Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad DD might be limiting herself

357 replies

JanseyB · 10/03/2024 02:25

I have twins, they are 17, in sixth form.
DD is on paper the more intelligent of the two, 8/9a at GCSE and predicted 2 A* and 2 As at a-level (French, German, Art and English). She is at a good local indie but the careers advisor seems to pay little attention to her (more interested in the Law, Medicine and Finance candidates).

DD has applied for Business/Management and German for uni. She's applied to Kings, UCL, Manchester, Bristol and Queen Mary, she has some offers back.

DD has now announced she wants to take a gap year, then maybe change her course of study all together. She has savings and will get some money for her 18th so she has said she wants to work and travel and figure it out.
DD actually wants to work in marketing but wants to do a degree related to foreign language as it's something she is naturally talented at.

DS is so much more put together, studying history then wants to do law and has a clear plan.

DD is saying she wants a gap year, 4 year (year abroad) undergrad then possibly marketing masters. Which just seems a bit chaotic.

She is so smart, I wasn't massively supportive of her A-level choices and I feel like we are going through it again. She got a bloody 9 in maths at GCSE and it feels such a waste to throw it away. She's also very sociable, likeable, sporty and works so hard, it just seems she's a bit lost?!

DH and I are both doctors, our path was quite clear and laid out from leaving school so I'm not sure how to approach this.

AIBU thinking she might be throwing it all away. How can I get her better careers advice when school aren't helping? She used to want to work in finance and I'm a little sad that over the last 2 years that has lost appeal to her!

Anyone here know a path that might suit DD, with her want of modern languages under grad and marking as a career with study abroad and gap years?

OP posts:
TheOccupier · 10/03/2024 10:16

She sounds great and maths will be useful in a marketing career. Look at the graduate recruitment websites for companies like Diageo, L'Oreal, Unilever, Procter & Gamble, etc and see what they look for. The academic standard is very high and if she gets into one of those companies she can work all over the world and will be making more money than a doctor by the time she's 40.

NovemberAutumn · 10/03/2024 10:14

MassiveOvaryaction · 10/03/2024 10:05

@JanseyB are you actually sad because you feel she's limiting herself, or because she's not planning to do what you wanted for her.
I think her plan sounds great, and I wouldn't be sad if it was something my dc wanted.

Growing up ddad always said he wanted one dc to be a solicitor and one an accountant. We neither are, but are happy and successful in our chosen fields and ddad has since said that that was all he wanted really.

My DM is 75 and was a child of an exceptionally pushy mother who prided herself of being a 'matriarch'. She had 4 kids. She was very clear what she expected them to do. One (my DM) was to be a nurse. One was to be a doctor (my uncle) one was to be a teacher (my aunt) and one was to stay at home and take care of her for all her days (other aunt). That was the expectation and anything else was not permitted. All the children followed those paths. My mother was miserable every day or her nursing life from the age of 17 to when she was 55 and retired due to her poor mental health. My uncle became a doctor until he retired due to his poor mental health and became a carpenter instead. Teacher aunt was the worst sort of person to ever be a teacher (similar to her mother) and was removed from the teaching profession for life due to inappropriate discipline practices. She then became the manager of a cafe. The stay at home aunt did that until her parents died and then had nothing and basically has to be propped up financially by her siblings.

Their parents' expectations probably ruined their lives- or at least certainly the first 30 years or so of their adult lives. But on paper they were achieving the success my grandmother demanded.

OP's daughter sounds fabulous.

Wafflesandcrepes · 10/03/2024 10:10

Hi OP, your daughter sounds very academic, very creative and very together actually. She’s just choosing a different path than the rest of the family and this makes her even more precious in my eyes.

I work in marketing and comms for a big, global brand. Your daughter is exactly the kind of graduates I’m looking for: interesting and interested and with a strong grasp of language and art. Wow.

For background, I studied law. And I can’t imagine anything worse than reviewing contracts all day or standing in court. And I certainly couldn’t do the super long hours. I’m happy. And my legal background means I get on well with our legal and compliance colleagues, which is a big plus for me in the eyes of my managers.

My advice for what it’s worth: spend time with your previous daughter, learn from her, let her open your eyes and mind to new things and cherish the diversity she brings to your family unit.

And my advice to her when choosing her first marketing role : go for a big consumer brand (ie: the likes of Unilever, Samsung etc…). This is where the interesting work is when it comes to marketing.

TerrorAustralis · 10/03/2024 10:10

Normallyfine · 10/03/2024 09:52

I had parents with similiar views to yours and guess what? We have an incredibly strained relationship. I’m a professional violinist. Even after graduating with Masters and on full scholarship from the top conservatoire in the UK, it isn’t enough. Even being employed in one of the worlds top orchestras isn’t good enough. Nothing will ever be good enough I’m afraid. You remind me of my parents who are coincidentally also doctors…….

I constantly get the “why don’t you become a doctor/other professional” wank from them. It’s exhausting and stupid. This is what I want to do with my life. As a result I hardly speak to my parents. It’s caused unnecessary friction for years. It sucks being the scapegoat. My brother who is a doctor continues to get the golden child treatment. Trust me when I say I’ve been in therapy and on medication for YEARS. I suffer from chronic anxiety and the worst self esteem issues, and it’s mainly because of this.

Please don’t dictate your daughters life. Let her follow her passion.

Edited

This is terribly sad. If you were my child I would be incredibly proud of you being a successful professional musician.

Testina · 10/03/2024 10:09

“DD is saying she wants a gap year, 4 year (year abroad) undergrad then possibly marketing masters. Which just seems a bit chaotic.”

It doesn’t sound remotely chaotic.

As my grade 9 (and further maths and Olympiad - though tbf lowest rung of Olympiad) daughter said to her friends who expressed surprise when she didn’t take the A level, “just because I’m good at maths, doesn’t mean I like maths”.

You really need to back off a smart girl who has a good plan. I’d be more worried about her brother who I’ll bet has got no interest in law at all.

misskatamari · 10/03/2024 10:07

Yabu.

I teach A level (one of the sciences), and it’s so obvious which students are doing the course because their parents have pushed/encouraged them to do it. It’s such a young age to have to make these decisions that set the course of your life, and honestly I think good on her for knowing herself well enough to say “I don’t know what I want yet, I want time to figure it out”.

Getting a 9 at GCSE maths shows she’s an intelligent young woman. But if she’s no interest in the subject that means nothing when it comes to further study. Please support her and encourage her to find a path doing something she loves. It’s so much more important that doing a course because it’s what you’re “good at”

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 10/03/2024 10:06

I read law.

As did my father, his wife, my uncle (by marriage), an aunt and a few others.

And based on what I’ve seen I would be more concerned about that career path (despite rather enjoying it myself, btw!). All purely anecdotal and based on a heavily skewed sample size, but still…

Your DD has a plan and intends to do something she enjoys (with perfectly decent career prospects). There’s nothing chaotic about that! Please don’t disapprove simply because she doesn’t want to follow the path you deem appropriate / desirable.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Xs-UEqJ85KE

Don't Be A Lawyer - feat. Burl Moseley - "Crazy Ex-Girlfriend"

Buy the season 4 album here: https://lnk.to/ceg4Don't Be A LawyerStarring Burl Moseley, Clark MooreWritten by Rachel Bloom, Jack Dolgen, & Adam SchlesingerJi...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Xs-UEqJ85KE

ilovesushi · 10/03/2024 10:05

Your DD sounds very together and focused. A gap year is a great idea particularly if she can spend it abroad honing her language skills. The unis she is applying for sound like very good ones. I am sure she could arrange a deferral and if she changes her mind about her course, she could enquire with admissions about transferring to a different degree course. Or she could go through the process again. None of this is a disaster. She sounds like a very bright girl who is doing some serious thinking about what she enjoys, what she is good at and what her future career aspirations are. I don't think you can ask for more than that. Please support her.

MassiveOvaryaction · 10/03/2024 10:05

@JanseyB are you actually sad because you feel she's limiting herself, or because she's not planning to do what you wanted for her.
I think her plan sounds great, and I wouldn't be sad if it was something my dc wanted.

Growing up ddad always said he wanted one dc to be a solicitor and one an accountant. We neither are, but are happy and successful in our chosen fields and ddad has since said that that was all he wanted really.

pinkpopcorn123 · 10/03/2024 10:04

My husband and I are also both Doctors. Our DC is studying an ology at a Russell group university. They love their course and I am very proud of them. It's their life, not ours. FWIW my non medical parents pushed my sibling down a science route for a greater earning potential. It didn't end well.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/03/2024 10:03

@JanseyB
DD is saying she wants a gap year, 4 year (year abroad) undergrad then possibly marketing masters

So she has a clear plan - its just not your plan.

Which just seems a bit chaotic

What is chaotic about the plan? Its clear - gap year, degree in business and languages followed by a business specialism.

The world of careers is wider than medicine, law and accounting. Don't kid yourselves either that she won't pick up on your disappointment in her compared to her brother when all she has done is to choose a different career path.

RosesAndHellebores · 10/03/2024 10:02

@JanseyB if a child or young person can't follow their dreams before they reach their mid 20s when can they?

Having fluency in a foreign language is extremely important to leading employers, whatever the field.

Please don't make the assumption that what your dc want to do now won't change in the next few years.

At 18/19 DS wanted to be a war correspondent and joined the TA, and edited his uni paper to that end. He decided he wanted to do an MSC in Philosophy, then he did a DPhil. He's now an acadiemic! Who knew.

In Lower 6th, dd was set on the conservatoire route with her singing. At the start of Upper 6th she decided to read Anthropology. Oxford turned her down. She aced her A'Levels, turned down her anthropology offer before getting in the car and when she sat down simply said "well Oxford didn't want me, let's see if Cambridge does". She read theology at Cambridge having downloaded the data sets for admissions and noting she had a 5:1 chance opposed to an 11:1 chance for Anthropology. Both, she concluded, studied the beliefs and cultures of different people. Like your dd she's a cracking linguist and kept Arabic going through three years. In her gap year she did a bit of hospitality and learnt British Sign Language!

She took a 1st despite a uni experience beset by Covid. She also did a bit of footlights and opera up there. She continues to Act and sing.

She's teaching English (and a bit of Drama) at secondary.

They both had an education that provided them with choices and potentially could set them up to be lawyers or bankers. It isn't what either wanted.

We can facilitate choice and success for our children but we can't make their choices for them. Our DC are mid/late 20s now, yikes ds nearly 30, we have seen many of their contemporaries slip off the paths carved for them by their parents.

Please don't underestimate your dd or the importance of fluency in another language in 21st Century Britain. Also, the grass isn't always greener. Many people earn eye watering amounts in Finance but very very few develop grey hairs in that world - many slither into sales in other sectors. Magic Circle Law firms and the big accountancy firms pay six figures shortly post qual but for that they buy one's soul and the pyramid is steep towards partnership.

However, almost every sector needs a comms and marketing expert and ones who are numerate as well as literate, with a language thrown in, can go a very long way, probably for 9 hours a day mostly, rather than 12 to 15.

I think you do your dd down and possibly expect too much from your ds. Law is exceptionally competitive and, believe it or not, the best magic circle firms and Chambers are looking for a second language.

Our children, including yours, are rarely predictable.

Apologies for the essay.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 10/03/2024 10:00

I went to King’s, 4-year modern languages degree with a year abroad. Took a few different jobs after uni but ended up as a manager working in marketing. My advice would be to sack off the gap year as she will have a year abroad anyway. Get temp jobs as content creator / marketing assistant etc during holidays etc. OR change the plan entirely and apply for an arts-based uni like University of the Arts in a field such as marketing / publishing etc. and lots of unis like this have a temp scheme for students to be able to apply for relevant jobs while they study. Lots of degrees have outbound opportunities abroad even if just during summer. Look up these opportunities to try and sell it to her that she can get overseas while she studies.

Twiglets1 · 10/03/2024 09:57

Normallyfine · 10/03/2024 09:52

I had parents with similiar views to yours and guess what? We have an incredibly strained relationship. I’m a professional violinist. Even after graduating with Masters and on full scholarship from the top conservatoire in the UK, it isn’t enough. Even being employed in one of the worlds top orchestras isn’t good enough. Nothing will ever be good enough I’m afraid. You remind me of my parents who are coincidentally also doctors…….

I constantly get the “why don’t you become a doctor/other professional” wank from them. It’s exhausting and stupid. This is what I want to do with my life. As a result I hardly speak to my parents. It’s caused unnecessary friction for years. It sucks being the scapegoat. My brother who is a doctor continues to get the golden child treatment. Trust me when I say I’ve been in therapy and on medication for YEARS. I suffer from chronic anxiety and the worst self esteem issues, and it’s mainly because of this.

Please don’t dictate your daughters life. Let her follow her passion.

Edited

Sorry to hear that - you have an incredibly successful career by almost anybody’s standards. Shame your parents have to be the outliers 🙁

Pinkoctopus6 · 10/03/2024 09:56

I know parents like you. Pushy.

It is YOU who are restricting your child’s choices.

You should take a long hard look in the mirror and give your (nearly) adult child freedom to choose her own life path.

do you accept that you are a stereotypical doctor-parent?

TheThreeCheesesOfTheApocalypse44 · 10/03/2024 09:54

The number of kids I know who struggle to use their degrees because of lack of life experience and work history.......I think your dd is making the right choice.

Maybe an apprenticeship of some sort would be better suited to her.

Normallyfine · 10/03/2024 09:52

I had parents with similiar views to yours and guess what? We have an incredibly strained relationship. I’m a professional violinist. Even after graduating with Masters and on full scholarship from the top conservatoire in the UK, it isn’t enough. Even being employed in one of the worlds top orchestras isn’t good enough. Nothing will ever be good enough I’m afraid. You remind me of my parents who are coincidentally also doctors…….

I constantly get the “why don’t you become a doctor/other professional” wank from them. It’s exhausting and stupid. This is what I want to do with my life. As a result I hardly speak to my parents. It’s caused unnecessary friction for years. It sucks being the scapegoat. My brother who is a doctor continues to get the golden child treatment. Trust me when I say I’ve been in therapy and on medication for YEARS. I suffer from chronic anxiety and the worst self esteem issues, and it’s mainly because of this.

Please don’t dictate your daughters life. Let her follow her passion.

Namechange25793 · 10/03/2024 09:45

She’s sounds great, especially the part about being a social people person. That will stand her in good stead.

Poor her having such a judgemental and pushy mum. Perhaps that’s why she wants some time out, to explore her own plans in her own time and space without your interference.

Give her space. Let her be. Even if she makes mistakes she will learn from them.

Sparkymoo · 10/03/2024 09:42

Her plan is entirely sensible. Support her.

Plus, bear in mind that many people start the kind of structured career path that makes you feel safe and leave it because it's not right for them.

Marketing is a well paid, interesting role for those who like it. A modern language is an increasingly scarce skill in the UK - plus taking a year out to work out what she wants is a great idea, she will develop soft skills and maturity.

Taking the piss slightly but maybe you need the career advice to respect your daughter and see that there are many ways to develop a career and develop as an adult and she is putting more planning and thought into it than the average.

AngelinaFibres · 10/03/2024 09:40

ViciousCurrentBun · 10/03/2024 09:29

Far better to take a gap year than make a mistake.

DS had been set to go in to the air force and they were very keen, he was in air cadets and had been in some meetings and was going to go funded degree route as a trainee officer. But he changed his mind.

He ended up working for almost two years and is now doing a Degree apprenticeship. He is very happy and fulfilled doing something he loves and studying hard whilst getting paid.

Read the posts on here of people that have children that refuse school and study, lay around gaming all the time, do drugs. You really do not have a problem at all.

My eldest son was set on the army and going to Sandhurst. He was in the army cadets and very, very fit. He passed the first assessment period for Sandhurst but then another opportunity came along and he took it. Through that he went back to Uni to do a masters , met his fabulous American wife, who was doing a masters at the same uni, and he now works for that uni . He gets paid a huge amount of money and no one is trying to shoot him or blow him up. We supported whatever he wanted to do.

BobbyBiscuits · 10/03/2024 09:40

There's nothing wrong with wanting a career in marketing surely? It covers lots of different things as well, from business to entertainment, fashion, law, academic...all these fields can have marketing related roles.

She does not necessarily have a clear path, but that is OK. You can't force someone to study maths and aspire to work for Goldman Sachs when they are clearly into the more creative side of things.

I'd say be supportive, the gap year will be very enriching. As long as she is travelling and not just dossing about at home.

She will find her feet eventually. She's clearly very bright.

Some people like you and DH knew all along what career you wanted. Which is great. Same with my Mum as a teacher. But me, I didn't really know at all until I was in my mid 20s.

Alaimo · 10/03/2024 09:38

I got good grades in school. Did lots of sciences and had the grades to get into medicine (grew up in a European country where there are no interviews for medicine, it's solely based on grades). I decided to take a gap year. Then took a second gap year. Ended up studying politics & international relations. Once I got to university I was focused, genuinely wanted to be there and loved studying, unlike many of my peers who'd started straight after A-levels.

I'm in my mid-30s now, and a university lecturer. To be honest, if I'd gone down the medicine route I probably would earn twice as much as I do. However, I have a career I love. I've had the opportunity to live in a few different countries. Regularly get to travel for work. It's everything I've ever wanted from a job.

HungryBeagle · 10/03/2024 09:38

There’s nothing wrong with her path. I did a similar degree, with a year abroad. Also a post grad marketing qualification. I now earn six figures and love my job. Just because she isn’t following your path, it doesn’t mean it’s not the right path for her.

user1984778379202 · 10/03/2024 09:37

She doesn’t sound lost at all. What she sounds is at odds with a mother who is projecting massively her own ambitions onto her. She is not you. You are not her. Let her follow her own path.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 10/03/2024 09:36

Mexicola · 10/03/2024 08:44

Separate note - if your son wants to do law why is he doing history?

He’ll waste a year and massive expense doing GDL to cram the 7 modules into a year.

Better to do law undergrad to start with.

Not really. Better to get a stellar class in a subject he loves.

But perhaps he doesn’t actually want to do Law: he’s just telling his mother he does so she won’t make a fuss about his wanting to do History.

Swipe left for the next trending thread