Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is being successful frowned upon by most on Mumsnet

316 replies

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 10:03

I have been/seen on some threads that people, are negative towards those that have become successful, children go to private school means the kids are entitled.

Why can't we celebrate that some people get lucky with an idea, take risks, work incredibly hard and pay their fair share on taxes.

I have seen people demand that the OP gives their profits to charity without even knowing what the OP gives to charity.

We need to celebrate all in society.

OP posts:
JockTamsonsBairns · 11/03/2024 01:34

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 10:36

Your comment says it all I married money or I am a women that earns a lot of money.

What about the people that have worked incredibly hard and I mean 90 hour weeks, 7 days a week to get to where they are the took huge risks that have paid off, why does it have to be your 2 examples?

But surely this is where the argument falls down?

I've been a domiciliary care worker for 28 years. My real time pay is less than NMW.

Up until two years ago, I worked 80/90 hours a week (for 40/50 hours' pay).
I used to work 7am until 10pm, five days a week. I recently adjusted it to 9am until 10pm five days a week - because I'm getting older now, and I physically can't do those hours.

Are you implying that I haven't "worked hard"? My sector is on its knees. Those of us who are committed to keeping Adult Social Care going are on our knees with sheer exhaustion.

In my 13 hour day, I'm caring for people who are frail, with dementia, who have acute mental health problems, people with mobility issues, medications, suicidal ideations, family breakdowns, adults with autism.
I'm feeding, bathing, carrying out continence care.
I'm speaking to GPs, District Nurses, Physios, OTs, pharmacists, paramedics, social workers.
I'm dealing with families of all shapes and sizes, often unhealthy dynamics.
I'm doing Palliative Care alongside bereavement care.

Please don't insinuate I'm not "working hard".

DeeCeeCherry · 11/03/2024 01:04

Schadenfreude
Envy/jealousy
Working class snobbery around how its thought monied people should or shouldn't talk in terms of their money

Goldenbear · 11/03/2024 00:53

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 23:04

@Beezknees

I've been here 10 years.

Then why would you think this is a uniquely UK site for UK people? It's global. How can you not know that? There's even a topic specifically for Australian & NZ MNers. And there are thousands of Americans and people from pretty much every English speaking country. Plus English speakers from non English speaking countries.

10 years and you didn't know this?

I have been on the site for 17 years and it was UK dominant as it is a London bas s internet forum. All the competitions are concerned with winning something in a UK context. Most people assume you are referencing the UK when discussing things, e.g schools, higher education, NHS

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 23:47

Waitingfordoggo · 10/03/2024 22:32

I didn’t realise you had asked me any questions. Are you sure you’re not mixing me up with a different poster?

As for success vs wealth… I saw the thread title and thought the thread was going to be about people who are doing well in life (in a generic sense) but when I opened the thread, realised it was really about professional success and wealth. Which is obviously fine and interesting as a topic thread in itself, but just got me thinking about how we use the word ‘successful’ and what people understand by it. The answers to your thread title could vary according to how people understand that word.

I apologise I mis quoted you.

Success can mean different things to different people, wealth is one measure of that.

People on MN it would seem do not like any successful, whatever that measure is.

OP posts:
tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 23:04

@Beezknees

I've been here 10 years.

Then why would you think this is a uniquely UK site for UK people? It's global. How can you not know that? There's even a topic specifically for Australian & NZ MNers. And there are thousands of Americans and people from pretty much every English speaking country. Plus English speakers from non English speaking countries.

10 years and you didn't know this?

Waitingfordoggo · 10/03/2024 22:32

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 19:04

Where did I say that wealth and success is measured in wealth, I said that no one should be judgmental.

Which your posts have been, because you have jumped to conclusions, you have yet to answer my post about disability, single parenthood.

Edited

I didn’t realise you had asked me any questions. Are you sure you’re not mixing me up with a different poster?

As for success vs wealth… I saw the thread title and thought the thread was going to be about people who are doing well in life (in a generic sense) but when I opened the thread, realised it was really about professional success and wealth. Which is obviously fine and interesting as a topic thread in itself, but just got me thinking about how we use the word ‘successful’ and what people understand by it. The answers to your thread title could vary according to how people understand that word.

LittleBearPad · 10/03/2024 21:00

NHStoPrivate · 10/03/2024 20:31

I think MN will have more highly paid women than average though - it has a relatively MC demographic. I do know what you mean though @Segway16, there do seem to be a lot of high earner women on MN 😄. And even more women who don't work, but their DH is a high earner.

I (have to 😄) work.

Name changes may make it appear there are more than you consider reasonable.

ancienticecream · 10/03/2024 20:59

It's not just a Mumsnet thing, it's a British thing. People don't like others to exceed here.

I take a look at the FIRE UK subreddit every now and again, and if anybody is doing well they're basically shot down... On a board that's all about financial independence and early retirement!

Beezknees · 10/03/2024 20:56

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 19:14

@Beezknees

That's a stupid comparison because this is a UK website, with people discussing life in the UK.

Huh??? Did you seriously think everyone on MN is living in the UK? You haven't been here long have you.

I've been here 10 years.

Papyrophile · 10/03/2024 20:36

As it happens, I have never earned £120k pa but I could show you my tax returns for 1998 proving that I earned £50k, for eight (very busy) months. There was no MN then; my email address was entirely numeric. My comms/information lifeline was my fax machine. I used a fax roll a week, every week, often more.

No gripes, no hardship: I loved every minute. Fascinating work with interesting, intellectually demanding clients. I was considerably less successful with kids.

NHStoPrivate · 10/03/2024 20:31

I think MN will have more highly paid women than average though - it has a relatively MC demographic. I do know what you mean though @Segway16, there do seem to be a lot of high earner women on MN 😄. And even more women who don't work, but their DH is a high earner.

I (have to 😄) work.

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 20:27

Segway16 · 10/03/2024 20:24

Because - depending which article you read - there are fewer than 100,000 women in the uk earning £120k or over. Most of them, it seems, happen to be on mumsnet.

I can assure you I do not earn 100,000, I am on at lot less.

OP posts:
Segway16 · 10/03/2024 20:24

Because - depending which article you read - there are fewer than 100,000 women in the uk earning £120k or over. Most of them, it seems, happen to be on mumsnet.

Papyrophile · 10/03/2024 20:14

I don't know how you reach that conclusion @Segway16 . I have never earned as much again as I did before I hatched my chick, but I waited until I was 43 to do so. 25 years ago, I was earning the FTE of £80k, which is probably comparable given inflation, in eight (frantic) months each year. Had I not become a mum, that would have continued for years... at least five or so, which would have been (then) significant for a self-employed freelance.

But having held up the household while DP got his business up and running, I stepped back to do the parenting. I wanted to.

I concede the point about good fortune: I have been lucky in life all through. I am clever, I was pretty and I still (at 67) have two living parents (inheritance is never going to be significant though). I did win the jackpot, but my DP had a cardiac in an ambulance at 50 that would have been fatal had it not happened in an ambulance, I have had cancer and my DC has been through some turmoil too. Life throws shit at everyone. It's how you deal with it.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/03/2024 20:13

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 18:33

@Willyoujustbequiet

A nurse saving lives and offering comfort or a teacher inspiring generations is far more of a successful person in my book.

No one suggested they aren't. This thread is about money. Not who has the most honourable profession.

It's not though, its been about succes and myself and others have repeatedly pointed out that doesn't necessarily equate to wealth.

Segway16 · 10/03/2024 19:37

Re. those of that think a lot of “high earners” on here are full of shit - £60k is not a particularly high earner. However, the sheer volume of women on mumsnet that supposedly earn £120k and over is statistically impossible.

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 19:14

@Beezknees

That's a stupid comparison because this is a UK website, with people discussing life in the UK.

Huh??? Did you seriously think everyone on MN is living in the UK? You haven't been here long have you.

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 19:12

@Waitingfordoggo the success referred to is obviously focused on money as the thread title is literally why do people frown upon success. No one is frowning upon the things you value as success

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 19:04

Waitingfordoggo · 10/03/2024 19:00

Well I think that’s debatable- I think the thread has a broader scope than that. The OP’s title doesn’t mention money but ‘success’.

The OP then went on to make it clear that to her, success and wealth are synonymous, but to many of us ‘success’ has a wider meaning than that.

I know quite a few people who are earning peanuts but who I nonetheless see as making a success of their lives because they are doing well at keeping multiple plates spinning in extremely challenging circumstances (for reasons that have already been mentioned numerous times- difficult start in life/lack of opportunity/single parenthood/disability or long-term illness/mental illness/caring responsibilities…) Those people should be celebrated as successful but their success has nothing to do with their earnings.

Where did I say that wealth and success is measured in wealth, I said that no one should be judgmental.

Which your posts have been, because you have jumped to conclusions, you have yet to answer my post about disability, single parenthood.

OP posts:
Teenangels · 10/03/2024 19:03

Workworkandmoreworknow · 10/03/2024 18:37

Most poster applaud the worker in the profession you named, and I work as one

Are you also a single parent? Do you have a child with disabilities? Do you support an elderly adult or one with a disability? Have you struggled for money only to have someone on here tell you that the answer is a better job, that you should have worked harder at school, that you're not independent if you receive even Child Benefit, that you're 'benefit scum'? Cod I've hung around here for years, under various needs, and have experienced all of that, multiple times.

I have not seen one person on here say that you are a benefit scrounger for claiming Child benefit a benefit that a family could earn 99k a year claim, please provide a link.....

Has any poster ever been told that because they have not contributed to the state they cant use the NHS, a previous poster was told that she should not have given birth in a NHS hospital because the family earned too much and was taking resources away for those less well off, can you not see the double standards.

OP posts:
Waitingfordoggo · 10/03/2024 19:00

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 18:33

@Willyoujustbequiet

A nurse saving lives and offering comfort or a teacher inspiring generations is far more of a successful person in my book.

No one suggested they aren't. This thread is about money. Not who has the most honourable profession.

Well I think that’s debatable- I think the thread has a broader scope than that. The OP’s title doesn’t mention money but ‘success’.

The OP then went on to make it clear that to her, success and wealth are synonymous, but to many of us ‘success’ has a wider meaning than that.

I know quite a few people who are earning peanuts but who I nonetheless see as making a success of their lives because they are doing well at keeping multiple plates spinning in extremely challenging circumstances (for reasons that have already been mentioned numerous times- difficult start in life/lack of opportunity/single parenthood/disability or long-term illness/mental illness/caring responsibilities…) Those people should be celebrated as successful but their success has nothing to do with their earnings.

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 18:55

Workworkandmoreworknow · 10/03/2024 18:37

Most poster applaud the worker in the profession you named, and I work as one

Are you also a single parent? Do you have a child with disabilities? Do you support an elderly adult or one with a disability? Have you struggled for money only to have someone on here tell you that the answer is a better job, that you should have worked harder at school, that you're not independent if you receive even Child Benefit, that you're 'benefit scum'? Cod I've hung around here for years, under various needs, and have experienced all of that, multiple times.

I have 2 children with ASC with my husband,

This is going to be outing but I was a single parent before I met my husband.

I have also cared for my Mum who had dementia along with my Dad.

As I have said its not a race to the bottom.

OP posts:
Workworkandmoreworknow · 10/03/2024 18:37

Most poster applaud the worker in the profession you named, and I work as one

Are you also a single parent? Do you have a child with disabilities? Do you support an elderly adult or one with a disability? Have you struggled for money only to have someone on here tell you that the answer is a better job, that you should have worked harder at school, that you're not independent if you receive even Child Benefit, that you're 'benefit scum'? Cod I've hung around here for years, under various needs, and have experienced all of that, multiple times.

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 18:33

@Willyoujustbequiet

A nurse saving lives and offering comfort or a teacher inspiring generations is far more of a successful person in my book.

No one suggested they aren't. This thread is about money. Not who has the most honourable profession.

Beezknees · 10/03/2024 18:32

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 18:28

@Beezknees

They really don't. People just get ticked off when those with money moan about how skint they are when they don't really know the meaning of skint

But it's all relative isn't it.

Most people on MN who think they know what 'really skint' is would be laughed at by people living in America who are poor and have no access to health care so see their loved ones die. Or kids in the Philippines who live on rubbish tips and forage for survival.
Yeah. They'd be looking at you thinking you are living a life of luxury.

That's a stupid comparison because this is a UK website, with people discussing life in the UK.