Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this normal ? Financial - H behaviour

81 replies

flabj · 10/03/2024 08:43

H is being gifted some money by family and has decided to open up a company with family to invest the money in certain things. I don't want to be too specific.

I'm not part of that company etc and was fine with this.

I've recently found out that a huge proportion of his salary will now also flow into the company in order to be able to keep making investments with said company.

Am I overreacting to think this is a bit off ?

I didn't mind the gifts / inheritance, but surely the salary is a stretch too far and should be our money ?

I also work etc but just worried about this and being kind of frozen out.

Or is this just normal and absolutely fine ?

Thanks for advice.

OP posts:
Calamitousness · 10/03/2024 10:13

@flabj
this is serious and I would seek independent financial legal advice on how you can be protected through this.
your husband should include you in all discussions and the fact he hasn’t is a huge concern.
m that aside you need to ensure assets are protected for you and one way may be to ensure that his parents share goes to you on death/withdrawal from company as well as having your husbands share if he dies.
But tell your husband your very valid concerns and that you need to seek advice to protect yourself.

Herdinggoats · 10/03/2024 10:13

I would tell him you will only agree if he offers full transparency, and you get independent legal advice that he pays for.

All money that he puts in is ring fenced or staircases his share % and is jointly owned by you both.

He absolutely should not be diverting funds away from you and himself in this way. On the face of it it sounds just like he is using his parents as a shield to keep a running away fund separate from you.

Greydogs123 · 10/03/2024 10:11

If this salary money is his “savings” money then how is he going to contribute to big things like holidays or a big car bill? Is he just expecting you to cover that because all your money basically is family money?
Surely the only salary money he should be investing is his spending money - the money which is left after all bills and some family savings is covered.
I think you should offer to invest some of your money in order to be a shareholder as well. You are then able to benefit from the business in the same way as the other people involved.

flabj · 10/03/2024 10:11

mrsdineen2 · 10/03/2024 10:09

May I suggest gently OP, than you comment that you (individually) needed legal advice was a bit of a misstep? It's sets it up as adversial, and sounds like the first step of a divorce.

You (as a couple) need legal advice to a ensure that this deal and company is structured in the best way for all parties.

I get it but be said ' people have doubts ' about me and that's why they did it. When I initially got a bit upset about it.

OP posts:
mrsdineen2 · 10/03/2024 10:09

May I suggest gently OP, than you comment that you (individually) needed legal advice was a bit of a misstep? It's sets it up as adversial, and sounds like the first step of a divorce.

You (as a couple) need legal advice to a ensure that this deal and company is structured in the best way for all parties.

InterIgnis · 10/03/2024 10:07

flabj · 10/03/2024 09:59

@InterIgnis thank you.

Yes I think just having it explained might help.

I don't want to come across grabby either but at the end of the day, he can make all these investments because I'm taking care of things at home, whilst also working full time and I very often spend all my money on looking after the family.

I make huge sacrifices as well and I always see the money I enable him to save ( by paying for a lot of stuff myself, even though I make less ) as a joint thing.

My savings are his and his savings should also be mine.

Where I think he’s wrong is in not being totally transparent with you.

Yes, he’s protecting family money in the event of a split. That doesn’t mean he anticipates a split, any more than putting on a seat belt means you anticipate getting into a car crash. It’s very normal in families that have wealth and assets, and is to preserve generational wealth and keep it generational. My husband and I have joint accounts and investments, but we also have non matrimonial ones. We speak openly about our financial setup though, and no one gets angry if there’s a question.

You deserve to be heard, and I don’t think requesting financial security in the event of something happening to him is unreasonable. Again, my husband and I have both made provision for the other, despite having our own assets. The ability to do that and not significantly impact the growth of the company and wealth does depend on the figures involved, however.

I really would recommend sitting down with a third party and getting a clear picture.

Superscientist · 10/03/2024 10:03

I would be concerned about unilateral decisions about family finances

It sounds like it isn't going to negativity impact your day to day life which is reassuring but would it impact longer term investments such as replacing cars if the kitchen?

You say it's a good investment but is that just based on the spin you get from your partner and his family? What is the competition like, a good idea is less of a good idea if there are a 100 other people setting up businesses with that good idea and there is only space for 20 such companies.

Where would partner draw the line? How did you find out about him investing his salary into the business? Was it after the fact? If the business needed more cash would he initiate further payments without discussion or put your home up for capital which would start to put your day to day life in difficulty

I wouldn't say there are glaring red flags here but there are definitely a few amber ones that need a bit more digging and more discussions about

flabj · 10/03/2024 09:59

@InterIgnis thank you.

Yes I think just having it explained might help.

I don't want to come across grabby either but at the end of the day, he can make all these investments because I'm taking care of things at home, whilst also working full time and I very often spend all my money on looking after the family.

I make huge sacrifices as well and I always see the money I enable him to save ( by paying for a lot of stuff myself, even though I make less ) as a joint thing.

My savings are his and his savings should also be mine.

OP posts:
Alwaystransforming · 10/03/2024 09:58

So this is his own money to do with as he wishes? It doesn’t impact joint money?

flabj · 10/03/2024 09:56

TempleOfBloom · 10/03/2024 09:54

I don’t think you are over reacting.

Rule #1 of investing: only invest what you could afford to lose.

That surely doesn’t include your salary income.

I'm not concerned whether this is a good investment. It's a good investment.

I'm just concerned that it's like he's moving his money in a way so I can't benefit from it, if we split or if he passed away.

OP posts:
InterIgnis · 10/03/2024 09:56

flabj · 10/03/2024 09:48

Indeed, I agree with keeping the inheritance separate but kind of draw the line at the salary.

Do you think I'm being unreasonable ?

No, but I don’t think he is either. You’re not on the same page financially, but that doesn’t mean that one of you is right and the other wrong..

I would get clarity, personally. I would recommend sitting down and talking out with him AND a financial advisor. There’s scope for compromise.

TempleOfBloom · 10/03/2024 09:54

I don’t think you are over reacting.

Rule #1 of investing: only invest what you could afford to lose.

That surely doesn’t include your salary income.

RandomMess · 10/03/2024 09:48

We can't you also be a partner?

You don't all have to hold shares equally.

flabj · 10/03/2024 09:48

InterIgnis · 10/03/2024 09:46

He’s reducing income tax, by the looks of it. Reinvested money is a business expense. If the company is profitable and has potential for growth, then reinvestment can make sense. I expect he has taken financial advice already.

You have separate finances, so what he’s investing isn’t coming from the marital pot. It appears that he’s kept the inheritance strictly as a non matrimonial asset.

Indeed, I agree with keeping the inheritance separate but kind of draw the line at the salary.

Do you think I'm being unreasonable ?

OP posts:
Haveyouanyjam · 10/03/2024 09:47

I don’t know anything about the financial side really but surely the solution is just to make sure that in the event of his death his shares go to you? I can’t see it being an issue otherwise as the profits would go to you as a family and it’s not impacting your day to day living. He should have discussed it with you but it doesn’t sound an unreasonable proposition from what you’ve laid out.

InterIgnis · 10/03/2024 09:46

He’s reducing income tax, by the looks of it. Reinvested money is a business expense. If the company is profitable and has potential for growth, then reinvestment can make sense. I expect he has taken financial advice already.

You have separate finances, so what he’s investing isn’t coming from the marital pot. It appears that he’s kept the inheritance strictly as a non matrimonial asset.

flabj · 10/03/2024 09:42

I know that maybe I'm being unreasonable. Which is why I wanted to get some advice on this.

OP posts:
flabj · 10/03/2024 09:36

Toblerbone · 10/03/2024 09:19

I think you should talk to a solicitor OP.

I did say this to H. I got so angry when I realised but I just don't know if I'm being unreasonable.

Just to clarify, I am not concerned at all that this is a good business venture or he's being taken advantage of or anything like that.

My issue is that he doesn't own the company by himself and that essentially he's taking money that would be ours jointly, into the company - where it will no longer be ours jointly.

If he dies or leaves me or whatever, I will be entitled to his share / half his share in the case of a divorce - and his parents would get most of it.

When actually, I make sacrifices to enable him to earn that money and my money goes only on our family. You could argue that our family does benefit from the company money too. So I just don't know if I'm being unreasonable.

But I would be more comfortable if he invested more than half his salary in a company he owned by himself/ or with me.

I said I'll get some advice on it and he got really mad.

OP posts:
mrsdineen2 · 10/03/2024 09:35

flabj · 10/03/2024 09:20

@mrsdineen2 we will as a family benefit from
100 percent what comes from that company.

It's just that in the event he leaves me or dies, his parents will be first in line.

That's a legal issue tbh, well over my head. Regarding profit, I don't doubt benefit from he profit, but just make sure your DH can prove, as much as anyone reasonably can, that the business will make a profit.

Mrsttcno1 · 10/03/2024 09:33

Initially I was going to say you’re right, but actually from your updates I can’t see any issue with this. Your current set up financially is such that you each pay a % of the bills and the rest of the money is “your” individual money, that means whatever each of you want to do with that money is up to you, he could save his bit, he could spend it on takeaways, he could invest it in this way, that is “his” money to do whatever he likes with. So on that basis, he’s not doing anything wrong.

In my marriage this would be different because we have joint finances, so all money is “our” money. Meaning that if my husband wanted to do this then it would be a discussion first & a decision to make together because we do see it all as “our” money. You mention this being “your/our” money but actually the set up you current have financially is such that you and your husband don’t actually have any shared money, you just share your joint bills and whatever is left is individually yours, and in that situation he can do whatever he wants with his bit just as you can.

flabj · 10/03/2024 09:20

@mrsdineen2 we will as a family benefit from
100 percent what comes from that company.

It's just that in the event he leaves me or dies, his parents will be first in line.

OP posts:
Toblerbone · 10/03/2024 09:19

I think you should talk to a solicitor OP.

mrsdineen2 · 10/03/2024 09:18

flabj · 10/03/2024 09:14

The parents aren't in the company for profit from it in any way.

Thanks for your perspective.

In that case it just becomes of question of whether or not it's a sensible business decision full stop. In which case he needs to fully justify and explain how you as family are going to see a return from his investment.

flabj · 10/03/2024 09:16

ScarlettSunset · 10/03/2024 09:13

Does this impact on the amount he is able to use to pay towards the household expenses and joint savings?
He can't reasonably expect to use his salary just for himself while you keep your household afloat and pay for all everyday living expenses.

It definitely will impact ' joint savings '. We've never had joint savings though.

Although I've been saying we should do that for years.

He has savings and I have savings, separately.

Now the amount he would be saving, is going into this company, which I'm not part of.

OP posts:
flabj · 10/03/2024 09:14

mrsdineen2 · 10/03/2024 09:12

Sorry for the cross post, your update changes things. If his parents gifted him the starting money, and he's using that to create the company, and gifting them back part ownership of that company, then the could very well be fair. He's not just giving a random person something for nothing.

The devil is in the detail though. Whether or not it's actually fair will depend on the exact numbers.

If it first gift was very small, his salary investment is big and he does more of the work, it's not fair to give them an equal share of profits.

If the amount he's going to invest from salary is a good bit less than their gift, and they'll be working as hard as he is for the company, then it's fair.

Like I said, your update complicated things, and there's no black and white answer, but I hope my comment gives you some perspective and helps you to judge the situation.

Edited

The parents aren't in the company for profit from it in any way.

Thanks for your perspective.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread