Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for thinking MIL's expectations are too high ?

230 replies

blueyavocado · 10/03/2024 22:34

Basically I gave birth 2 weeks ago , partner is on paternity leave and is a massive support . Right now our priority is our baby and ourselves. We live with his parents

Baby is well looked after and is content and happy. But MIL is having high expectations from the both of us with regards to keeping the house immaculate. We are already looking after our baby and helping out with the ; cooking , dog walks , unloading the dishwasher , laundry , making the kitchen tidy etc but whatever we do is not enough.

Today I spent the morning making cupcakes for her and preparing a roast on top of trying to cluster feed a very fussy baby . My partner was supporting me, but she came home and immediately moaned about the sink being full of cups that we had to hand wash as the dishwasher hadn't cleaned them and the bin not being emptied. She moaned that my DP does nothing and I explained he had been up all night feeding and changing LO.

It's continuous, the other day she wanted to book a holiday and kept demanding for me , but I was in the middle of feeding out little one.

I just don't know what to do, AIBU? Or are her expectations to high? I feel like I've not even had a chance to recover. She keeps nagging me about exclusively breast feeding , but I don't have the time with everything she expects us to do. I'm only managing to breast feed him 2 times a day, the rest is bottle as it takes up a lot of time

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
nonmerci99 · 15/03/2024 09:11

She sounds pretty horrible. I would agree with others that your best bet is to either ignore her dramatics while trying your best to conform to her totally unreasonable demands OR do everything you can to get out of there, and fast. It's utterly bizarre she invited you to move in and is treating you both the way she is. She sounds like she might be a narcissist, since this is pretty classic behaviour for those types.

Crumblespiesetc · 14/03/2024 16:07

The fact that she suggested you move in and insists upon these weirdly high standards within 2 weeks of the baby's arrival sounds unbearable.

Maybe she didn't realise what it would be like. That's the only possibly defense I can think of, even then, her behaviour sounds really trying.

If you can afford to move out, I would do so. Unless you are willing to pay the high mental cost of living on eggs shells for the years it would probably take you to save up. I was priced out of my home neighbourhood decades ago - it is possible to relocate and be happy! Obviously a big decision, but I couldn't tolerate what you are describing.

thefarrierswife · 14/03/2024 15:34

It sounds like a difficult situation and MIL sounds hard to deal with. Unfortunately you're in a situation where you either stay where you are and put up with your MIL, at the end of the day it is her house, her rules, unreasonable or not.

You and your partner need to make a plan on moving out into your own home together. It might not be the area you wanted, but now you have a child you'll have to provide a home. Or stay with your in laws but be prepared to live with the requests.

howshouldibehave · 14/03/2024 12:54

Today I spent the morning making cupcakes for her and preparing a roast on top of trying to cluster feed a very fussy baby . My partner was supporting me, but she came home and immediately moaned about the sink being full of cups that we had to hand wash as the dishwasher hadn't cleaned them and the bin not being emptied.

Kitchen was immaculate as I was cooking

It doesn’t sound immaculate, to be fair. I don’t think I’d have been doing a roast/making cupcakes two weeks after giving birth. She’s probably stressed with stuff everywhere.

That aside, it doesn’t sound like you can continue to live in her house for long-you’d have had more privacy in your one-bed flat.

What’s your plan/timeline for moving out?

HeathenPlayingHouse · 14/03/2024 10:38

It sounds like a really hard situation OP, and I'm not sure I can offer any suggestions more helpful than previous posters.

But I do want to send you a big virtual hug- the idea that you spent your first Mother's Day, with a newborn no less, cooking and baking and basically having to fuss over your MIL makes me so sad.

We can never know all the ins and outs of a situation just from reading a post, but I hope you know you deserved more than that.

WhistPie · 14/03/2024 08:01

@doppelganger2. I also dont get why you were booking a holiday. Weird financial priority in your circumstances

She was booking a holiday for the MIL

doppelganger2 · 14/03/2024 07:11

She keeps nagging me about exclusively breast feeding , but I don't have the time with everything she expects us to do. I'm only managing to breast feed him 2 times a day, the rest is bottle as it takes up a lot of time

I don't understand this comment. You are in mat leave, DP is on pat leave and you don't have time to breast feed (which is, uf established the quickest and easiest way too feed a baby - no bottle prep etc.

I also dont get why you were booking a holiday. Weird financial priority in your circumstances.

ultimately, when you live with someone else, you adjust to their standards. I would focus on moving out! Your Mil is not the problem here.

Bushra385 · 14/03/2024 01:46

It does sound like a lot if pressure ! I understand you want to do 50/50 on the parenting and chores but trust me you would actually get more rest if you nurse baby on demand . Breastfeeding exclusively sounds daunting but in reality once you get the support from the feeding team , and you get the hang of it , it’s easy just to stick baby on and rest rest rest . Even at night you can stick the baby on to latch and you hardly even have to wake up ! This way you do get rest and people can’t demand chores off you . No shade to FF, if that’s what you prefer though , I hope you can move out soon . We moved from a nice flat in zone 2 to a family home in zone 6 , it takes time but is doable . X

Middleagedspreadisreal · 13/03/2024 20:12

I so feel for you :(

Sleepytiredyawn · 13/03/2024 14:53

Is it possible that now baby is here and with her own son being home for 2 weeks it’s just a tad more untidy than it usually is. She may chill out once he’s back at work. But your baby won’t stay a baby for long, there will be toys out soon, so she either needs to learn to cope with a little mess or you may need to move out sooner than planned for all of your Sanity.

sunshinemode · 13/03/2024 14:45

All the comments about what is the partner doing. Surely paternity leave is for partners is bond with their babies too. It sounds like that is what they are doing as new parents trying to establish a relationship with their baby and a new relationship with each other as parents now. Well done to you both. It is incredibly difficult to live in someone else's house.

T1Dmama · 13/03/2024 10:09

blueyavocado · 11/03/2024 10:13

Before baby was born we spent all our time in our bedroom and used to come down to help out with cooking, cleaning etc. MIL told us not to spend all our time in our room when we have baby, so we've been spending more time downstairs but it feels like we are getting in the way. It feels like a no win situation

You need to spend more time in your room again. Tell her the reason why! Say you want to feed baby without having chores found for you, DH needs to say he doesn’t want to be downstairs as she finds him things to do and he and you both need time to recover and bond! Maybe it needs to be pointed out to her that you’re both doing too much of her work when you’re meant to be resting and establishing routines with baby.
Let her walk her own bloody dogs, they’re her responsibility! Tell her you’re pay for a cleaner once a week if she doesn’t want to do it but you don’t have time!
you need to set some boundaries now or you’ll be doing everything alone when DH goes back to work!!
I know it hee home, but I disagree with PP that that somehow gives her the right to treat you like slaves! Your DH needs to say things like ‘Mum the holiday can wait… you can see @blueyavocado is feeding!!….. or actually when baby needs feeding I’d go to your room and feed and DH tells her it’s because you need some peace to do it and not to be given things to do!
I hope you can move out soon… maybe look at jobs and houses elsewhere away from London later on x
good luck and congrats

T1Dmama · 13/03/2024 09:48

Your husband needs to tell his mum that he’s off to bond with baby and he’ll you, not to walk the dogs! When baby needs feeding you need to stop what you’re doing and feed them… hubby needs to take over what you were doing or that job waits!
he needs a word with MIL and tell her that right now he’s happy to clear up after you both but he is t there to be her dog sitter or cleaner and neither are you!!

Mumof3confused · 13/03/2024 07:56

The dishwasher might need rinse aid or salt topping up.

