Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother’s Day Expectations

32 replies

GwinGwyn · 10/03/2024 17:32

AIBU to think that some posts today could have been avoided by people clearly expressing to their family/others what they expected from today?

I didn’t see my mum today as I am moving tomorrow and I am in the middle of packing boxes. But she knew weeks in advance (as much notice as I got) and I sent her a card, texted her today (we chatted yesterday), and I’m going to take her for lunch once settled - sometime around Easter, we’ll tie down a date.

But I see so many posts on here where people just haven’t had an honest conversation about what they wanted and seem to think people know through osmosis or psychic ability. Maybe you think I am crap for not dropping everything and driving 80 miles to my mum today - she doesn’t - texted her first thing to say HMD and she replied: “Couldn’t do it without you! Xxx” which I thought was incredibly sweet.

Not to say people don’t have issues with their mothers - I have over the years - but so many people on here are upset because they didn’t have their perfect day, but didn’t seem to communicate what they wanted in advance. We are all living in a world of blended families, people working mad hours, living at a great distance from another. This genuinely isn’t aimed at anyone - I read stuff and felt guilty that I hadn’t done more for my mum - but then it kind of dawned that my mum is fine because we both knew what today would look like.

AIBU to think mums have a role in speaking to their loved ones about what they do/don’t want for today? People aren’t mind readers. But if they know, something is agreed and people are arseholes, then fair enough obviously….

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Beanui · 16/03/2024 17:33

My husband took the next day off work to spend the day with us unprompted and I didn’t have to cook all day and he took me out to dinner. He said he knows this doesn’t count as Mother’s Day, but he’s sorry and we have the rest of our lives together and he’ll do better for all the years to come. And he ordered the mug and said he’s sorry it took so long.

bozzabollix · 12/03/2024 00:44

Beanui · 11/03/2024 22:06

Been married 5 years. Pregnant with my 4th child. Every single Mother’s Day, Christmas, birthday, Valentines I have asked for the same thing. I want a mug that matches the one I bought him when he became a dad, but I want the mum version. He always says he same thing: he wants me to buy it for myself, wrap it, and gift it to myself for him. I say no Inwant him to get it for me. And he says he doesn’t feel like it. Just typing it out makes me start crying. It’s just so effing hurtful. Yesterday, again, nothing. No help, no nothing. After I made breakfast he said he was going to go take a nap and said I should clear the table faster so perishables don’t spoil. I literally felt like I had a knife in my heart all day. I feel emotions very physically and it is like a very physical pain. It’s worse than labor. This year I tried to be honest about how hurt I was and how this is a big deal. Like, really big. He would seem to get it for a few seconds, but the second I act like I am feeling better because he is sorry and going to do better it instantly just becomes, “Great. We can forget about this now. I made some empty promises and that’s good enough and I’m going to do the exact same thing in future. Also a little joke/but not really joking about how it’s not a big deal and I was actually right to do nothing and you should be happy with nothing because I’m just such a great husband.” Anyway, after all the talk about how sorry he was and he’s going to make it up to me he comes home from work today and hadnt done anything to make it up. Then he complained that the potatoes would have tasted better cooked in the skins and started nearly yelling at me for not making homemade yogurt and accused me of spending all the money in his credit card, only to find out I hadn’t spent anything it was his own things that had taken a few days to go through. I’m looking at flights and am seriously considering just getting in a taxi and leaving him for a while until I cool down. I think I’ll go to Switzerland and actually spend some of the money on the credit card for once.

And I’ll smash his mug before I go and say now I won’t be needing that matching mug anymore.

Go to Switzerland and stay there. Your husband isn’t worth coming back for.

SallyWD · 11/03/2024 23:10

My DH always asks me what gifts I want and what I want to do, the he arranges everything. Ok, there are no surprises but we always have a really lovely time and I'm not disappointed.

Itsacruelsummer · 11/03/2024 22:51

It's never just about Mothers Day is it. Often it's just a bench mark to measure a relationship by/ expose the faultlines in a relationship. The tension is always with the partner and not with the children. Social Media has also made it very ott and performative and a whole day thing.

I had a nice day- despite having to be very explicit about what I really wanted (a lie in). Life is too short to lay traps for your partner. That said some of the men on here sound shit!

cadburyegg · 11/03/2024 22:33

I know what you mean op.

I've been split with my exh for 3 years and I often don't get anything from the kids facilitated by him, or if I do it's some pointless bath set that he's got cheap somewhere and the kids have no clue what it is. So 2 weeks ago I told him that if he was going to do something for MD then can he take the kids somewhere to pick something. It's not about the money. Anyway, to my surprise he stepped up and I got a couple of nice things even if they weren't what I would have chosen.

What did make me laugh is seeing a mumfluencer I follow on insta, post a reel about how she wanted a nice relaxing day but her day was full of feeding babies and other mum related tasks. She has a 3 year old and twin babies, I think she was being unrealistic to expect the whole day off!

Beanui · 11/03/2024 22:26

The ironic thing is that I have a semi-stalker I have been trying to stop contacting me for 8 YEARS who always finds a way to message me happy Mother’s Day since he found out I’m married. I always block and report him for harassment and while very creepy and disgusting, in a twisted way it shows that when you care, you remember. He even used to buy me flowers every week. I never had to explain to him that women like flowers and being appreciated on Mother’s Day. Apparently he heard that himself at some point in his life.

Beanui · 11/03/2024 22:06

GwinGwyn · 10/03/2024 17:32

AIBU to think that some posts today could have been avoided by people clearly expressing to their family/others what they expected from today?

I didn’t see my mum today as I am moving tomorrow and I am in the middle of packing boxes. But she knew weeks in advance (as much notice as I got) and I sent her a card, texted her today (we chatted yesterday), and I’m going to take her for lunch once settled - sometime around Easter, we’ll tie down a date.

But I see so many posts on here where people just haven’t had an honest conversation about what they wanted and seem to think people know through osmosis or psychic ability. Maybe you think I am crap for not dropping everything and driving 80 miles to my mum today - she doesn’t - texted her first thing to say HMD and she replied: “Couldn’t do it without you! Xxx” which I thought was incredibly sweet.

Not to say people don’t have issues with their mothers - I have over the years - but so many people on here are upset because they didn’t have their perfect day, but didn’t seem to communicate what they wanted in advance. We are all living in a world of blended families, people working mad hours, living at a great distance from another. This genuinely isn’t aimed at anyone - I read stuff and felt guilty that I hadn’t done more for my mum - but then it kind of dawned that my mum is fine because we both knew what today would look like.

AIBU to think mums have a role in speaking to their loved ones about what they do/don’t want for today? People aren’t mind readers. But if they know, something is agreed and people are arseholes, then fair enough obviously….

Been married 5 years. Pregnant with my 4th child. Every single Mother’s Day, Christmas, birthday, Valentines I have asked for the same thing. I want a mug that matches the one I bought him when he became a dad, but I want the mum version. He always says he same thing: he wants me to buy it for myself, wrap it, and gift it to myself for him. I say no Inwant him to get it for me. And he says he doesn’t feel like it. Just typing it out makes me start crying. It’s just so effing hurtful. Yesterday, again, nothing. No help, no nothing. After I made breakfast he said he was going to go take a nap and said I should clear the table faster so perishables don’t spoil. I literally felt like I had a knife in my heart all day. I feel emotions very physically and it is like a very physical pain. It’s worse than labor. This year I tried to be honest about how hurt I was and how this is a big deal. Like, really big. He would seem to get it for a few seconds, but the second I act like I am feeling better because he is sorry and going to do better it instantly just becomes, “Great. We can forget about this now. I made some empty promises and that’s good enough and I’m going to do the exact same thing in future. Also a little joke/but not really joking about how it’s not a big deal and I was actually right to do nothing and you should be happy with nothing because I’m just such a great husband.” Anyway, after all the talk about how sorry he was and he’s going to make it up to me he comes home from work today and hadnt done anything to make it up. Then he complained that the potatoes would have tasted better cooked in the skins and started nearly yelling at me for not making homemade yogurt and accused me of spending all the money in his credit card, only to find out I hadn’t spent anything it was his own things that had taken a few days to go through. I’m looking at flights and am seriously considering just getting in a taxi and leaving him for a while until I cool down. I think I’ll go to Switzerland and actually spend some of the money on the credit card for once.

And I’ll smash his mug before I go and say now I won’t be needing that matching mug anymore.

GwinGwyn · 11/03/2024 20:16

Geebray · 11/03/2024 18:39

Well thank you. Very kind of you.

Why have you started a thread just to criticise mothers?

You think that was my intention? Way off base.

Thanks for the snark. I was being genuine.

OP posts:
Updownleftandright · 11/03/2024 18:56

I didn't get anything and never do expect anything. I'm just glad I don't have to bother with father's day now 😀My OH wont be getting anything from me and I won't go out out of my way to drop hints to the kids about making cards either. He won't care, and that's the thing - if the tables were turned in your household, they wouldn't care that they didn't get anything for fathers day, so stop doing it for them if they can't be arsed with you! That's my advice.

I find valentines, fathers day, birthdays, easter and christmas far too much hassle on top of all the other weird days (world book day, pancake day, anniversaries etc) you are expected to remember too. This is all more mental load and disappointment for women. Just stop doing it all if your partners and children don't care, and use the time and money for yourself.

Tara336 · 11/03/2024 18:53

I had the day I wanted which was a quiet lunch with my DM and DD I booked it for us and it was a nice day, I dont know what it is about mothers day and valentine day but I hate SM on those days as its all a bit competitive over what gifts/flowers/cards are received its a bit sad really.

GwinGwyn · 11/03/2024 18:41

StrangeThread · 11/03/2024 18:37

‘AIBU to think mums have a role in speaking to their loved ones about what they do/don’t want for today? ‘

YABU. I had an incredible day. My husband and young adult kids stepped up and I was valued. I didn’t give them any hints or clues. They know me, love me and recognise I am a great mum. I am not bragging but saying that in a loving family, where you have been with your spouse for more than a year, it’s ok to expect this stuff without having to be prescriptive. MD happens every year. It’s not a surprise.

You rather hit the nail on the head there where you said they ‘know you ‘ which must mean they know that you want to feel valued on that date (plenty of mothers don’t give a toss about Mother’s Day after all - I know at least two). So that negates the need to communicate. My point was about examples where families had seemed to completely ignore the day and mothers were at a loss to understand why and were very disappointed.

I don’t think I am ABU to think that talking about preferences can help to avoid these situations. But agree to disagree.

OP posts:
Geebray · 11/03/2024 18:39

GwinGwyn · 11/03/2024 18:38

I didn’t say people couldn’t be disappointed at all, just that expressing your preferences could help avoid a disappointing or upsetting outcome. If they both know you care about Mother’s Day and wanted a card or gift and didn’t supply these then of course you have every right to be sad, I totally understand that.

Well thank you. Very kind of you.

Why have you started a thread just to criticise mothers?

GwinGwyn · 11/03/2024 18:38

Geebray · 11/03/2024 18:33

Please let some of us be disappointed, without putting yet more emotional load on us.

DC is 20. I got nothing yesterday. From DC or DH. It's not on me, you know?

I didn’t say people couldn’t be disappointed at all, just that expressing your preferences could help avoid a disappointing or upsetting outcome. If they both know you care about Mother’s Day and wanted a card or gift and didn’t supply these then of course you have every right to be sad, I totally understand that.

OP posts:
StrangeThread · 11/03/2024 18:37

‘AIBU to think mums have a role in speaking to their loved ones about what they do/don’t want for today? ‘

YABU. I had an incredible day. My husband and young adult kids stepped up and I was valued. I didn’t give them any hints or clues. They know me, love me and recognise I am a great mum. I am not bragging but saying that in a loving family, where you have been with your spouse for more than a year, it’s ok to expect this stuff without having to be prescriptive. MD happens every year. It’s not a surprise.

Geebray · 11/03/2024 18:33

Please let some of us be disappointed, without putting yet more emotional load on us.

DC is 20. I got nothing yesterday. From DC or DH. It's not on me, you know?

GwinGwyn · 11/03/2024 18:30

Avocadorable · 10/03/2024 22:12

Usually Mother’s Day is over looked in my house and I would spend the day disappointed, this year told them all DH included they are usually useless so instead of high hopes I would settle for new flower beds dug out and composted, we only moved here 6 months ago. the whole house can’t lift an arm tonight they are so sore flower beds amazing though 👍 going to plan everything like that from now on, birthdays Xmas the lot :)

I honestly think that is the way forward! Enjoy your flower beds!

OP posts:
GwinGwyn · 11/03/2024 18:29

Cherrysherbet · 10/03/2024 21:13

I disagree.

I think we should know what our Mums like, and make the effort to give something appropriate.

It doesn’t have to be expensive. A card and some flowers that you know they like. This shouldn’t need to be communicated. If you have a decent relationship with your Mum, you should take an interest in what they like.

You shouldn’t need to spoon feed them every year.

I get your point, but surely there’s no harm in asking to check that tastes or opinions haven’t changed? I think asking is being solicitous of someone’s feelings, it shows you care.

OP posts:
GwinGwyn · 11/03/2024 18:26

PurpleWhirple · 10/03/2024 18:16

I have been very vocal about the fact that all I wanted was to go out for a nice meal. I cook every bloody day and I don't want to cook on Mother's Day. It's all I ask, every year.

Nothing booked so my DH is cooking. He's a shit cook. I won't apologise for being disappointed.

Totally fair enough, as I said if you’ve communicated it, it’s been agreed and doesn’t happen then you have every right to be angry and upset.

OP posts:
Avocadorable · 10/03/2024 22:12

Usually Mother’s Day is over looked in my house and I would spend the day disappointed, this year told them all DH included they are usually useless so instead of high hopes I would settle for new flower beds dug out and composted, we only moved here 6 months ago. the whole house can’t lift an arm tonight they are so sore flower beds amazing though 👍 going to plan everything like that from now on, birthdays Xmas the lot :)

LadyDaisy42 · 10/03/2024 21:53

I agree that people aren't mind readers. But, I really don't think I should have to spell out to DH (who I have been with for 20 years) what I might like on Mothers Day (our kids are still young enough to need him to take them to shops to get card/gift). A few years ago he actually got something for his own mum and completely forgot to get anything for me.

We have never been materialistic with presents, a small gift plus card is more than sufficient. But otherwise today has literally been a normal Sunday. I've been sorting out washing, organising school clothes for the week, tidying up, going to the supermarket, meal planning, made the kids meals, cleared up after them etc. I honestly don't think I'm being unreasonable to think he might say to the kids "right, we need to clear up after lunch, mums having a break today" and not need prompted to do it. But no. We have boys and I think it needs to be a better example for them as they grow up and become partners/husbands/fathers themselves and appreciate the value of the females in their lives. I'm not ungrateful, I'm just disappointed.

ohtoday · 10/03/2024 21:40

I made sure I expressed to my husband - when he spectacularly failed to do anything for Mother's Day last year (our baby's first) - exactly what I wanted. Lunch out, a cup of tea in bed, and a card. Maybe time to have a bath or do my nails.

I got nothing from him. Nada. Not even a card. He asked on Saturday "where do you want to go for lunch tomorrow?" As if less than 24hrs notice would work.

When the baby woke up this morning I asked if he could go to him and he said "why?". ITS MOTHERS DAY.

I have a 12 yr old from a previous marriage who has bought me a lovely body shop set with her pocket money and a card so all was not lost.

My expectations weren't high. He went out for lunch yesterday while I stayed at home with the baby who's been a bit snotty. I've been working so so so hard lately going back to work and I just wanted this one day to be about making me happy and relaxed. Absolutely devastated and so selfish on his part. I just feel so bloody unappreciated, lonely, and sad.

Cherrysherbet · 10/03/2024 21:13

I disagree.

I think we should know what our Mums like, and make the effort to give something appropriate.

It doesn’t have to be expensive. A card and some flowers that you know they like. This shouldn’t need to be communicated. If you have a decent relationship with your Mum, you should take an interest in what they like.

You shouldn’t need to spoon feed them every year.

tiktokontheclock · 10/03/2024 20:57

DH asks me what I want and I just tell him. Sometimes I fancy a meal out, mostly it's just some peace! agree it's strange these conversations don't happen but...I can also see it happening

HarrietSchulenberg · 10/03/2024 20:54

I agree. I gave my (older teenage and adult) children a list of things I would like and they took notice. Nothing expensive and ex-H helped the youngest one out with a tenner as he didn't have enough money. I am very pleased, not just with my gifts but with the fact that they listened to me.

Hufflemuff · 10/03/2024 20:51

I have always made sure that fathers day is a whole thing in our house for my DH. I buy him a present for about £40, we go out for breakfast then we have a takeaway for dinner. I make sure I'm in a lovely jovial mood, he doesn't have to do anything all day. He has this expectation for all this which I always make happen.

Today, aside from a present thrust at me, half heartedly (which I had to pick) my day has been exactly the same. I've gone to bed fucking hungry because I didn't want to cook and DH obviously CBA/decided he didn't want to buy me a takeaway. Probably too tight despite insisting this on "his days"

When Fathers Day comes around in June it will look very different to previous years. He can go and fuck himself.