Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want more children as an unnatural mother

29 replies

Chasingyourtail · 11/03/2024 06:47

Unnatural is probably the wrong word but I certainly wasn't a natural mother first time around. We are now 4 years on from finding out we were going to have our first baby. I found motherhood tough - I don't think COVID helped this and there was of course a lot of usual feelings around not wanting to get things wrong.

I keep envisioning a pregnancy in which DH comes to the scans, I can meet up with other mums and attend baby groups, and doing it all again with the experience I have now. I think what's stopping me is imagining my parents and others who saw my post natal depression last time and not believing I am capable. I rely a lot on my family for help so while I am coming round to the idea of another baby, I am worried about feelings of failure rushing back. I'm nearly 32 if that is at all helpful/relevant.

OP posts:
Moneybum · 11/03/2024 07:10

I had a second child and he’s much different to my first, and with increased confidence, I am enjoying it so much more. I also struggled first time round and would also describe myself as not a natural mother in the sense you mean it.

im not sure a reason to do it is to help deal with the trauma/issues you had with your first, as your desire to relive the experience of a newborn and maternity leave more positively may not happen. I would recommend counselling as a place you can talk through your feelings about your first. but if you have other motivations (such wanting a sibling for your child, you and your partner liking the idea of a bigger family or whatever) then do it.

I think you should consider how you might react and cope if you had a high needs/intense baby, versus a chilled happy one. I just wanted to post here as someone who was very fearful about number 2 (but who decided to do it for a number of reasons including wanting DD to have a sibling) who has had a positive second time experience.

TheWildRumpyPumpus · 11/03/2024 07:00

How are you finding motherhood now OP? I learnt the hard way that having a second child when I was already struggling to enjoy parenting the first was not a good idea.

When you say you rely on family for a lot of help, what do you mean? In my case my Mum and in-laws basically co-parented after my second as DH needed to keep working and I was seriously debilitated with PND. I’d understand them expressing concerns about me having another pregnancy/child.

SmileyClare · 11/03/2024 06:58

Post natal depression is nothing to do with not being a “natural mother”.
Due to your history, you and those around you will know the signs of PND and how to treat it. You may well not suffer anxiety and depression after a second pregnancy.

However if you rely heavily on family for support (childcare?) then a conversation with those family members you want help from is needed before having a second child.

jeaux90 · 11/03/2024 06:51

I stuck with one child OP. The early years were really tough. It comes down to what is more compelling, your fear of repeating history or your need for another child.