Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked DH if he'd marry me again

258 replies

ChoccieEgg49 · 10/03/2024 12:28

Just that really.

We were chatting about couples in general. I asked him, if knowing what he knows now about me, would he still marry me and I'd still be his one (was hoping for a resounding 'yes!' here) he looked thoughtful for a minute, mulling over my question. Every millisecond stung my heart.

He said 'I do wish we had more in common like hobbies etc'. I said, ok, but that's not my question. Would you marry me if we rewound to the start?

He babbled on about how most couples just trundle along and its not like it is in the beginning etc. He spoke of people he knows who go hiking or to the gym together.

Tears stung my eyes.

It's really hurt.

I guess he's settled and he's not as happy as I thought. I've never been the gym bunny type, but we have a good life, travel, go out, laugh together. I'm a good wife, honest, trustworthy, cook blah blah. I can't help feeling now that I'm not enough. I've cried (not in front of him)

I wish I'd never even asked this question now. Maybe ignorance is bliss?

AIBU?

OP posts:
Dibilnik · 10/03/2024 18:09

I think it's sad how many PPs think a wife should never ask this question because she might not like the answer 🤦🏻‍♀️

Megifer · 10/03/2024 18:09

Alwaystransforming · 10/03/2024 18:01

Did he say marrying her was a mistake and he regretted it?

I think he has very strongly alluded to that tbh.

So anyway, is it OK for me to say that to my kid? If I mealy mouthed it a bit like ops DH maybe and paused considering my response, and said "well it's true that when DC come along your life changes and you can't do things you want to....."

That ok?

DrJoanAllenby · 10/03/2024 18:07

Poor bloke can't win. If he had gushed over you he would be a liar but he told you the truth.

Damned either way.

Getting tearful was manipulative as you instigated the situation by asking him and then didn't like his reply!

drowninginsick · 10/03/2024 18:07

ChoccieEgg49 · 10/03/2024 12:39

Some are saying IABU to ask this question. I just wondered why you think that? Of course, I was looking for a big cuddle and "of course I'd marry you all over again"! I didn't expect the pause and negativity so that hurt. My own fault for asking I guess.

Well that's the problem then!! You should have just gone in for a cuddle. If I was asked this question I would answer thoughtfully.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 10/03/2024 18:04

Megifer · 10/03/2024 17:58

So just so I'm clear, if my DC ask me if I'd have kids again if I could go back in time, it would be OK for me to say "well you were a mistake that I regretted at the start, so it wouldn't happen again anyway as I'd be more careful next time"?

That's OK isn't it? It's honest.

It's hardly comparable, is it?

Epidote · 10/03/2024 18:03

You asked the questions, he didn't want to answer it and you insisted. YABU.

Alwaystransforming · 10/03/2024 18:01

Megifer · 10/03/2024 17:58

So just so I'm clear, if my DC ask me if I'd have kids again if I could go back in time, it would be OK for me to say "well you were a mistake that I regretted at the start, so it wouldn't happen again anyway as I'd be more careful next time"?

That's OK isn't it? It's honest.

Did he say marrying her was a mistake and he regretted it?

Megifer · 10/03/2024 17:58

So just so I'm clear, if my DC ask me if I'd have kids again if I could go back in time, it would be OK for me to say "well you were a mistake that I regretted at the start, so it wouldn't happen again anyway as I'd be more careful next time"?

That's OK isn't it? It's honest.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 10/03/2024 17:52

Megifer · 10/03/2024 17:49

Oh sorry, that was an example of tact, not that I really think "does my arse look big in this" is the same as "would you marry me again" 🤣

Fwiw I think he should have said yes in the moment (assuming he didn't want to hurt his wife....maybe he did?), told op it's a daft question, then address any unhappiness another time.

What he's done here whether he realises it or not is he really has just told op "no I wouldn't have married you again because we don't now go to the gym together".

Ah, I got you Grin

I do agree he should have been more tactful but in his mind, he probably just thinks he was answering her question lol.

He didn't say yes or no, he just said he'd prefer it if X happened more. I don't think that's as hurtful as it's being made to be, it just doesn't give OP the nice fuzzy feeling she wanted when she asked.

Stuckinthemiddle7890 · 10/03/2024 17:49

Lampslights · 10/03/2024 17:39

Don’t be daft 😂 the poster and no one else is saying you shouldn’t want a good answer, or that you shouldn’t get upset if told the truth. The nuance is don’t as, if you’re not prepared to hear what you don’t want to hear.

however. My opinion is you should want to hear the truth.

You literally just confirmed what I said🤦‍♀️ and I'm not daft thanks.

Megifer · 10/03/2024 17:49

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 10/03/2024 17:38

I think you're comparing apples and oranges, tbh. Talking about whether you'd still have married your partner isn't remotely the same as asking "does my bum look big in this".

To me, "Would you still have married me if you knew what you know now" isn't the lighthearted question OP (and others) are trying to make it out to be. It's pretty loaded and let's be honest, there's only one acceptable answer so if your answer is anything but "yes, of course" then you're put into a really difficult situation.

I know what people are saying when they say "oh, he should have just said yes" but I don't think I would want my husband to say "oh of course dear" just to shut me up or make me feel better.

But then again, I find that kind of question incredibly annoying and if DH ever said it to me, I'd probably say "no, I'd have buried you under the patio before the wedding ceremony".

Oh sorry, that was an example of tact, not that I really think "does my arse look big in this" is the same as "would you marry me again" 🤣

Fwiw I think he should have said yes in the moment (assuming he didn't want to hurt his wife....maybe he did?), told op it's a daft question, then address any unhappiness another time.

What he's done here whether he realises it or not is he really has just told op "no I wouldn't have married you again because we don't now go to the gym together".

Fofftwenty21 · 10/03/2024 17:47

YABU don't ask questions if you don't want an honest answer.

Could you listen to what he is saying instead that we wants you to share more interests and do more things together and work on that?

doneandone · 10/03/2024 17:45

How long have you been married and do you have children? If not married long with no children id consider divorce. I wouldn't want to be with someone who regretted marrying me. Sorry op Flowers

BeretRaspberry · 10/03/2024 17:40

SchoolQuestionnaire · 10/03/2024 13:09

I don’t actually agree with the majority here. I probably feel a similar way about my dh as your dh does about you op. I love physical activity and being outdoors. I run, walk, ride my bike and workout regularly. Dh will come under sufferance occasionally but it’s not his thing. I would prefer it if we did more together and had more shared interests but I would marry him again tomorrow. 20+ years on and he is my biggest supporter and still makes me laugh more than anyone else. I can do my hobbies with anyone but I couldn’t find another him.

I agree with this. I’ve asked my husband and he’s asked me periodically over the years. Usually around our anniversary where we’ve been reminiscing and I or he has said something like ‘would you do it all again?’.

We also do separate things, more so because I have chronic illnesses and I’m restricted. There’s nothing more that I want than us being able to do more together. It certainly doesn’t mean I wouldn’t marry him again.

I don’t understand why OP’s husband couldn’t answer yes (because surely if he wants to spend more time with her then he can’t be wanting out of the marriage). If necessary he could have brought it up at another point.

Lampslights · 10/03/2024 17:39

Stuckinthemiddle7890 · 10/03/2024 17:34

Oh please! As if we don't or can't ask questions like that, of course we want a good answer ! And if the answer isn't good then yes some ppl get upset.

Don’t be daft 😂 the poster and no one else is saying you shouldn’t want a good answer, or that you shouldn’t get upset if told the truth. The nuance is don’t as, if you’re not prepared to hear what you don’t want to hear.

however. My opinion is you should want to hear the truth.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 10/03/2024 17:38

Megifer · 10/03/2024 17:33

But he could have used another time to bring up the fact that not going for hikes/whatever together upsets him to the point he wouldn't marry op again. Is it so odd to want a bit of tact and diplomacy in a relationship? That's different to being lied to.

Unless of course he does genuinely mean "no I wouldn't have married you had I known we wouldn't be hiking together in 20 years time but here we are now so let's just drudge on" (in which case op tbf I'd be tempted to let himself hike honestly out the door)

My dp is a dickhead at times but christ even he can manage a "I think the other one is much nicer on you" when I ask him if my arse looks big in a certain dress.

I think you're comparing apples and oranges, tbh. Talking about whether you'd still have married your partner isn't remotely the same as asking "does my bum look big in this".

To me, "Would you still have married me if you knew what you know now" isn't the lighthearted question OP (and others) are trying to make it out to be. It's pretty loaded and let's be honest, there's only one acceptable answer so if your answer is anything but "yes, of course" then you're put into a really difficult situation.

I know what people are saying when they say "oh, he should have just said yes" but I don't think I would want my husband to say "oh of course dear" just to shut me up or make me feel better.

But then again, I find that kind of question incredibly annoying and if DH ever said it to me, I'd probably say "no, I'd have buried you under the patio before the wedding ceremony".

Stuckinthemiddle7890 · 10/03/2024 17:34

TinyGingerCat · 10/03/2024 12:37

YABU Don't ask questions you don't want the answer to.

Oh please! As if we don't or can't ask questions like that, of course we want a good answer ! And if the answer isn't good then yes some ppl get upset.

Megifer · 10/03/2024 17:33

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 10/03/2024 17:21

Because OP seemingly just wanted a nice "yes, of course darling" - she didn't want to actually hear the reality. So if he'd given her the answer she wanted, he'd have been lying to her.

Asking these questions rarely ever ends well, especially if you're really just fishing for compliments.

But he could have used another time to bring up the fact that not going for hikes/whatever together upsets him to the point he wouldn't marry op again. Is it so odd to want a bit of tact and diplomacy in a relationship? That's different to being lied to.

Unless of course he does genuinely mean "no I wouldn't have married you had I known we wouldn't be hiking together in 20 years time but here we are now so let's just drudge on" (in which case op tbf I'd be tempted to let himself hike honestly out the door)

My dp is a dickhead at times but christ even he can manage a "I think the other one is much nicer on you" when I ask him if my arse looks big in a certain dress.

OhmygodDont · 10/03/2024 17:32

Yeahno · 10/03/2024 17:28

I think most married couples would prefer to the "yes, of course darling" or something similar. Not sure why is the OP wrong to be upset.

She’s not wrong to be upset she’s wrong for asking such a teenager type question. Might of well of asked him the would you love me if I was a worm.

Its nonsense.

DanielGault · 10/03/2024 17:30

Brawcolli · 10/03/2024 16:57

You’re not being unreasonable, what’s unreasonable is all the people piling on to tell you how silly you are for asking what you thought was just a fun question! Of course you aren’t ’fishing’ or asking him to lie, how ridiculous.

Well it didn't turn out to be that much fun, did it!

Yeahno · 10/03/2024 17:28

I think most married couples would prefer to the "yes, of course darling" or something similar. Not sure why is the OP wrong to be upset.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 10/03/2024 17:21

Yeahno · 10/03/2024 17:18

Not sure what all that talk of lying is about. If the OPs husband meant no, then she is right to be upset. If he said yes but let's work on these issues, that would have been better. He didn't have to lie

Because OP seemingly just wanted a nice "yes, of course darling" - she didn't want to actually hear the reality. So if he'd given her the answer she wanted, he'd have been lying to her.

Asking these questions rarely ever ends well, especially if you're really just fishing for compliments.

slippedonabanana · 10/03/2024 17:18

Your husband didn't say that he'd marry you again. He couldn't say 'yes'. It's perfectly normal to be upset by that especially if you didn't know that was how he felt. Nobody wants to be with someone who'd pass on marrying them again.

You need to discuss it more to see where to go from here.

Yeahno · 10/03/2024 17:18

Not sure what all that talk of lying is about. If the OPs husband meant no, then she is right to be upset. If he said yes but let's work on these issues, that would have been better. He didn't have to lie

Shesmyhero · 10/03/2024 17:12

ChoccieEgg49 · 10/03/2024 12:39

Some are saying IABU to ask this question. I just wondered why you think that? Of course, I was looking for a big cuddle and "of course I'd marry you all over again"! I didn't expect the pause and negativity so that hurt. My own fault for asking I guess.

But... the fact you were hoping for this suggests to me you are wanting some affection/reassurance from him you currently don't get. You are concerned now he has not said he is overwhelmingly happy....but are you overwhelmingly happy? I'd take a punt that most people would not ask this question of their partners... something triggered you to ask this question - I am guessing you are feeling a certain way but only you can be honest with yourself and ask yourself the question....why did you ask this question? What was I feeling at the time? What response did I want and why did I want it?