Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is being successful frowned upon by most on Mumsnet

316 replies

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 10:03

I have been/seen on some threads that people, are negative towards those that have become successful, children go to private school means the kids are entitled.

Why can't we celebrate that some people get lucky with an idea, take risks, work incredibly hard and pay their fair share on taxes.

I have seen people demand that the OP gives their profits to charity without even knowing what the OP gives to charity.

We need to celebrate all in society.

OP posts:
Itscatsallthewaydown · 10/03/2024 11:33

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 11:31

This poster just confirms everything.

They don’t though, do they? Just reinforces your own prejudices

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 11:32

midgetastic · 10/03/2024 11:30

Bragging and conspicuous consumption are not generally something the UK as a whole considers nice

I guess because it can lead naturally to jealously and envy and other emotions that don't make a coherent society

Because no one likes to feel that the other person considers themselves superior to you - that's something that should be driven by respect not demanded

Where has anyone every said that they are superior to others?

OP posts:
Teenangels · 10/03/2024 11:31

whistleblower99 · 10/03/2024 11:27

Thus proving the point of the op and what I’ve said. These people are the majority on mn now. Literally spending all day going on threads which really aren’t relevant to them to make themselves angry. They are like volunteer forum police spending all day trying to pull down people different to them. Saying they shouldn’t be posting. The irony is strong.

This poster just confirms everything.

OP posts:
ntmdino · 10/03/2024 11:31

MobileStationery · 10/03/2024 11:26

That 10 million figure is VERY misleading I think.
It includes students... And the sick.. and CARERS FFS.

It's a stupid figure that tells a different story than the actual facts of it.

Which brings up another point, that in a properly civilised society there would be no need for family to be full-time carers of the sick.

midgetastic · 10/03/2024 11:30

Bragging and conspicuous consumption are not generally something the UK as a whole considers nice

I guess because it can lead naturally to jealously and envy and other emotions that don't make a coherent society

Because no one likes to feel that the other person considers themselves superior to you - that's something that should be driven by respect not demanded

Itscatsallthewaydown · 10/03/2024 11:29

whistleblower99 · 10/03/2024 11:27

Thus proving the point of the op and what I’ve said. These people are the majority on mn now. Literally spending all day going on threads which really aren’t relevant to them to make themselves angry. They are like volunteer forum police spending all day trying to pull down people different to them. Saying they shouldn’t be posting. The irony is strong.

See under the dictionary definition of ‘hyperbole’

InterIgnis · 10/03/2024 11:29

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 11:26

The irony lol.

In a thread about the subject?

Itscatsallthewaydown · 10/03/2024 11:28

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 11:06

😂

Honestly

🤷‍♀️If the cap fits I suppose.

We’re either a hotbed of snarling revolutionaries surrounding the guillotine, or we’re not particularly keen on smugness, entitlement, or demanding respect because someone’s made a few bob. My money is on the latter.

MotherofGorgons · 10/03/2024 11:28

It doesn't matter for what reasons they are not working. The effect on the economy is the same.

Alcyoneus · 10/03/2024 11:28

It’s also the lack of imagination, that’s astounding. On the high earner threads, you get people sneering at high earning women saying it can’t possibly be true, they are making it up, they are fantasists.

It takes a special level of closed mindedness and low expectations to think that anyone saying they earn 6 figures must be lying.

Or when someone starts a thread saying they have 27p in savings and would like to invest, asking for advice. Oh, well, what audacity. How dare they come on here flaunting their wealth when some people cannot afford to eat.

Or if someone says they want to get a cleaner to free up some time. Well, how elitist and pretentious. Don’t they have any humility.

Such pathetic attitudes.

whistleblower99 · 10/03/2024 11:27

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 11:25

So millions of retired, disabled and carers who may be unable to work don't exist?

Edited

Thus proving the point of the op and what I’ve said. These people are the majority on mn now. Literally spending all day going on threads which really aren’t relevant to them to make themselves angry. They are like volunteer forum police spending all day trying to pull down people different to them. Saying they shouldn’t be posting. The irony is strong.

MobileStationery · 10/03/2024 11:26

midgetastic · 10/03/2024 11:22

So 10 million working age people are not working

Some because they have worked hard and been lucky and retired early so self funded

Some because they can't get a job that pays as much as the childcare would cost

Sone because they are illl, in pain, waiting for surgery , waiting for mental health support

And a small number who are happy to live off benefits

That 10 million figure is VERY misleading I think.
It includes students... And the sick.. and CARERS FFS.

It's a stupid figure that tells a different story than the actual facts of it.

Why is being successful frowned upon by most on Mumsnet
Sparklesocks · 10/03/2024 11:26

easylikeasundaymorn · 10/03/2024 10:49

100% agree with your second example. Even when they don't say so explicitly and it's more of a 'we earn xxx but we work hard for that,' (with the implication that social workers and carers on a tenth of that wage just sit around chilling all day.)

Same as all the 'how much do you earn' threads where people genuinely say they could not live on less than (large amount) a year, when what of course they mean is they could not lead their current lifestyle on less than that. It does come across as out of touch and unfeeling.

But with the first example - MN is a huge site with hundreds of thousands (more?) users - people who are better off, and asking about things like private school fees/stables/nannies are presumably hoping from input from others in the same position, of which there will, due to the size of the site, be many. Unless MN sets up a 'income of over £100,000' only board, there's no way of targeting a post just at others with the same income as you that won't be offended or upset. What I don't understand is why (and this applies to many topics on mn not just money) people bother clicking, and then posting on a topic that isn't relevant to them. If I see a post complaining about the au pair not doing the cleaning or the cost of this year's school ski trip, I just think 'nice problem to have,' and click on something that's more relevant/interesting to me. I don't see the point of jumping on castigating the OP for their privilege etc.
There should be a big header at the top of every topic saying "BTW you don't HAVE to comment on every single post you read."

Of course, but it works both ways surely? As you say MN posters are not a monolith, and are all from different backgrounds/incomes etc, so if you start a thread hoping for sympathy about your rising stable costs/school fees/nanny fees - you will get a range of responses and some of those will be users who can’t relate.

And sometimes maybe views from others might put things in perspective. You could argue ‘don’t reply if it’s not relevant to you’ and absolutely I agree, I’ve seen people who outright say they’ve never breastfed replying earnestly with breastfeeding advice on threads 😄 But equally if you post a very specific issue/lifestyle problem on a very generalised board like AIBU (which is literally a board for asking people if you’re in the right about something) - you have to expect all sorts of responses.

MotherofGorgons · 10/03/2024 11:26

We need to be super supportive of women who earn a lot, given all the posts about abuse, physical or mental. Often comments on here are like " I preferred to spend time with my DC" or " You must be lying because I don't know anyone who earns over £50 k".

Someone needs to be paying those taxes also if £10 m are going to be paying nothing.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 11:26

InterIgnis · 10/03/2024 11:25

Not really. They don’t need to acknowledge the unrelated and thus irrelevant situations of others in some weird act of appeasement. Not everything has to be about you and/or what you consider important.

The irony lol.

InterIgnis · 10/03/2024 11:25

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 11:21

But it depends on the wording of the initial thread really. If there is clear insight but they acknowledge that and seek advice fair enough. If they are completely tone deaf then they may deserve to get their arse handed to them.

Edited

Not really. They don’t need to acknowledge the unrelated and thus irrelevant situations of others in some weird act of appeasement. Not everything has to be about you and/or what you consider important.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 11:25

Alcyoneus · 10/03/2024 11:19

Well, yes. It’s an indicator of people wanting to haul themselves out of bed for almost 40 hours to try and earn and crust.

When almost 10 million working age people don’t.

So millions of retired, disabled and carers who may be unable to work don't exist?

EvelynBeatrice · 10/03/2024 11:24

There's some truth behind the old saying ' An American looks admiringly at a man in a fabulous car driving by and thinks one day I'll have one of those ... a Brit looks at the same car and thinks why should he have that...'

Helfs · 10/03/2024 11:22

Jealousy

You can see it in the threads where people work in flexible roles and don’t need to work their full hours every week, or can be super flexible regarding their hours or location - loads of posters seem to find that an issue too!

midgetastic · 10/03/2024 11:22

So 10 million working age people are not working

Some because they have worked hard and been lucky and retired early so self funded

Some because they can't get a job that pays as much as the childcare would cost

Sone because they are illl, in pain, waiting for surgery , waiting for mental health support

And a small number who are happy to live off benefits

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 11:21

InterIgnis · 10/03/2024 10:54

The nerve that finds it tedious seeing the same drums being banged every time someone starts a thread about struggling as a higher earner? Sure.

When people are suddenly finding themselves, through no fault of their own, struggling to afford the lifestyle that they could previously easily afford, of course they’ll take issue with that. That other people have less doesn’t negate this being a problem for those with more. They should be able to post about their own experiences/ask for advice without having to pander to the sensibilities of those who just want them to shut up. People post about plenty of things I have no interest in/can’t relate to, but funnily enough I don’t go into those threads and make them about me.

But it depends on the wording of the initial thread really. If there is clear insight but they acknowledge that and seek advice fair enough. If they are completely tone deaf then they may deserve to get their arse handed to them.

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 11:20

WickerMam · 10/03/2024 10:57

I think people get annoyed mainly when posters don't acknowledge the privilege they have.

E.g. I grew up in a council house, and am now doing pretty well. Yes, I worked hard. But I also had supportive parents, and a natural ability for academic learning. Massive advantages.

Many successful people "took risks". All the risk takers I know are well aware that their parents would cover their mortgage if they were about to default. So risking £££££ in a business knowing there is no chance of you going hungry is less "risky" than giving up a minimum wage job to retrain, if you have no fall back.

It's fine to be successful - it's not fine to think it makes you better than anyone else.

My husband grow up in a council house, left school at 15, and we took a huge risk and knew that we had no one to pay the mortgage and we would go hungry if it did not work out.

OP posts:
Alcyoneus · 10/03/2024 11:19

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 11:15

Well no. Not working full time is no indicator of success or political leanings really. Also disagreeing with a position doesn't equate to being envious of it. You appear to be making huge assumptions about things you can't possibly know.

Well, yes. It’s an indicator of people wanting to haul themselves out of bed for almost 40 hours to try and earn and crust.

When almost 10 million working age people don’t.

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/03/2024 11:19

Quite a lot to unpack here:

Theres definitely a culture of chippiness about people who earn good money. You see this manifesting in the threads where people express incredulity that a woman can earn over £100k or have her own property, it actually makes me realise how little progress there’s been in equality.

There’s definitely an element of good old British tall poppy syndrome in which people don’t like being confronted with others success.

On the other hand the way some people choose to talk about their wealth can be incredibly vulgar on here sometimes. It’s just not really necessary to announce “DH and I are millionaires and send all three kids to Eton”. No one should be ashamed of being affluent but there are ways to read the room and not be a complete arse in the way you talk about it.

Iloveyoubut · 10/03/2024 11:19

Bragging posts aside, people will be annoyed/ upset/angry/hostile about whatever someone has (or what they perceive them to have) that they wish they had but can’t admit it to themselves because on some level it’s too painful. Sometimes they don’t even know they wish they had it but they get triggered by the shame of not having it and don’t realise why. I include myself in this! (Including myself is just a disclaimer! I have no conscious hostilities towards anyone who has anything I wish I had).

Swipe left for the next trending thread