Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked DH if he'd marry me again

258 replies

ChoccieEgg49 · 10/03/2024 12:28

Just that really.

We were chatting about couples in general. I asked him, if knowing what he knows now about me, would he still marry me and I'd still be his one (was hoping for a resounding 'yes!' here) he looked thoughtful for a minute, mulling over my question. Every millisecond stung my heart.

He said 'I do wish we had more in common like hobbies etc'. I said, ok, but that's not my question. Would you marry me if we rewound to the start?

He babbled on about how most couples just trundle along and its not like it is in the beginning etc. He spoke of people he knows who go hiking or to the gym together.

Tears stung my eyes.

It's really hurt.

I guess he's settled and he's not as happy as I thought. I've never been the gym bunny type, but we have a good life, travel, go out, laugh together. I'm a good wife, honest, trustworthy, cook blah blah. I can't help feeling now that I'm not enough. I've cried (not in front of him)

I wish I'd never even asked this question now. Maybe ignorance is bliss?

AIBU?

OP posts:
Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 14:37

Another example of a question like this is "if you won the lottery would you halve it with me/buy me a house in Hampstead".

Statistically, lottery winners' marriages tend to fail. The "honest" answer is probably "well chances are we'd blow most of it on divorce lawyers" or similar.

But you're never going to win the lottery so a better answer is "yes hun I'd fly us to the moon and build us a house there, now let's see what on telly".

Impossible questions deserve impossible answers

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 14:29

For people who say "it's important to be honest" about everything, please learn nuance, and think about the outcomes of your words.

There are certain questions that aren't looking for a long winded "honest" answer. The spirit of the question was a light hearted affectionate triviality.

Compare questions like "I made curry for tonight is that ok"
"Would you rather be a dog or a cat"
"Would you love me if I were a worm"
"Do you think Kim Kardashian's prettier than me"
"Will you still need me/feed me when I'm 64"

They're throwaway questions requiring throwaway answers. Respond yes dear, fine, no love, of course, cockatoo/kangaroo/Malibu, as required.

anareen · 10/03/2024 14:26

Lex345 · 10/03/2024 14:24

I think the way you take this depends on the context of the conversation before you asked.

You said you were chatting about couples in general-was this like "those two are so incompatible, they have nothing in common"?

Because then his answer makes sense.

Trouble here is you have asked a question you loaded with emotion; DH has given a logical answer.

What was it about the conversation you were having that made you need reassurance?

I would tell him-calmly-you feel upset by his answer-and why. He has probably no idea this has upset you.

Stoicism!

Bestyearever2024 · 10/03/2024 14:25

neverenoughplants · 10/03/2024 14:21

In some ways, it's not unreasonable to ask, as long as it's a genuine question and you acknowledge that you may hear an answer that you don't like.

If you ask a question where you've already decided that only a "yes" answer is acceptable or tolerable, then it isn't really a question - it's a test.

Exactly this ^

Also, if you think you're a good wife because you're honest, have a laugh and you cook.....well 🤣🙄

It's a shame you don't want to improve your marriage with this new information

Lex345 · 10/03/2024 14:24

I think the way you take this depends on the context of the conversation before you asked.

You said you were chatting about couples in general-was this like "those two are so incompatible, they have nothing in common"?

Because then his answer makes sense.

Trouble here is you have asked a question you loaded with emotion; DH has given a logical answer.

What was it about the conversation you were having that made you need reassurance?

I would tell him-calmly-you feel upset by his answer-and why. He has probably no idea this has upset you.

neverenoughplants · 10/03/2024 14:21

ChoccieEgg49 · 10/03/2024 12:39

Some are saying IABU to ask this question. I just wondered why you think that? Of course, I was looking for a big cuddle and "of course I'd marry you all over again"! I didn't expect the pause and negativity so that hurt. My own fault for asking I guess.

In some ways, it's not unreasonable to ask, as long as it's a genuine question and you acknowledge that you may hear an answer that you don't like.

If you ask a question where you've already decided that only a "yes" answer is acceptable or tolerable, then it isn't really a question - it's a test.

Iamnotawinp · 10/03/2024 14:19

It’s possible you just asked that question at the wrong time.

It sounds like the question of you not doing certain hobbies with him is a gripe of his. I’m sure you have similar ones about him.

But if you’d both just come back from doing something really fun together and had been having a lot of laughs and chat -his answer would probably been more in line what you hoped he’d say.

Perhaps reframe this and think of it as an opportunity for you to address this issue together. He may need to understand that couples not doing things together is perfectly normal for some couples. Or it may be that his current hobbies don’t interest you, but you both could find something that you like to do together.

Only you can know if his expectations are too high or yours aren’t high enough.

Wishimaywishimight · 10/03/2024 14:19

I think it was one of those random 'wonderings' that weren't meant to be taken too seriously or thought about too deeply.

OP was hoping for a lighthearted "of course I would" - if he had just done this it would all have passed over in seconds.

If DH asked me that question I would genuinely answer as above and that is truly how I feel however had I paused and really delved into it might I say I wish he enjoyed the same type of music as me or going to musical theatre shows or might he wish he could discuss his sports interests with me? Yes, we could but I don't think the question warranted such analysis when, at heart, I love him very much despite the fact we have different interests.

Iloveyoubut · 10/03/2024 14:14

OhmygodDont · 10/03/2024 12:34

Yabu to ask the question. Ask such a question and be prepared to be hurt.

It’s the same when parents admit if they could go back in time they wouldn’t have had any or as many children but they also love their children and wouldn’t actually change them for the world either. That they would have had them older or younger. But those same children then wouldn’t exist.

If I could go back in time I’d make many changes in my life but then actually that would change my whole life’s trajectory.

Your dh while not very thoughtful answered your silly question with a he just wished you had more in common. Maybe use that as a way to see if there are some of his hobbies you maybe interested in or if you could get him involved in any of yours. Sounds like he misses a shared adventure with you.

Your silly question? Wow.

Alwaystransforming · 10/03/2024 14:13

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 13:52

But that was not the time to bring up how he wants to do more hobbies with her. He turned a small thingy (joint hobbies) into a big existential problem about the marriage.

What was he hoping for - hoping op would start doing more hobbies, or hoping op's self esteem would be crushed?

Because if he was hoping for option A, there are far far better ways of going about it.

If he was hoping for option B (crushing op's self esteem), he did it great, spot on

Why is that not the time?

She asked a question. He answered it honestly. She set the time by asking.

It was a loaded question that only one response would have been acceptable. If you don’t want to hear what people say, don’t ask them a question about it.

Topicmanger · 10/03/2024 14:12

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 13:58

Can people honestly not see the difference?

Imagine op's dh one day started a new conversation "I was thinking, op, I wish we spent more time together on the weekends. Don't you think you might like playing golf if you tried?" - Nice, affectionate, hopefully effective.

Rather than as a response to "Honeybun, I'd marry you again, wouldn't you?" "Ahem, well, stwictly speaking if I'd known you'd never play croquet then I'd probably not bothered"

Ffs two completely different actions with entirely different outcomes.

Any joint croquet they play going forward would be tinged by sadness and guilty obligation.

Op, your husband is at worst cruel, at best an idiot

My God, I find this bitter interpretation absolute bonkers. Not to mention dishonest as the H never actually said what you are claiming.

OP, if you want to wreck you marriage, believe this poster's interpretation.

Toblerbone · 10/03/2024 14:11

Hi OP, YANBU to be feeling hurt, but as others have said I think you can turn this into a positive thing.

Have you heard of the love languages? His response makes me think that quality time together is his love language. Maybe you're more about words or actions?

You don't need to become a gym bunny but maybe use this as an opportunity to think about ways you can spend time together that will be enjoyable for both of you.

C1N1C · 10/03/2024 14:11

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 13:58

Can people honestly not see the difference?

Imagine op's dh one day started a new conversation "I was thinking, op, I wish we spent more time together on the weekends. Don't you think you might like playing golf if you tried?" - Nice, affectionate, hopefully effective.

Rather than as a response to "Honeybun, I'd marry you again, wouldn't you?" "Ahem, well, stwictly speaking if I'd known you'd never play croquet then I'd probably not bothered"

Ffs two completely different actions with entirely different outcomes.

Any joint croquet they play going forward would be tinged by sadness and guilty obligation.

Op, your husband is at worst cruel, at best an idiot

I disagree.

He literally JUST said that he wished they did more together.

-If he answered with a lie, he's being deceptive.
-If he answers with the truth, he's cruel or an idiot.

For all we know, he might have been suggesting rambles, cinema, archery... or whatever took his fancy, every day for the whole marriage. Maybe he goes out running daily, and OP has never asked whether she could join him.

I don't see how this is any different than any other 'affirmation' question...

"OP dear, I actually think you'd look better in the red dress"
vs
"DH, does my bum look big in this black dress?"...
... "Yes it does"

Because OP was asking with an expectation of positivity. She got the truth. I'm not sure how he could have answered it more tactfully either.

Topicmanger · 10/03/2024 14:09

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 13:52

But that was not the time to bring up how he wants to do more hobbies with her. He turned a small thingy (joint hobbies) into a big existential problem about the marriage.

What was he hoping for - hoping op would start doing more hobbies, or hoping op's self esteem would be crushed?

Because if he was hoping for option A, there are far far better ways of going about it.

If he was hoping for option B (crushing op's self esteem), he did it great, spot on

Sorry, I find it really hard to see the logic in this somewhat paranoid interpretation.

She asked a question that called on him to reflect on his feelings about the marriage. And he did. He answered in a positive way which expressed a desire to spend more time together.

opentoadvice88 · 10/03/2024 14:08

I think it’s a testament to your marriage that he felt he could give an honest answer.

Of course it’s upsetting but I would see it as a kick up the arse. He’s communicating what he’d like for a happier marriage and it’s up to you if you want to fulfil that.

DanielGault · 10/03/2024 14:07

ClutchingOurBananas · 10/03/2024 14:04

If you’d wanted to have a positive conversation on this kind of topic, it would be much better to go into it by telling your DH that you had been thinking and if you were to go back in time, you’d definitely marry him.

The thing about posing it as a question is that it feels like opening up a ‘we shouldn’t have married each other’ conversation. Anyone would pause and think in response to this kind of question.

Even that though is inviting a response of some sort. It's just a stupid conversation to have really. Unless you're planning on a divorce! No good can come of it really.

Gymnopedie · 10/03/2024 14:06

Imagine op's dh one day started a new conversation "I was thinking, op, I wish we spent more time together on the weekends. Don't you think you might like playing golf if you tried?" - Nice, affectionate, hopefully effective.

But given that the OP says she's not the gym bunny type, her answer could just as easily been 'no I know I wouldn't like it'. Would that be any more helpful than her DH's reaction here? Would she look at that answer from DH's pov?

ClutchingOurBananas · 10/03/2024 14:04

If you’d wanted to have a positive conversation on this kind of topic, it would be much better to go into it by telling your DH that you had been thinking and if you were to go back in time, you’d definitely marry him.

The thing about posing it as a question is that it feels like opening up a ‘we shouldn’t have married each other’ conversation. Anyone would pause and think in response to this kind of question.

Bunnyhair · 10/03/2024 14:01

Ouch. But yes, don’t ask a question if you are likely to be utterly crushed if you get anything but the one particular answer you want. You were fishing for something, you weren’t genuinely asking.

It doesn’t sound like he was being cruel. He was answering in good faith.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 10/03/2024 14:00

Wow I'm surprised by these responses, I think yanbu, it was a light hearted question and he way overthought it.

IMO it's the complete opposite. I think it's a pretty loaded question and it's actually quite manipulative to ask it.

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 13:58

Can people honestly not see the difference?

Imagine op's dh one day started a new conversation "I was thinking, op, I wish we spent more time together on the weekends. Don't you think you might like playing golf if you tried?" - Nice, affectionate, hopefully effective.

Rather than as a response to "Honeybun, I'd marry you again, wouldn't you?" "Ahem, well, stwictly speaking if I'd known you'd never play croquet then I'd probably not bothered"

Ffs two completely different actions with entirely different outcomes.

Any joint croquet they play going forward would be tinged by sadness and guilty obligation.

Op, your husband is at worst cruel, at best an idiot

OhmygodDont · 10/03/2024 13:56

So his the bad guy for answering…as his trying to destroy her self esteem.

Maybe if op wanted an ego boost she should have asked what does he love about her.

Nothing more tiring than those would you still love me if… would you still be with me if… if you could change one thing about us/me what would it be…

They are all questions designed to get your partner to just tell you how great you are, or feed you ammo to make them the problem or issue when they tell the truth but don’t like it.

Get the right answer doesn’t mean the partner means it. Get the wrong answer run off to friends / family about how horrible partner is because …. Or just be mopey and sulky and make partner feel bad for being honest and now they feel they must tiptoe around.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 10/03/2024 13:55

There are worse regrets that he could have expressed than not spending enough spare time with you. My husband loves hiking and would love me to go with him. If he was asked this I bet he would say something similar. But that doesn't mean he would rather be married to someone else just so that he could go hiking with them. We have a whole life together that he really values, and a whole world of shared jokes and interests. Just not... hiking.

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 13:52

Topicmanger · 10/03/2024 13:47

Staying married to you, but grinding down your self esteem, isn't good at all

Grinding her down by saying he'd like to spend more time with her doing things that they both enjoy together?

Gosh, her bloke really needs to work on his emotionally abusive bastard schtick doesn't he? Because he sucks at it.

This is an essentially a post saying, 'My H says he wants to spend more time with me, doing stuff we both like. I'm so hurt.'

I mean really!

I'm the first to call out a twatty H, but this man is not it.

But that was not the time to bring up how he wants to do more hobbies with her. He turned a small thingy (joint hobbies) into a big existential problem about the marriage.

What was he hoping for - hoping op would start doing more hobbies, or hoping op's self esteem would be crushed?

Because if he was hoping for option A, there are far far better ways of going about it.

If he was hoping for option B (crushing op's self esteem), he did it great, spot on

HarpieDuJour · 10/03/2024 13:51

My husband asks this sort of question reasonably often. Because I don't want to lie, I fudge the answer (I usually ask if it matters after 30 years of marriage, or give a suitably vague answer. If I think he might otherwise lose his temper, I joke about having to marry him because I loved his dog.). As it happens, I wouldn't marry him again, or even give him the time of day, and him getting all needy and demanding validation from me is hugely irritating.

However, if he had never abused me, lied to me or controlled me, then I would probably say "yes, but I do wish we did more together". OP, your husband sounds like a decent man, so you should be able to talk to him about this. He might be having doubts, but he might just have been irritated by the question, and you can only find out by asking him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread