Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for thinking MIL's expectations are too high ?

230 replies

blueyavocado · 10/03/2024 22:34

Basically I gave birth 2 weeks ago , partner is on paternity leave and is a massive support . Right now our priority is our baby and ourselves. We live with his parents

Baby is well looked after and is content and happy. But MIL is having high expectations from the both of us with regards to keeping the house immaculate. We are already looking after our baby and helping out with the ; cooking , dog walks , unloading the dishwasher , laundry , making the kitchen tidy etc but whatever we do is not enough.

Today I spent the morning making cupcakes for her and preparing a roast on top of trying to cluster feed a very fussy baby . My partner was supporting me, but she came home and immediately moaned about the sink being full of cups that we had to hand wash as the dishwasher hadn't cleaned them and the bin not being emptied. She moaned that my DP does nothing and I explained he had been up all night feeding and changing LO.

It's continuous, the other day she wanted to book a holiday and kept demanding for me , but I was in the middle of feeding out little one.

I just don't know what to do, AIBU? Or are her expectations to high? I feel like I've not even had a chance to recover. She keeps nagging me about exclusively breast feeding , but I don't have the time with everything she expects us to do. I'm only managing to breast feed him 2 times a day, the rest is bottle as it takes up a lot of time

OP posts:
DrinkinghelpsThinking · 11/03/2024 15:29

PurplGirl · 11/03/2024 15:07

Oh OP, I’m sorry you’re getting so many unhelpful and judgy comments. Your MIL sounds awful. I don’t care if it’s her house, she’s in the wrong.
People saying your partner should be doing more, keeping the house immaculate, you’d both have to clean up after yourselves if you had your own home blah blah blah. No you wouldn’t. You’d be able to choose how much and when you cleaned up. You’d be cleaning up after yourselves only, not walking other people’s dogs etc.
I’m so mad that this is your FTM experience. Do you want to breastfeed? If you do, then please, I I urge you to seek out feeding support pronto. At 2 weeks you can still pull this back. But you’ll need to go back to basics, breastfeed on demand and do very little wise for a few weeks.
Just because you’re living in her house does not mean your little family of 3 have to dance to her tune. If it were me, I’d ask partner to tell her that you will both be focusing on baby/you for the next few weeks. You’ll clean up after yourselves and help with chores, but you’d like the space to choose when you do that. If she has any issues, please can she have a quiet word with her son, as you really need to focus on breastfeeding etc. People like her need to be stood up to.
best wishes to you and congrats!

Also, OP, I got really stressed out after my 2nd kid with non-family related stuff and this really decreased my supply. So, like this poster says, it’s really important actually for you partner to take care of everything else so you focus on your supply and bonding (if that’s what you choose to do of course).

PurplGirl · 11/03/2024 15:07

Oh OP, I’m sorry you’re getting so many unhelpful and judgy comments. Your MIL sounds awful. I don’t care if it’s her house, she’s in the wrong.
People saying your partner should be doing more, keeping the house immaculate, you’d both have to clean up after yourselves if you had your own home blah blah blah. No you wouldn’t. You’d be able to choose how much and when you cleaned up. You’d be cleaning up after yourselves only, not walking other people’s dogs etc.
I’m so mad that this is your FTM experience. Do you want to breastfeed? If you do, then please, I I urge you to seek out feeding support pronto. At 2 weeks you can still pull this back. But you’ll need to go back to basics, breastfeed on demand and do very little wise for a few weeks.
Just because you’re living in her house does not mean your little family of 3 have to dance to her tune. If it were me, I’d ask partner to tell her that you will both be focusing on baby/you for the next few weeks. You’ll clean up after yourselves and help with chores, but you’d like the space to choose when you do that. If she has any issues, please can she have a quiet word with her son, as you really need to focus on breastfeeding etc. People like her need to be stood up to.
best wishes to you and congrats!

MoaningMeowing · 11/03/2024 14:56

Sorry OP I read your thread but can’t work out if you want to BF or not.

We have a six month old and during DHs paternity he did all of the household chores and I essentially stayed in bed EBF on demand.

While I’m probably a few years older than you/got our own house/planned our baby I still felt a lot of pressure from my mum/MIL. Remarkable how they left hospital and went straight back to ironing shirts/cooking the dinners/doing the gardening. However they seem to forget that bottle feeding was promoted and BATCH made, spent a week in hospital recovering and they did have a lot more female support than they care to remember. I think there’s an element of the green-eyed monster as they had no support from their husbands…

Emmz1510 · 11/03/2024 14:31

I think between the two of you you should be able to manage caring for the baby and keeping the home reasonably tidy, at least tidying up after yourselves.

Funkytuna · 11/03/2024 14:29

Richmond is really expensive. You need to move to a one bed in a cheaper area. If that means finding new jobs as well then so be it.

WildRose42 · 11/03/2024 14:23

Some of the comments on here are ‘shocking’! OP you are doing your best. You’re having to deal with just having a baby, recovering, MIL breathing down your neck at every given chance. Instead of moaning at you why don’t she offer some support. Having a baby isn’t easy. Obviously your DH wants to help, which is wonderful, some men don’t bother, so hats off to him for being a hands on dad. Try not to do too much, you’re still in recovery, and need to rest too. Your MIL seems like she’s too demanding and perhaps isn’t happy you’re living under her roof full time, but that’s the situation as it is, and she’s got to stop complaining. All those saying ‘move out, get your own place’ it’s not always that easy! Some people do have to rely on other family, that’s what families do. You don’t know their financial circumstances.

This poor lady is no doubt all over the place after having a baby, she probably don’t know if she’s coming or going, trying to please everyone. She sounds like she needs a break. they all need to cut her some slack. Yes if she had her own place she would need to clean and tidy, but it would be at her own leisure, no one breathing down her neck all day. The MIL needs to chill out. What’s a few cups! Maybe instead of moaning, cuddle her grandchild…enjoy them being there and helping more. 🙄

ittakes2 · 11/03/2024 14:20

Your baby might be chilled out now but as they get stronger they can cry more / fight sleep. I think you need to look at moving out its unfortunately not going to get better and may get worse.

Shesmyhero · 11/03/2024 14:14

I really don't understand - I had premature twins who needing feeding every two hours - what on earth are two adults doing for 24 hrs a day with a chilled out baby who feeds every 3 hours roughly that the cups in the sink are too much to do? I mean only one person can feed and hold a baby at any given time - and there are two of you.

namechange55465 · 11/03/2024 13:15

There are lots of places you could live within commuting distance of Richmond and Kings Cross that aren't £2k a month. If you're willing to move jobs even better.

Living with MIL clearly isn't working - you need to move out.

WhistPie · 11/03/2024 13:12

blueyavocado · 11/03/2024 10:39

Near Richmond upon Thames

Move to Wood Green or similar then

tennesseewhiskey1 · 11/03/2024 12:55

Well then you need to live outside of London - NHS has hospitals everywhere. It’s untenable - you have to move to a cheaper place

pinkyredrose · 11/03/2024 12:48

Why don't you look for a flat nearer work, Richmond prices are extortionate.

Gloriosaford · 11/03/2024 12:46

Mother-in-law sounds like a nutcase personality disordered person but you are living under her roof and you will have to abide by her terms and conditions.

pinkyredrose · 11/03/2024 12:40

blueyavocado · 10/03/2024 23:22

Before I gave birth his plan was for me to rest in bed with baby whilst he was off for two weeks and he would take care of everything else , MIL said that it's ridiculous

She's right, it is ridiculous.

Move out ASAP!

MoreLidlThanWaitrose · 11/03/2024 12:39

Think of the long term gains. If you WANT to exclusively breastfeed (if not then disregard everything I’m about to say) then it will be much quicker and easier than formula feeding once it clicks. But you have to put in the time now. Stop sharing baby duties and doing housework. Focus on feeding and feeding alone. Housework is a DP job for now. All you are doing at the moment is sharing baby AND housework. So just take one main job each.

MooseOnTour · 11/03/2024 12:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

JackNoMiddleNameReacher · 11/03/2024 12:33

You need to move out to your own place
Here’s some two beds up to 3miles away from you OP, much less than £2000pcm.

AIBU for thinking MIL's expectations are too high ?
AIBU for thinking MIL's expectations are too high ?
crockofshite · 11/03/2024 12:31

Congratulations on your baby. You and your partner sound like brilliant parents, doing everything right for your baby and for yourselves and also trying hard to help your mil with her housework, dogs, chores and god knows what else.

Unfortunately your mil sounds like hard work and I hope you are able to find somewhere else to live very soon.

I wonder who will do all her skivvying and running after her when you move out with her son. I also feel sorry for her husband.

KreedKafer · 11/03/2024 12:23

If your MIL likes her house to remain immaculate, and you are living in her house, then I'm afraid it doesn't really matter whether you think her expectations are 'reasonable' because you are living in her home and you need to respect her rules.

Right now our priority is our baby and ourselves

But you are living in someone else's house so you are bound by their priorities as well as your own.

You and your partner got you pregnant by accident while living in a studio flat, and can't afford anything else. Your in-laws have kindly provided you with accommodation, which they were in no way obliged to do. You are in a 'beggars can't be choosers' situation right now and you need to either suck it up and stick to your MIL's exacting standards, or find an alternative arrangement.

yikesanotherbooboo · 11/03/2024 12:02

I agree with the majority; your job is to recover from your delivery and establish feeding. You are living with your ils so need to fit in with their standards . Your DH is being very unreasonable if he has reverted to teenaged child mode and isn't picking up the domestic chores. Before long you will be able to offer more time to get things done in the house . If you were living in your own home the chores would still need to be done.

tillytoodles1 · 11/03/2024 12:01

SwordToFlamethrower · 10/03/2024 23:07

Bloody hell!!!! Stooooooop!!!! Why are you doing all this?

Just STOP. Tell your mil to PISS OFF.

And they'll probably get thrown out.

TeaKitten · 11/03/2024 11:58

Picklestop · 11/03/2024 11:48

But then still perhaps she should not be creating even more mess in the kitchen by making cupcakes. Yes she should be recovering but her idle partner should be emptying the dishwasher and washing cups.

Yep that’s what I said.

Picklestop · 11/03/2024 11:48

TeaKitten · 10/03/2024 22:44

Gently, she’s 2 weeks post partum, it’s Mother’s Day and her partner is on paternity leave. He should be doing all that crap while she feeds and cuddles her baby.

But then still perhaps she should not be creating even more mess in the kitchen by making cupcakes. Yes she should be recovering but her idle partner should be emptying the dishwasher and washing cups.

MCOut · 11/03/2024 11:48

You’re getting a really hard time on here OP. Congratulations on your DC! My Mum and MIL took time off to come and help us at this stage post partum. I think she sounds unreasonable especially if you had both successfully met her standards before hand. She should extend you some grace.

That being said, I know it’s expensive, but having your own place is invaluable. In the most respectful way, young families do not live in Richmond, unless they have great incomes. If you move further out, even just 15/20 minutes, the rents are cheaper and you can still benefit from the Waterloo trains.

DrinkinghelpsThinking · 11/03/2024 11:34

blueyavocado · 11/03/2024 10:44

She goes on about how she did it all alone , her husband only had a week paternity leave , she kept the house immaculate, nursed her babies and went back to work at 11 weeks post baby. Went on maternity leave 6 days before she was rue

I’ve heard this from so many MIL’s. My Mum also says this type of stuff, but what she forgets is that she didn’t bond well with her children (thankfully we have a lovely bond now after loads of convos). You can probably see first hand where her priorities lie, OP. She’d rather everything in constant order than for you to bond with your bubs. But please remember, you can’t get these early days back and they are so very precious. Yes its her house and all that, but you also mention you are paying rent whilst staying with her, surely you should get some semblance of peace. How is FIL about all this?

MIL is projecting onto you, I’m sure she too would have liked to have a different experience with her kids.