sip or gulp water" there are loads of examples of people saying it's better to sip in small amounts. I'm not saying it's good advice, but have read so many times in magazines, articles, etc., that it's better to sip.

And if you google flat earth…
Just because something can be found through google doesn’t mean it’s true.

Zapss · 11/03/2024 15:42

Eat when you're hungry; drink when you're dry.

And never shoot an unarmed man.

anunlikelyseahorse · 11/03/2024 15:38

Glugging is fine, obviously if you drink litres and litres you die, but we're talking a lot of litres relative to body size in a short amount of time.
Glugging down if you have d and v isn't recommended because you're more likely to vomit or shit it all out again. You'll still absorb some fluid, but sipping is a bit kinder to your digestive tract.
Sipping is recommended if you're someone who struggles to keep up with fluids (elderly people don't always feel thirsty so small regular sips through the day are recommended as Glugging down fluid may not be very easy or practical for numerous reasons) sipping is recommended if there are swallowing difficulties. And sipping can help stimulate the 'thirst' feeling.
General rule of thumb is 30 mls per kilo of body weight for a normally active person, obviously if you sit on your arse all day, you won't need so much, if you're a gym bunny you'll need a bit more, if you're a sweaty individual you'll need more again, but generally humans are quite good at knowing when they are thirsty and when they aren't. Sometimes the messages get scrambled and hunger can be mistaken for feeling thirsty, some foods and drinks (coffee being the main one) can dull the 'thirst' feeling. Just as some foods can increase thirst.
Glugging or sipping is fine. Too much of anything tends to be bad for you, and too little fluid can be bad for you.
If your wee is yellow, dark yellow or orange (and you're not on any meds) then you need to up your fluid intake a bit, a little bit more and quite a lot respectively.
If your wee is pale / very pale yellow it's all good.

Londonscallingme · 11/03/2024 15:01

I suspect your confusing guidance designed to encourage people (who don’t drink enough) to drink more; ie sipping throughout the day might be more manageable etc. with a suggestion that sipping is better than other methods. FWIW I down a pint when I remember and I’m not concerned about my kidneys.

Upallnight2 · 11/03/2024 15:00

OK so I was on a first aid course recently, and the guy doing it told us that if you drink over (measured out a few inches with his fingers) at once it will just go through you and you won't get the hydration you would if sipping.

However I know people have died (not personally obviously) from electrolyte imbalances because they drank a large amount of water at once 🤷‍♀️ so how does that work??

NancyPickford · 11/03/2024 14:58

12,000 long years have passed since we were hunter-gatherers. Things may have changed.

Mrsjayy · 11/03/2024 14:53

they are probably saying sip so they can flog the latest cup or whatever a few glasses of water a day isn't going to flood your kidneys.

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 11/03/2024 14:51

Provided that you drink enough, it does not matter whether you drink it by the glassful or sip from a bottle throughout the day, but the latter offers far more opportunities for being an annoying little tit.

DrJoanAllenby · 11/03/2024 13:56

Maybe you're still a Neanderthal Hunter gatherer but the rest of us have evolved and don't have a pressing need to gulp down a beverage in order to avoid a spear up the arse from a fellow Hunter gatherer or being chased by Woolly Mammoth.

mondaytosunday · 11/03/2024 13:34

I've only heard you shouldn't glug alcohol. Horses shouldn't be allowed to drink loads after exercise for some reason or other.
You can drink too much water, but that would be litres and litres and litres.

SwordToFlamethrower · 11/03/2024 13:27

My MIL is very controlling and obbsessive and one of many stories I have of her related to this post.

I was visiting my then BF and was given a glass of squash, which I drunk down in one.

She went berserk saying I shouldn't do it because it is REALLY bad.

She also went on to say drinking water is bad for you and you should drink teas, juices and squashes.

On a totally unrelated note... MIL has a mouth full of fillings, crowns and replacements due to the sugar she consumes. I've never had a filling in my life and I'm 46.

She seems to think I might die if I don't sip drinks. I've never done that, I always just down them.

Redtedbed · 11/03/2024 13:17

Isn't that when you're ill? So if you're going to throw up, you're not chucking up an entire glass of water?

Herdinggoats · 11/03/2024 13:14

There’s a few TikTok fads around this. Sipping water, adding a pinch of salt (as if most of us don’t have diets that are too high in salt anyway 🤣) all sorts. It’s basically influencers wanting to have something (anything) to talk about.

And drinking water is a good one because for followers it is relatively low effort - I much prefer being told I can get toned and lose cellulite by sipping water than by going to the gym!!!!

coureur · 11/03/2024 13:13

I have never heard this. It's rubbish. Water absorption is limited both mechanically (by the rate of emptying of the stomach into the small intestine) and physiologically (by the water uptake of the small intestine). Whether you take sips or gulps is completely irrelevant.

littlegrebe · 11/03/2024 13:10

As hunter gatherers our role was to stay alive long enough to raise the next generation before being eaten by a sabre tooth tiger. Living long enough to wear out your kidneys was pretty rare so I'm not sure the prehistoric approach is helpful here.

Having said that, I have never ever heard this advice.

Nevermindtheteacaps · 11/03/2024 13:09

The constant water sipping culture is ANNOYING. Ppl constantly carrying about water bottles, fretting about filling them...

And those Stanley cups? What fresh hell?

Just drink your water and get on with life

AgnesX · 11/03/2024 13:09

HolidayAtNight · 11/03/2024 12:53

Also, the current massive popularity of water bottles indicates a preference for constant access to water.

That's just fad and fashion....how did people used to manage.

That said, access to liquid can only be a good thing.

ItIsEverywhere · 11/03/2024 13:08

I have a cup on my desk at work which I try to have a drink of each time I feel like having a snack (too often)!
If I'm actually thirsty I'll drink the whole cup.

HolidayAtNight · 11/03/2024 13:05

pimplebum · 11/03/2024 13:00

All this angst and all you have to do google nhs ....

You have literally never worked yourself up into such a lather over a non issue

Learn to distinguish reputable facts from "magazine / online articles"

I promise I'm not in a lather. Just curious about it as I've seen this trend towards constant sipping develop over my lifetime and noticed the increase in water bottles for children and adults. Sometimes it's interesting to think about things and discuss them.

OP posts:
HungryBeagle · 11/03/2024 13:04

Not anything I’ve ever really thought about. I just have a drink when I’m thirsty.

ComtesseDeSpair · 11/03/2024 13:03

HolidayAtNight · 11/03/2024 12:53

Also, the current massive popularity of water bottles indicates a preference for constant access to water.

I suspect it has as much to do with clever marketing about the benefits of constant access to water driving the preference because bottled water and water bottles have a saleable value in a way that waiting until you get home to have a glass of tap water doesn’t.

I’ve never met or heard of anyone whose kidney dysfunction was because they drank glasses of water at a time rather than in sips.

pimplebum · 11/03/2024 13:00

All this angst and all you have to do google nhs ....

You have literally never worked yourself up into such a lather over a non issue

Learn to distinguish reputable facts from "magazine / online articles"

CaptainMyCaptain · 11/03/2024 12:59

I've never heard of the sipping thing.

HolidayAtNight · 11/03/2024 12:53

Also, the current massive popularity of water bottles indicates a preference for constant access to water.

OP posts: