Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is being successful frowned upon by most on Mumsnet

316 replies

Teenangels · 10/03/2024 10:03

I have been/seen on some threads that people, are negative towards those that have become successful, children go to private school means the kids are entitled.

Why can't we celebrate that some people get lucky with an idea, take risks, work incredibly hard and pay their fair share on taxes.

I have seen people demand that the OP gives their profits to charity without even knowing what the OP gives to charity.

We need to celebrate all in society.

OP posts:
Papyrophile · 11/03/2024 21:35

I earned very well as a self-employed writer in a very specialist world, but not six figures 20 years ago. Honestly, at the time I was very very driven and hugely competitive (maybe not likeable) but if I was 40 again, I'd definitely be gunning to earn over £100k. The world has shifted too. Freelance writers now apparently earn less per day than I did in 1990.

Waitingfordoggo · 11/03/2024 21:34

My apologies @Teenangels, I thought you had said earlier in the thread that you didn’t earn very much- but perhaps I am mistaken, and I wasn’t implying you don’t work. I also realise you supported your H as he set up and ran his business, and that you have had all the home and family stuff to do as well. I did not say, and do not think, that you’re not a hard worker yourself!

I haven’t made any assumptions about your wealth!

Teenangels · 11/03/2024 21:29

Waitingfordoggo · 11/03/2024 20:59

Teenangels could be the chair of a mega corporation or she could be a competent, cheerful suburban hairdresser that people enjoy going to: she hasn't said

I think the OP has said that her wealth has come about as a result of her husband’s business.

No, I have my own career, and I am very proud of it and you Doggo would think its a very noble career. I would be classed as a high middle income.

My husband set up his business, I was the main breadwinner, did the books, invoicing, even went out to help him on a weekend, took loans out, had a few years of having no money, looking after the kids, working and doing everything at home, to support him doing a 90 hour week. At the start he was also working full time and gave that up to put his full energy into the business. All of this and have SEN children.

He would say that he could not have done what he has done without me.

I have also never mentioned what our wealth is, you are only assuming and making judgements.

OP posts:
newmummycwharf1 · 11/03/2024 21:25

Screamingabdabz · 11/03/2024 21:09

It’s the “worked hard” bollocks that really triggers me.

I heard a long term unemployed (UMC) Financier on radio 4 the other day say he was so keen to work he’d ’even taken a job with the Royal Mail as a postman for 3 months’. He said it was the hardest he’d worked for the least money.

Working hard is just a way of life for the working classes. Why do the ‘successful’ always trot it out like a mantra?

You’re successful because you’re either privileged, connected, lucky or in very few cases extremely talented. But it’s usually privilege.

That privilege doesnt just happen. People make choices - multiple choices that lead them or their descendants to be privileged. There are systemic inequalities but we can all agree there are many reasons we all make choices that may not lead to earning highly. For one, it may not even be a desire for some and that is ok. But it is not ok to put down people who value high earning roles and do what it takes. And yes, luck and good fortune plays a role but by nature the word 'luck' suggests they had nothing to do with it and as such could have occured for anyone. Truth is we have a very important role in determining our own destinies. We all do - and money is not the only marker of success but for those that value having a lot of money - I dont chastise them because I am not willing to take the risks/pay the price they paid! In most cases, I have a better quality of life and they get to buy the fine things in life - who won?

I didnt listen to the R4 - but if that was someone senior in finance - he was likely reasonably well-off by taking a risk to accept a finance role where we will know they hire and fire without mercy, versus a lesser paid public sector role. Unfortunately he is suffering the negative consequence of that choice now. But some would have berated him for his 'privilege' when times where good

Papyrophile · 11/03/2024 21:24

And very sadly for the chap on R4 (I heard the interview too) he's a victim of the promotion choke. No organisation can promote everyone, so there is a constant cull process.

Screamingabdabz · 11/03/2024 21:23

Papyrophile · 11/03/2024 21:19

I don't disagree @Screamingabdabz . You are successful because you are all the things you suggest, but only if you put in the effort. Your connections might get your foot in the door, but you are the person who has to kick it open. I don't think privilege has a huge role, or at least a much smaller one now than it did, because to succeed in a global talent market, the froth gets skimmed off very fast. You perform and deliver, or are chewed up and spat out.

That’s how all jobs work.

It’s just that if you’re privileged or connected your ‘effort’ pays six figures as opposed to minimum wage. And if you don’t make the effort it won’t make you homeless or mean you can’t feed your kids.

Papyrophile · 11/03/2024 21:19

I don't disagree @Screamingabdabz . You are successful because you are all the things you suggest, but only if you put in the effort. Your connections might get your foot in the door, but you are the person who has to kick it open. I don't think privilege has a huge role, or at least a much smaller one now than it did, because to succeed in a global talent market, the froth gets skimmed off very fast. You perform and deliver, or are chewed up and spat out.

Waitingfordoggo · 11/03/2024 21:15

Oh yes, agree @Papyrophile- I keep trying to persuade my teens to look at getting into a trade!

Papyrophile · 11/03/2024 21:11

@Waitingfordoggo , if you are a good tradie, then I think that you can be very successful much quicker these days. A really good kitchen or bathroom fitter, who's pleasant to deal with, is going to get their details passed around the DC's schools faster than measles.

Screamingabdabz · 11/03/2024 21:09

It’s the “worked hard” bollocks that really triggers me.

I heard a long term unemployed (UMC) Financier on radio 4 the other day say he was so keen to work he’d ’even taken a job with the Royal Mail as a postman for 3 months’. He said it was the hardest he’d worked for the least money.

Working hard is just a way of life for the working classes. Why do the ‘successful’ always trot it out like a mantra?

You’re successful because you’re either privileged, connected, lucky or in very few cases extremely talented. But it’s usually privilege.

Papyrophile · 11/03/2024 21:05

So has mine! But I was the person who supported us for the first three years of starting the business.

There's an old saying about starting a business: the first year you pay for it, the second year, it pays for itself, and the third year it pays for you. But that rule only works if you had a solid commercial proposition to start with.

Waitingfordoggo · 11/03/2024 20:59

Teenangels could be the chair of a mega corporation or she could be a competent, cheerful suburban hairdresser that people enjoy going to: she hasn't said

I think the OP has said that her wealth has come about as a result of her husband’s business.

Papyrophile · 11/03/2024 20:48

There are some people who think not earning to their ability makes them virtuous! We need everyone to aspire to earn as much as possible. High earners fund a better quality of life for everyone and will be the spur that demands higher eco-standards, better education and health -- because these things cost.

LadeOde · 11/03/2024 20:41

I agree @OP. On a thread about careers for young people and whether they really need so many A's at A'level one poster commented that you only need those 'if you are the type that's greedy and goes after the high paying careers and that says a lot about you'. Couldnt believe what i was reading, as if aiming for a low paid salary is a virtue.

Papyrophile · 11/03/2024 20:40

@ligh, you may be disabled or unfortunate or unlucky, or just wet. Teenangels could be the chair of a mega corporation or she could be a competent, cheerful suburban hairdresser that people enjoy going to: she hasn't said. But you have outed yourself as a curmudgeonly grump who despises anyone who has been more successful in life than you. Be happy.

Papyrophile · 11/03/2024 20:32

I think that's pretty rude @ligh . And very judgemental. @Teenangels has I guess worked hard, taken decisions and risks, and has achieved a degree of success for her family. If a person is clever and healthy, and doesn't need society's support to provide for their family, while paying taxes (probably quite a lot of tax) by doing so she's contributing to your safety net, possibly paying a second time for healthcare and education.

Teenangels · 11/03/2024 20:28

ligh · 11/03/2024 20:02

@Teenangels you started with nothing, gained some wealth, and lost your humanity.
Congrats.

Really lost my humanity!!!

Congrats you have just shown why I did this AIBU.

Insults really, again makes my point.

Take care.

OP posts:
ligh · 11/03/2024 20:02

@Teenangels you started with nothing, gained some wealth, and lost your humanity.
Congrats.

Teenangels · 11/03/2024 17:31

sittingingold · 11/03/2024 14:53

^^ @Teenangels this might help you (if you have an open enough mind and heart) to appreciate the amount of hours you spend at work isn't as big a part of your success as you might imagine. Social mobility is much more unusual than the movies would have you believe.

I think if you had a bit more of an open mind you might be willing to consider that the privilege and circumstances of the family you are born into has a much bigger impact on the likelihood of material success (as well as health outcomes etc).

I didn't choose which family I was born into (luckily it was fairly financially privileged as I wouldn't have been able to take many steps in the race in the video I linked) I wasn't aware we could choose our birth families, must have missed the memo

Perhaps you should read my comments.

Husband left school at 15, parents lived in a council house and did not have one qualification between them.

We started with nothing.

OP posts:
pestaloon · 11/03/2024 15:04

The more I practise the luckier I get 🤷‍♀️

sittingingold · 11/03/2024 14:53

^^ @Teenangels this might help you (if you have an open enough mind and heart) to appreciate the amount of hours you spend at work isn't as big a part of your success as you might imagine. Social mobility is much more unusual than the movies would have you believe.

I think if you had a bit more of an open mind you might be willing to consider that the privilege and circumstances of the family you are born into has a much bigger impact on the likelihood of material success (as well as health outcomes etc).

I didn't choose which family I was born into (luckily it was fairly financially privileged as I wouldn't have been able to take many steps in the race in the video I linked) I wasn't aware we could choose our birth families, must have missed the memo

Teenangels · 11/03/2024 13:49

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 11/03/2024 09:25

I don't think being successful is frowned upon, but being tone deaf is.

What do you consider being tone deaf?

I have seen many posters including the recent AMA, getting awful comments just for the sake of it.

OP posts:
marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 11/03/2024 09:25

I don't think being successful is frowned upon, but being tone deaf is.

Teenangels · 11/03/2024 06:47

JockTamsonsBairns · 11/03/2024 01:34

But surely this is where the argument falls down?

I've been a domiciliary care worker for 28 years. My real time pay is less than NMW.

Up until two years ago, I worked 80/90 hours a week (for 40/50 hours' pay).
I used to work 7am until 10pm, five days a week. I recently adjusted it to 9am until 10pm five days a week - because I'm getting older now, and I physically can't do those hours.

Are you implying that I haven't "worked hard"? My sector is on its knees. Those of us who are committed to keeping Adult Social Care going are on our knees with sheer exhaustion.

In my 13 hour day, I'm caring for people who are frail, with dementia, who have acute mental health problems, people with mobility issues, medications, suicidal ideations, family breakdowns, adults with autism.
I'm feeding, bathing, carrying out continence care.
I'm speaking to GPs, District Nurses, Physios, OTs, pharmacists, paramedics, social workers.
I'm dealing with families of all shapes and sizes, often unhealthy dynamics.
I'm doing Palliative Care alongside bereavement care.

Please don't insinuate I'm not "working hard".

Where have I said that you are not working hard, I have and would never say that….

What I am saying is that people on MN are saying that people who are wealthier than them have done it through privilege and then tell them what to do with their money basically sneering at people, do you think that people that have money have not worked hard? I have said we should celebrate everyone not bring people down. Its simple really.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread