Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is being successful frowned upon by most on Mumsnet

316 replies

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 10:03

I have been/seen on some threads that people, are negative towards those that have become successful, children go to private school means the kids are entitled.

Why can't we celebrate that some people get lucky with an idea, take risks, work incredibly hard and pay their fair share on taxes.

I have seen people demand that the OP gives their profits to charity without even knowing what the OP gives to charity.

We need to celebrate all in society.

OP posts:
ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 10/03/2024 13:33

I think it's actually easier for people to think the people who are financially better off than them are all so due to privilege and luck (it will apply to some but not all) and for better off people to think those will less money is due to laziness and lack of effort (will apply to a minority but again not all).

That way, no one at the upper end has to consider how unequal society is & what they can do to reduce that.

No one at the other end also has to consider their choices may have led to different results.

It means neither side have to self reflect at all and blaming each other becomes the default.

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 13:33

Waitingfordoggo · 10/03/2024 13:26

Just to clarify: I meant that cleaners and carers who work long hours (and those who have to work nights) deserve to be paid more than they currently are, not that they should be paid more than hedge fund managers or KCs or whatever. Most hard grafters in all professions have had to work a few nights to get where they are. But I do feel for those who work night shifts for decades as it’s shown to shorten life expectancy.

It sounds like your husband has worked hard to establish his business- good for him, of course that’s admirable. You said that he had to take some massive risks along the way. That is brave but just not always possible. What sort of financial/professional risks can someone take if they have absolutely 0 assets, no family money to fall back on, rent to pay and children to feed?

As I stated we took massive financial risk without any assets and had no family to fell back on, with at the time 1 child, We would have been left with nothing. I was working but that would have not paid all the bills.

His parents lived in a council house and did not have one qualification between them.

OP posts:
Morph22010 · 10/03/2024 13:27

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 13:01

@Itscatsallthewaydown There’s plenty who have started with nothing, have worked hard and still don’t have much. Mostly people in useful occupations TBH.
What you’re talking about there is luck.

It's rarely luck and it's an important message to young people that luck is a very very small part of success.

It's usually one degree of risk taking along with all the hard work, dedication and commitment. Risk taking not to go into a safe career. Risk taking to push to do something different.
People who go into rewarding and admirable fields like nursing and teaching work tremendously hard but they took zero risks. It's the element of pushing yourself out there that is the major factor in financial success.

And in my experience some of the most successful people in financial terms aren’t necessarily the brightest, often far from it, as they’ve taken risks that someone with better understanding would never do, but they’ve paid off- which can be an element of luck

Waitingfordoggo · 10/03/2024 13:26

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 13:16

And yet some on here are saying its only because of privilege

Yet some are also saying that people that do physical work should be paid more, those that work nights should be paid more, guess what that is what my husband has done, and still does. Everyone assumes that to be wealthy you have to do a MN high earner role.

Just to clarify: I meant that cleaners and carers who work long hours (and those who have to work nights) deserve to be paid more than they currently are, not that they should be paid more than hedge fund managers or KCs or whatever. Most hard grafters in all professions have had to work a few nights to get where they are. But I do feel for those who work night shifts for decades as it’s shown to shorten life expectancy.

It sounds like your husband has worked hard to establish his business- good for him, of course that’s admirable. You said that he had to take some massive risks along the way. That is brave but just not always possible. What sort of financial/professional risks can someone take if they have absolutely 0 assets, no family money to fall back on, rent to pay and children to feed?

ScierraDoll · 10/03/2024 13:25

jeaux90 · 10/03/2024 10:21

Women are socialised differently to men. We are judged whatever we do.
Work, not work, have kids, don't have kids.

The trick is not GAF and crack on.

But yes I agree, women should support each other and celebrate success.

But women don't support each other, this notion of a "sisterhood" is bullshit.
Women are as bitchy as hell, we judge each other constantly and martyrdom seems to be our sole objective in life

excessivescreentime · 10/03/2024 13:23

Yep I've noticed that anyone with a nanny is not allowed to have any problems/questions.

But perhaps that's not all of Mumsnet. I suspect that posts from well-to-do mum's catch the eye of people who feel bitter about that sort of thing, and they feel moved to post. Then after a bit you get a few people turning up and saying "what's wrong with working hard and earning lots of money?"*. While a lot of other users just scroll on by because they're not that interested in class warfare. In the meantime the poor OP's post asking for advice basically gets ignored.

So there is probably (or possibly?) a silent majority who don't hate well off people.

(I don't have a nanny btw)

*not helpful as it's obviously possible to be hardworking and skint.

bombastix · 10/03/2024 13:23

I'm so far from women claiming credit for their husbands salaries. It is not 1950. Congrats to the husband. The woman did not earn it and is not "successful"

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 13:20

bombastix · 10/03/2024 13:18

No reason at all. But the 200k husband is not her achievement. It is his hard work, is it not?

Oh my goodness, this is exactly what I was saying....... tearing people down.

OP posts:
bombastix · 10/03/2024 13:18

TheNeverEndingOver · 10/03/2024 13:09

That woman on the AMA thread also got criticised for using the NHS to give birth as her husband earnt over 200k. Why shouldn’t she.

No reason at all. But the 200k husband is not her achievement. It is his hard work, is it not?

bombastix · 10/03/2024 13:17

Carers and cleaners do hard graft. I am a lawyer. I don't look down my nose at them. I graft too. People who strive get my admiration. People who don't, well no, I don't celebrate that. What has an individual done is key? What did they do?

Not. I have access to a lot of money. Difference is massive.

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 13:16

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 12:57

But feeling proud of yourself because you worked hard and are a massive success is great. Why are people so put out by it. It's not saying people who haven't got much in life don't work hard. It's like saying 'I worked really hard on my diet and exercise, transformed my life and now I look like a million pounds' doesn't mean everyone who looks a bit shit is lazy and a glutton.

This is exactly what the Op is saying. Why do some people see it as bragging. Why pull people down? Don't get me wrong, some people do brag. But just being wealthy and successful and saying you worked super hard for it is not necessarily bragging and it's not a commentary on anyone else.

It's a better message than being super wealthy and successful and not having worked hard for it. It's important that younger people realise it wasn't always handed to people on a plate. That sometimes we can create the life we want through hard work, dedication, commitment and taking the right risks.

And yet some on here are saying its only because of privilege

Yet some are also saying that people that do physical work should be paid more, those that work nights should be paid more, guess what that is what my husband has done, and still does. Everyone assumes that to be wealthy you have to do a MN high earner role.

OP posts:
Beezknees · 10/03/2024 13:11

No one frowns upon successful people here.

What is frowned upon is those who are successful but look down on those who aren't as "jealous" or "not worked hard enough" and moan about not getting help like people on benefits do.

TheNeverEndingOver · 10/03/2024 13:09

That woman on the AMA thread also got criticised for using the NHS to give birth as her husband earnt over 200k. Why shouldn’t she.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 13:09

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 13:01

@Itscatsallthewaydown There’s plenty who have started with nothing, have worked hard and still don’t have much. Mostly people in useful occupations TBH.
What you’re talking about there is luck.

It's rarely luck and it's an important message to young people that luck is a very very small part of success.

It's usually one degree of risk taking along with all the hard work, dedication and commitment. Risk taking not to go into a safe career. Risk taking to push to do something different.
People who go into rewarding and admirable fields like nursing and teaching work tremendously hard but they took zero risks. It's the element of pushing yourself out there that is the major factor in financial success.

I disagree. It's luck more often than not. Luck and privilege.

You can't possibly assume people who went into those careers took no risks. You know nothing of their circumstances and the sacrifices they may have made. And again its measuring success as only financial.

A nurse saving lives and offering comfort or a teacher inspiring generations is far more of a successful person in my book.

GoingDownLikeBHS · 10/03/2024 13:07

I think there could also be a thread directly under yours entitled "Why is there so much contempt on MN for people who work hard and never get anywhere?" - it's like if you are struggling it must be because you are stupid, lazy or somehow "less" than people are are managing (or doing very well for themselves).

I just think this reflects society; its an attitude that current government are keen to promote.

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 13:03

Desecratedcoconut · 10/03/2024 12:52

How about every single post. What does it matter to you what people think? Own your principles and make your decisions and be proud of how you live your life but, playing the victim because you can't get universal approval on MN is incredibly needy.

You take out of it whatever you think, my principles are my own and your are yours.

I do hate the judgement and people would be up in arms if it was against someone who did not have much.

You do you

OP posts:
Itscatsallthewaydown · 10/03/2024 13:02

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 13:01

@Itscatsallthewaydown There’s plenty who have started with nothing, have worked hard and still don’t have much. Mostly people in useful occupations TBH.
What you’re talking about there is luck.

It's rarely luck and it's an important message to young people that luck is a very very small part of success.

It's usually one degree of risk taking along with all the hard work, dedication and commitment. Risk taking not to go into a safe career. Risk taking to push to do something different.
People who go into rewarding and admirable fields like nursing and teaching work tremendously hard but they took zero risks. It's the element of pushing yourself out there that is the major factor in financial success.

Nurses take ‘zero risk’?! Fuck right off. Life and death decisions every day.

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 13:01

@Itscatsallthewaydown There’s plenty who have started with nothing, have worked hard and still don’t have much. Mostly people in useful occupations TBH.
What you’re talking about there is luck.

It's rarely luck and it's an important message to young people that luck is a very very small part of success.

It's usually one degree of risk taking along with all the hard work, dedication and commitment. Risk taking not to go into a safe career. Risk taking to push to do something different.
People who go into rewarding and admirable fields like nursing and teaching work tremendously hard but they took zero risks. It's the element of pushing yourself out there that is the major factor in financial success.

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 13:00

JassyRadlett · 10/03/2024 12:48

I don't think you've actually read my post.

It's increasingly difficult to achieve what you've done, or what my husband has done (I'm an immigrant but with a more privileged background, so harder to slot me into a box in UK society.

It's great that you realise that you've been both hardworking and lucky. Unfortunately not everyone does recognise that, or recognise how much more stratified and stagnant our society has become over the last couple of decades. And I can understand why people get pissed off when it's implied that if only they had also worked hard enough, the same result would have been available to them.

It's a bit like people who bought property in 2002 telling young people today to just give up drinking lattes and avocados.

And I'll disagree with you on celebrating everyone. Some people's journeys and achievements are much more to be celebrated than others'.

I read your post and I was talking from my own experience.

I think it ok, to celebrate everyone.

OP posts:
tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 12:57

SasumaFan · 10/03/2024 10:46

I think it's the bragging that's frowned upon, rather than the (financial) success.

Also people get tired of "I worked hard for it", as if nobody who struggles financially also works hard. Newsflash: they do.

But feeling proud of yourself because you worked hard and are a massive success is great. Why are people so put out by it. It's not saying people who haven't got much in life don't work hard. It's like saying 'I worked really hard on my diet and exercise, transformed my life and now I look like a million pounds' doesn't mean everyone who looks a bit shit is lazy and a glutton.

This is exactly what the Op is saying. Why do some people see it as bragging. Why pull people down? Don't get me wrong, some people do brag. But just being wealthy and successful and saying you worked super hard for it is not necessarily bragging and it's not a commentary on anyone else.

It's a better message than being super wealthy and successful and not having worked hard for it. It's important that younger people realise it wasn't always handed to people on a plate. That sometimes we can create the life we want through hard work, dedication, commitment and taking the right risks.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 12:57

Allfur · 10/03/2024 12:42

Choices not everyone has

Exactly. I think the lack of awareness of privilege is much of the problem. You see it all the time on here.

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/03/2024 12:52

Allfur · 10/03/2024 12:42

Choices not everyone has

You’re missing the point. I was explaining why I wanted to be successful.
My success has given me choices for my DC, choices that I didn’t have growing up as a free school meals girl with a father who was in and out of work all the time.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 12:52

jeaux90 · 10/03/2024 12:38

Treating everyone the same is sometimes the most unfair thing to do though.

My DD goes to private school because the state school is absolutely crap with SEN.

She is flourishing at the school she is in.

I have worked my arse off as a lone parent to get to a six figure salary so I could afford it.

Not all state schools. Dc have SEN and they've had amazing support.

Postcode lottery perhaps.

Desecratedcoconut · 10/03/2024 12:52

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 12:49

Where have I asked for applause, I look forward to you providing evidence.

Please read my OP again

How about every single post. What does it matter to you what people think? Own your principles and make your decisions and be proud of how you live your life but, playing the victim because you can't get universal approval on MN is incredibly needy.

Waitingfordoggo · 10/03/2024 12:51

LittleBearPad · 10/03/2024 11:33

The working hard at school is usually followed by working hard in a career. Those earning well may well be working longer hours than the cleaners and carers you cite.

Some of them probably will be working longer hours, yes. I think it’s safe to assume though that anyone working in physically demanding jobs (and especially those who have to work nights) are likely to have more profound impacts on their health than those who are working long hours in office environments. Both are ‘hard work’ but one is harder work than the other IMO. Carers and cleaners (and many other workers in physical jobs) should be paid more than they are is what I’m saying really.

Swipe left for the next trending thread