Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sad DD might be limiting herself

357 replies

JanseyB · 10/03/2024 02:25

I have twins, they are 17, in sixth form.
DD is on paper the more intelligent of the two, 8/9a at GCSE and predicted 2 A* and 2 As at a-level (French, German, Art and English). She is at a good local indie but the careers advisor seems to pay little attention to her (more interested in the Law, Medicine and Finance candidates).

DD has applied for Business/Management and German for uni. She's applied to Kings, UCL, Manchester, Bristol and Queen Mary, she has some offers back.

DD has now announced she wants to take a gap year, then maybe change her course of study all together. She has savings and will get some money for her 18th so she has said she wants to work and travel and figure it out.
DD actually wants to work in marketing but wants to do a degree related to foreign language as it's something she is naturally talented at.

DS is so much more put together, studying history then wants to do law and has a clear plan.

DD is saying she wants a gap year, 4 year (year abroad) undergrad then possibly marketing masters. Which just seems a bit chaotic.

She is so smart, I wasn't massively supportive of her A-level choices and I feel like we are going through it again. She got a bloody 9 in maths at GCSE and it feels such a waste to throw it away. She's also very sociable, likeable, sporty and works so hard, it just seems she's a bit lost?!

DH and I are both doctors, our path was quite clear and laid out from leaving school so I'm not sure how to approach this.

AIBU thinking she might be throwing it all away. How can I get her better careers advice when school aren't helping? She used to want to work in finance and I'm a little sad that over the last 2 years that has lost appeal to her!

Anyone here know a path that might suit DD, with her want of modern languages under grad and marking as a career with study abroad and gap years?

OP posts:
SapphireOpal · 10/03/2024 10:48

ilovebreadsauce · 10/03/2024 10:22

I think people saying encouraging them do whatever degree they want, are probably speaking from a position of financial privilege and being able to support their kids to retrain when they find their degree doesn't lead to a job where they can support a decent lifestyle

I know far more people who have had to retrain because their parents forced them into a "status" career that they hated and was awful for their mental health than the opposite.

MinkyWinky · 10/03/2024 10:47

She sounds like she is actually quite clear on what she wants to do. Marketing has the potential to be a really good career. She can work across lots of different industries including healthcare, finance and IT. It involves a lot of different skills. She will need to be comfortable working with figures as there is a lot of financial planning involve (budget management, strategic planning and stock planning), so her ability with maths is will be well used.

I work with people in marketing at a European level where languages are an absolutely asset. A lot of the team I work with have MBAs.

BusyMummy001 · 10/03/2024 10:46

Just going to add, my DD was a straight 9s at GCSE student too. Felt that she was supposed to be opting for Oxbridge or a Russell Group uni and taking socially admired A levels. Flunked out of 6th form twice as she struggled with her self-perceived need to do what other’s rated as appropriate. She was benchmarking herself against us (DH Cambridge; me several academic degrees from RG unis) and against the ‘clever’ group in her year.

We’ve finally managed to make her understand that a degree in animation, despite the potential low pay if she gets into it, is absolutely fine by us and that we just want her be happy.

Nothing could make me prouder of seeing her name in the long list of credits in a Disney Pixar film one day or to see an advert and think, she did that. Am just sad that she thought we’d only be proud of her if she followed a traditional path (where, frankly, careers in medicine, law, teaching etc don’t really pay that well unless you are a high flyer and are not as respected as they once were anyway).

serin · 10/03/2024 10:44

She sounds great OP.
Let her be herself.
My DD studied English Lit with Drama. Coming from a scientific family, we were surprised but let her get on with it.
She now earns much more than her boyfriend (who is a surgeon) and has very little stress in her life.

AHaresPaw · 10/03/2024 10:44

It sounds like your are limiting your daughter to what you want her life to be, rather than her limiting herself. It sounds like she has a plan but also doesn’t want to rush into it either. Long story short, I wish I had taken my time at 18 figuring out what path I wanted to go down, so I think she’s being sensible.

LondonJax · 10/03/2024 10:43

Another vote for being unreasonable here I'm afraid.

Our DNephew had his whole career mapped out. He was going to university to study sports science, knew exactly what he wanted to do with the degree. Got to university, one term in and changed his mind. He switched to study business. His parents were fully supportive (his dad had also switched degrees after the first couple of terms in his day). Got his degree.

He started work at a major UK company, five years in he was asked if he wanted to go overseas to oversee the setting up of a new office. He'd never lived abroad and his was in Asia so a very different experience. He took a bit of advice from his parents, friends and us. All of whom said to do it. He could always come back and could always get another job if he hated it.

Ten years later he's moved around Asia, still with the same company. He's heading up a division now, married and living the best life. He and his wife travel extensively as they have money in their pockets. Changing his 'path' was the best thing he ever did. Because he knew he'd be unhappy in the path he'd originally chosen.

It takes a lot of personal insight and a bit of guts to say 'you know what, I don't think that's for me'. Ultimately your children have to live their own life and it's better that your DD gets up every day looking forward to what it will bring rather than lay awake at night wondering how she'll cope with the day ahead isn't it? That has to come from her own choice. She knows her dreams, you don't and never will completely. And, if the degree isn't right, she can switch (within reason). People retrain all the time and the gap year may give her a bit of insight - maybe even a job offer post university. Who knows?

Raincoatsandwellies · 10/03/2024 10:43

Yabu.
Whilst I do understand the logic of your thought, being good at something doesn't make you like it or want to do it for the majority of your life. Marketing is a huge market and there are a lot of specialist and niche areas to it, with great salary prospects and travelling opportunities. Add qualifications regarding foreign languages to that and she can have an exceptional salary.

This is your DDs whole life and sounds like she's looking at it long term rather than a box ticking exercise of I'm good at this I'll do it for now.

Going to uni and getting into that kind of debt - she's being sensible and making sure the options she chooses are actually worth that debt to her.
People are good at jobs they love, not because they've got a degree in it.

Better for her to make the chaos happen now, making choices that impact the next 40 years of her life than 'set' her path and get to her late 30s and feel like she's stuck in an industry she hates.

SapphireOpal · 10/03/2024 10:43

Languages and art are some of the most intense A Levels imo and that's a totally fine combination to get into even Oxbridge. Why on earth were you "not supportive" of them? Snobbery?

DS has escaped your wrath and he's doing History, a non-science subject that isn't specifically useful for many jobs. He's also planning to do a subject followed by a different masters same as his sister. Golden child dynamic by any chance?

Stop comparing your girl to her brother and back the fuck off. She's told you what she wants to do. And even if she had no idea, she's nearly 18 and it's her life.

MaloneMeadow · 10/03/2024 10:40

In what world is a gap year and a degree with a year abroad chaotic?? That’s perfectly normal and healthy!

Trulyme · 10/03/2024 10:40

OP do you have any regrets in your life?

Do you not wish that you could have chosen your path a bit more or had more freedom?

I am going to encourage my DD to go to uni and get a decent job but I’m also going to encourage her to travel, get life experience and have as much fun as she possibly can whilst she’s still young.

You’ve got your entire life you get a good career.
You only have one shot at being young and free.

RoseGoldEagle · 10/03/2024 10:39

She doesn't sound at all like she is limiting herself. It's her life OP. I know you want her to "reach her maximum potential"- but what does that even mean, really? Pursuing a career that will get her the most amount of money? Pursuing a career that is well respected? Even if that's not where her passions lie and won't make her happy? What's the POINT of it all, really, if you're just focused on doing well for the sake of doing well, rather than enjoying your one and only life? I know SO many unhappy doctors, vets, lawyers etc etc- none of these well respected options are of any value at all if you're not going to enjoy them. You are the one that seems to have the limited view of what makes a worthwhile choice, she sounds confident, she has a plan- you need to let her make her own choices. She might find something she thrives at and adores, she might bounce around a few things and struggle for a while, but to be a well rounded adult you have to make these choices for yourself. If you've done a good job parenting her, and it sounds like you have, she will be well able to find her own path- not the one you think is right for her.

ilovebreadsauce · 10/03/2024 10:37

I will also say a grade 9 at maths gcse ( not even FM) is really not evidence of being good at maths! Grin

KattyBoomBoom95 · 10/03/2024 10:36

I'd let her carve her own path. I was pushed down the degree/corporate job path and hated it. Spent a few years at a desk and was bored out my mind. I sacked it off to do something fun as life is too short (driving trucks in my case).

Family were horrified but I'm now doing very well running a haulage business with a mate. We have trucks in Cemex, Hanson, Aggregate Industries, and Tarmac, and are doing lots of work on HS2, Midlands Metro, and many other big civil builds.

Was just a waste paying back all that money on a student loan for nothing!

AngelinaFibres · 10/03/2024 10:34

TerrorAustralis · 10/03/2024 10:10

This is terribly sad. If you were my child I would be incredibly proud of you being a successful professional musician.

Me too. Went to a concert once at Symphony Hall. A little girl sat next to me. She was about 8 and absolutely fizzing with excitement. She had fabulous red hair. When the orchestra came out she said to me " that's my aunt there". Her aunt was the 1st violin ( with the same fabulous hair).The child's parents and grandparents were in the row. The pride from them was enormous. I am so sorry you haven't felt that.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 10/03/2024 10:33

So the OP has returned to reply to one post that does not answer the question she asked and has not responded to all of the people telling her why she is being unreasonable.

waltzingintomonday · 10/03/2024 10:33

Yes, YABU. I took a gap year, then a 4 year languages degree, then did a masters in something unrelated. My parents were insistent I should be studying sciences or maths at A-level, but I didn't want to. I really feel for your DD. She could be the best mathematician in the world but if she doesn't enjoy it, then that's what matters most. Her decisions don't sound at all outlandish, she just needs your support.
For what it's worth, my brother took the maths/sciences route. He enjoyed it. We now work in the same field and are both successful.

NovemberAutumn · 10/03/2024 10:33

MassiveOvaryaction · 10/03/2024 10:27

That sounds really hard. The only non-negotiable we had really was going to uni. I know they were concerned that I'd picked something I enjoyed rather than something I was naturally good at, but I was still supported in my choices. I'm glad my parents weren't like your grandmother!

I am glad also that MY parents were not like my grandmother! They were both really clear 'Do whatever interests you at university- your path will follow'. They were right. I say that now to my Dcs.

BusyMummy001 · 10/03/2024 10:30

I think your DD sounds very together.

A year out to earn, travel, become more fluent in a language and be certain that the degree choice she’s made is the right one for her sounds eminently sensible. It may boost her self confidence, develop self-reliance and independence all things that will enhance her university experience.

It’s a little unfair to compare her to her brother and maybe she is hoping the year apart will enable her to be seen independently from him and not constantly measured against him.

I’d support her and let her make her own decision on this.

MassiveOvaryaction · 10/03/2024 10:27

NovemberAutumn · 10/03/2024 10:14

My DM is 75 and was a child of an exceptionally pushy mother who prided herself of being a 'matriarch'. She had 4 kids. She was very clear what she expected them to do. One (my DM) was to be a nurse. One was to be a doctor (my uncle) one was to be a teacher (my aunt) and one was to stay at home and take care of her for all her days (other aunt). That was the expectation and anything else was not permitted. All the children followed those paths. My mother was miserable every day or her nursing life from the age of 17 to when she was 55 and retired due to her poor mental health. My uncle became a doctor until he retired due to his poor mental health and became a carpenter instead. Teacher aunt was the worst sort of person to ever be a teacher (similar to her mother) and was removed from the teaching profession for life due to inappropriate discipline practices. She then became the manager of a cafe. The stay at home aunt did that until her parents died and then had nothing and basically has to be propped up financially by her siblings.

Their parents' expectations probably ruined their lives- or at least certainly the first 30 years or so of their adult lives. But on paper they were achieving the success my grandmother demanded.

OP's daughter sounds fabulous.

That sounds really hard. The only non-negotiable we had really was going to uni. I know they were concerned that I'd picked something I enjoyed rather than something I was naturally good at, but I was still supported in my choices. I'm glad my parents weren't like your grandmother!

Ireolu · 10/03/2024 10:24

You remind me of my mum. Horrified about my initial choice for degree. Swayed me into a professional degree. Now have zero job satisfaction managed by working part time. Support and listen to your DD who is clearly very bright and will be fine.

ilovebreadsauce · 10/03/2024 10:22

I think people saying encouraging them do whatever degree they want, are probably speaking from a position of financial privilege and being able to support their kids to retrain when they find their degree doesn't lead to a job where they can support a decent lifestyle

CaribouCarafe · 10/03/2024 10:21

My mum could've written the same thing as you, I was predicted A* and As at A level, had a Cambridge offer etc. Decided to do a "fluffy" humanity rather than go into law/medicine/finance.

Guess what, my brain didn't atrophy!

10 years later, I'm now a high earner with a much better work/life balance than any doctors, lawyers or finance people that I know.

Life is about more than just getting a status job.

DGPP · 10/03/2024 10:19

It doesn’t sound remotely chaotic. There is nothing wrong with creative industries, gap years or four year degrees.
I have all of the above, work in a creative area, earn plenty and am top of my field.
Let your daughter find her own way.

Maria1982 · 10/03/2024 10:19

please don’t make the (very common) mistake parents make of projecting onto our children what we think ‘good’ is.

she sounds smart. She doesn’t sound chaotic to me! She wants to have a gap year - that is probably perfectly sensible!

Many of us - myself included - bowed to parental pressure and were influenced into choosing something ‘suitable’ at university. Sometimes it works out, sometimes it doesn’t. My dad went to uni to do law, as his father had done. Quit within the year, did modern languages and became an interpreter instead. Loved his job his whole life.

Not only do I think you should not try to push your opinions onto your DD, I think you should work really hard to try to learn about what she likes, and like it with her, to an extent. Otherwise I’m sure your feelings will be showing to her, and she will feel less-than her brother. Which is such an awful, miserable feeling, and so unnecessary when she’s clearly bright but just not interested in what you think of as a suitable career path.

SoSo99 · 10/03/2024 10:16

TrentCrimmOfTheIndependent · 10/03/2024 04:13

How strange - your DD literally has a plan? It’s just not the plan you want her to have.

She sounds more switched on than many 17yo IMO. My DDs didn’t have a clue about their careers at that age/stage. Incidentally they both studied modern languages and have now decided to become lawyers, and have got training contracts / vac schemes at City law firms. So they have studied what they wanted to and are now on a ‘professional’ route, but I would have equally been happy if they’d chosen something else instead.

Please support your daughter, she sounds fab. And I hope you don’t make it clear that you prefer your son’s plans - that would really alienate her.

<<What this person said. SO many people would be delighted to have a daughter as switched on and motivated as your daughter. Please don't screw it up for her by imposing your fixed views