Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked DH if he'd marry me again

258 replies

ChoccieEgg49 · 10/03/2024 12:28

Just that really.

We were chatting about couples in general. I asked him, if knowing what he knows now about me, would he still marry me and I'd still be his one (was hoping for a resounding 'yes!' here) he looked thoughtful for a minute, mulling over my question. Every millisecond stung my heart.

He said 'I do wish we had more in common like hobbies etc'. I said, ok, but that's not my question. Would you marry me if we rewound to the start?

He babbled on about how most couples just trundle along and its not like it is in the beginning etc. He spoke of people he knows who go hiking or to the gym together.

Tears stung my eyes.

It's really hurt.

I guess he's settled and he's not as happy as I thought. I've never been the gym bunny type, but we have a good life, travel, go out, laugh together. I'm a good wife, honest, trustworthy, cook blah blah. I can't help feeling now that I'm not enough. I've cried (not in front of him)

I wish I'd never even asked this question now. Maybe ignorance is bliss?

AIBU?

OP posts:
mydrivingisterrible · 10/03/2024 15:11

People are going to be unreasonably unpleasant on AIBU so don't mind some replies 😊

  1. It's a common sort of 'playful' question many partners ask, expecting a 'in a heartbeat' or some other romantic reply.
  1. Your husband answered honestly, but that was a shocking/unexpected truth and I'd have exactly the same emotional response as you.

I wonder if this bold face honesty can be used to improve things?

LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething · 10/03/2024 15:11

All these posters who think it's just crazy and unreasonable to expect one's husband will just say, "of course!"

Sad.

YANBU but I'd give him the benefit of the doubt in that he thought you were actually looking for an in-depth assessment of your relationship. That he's basically come up with wanting to spend more time with you doing things he thinks are fun is no bad thing, really, but I'd gently bring up with him later today that you were actually looking for a bit of affection and reassurance, and could you have some now, please inexchange for coming on his bloody outdoorsy trips ?!

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 15:08

Topicmanger · 10/03/2024 15:06

If he'd gone all serious and gave "honest" analytical answers about how lack of sleep depletes collagen etc, it wouldn't have matched the spirit of my question at all

I would suggest that your interpretation is not matching the spirit of his answer. He answer was saying he would like them to spend more time together doing joint stuff, and your interpretation is, 'HE'S CRUEL! HE WANTS TO DESTROY YOUR ESTEEM, OP.'

Its you who is not reading the room here, not him.

I think the outcome speaks for itself.

Tears came to her eyes. Every millisecond hurt.

He's misjudged his response for sure

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 15:07

Alwaystransforming · 10/03/2024 15:05

Yes I know it’s an old meme taking the piss out of insecure women. And the point of the meme was that the boyfriend wasn’t doing anything wrong by answering honestly.

Of course your dh might communicate differently to me. We are all individuals. I would imagine I have nothing in common with your dh, so no reason to think I would communicate the same way. That was my point. Not everyone communicates the same way.

and if you only communicate in a way that suits you and not the person you are communicating with, these things will happen. Which is what happened here. Op was looking for something she felt she needed at that moment. He answered the actual question she asked.

Really? I felt the point of the meme was how they both hilariously took the question too seriously

Topicmanger · 10/03/2024 15:06

If he'd gone all serious and gave "honest" analytical answers about how lack of sleep depletes collagen etc, it wouldn't have matched the spirit of my question at all

I would suggest that your interpretation is not matching the spirit of his answer. He answer was saying he would like them to spend more time together doing joint stuff, and your interpretation is, 'HE'S CRUEL! HE WANTS TO DESTROY YOUR ESTEEM, OP.'

Its you who is not reading the room here, not him.

Longdarkcloud · 10/03/2024 15:06

Tell DH you’ve been thinking about what he said and are wondering if there was a new interest/hobby that you could both take up. Or maybe you have a hobby he might like to try.
Provided you’re both fit you could take up walking and birdwatching or history and visiting historic places. Genealogy includes several areas of interest and we all have DNA and a family.
Use this as a way to improve your relationship — better than him one day saying we no longer have anything in common.

Alwaystransforming · 10/03/2024 15:05

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 14:58

Well I guess my dh is a different type than you - that's why I married him. I know he knows I just need a throwaway answer.

Op's dh just can't "read the room".

The worm thing isn't something I made up, it's an old meme

Yes I know it’s an old meme taking the piss out of insecure women. And the point of the meme was that the boyfriend wasn’t doing anything wrong by answering honestly.

Of course your dh might communicate differently to me. We are all individuals. I would imagine I have nothing in common with your dh, so no reason to think I would communicate the same way. That was my point. Not everyone communicates the same way.

and if you only communicate in a way that suits you and not the person you are communicating with, these things will happen. Which is what happened here. Op was looking for something she felt she needed at that moment. He answered the actual question she asked.

ViciousCurrentBun · 10/03/2024 15:04

It can be a problem for some people if they don’t do things together especially after children have grown up.

We enjoy hiking, games and crosswords and quizzes. Maybe for some it’s not an issue but it would always have been an issue for me. Because that’s how I want to spend my spare time.

FictionalCharacter · 10/03/2024 15:03

ChoccieEgg49 · 10/03/2024 12:39

Some are saying IABU to ask this question. I just wondered why you think that? Of course, I was looking for a big cuddle and "of course I'd marry you all over again"! I didn't expect the pause and negativity so that hurt. My own fault for asking I guess.

I don't think yabu. I'm sure most of us would think he'd say "of course I would".

user1492757084 · 10/03/2024 15:00

No wonder you were hurt. Take it on the chin.

Buy your selves some hiking boots.
Also start doing something that you have thought you'd like to do together. Be it sauna and swim, ballroom dancing, or water colours.

Why is it, do you think, that DH has never suggested, hiking?

Hoplolly · 10/03/2024 15:00

If my DH asked that question he knows what answer he'd get!

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 14:58

Alwaystransforming · 10/03/2024 14:54

That’s not how communication works.

Thats how communication works when you think everyone thinks like you.

Some of us, hate being asked questions that aren’t questions. Some of us don’t like hints for compliments. Because we either don’t pick up on or might compliment the wrong thing.

Why is it up to one group of people to just know what to say when we are asked questions that aren’t questions. Why do they need to play along? Why isn’t it up to the other person to not ask an open question if there is only one exact answer that will be accepted?

I genuinely couldn’t be arsed with having conversations like ‘would you love me if I was worm/kangeroo etc?’. That’s something a child would say.

This was a test. Except he didn’t know.

Well I guess my dh is a different type than you - that's why I married him. I know he knows I just need a throwaway answer.

Op's dh just can't "read the room".

The worm thing isn't something I made up, it's an old meme

Bobbotgegrinch · 10/03/2024 14:58

Spectacularly stupid question to ask.

Never ask a question that you don't want an honest answer to.

Dibilnik · 10/03/2024 14:57

ChoccieEgg49 · 10/03/2024 12:39

Some are saying IABU to ask this question. I just wondered why you think that? Of course, I was looking for a big cuddle and "of course I'd marry you all over again"! I didn't expect the pause and negativity so that hurt. My own fault for asking I guess.

How hurtful OP, it's opened up a can of worms hasn't it.

It's the sort of thing I ask DH now and then just because I enjoy the answer so much.

I think you need to ask him again how much store you should set by it, though. He might have been coming at it all kinds of angles, e.g. ... he loves you and couldn't possibly imagine life without you, even though you might not be the obvious choice based on hobbies and interests.

He might be appalled to know you think he's "settled."

Or he might hope you will share more interests with him.

Or, worst case scenario, you don't quite have the intimacy you thought you had.

Knowing the truth, whatever it is, is only going to help you create a brighter future, so try not to be afraid and ask him.

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 14:56

LolaSmiles · 10/03/2024 14:44

Mumoftwo1312
None of those are comparable to a trick gotcha question asking your spouse what OP did.
Asking your spouse if they'd love you as a worm is funny.
Asking a spouse if they'd still marry you knowing what they know about you now is inviting them to reflect on the relationship and on the surface is a reflective question.

Though personally I don't think the Kim Kardashian question is funny/lighthearted either. Personally I think that's also fishing for compliments in a manipulative way and I'd be willing to be that the man in that situation wouldn't be able to win because only a very insecure woman would do that sort of thing. If he says "no you're the most beautiful woman that's ever existed and I never notice anyone's attractiveness" then she'll probably accuse him of lying. If he says that KK is attractive then she'll probably sulk and claim he's really hurt her feelings.

Unfortunately when insecure people ask fishing questions in the hope they get the response they want, there's a chance their partners aren't going to mind read and play the game "correctly".

I'd hate to feel like DH was testing me all the time. It would be exhausting.

I just don't think it's that deep honestly. Calling these questions manipulation, even the Kardashian one, is way overthinking it.

I've recently asked dh idly, when I was looking in the mirror getting ready "do you think I'm still young-looking or have I really aged since having the kids" and he replied without looking up "young definitely, not a day over 21"

A separate time I was looking at photos on my phone and there was one from before we had kids and I showed him and laughingly asked if he recognised us and he laughed and said we'd aged 10 years in 5. (I agreed.)

That's what spouses do. I know he was joking both times. I don't even need a literal answer, I'm just making idle chit chat.

If he'd gone all serious and gave "honest" analytical answers about how lack of sleep depletes collagen etc, it wouldn't have matched the spirit of my question at all.

Alwaystransforming · 10/03/2024 14:56

SwordToFlamethrower · 10/03/2024 14:42

I just asked my dh of 4 years (10 years altogether) if he'd marry me again and he didn't pause for a millisecond, he just grinned and said "yes!!!"

That's what married couples should say! That's what OP was expecting, so he has been hiding his true feelings from OP, and that is not fair!

I'm sorry for you OP. Maybe he needs to work on your marriage if he has a problem, instead of hiding.

But now everyone wants to give it recover an answer that is simply one that said ‘because that’s what married couples should say’.

Alwaystransforming · 10/03/2024 14:54

Mumoftwo1312 · 10/03/2024 14:29

For people who say "it's important to be honest" about everything, please learn nuance, and think about the outcomes of your words.

There are certain questions that aren't looking for a long winded "honest" answer. The spirit of the question was a light hearted affectionate triviality.

Compare questions like "I made curry for tonight is that ok"
"Would you rather be a dog or a cat"
"Would you love me if I were a worm"
"Do you think Kim Kardashian's prettier than me"
"Will you still need me/feed me when I'm 64"

They're throwaway questions requiring throwaway answers. Respond yes dear, fine, no love, of course, cockatoo/kangaroo/Malibu, as required.

That’s not how communication works.

Thats how communication works when you think everyone thinks like you.

Some of us, hate being asked questions that aren’t questions. Some of us don’t like hints for compliments. Because we either don’t pick up on or might compliment the wrong thing.

Why is it up to one group of people to just know what to say when we are asked questions that aren’t questions. Why do they need to play along? Why isn’t it up to the other person to not ask an open question if there is only one exact answer that will be accepted?

I genuinely couldn’t be arsed with having conversations like ‘would you love me if I was worm/kangeroo etc?’. That’s something a child would say.

This was a test. Except he didn’t know.

SignoraVolpe · 10/03/2024 14:53

SwordToFlamethrower · 10/03/2024 14:42

I just asked my dh of 4 years (10 years altogether) if he'd marry me again and he didn't pause for a millisecond, he just grinned and said "yes!!!"

That's what married couples should say! That's what OP was expecting, so he has been hiding his true feelings from OP, and that is not fair!

I'm sorry for you OP. Maybe he needs to work on your marriage if he has a problem, instead of hiding.

Me too.
Dh and I have little in common.
He’s sporty and a foodie. I’m not.
When I asked him he said ‘Of course I would.’
FWIW we’ve been married 40 years.

Everythinggreen · 10/03/2024 14:53

Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
Real life isn't the staged, pre planned Tik Toks of married couples relentlessly fawning over each other like teenagers.

LuluBlakey1 · 10/03/2024 14:49

I asked DH - he didn't say anything romantic either, just 'I told you when I proposed, you're stuck with me for good. Thick and thin and all that.' He did smile. 🙄

DustyLee123 · 10/03/2024 14:46

After 30 years of marriage I’d say no, I’d not marry him again. But if you’d asked me 10+ years ago I’d have said yes. And if I’d not married him I wouldn’t have my kids.
The answer now is very different to 10/20/27years ago.

LolaSmiles · 10/03/2024 14:44

Mumoftwo1312
None of those are comparable to a trick gotcha question asking your spouse what OP did.
Asking your spouse if they'd love you as a worm is funny.
Asking a spouse if they'd still marry you knowing what they know about you now is inviting them to reflect on the relationship and on the surface is a reflective question.

Though personally I don't think the Kim Kardashian question is funny/lighthearted either. Personally I think that's also fishing for compliments in a manipulative way and I'd be willing to be that the man in that situation wouldn't be able to win because only a very insecure woman would do that sort of thing. If he says "no you're the most beautiful woman that's ever existed and I never notice anyone's attractiveness" then she'll probably accuse him of lying. If he says that KK is attractive then she'll probably sulk and claim he's really hurt her feelings.

Unfortunately when insecure people ask fishing questions in the hope they get the response they want, there's a chance their partners aren't going to mind read and play the game "correctly".

I'd hate to feel like DH was testing me all the time. It would be exhausting.

SwordToFlamethrower · 10/03/2024 14:42

I just asked my dh of 4 years (10 years altogether) if he'd marry me again and he didn't pause for a millisecond, he just grinned and said "yes!!!"

That's what married couples should say! That's what OP was expecting, so he has been hiding his true feelings from OP, and that is not fair!

I'm sorry for you OP. Maybe he needs to work on your marriage if he has a problem, instead of hiding.

Flickersy · 10/03/2024 14:41

I have definitely read this OP before. Quite a while ago I think....

thebestinterest · 10/03/2024 14:37

😂😭

This is like going through a partners phone… don’t do it unless you want to find something to be upset about.