I don’t have a solution for your MIL other than to move out.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 13/03/2024 07:13

blueyavocado · 11/03/2024 00:02

Kitchen was immaculate as I was cooking , the only thing not done at that point was the bin and DP had an operation on Friday so can't lift hesvg

How big is the bin?

howshouldibehave · 13/03/2024 06:58

How much rent are you paying her? What will this money get you in a rental property?

Skodacool · 13/03/2024 06:49

I can’t believe some of the comments on here. Sure, it’s MIL’s house so her rules, but this one is expecting OP and her partner to be her servants. Her behaviour is nothing short of bullying, she should be supporting her DIL with the baby.

Skodacool · 13/03/2024 06:32

Pippa12 · 10/03/2024 22:42

Gently, I’d of unpacked the dishwasher, washed the cups and emptied the bin before I started making cupcakes and preparing a roast.

If you live in somebody else’s home it doesn’t really matter if you deem their standards ‘too high’, you have no choice but to abide by them.

I imagine you’re saving up so you can stand on your own two feet? Until then, you’ll have to comply.

Hello MIL

Properjob · 13/03/2024 06:08

I can't believe some of the responses here. The MIL sounds like an entitled, narcissistic cow. This is her grandchild, why is she not helping YOU a bit? You are paying rent, so make sure DP cleans up any small mess of yours, then go to your room shut the door in her face and breastfeed. Get takeaways and stop cooking for her. Start looking for a rental....

Buffs · 13/03/2024 00:22

You’d be better off in your old studio flat. You really need very little space with a young baby.

MarvellousMonsters · 12/03/2024 23:57

If you are only breastfeeding 2 times a day this will cause problems with your milk supply. At two weeks pp you should be resting, healing and breastfeeding, whilst your partner does the cooking etc. That's what his paternity leave is for. You feed the baby, and your partner should be looking after you. What exactly is he doing all day that he can't keep on top of the dishes etc? Stop letting other people take the baby whilst you cook a roast and make cup cakes.

As for MIL, she needs to have this conversation with her son, if he's incompetent, it's her own fault for not teaching him to do this stuff as he was growing up.

Over40andNotalotofpatienceleft · 12/03/2024 22:50

For goodness sake! It’s a baby.
Yes you do need to rest but you both need to get in to the swing of managing basic housework, feeds, and life in general. You’re lucky, your DH is helping with the night feeds many mothers go home to no help at all and manage perfectly fine. Living with inlaws is difficult but essentially it is their house and you chose to give up your studio to live with them.

OldPerson · 12/03/2024 21:34

You need to find somewhere else to live. It sounds like you've always been living with his parents and now you've saddled them with your baby 24/7. If you're in a position where you're unable to afford your own place and to financially raise your child independently - then suck it up. A crying baby is demanding. Unless it was their decision for you to procreate - then you have an added responsibility to make sure you both compensate for your crying, demanding bundle of joy. So with you both off work, add washing up to your daily chores. If you can't cope, sit down with your in-laws and work out what you can do to set eveyone's expectations.

JayJayj · 12/03/2024 21:32

I’m struggling with how you don’t have time to breast feed but have time to make a bottle?? If you are wanting to breast feed you need to do it more consistently to get your supply otherwise you will not produce enough. That is if you are wanting to. I can’t understand why you are doing so much though if you only gave birth 2 weeks ago. You need to be resting and binding and doing those feeds.
is the house really that much of a mess???
it’s obviously not working living with the parents you need to get out as soon as you can.

SpiritOfEcstasy · 12/03/2024 20:54

This post made me so sad. This ought to be the happiest, most euphoric time of your lives - planned or unplanned baby. In your situation I think I’d ask your partner to have a calm chat with his DM and explain that this is fast becoming untenable and why. If she can’t be more accommodating, welcoming and reasonable I would suggest you start looking for jobs in a much cheaper, out of London area and make a fresh start somewhere more affordable. She sounds like an OCD, miserable, begrudger. Cups in a sink? Seriously? She will see a whole lot less of her DGC but from the sounds of her that’s probably not a bad thing!