Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours keep asking for favours!

513 replies

Popcornlassie28 · 09/03/2024 23:12

My husband and I live in a village around 15 minutes from the local shops etc. We currently have two children and I’m pregnant with our third. We both work (I work shifts) and I’m also studying at uni so I’m always constantly busy being a mother, at work or as a student.

My neighbours are middle aged with no children. One drives and the other doesn’t. Recently due to medical reasons the one who drives has had to stop driving until a health clear.

Since then, I will be home with the children before/after school, getting ready for work or coming off a night shift that morning and SO ready to sleep and my neighbour will come knocking asking to be taken to work often because she’s ’missed the bus’, ‘bus doesn’t run at this time’ etc. They do not take no for an answer and she will return two, three times plus until I answer as she knows I’m home as my car is in the driveway. She is very forceful.

I haven’t minded up until this point helping where we can but it’s getting a bit much. There is never any offer for fuel money either and it’s a 30 minute round trip to drop her to where she needs to go.

In the warmer weather, they will put their heads over the fence while I’m relaxing in my garden to ask for things and ask my children ‘Go and grab Mummy/Daddy’ so they can ask for more lifts/favours. My garden should be a safe haven where my children can play and we should relax without being bothered? Or am I wrong here? I would knock the front door and if they don’t answer I wouldn’t dream of being that pushy.

I have been polite to keep the peace but they are now asking my husband to give lifts at 8am into work on Sunday morning as ‘bus isn’t running’ and even though I’m pregnant ‘Can you pick up the 2 litre bottles of water from the shop for me? They are heavy for me to carry on the bus’. My husband is saying it’s going too far and to start pushing back and being forceful with her.

How can I be forceful but polite? Am I being unreasonable? I am terrified when the baby comes she will be banging the door down to be taken out when I’ve just got them settled and I don’t want to fall out but I know I will lose my temper at this point.

OP posts:
Ilovecleaning · 12/03/2024 10:32

DriftingDora · 12/03/2024 08:36

I'll help you order a taxi"

No, you don't offer this, otherwise you'll probably end up being asked to help her go to the toilet as well.

When will people get the message that the only viable way to deal with people like this is a flat "no" - no silly excuses, no apologetic manner, just a firm decisive "NO". These people are not just thick, they are mega-thick - but they are devious and manipulative and just looking for that chink in your armour. Silly excuses will never solve the problem, as Mrs Nobrain will just return again and again. If she still persists after a couple of firm NO's, then it's time for a police/legal intervention - and telling her so.

Absolutely right. I have a relative through marriage and I have reduced contact dramatically and refused ‘invitations’ ( which means ‘ would you like to go xyz, give us a lift and you pay’) and said no no no until eventually they stopped asking. More to the point, I do not care how they feel about it and I couldn’t care less whether they like me or not: that’s how OP (who seems a nice person) should feel. Or try to 😊

Mountainpika · 12/03/2024 10:21

Keep the petrol low in the car. Next time they ask, drive them to the nearest garage and say, "Well either you pay for a tankful of petrol, or I'll go straight home again."

Scaffoldingisugly · 12/03/2024 10:12

Sprinklers around your entrances. Set them when you are home only...

Mountainpika · 12/03/2024 10:12

As others have said, just say no. Give no reasons, no excuses, no 'sorry'. Nothing that she can pick up on and try and argue with or question.
Write NO on bits of paper and every time she asks, give her one of the bits of paper.

Ginandpangolins · 12/03/2024 10:10

masterblaster · 12/03/2024 07:12

“I’ve had wine”
”at 7 am? Whilst pregnant?”
”don’t judge me”.

Love this! Please do this.

104c · 12/03/2024 10:06

Nope can't help, midwife has said I am strictly limited to essential [driving/shopping/whatever you are being asked] only and need my uninterrupted rest hours as im so busy with work, children and study. Here's the card for a nice local taxi firm though - much easier than the bus!

MadDogMama · 12/03/2024 10:02

I have a neighbour like this, she expects the world to respond to her needs and she really started to take the piss out of my generosity. DH and I were going through a particularly stressful time due to a major, life altering event and we (I) had to stop pandering to her, so the next time she asked us to help her I politely told her we were under so much pressure ourselves and wouldn't be able to help (she knew what we were going through). She became quite unkind to me and I stood my ground with a firm "I'm sorry, but you are going to have to start asking other people to help you".
She hasn't asked for anything since. Despite this, we are still pleasant when we see one another in the street.

Some people in life are takers, and the more you give, the more they will expect.
Stand your ground firmly and stick to your guns. You aren't there to sort their lives out, they will have to find another way.

Mommamil · 12/03/2024 09:19

That's outrageous, tell them they will have to get taxis or ubers next time they want a lift. They can sign up for home delivery shopping if they can't make it to the shops, that's a straightforward way to solve that issue for them.

DriftingDora · 12/03/2024 08:36

74Violette · 12/03/2024 08:05

Why is your neighbour not using taxis like any normal person in the same situation? Absolute CF
Next time she asks for a lift say, "I'm sorry I can't I'm very tired and fuel is expensive. I'll help you order a taxi"

I'll help you order a taxi"

No, you don't offer this, otherwise you'll probably end up being asked to help her go to the toilet as well.

When will people get the message that the only viable way to deal with people like this is a flat "no" - no silly excuses, no apologetic manner, just a firm decisive "NO". These people are not just thick, they are mega-thick - but they are devious and manipulative and just looking for that chink in your armour. Silly excuses will never solve the problem, as Mrs Nobrain will just return again and again. If she still persists after a couple of firm NO's, then it's time for a police/legal intervention - and telling her so.

74Violette · 12/03/2024 08:05

Why is your neighbour not using taxis like any normal person in the same situation? Absolute CF
Next time she asks for a lift say, "I'm sorry I can't I'm very tired and fuel is expensive. I'll help you order a taxi"

biscuitsnow · 12/03/2024 07:43

Why are people suggesting baseball bats and drinking wine at 7am? thats ridiculous- this neighbour is clearly an arsehole and will likely call the police if she does that. Then, she'll have the hassle of that and explaining it to them.

Equally- telling the neighbour to go and fuck herself sounds very tempting but someone who struggles with being a people pleaser and saying no is no way going to suddenly be able to do that, its not going to happen.

OP- all it needs is a firm but polite "no, I cannot do that". Then used the broken record technique by repeating over and over again. You must not give in as PP said, it will only teach her that she has to ask 15 times before you cave.

Don't start giving excuses eg I cant lift as am pregnant or the car isnt working. If you do that, the neighbour will just constantly come back when you arent pregnant any more and she can see you driving the car. Then you'll have to make up more and more excuses. Just say No, I cannot do it, I am too busy" every single time. If you start getting baseballs bats out she could report you for threatening her. She cannot report you for saying no to a lift.

canyouseemyhousefromhere · 12/03/2024 07:36

Your husband should knock one evening and tell them that you won't be able to give any more lifts but "here is the number of the local cab firm".

masterblaster · 12/03/2024 07:12

“I’ve had wine”
”at 7 am? Whilst pregnant?”
”don’t judge me”.

QuaintLemur · 12/03/2024 02:42

Don't make excuses. Don't apologise. It's demeaning to be put in a position where you feel you have to. Say no, you're resting/looking after your children/ studying, they have to start using a taxi service. If they keep knocking at the door or calling you outdoors, tell them to stop as it's unsettling the children. Be quiet but firm, they don't understand anything less.

27Bumblebees · 12/03/2024 02:06

"No I can't help, hope your get it sorted. Bye."

This is not your problem to solve, it is theirs. You should not be saying sorry, making excuses, parking your car elsewhere (!!??) or printing out phone numbers for local taxi firms. Just say no.

If asked why not, say "it doesn't work for me". Maintain eye contact, serene face, do not break. Then say, "hope you get it sorted, and shut the door".

chrisfromcardiff · 12/03/2024 01:31

Sleeptastic · 10/03/2024 12:47

That classic Friends line from Phoebe would work well here.

"Oh I wish I could but I don't want to."

I had forgotten this! I must adapt this into my life.

chrisfromcardiff · 12/03/2024 01:30

Bettyfromlondon · 10/03/2024 07:48

A lot of these suggestions are very wordy. Time to blast back with the minimum number of words possible:
Door knocks.
You fling it open and blast "What now?"
Request for lift.
"What!! When did I become your free taxi service! I'm fed up.of this nonsense. Don't ask me again!"
Close door.

Practise a few times to get the feel of it and get used to raising your voice a bit.
Good luck!

I like the way you think!

chrisfromcardiff · 12/03/2024 01:25

PinkArt · 09/03/2024 23:16

The old MN classics that no is a complete sentence and that doesn't work for me very much apply here. And I'd say to them, please stop asking when I've said no, it's becoming rude.
They don't sound like people you'd want to be friends with so just meet their pushiness with as firm a no as is needed to get your point across.

This. Being polite isn't working so just say, "No, I can't help you any more. Please stop asking." If they pop their head over the fence say in a very annoyed voice, "Please stop disturbing my privacy." Feel free to swear. They don't sound like people you want to be friends with at all.

potato57 · 12/03/2024 01:17

She's like a child, she's repeating the behaviour because she knows you'll give in eventually.

I would turn the doorbell off, shut the dining room curtains, and ignore the knocking. She's not going to stand there all night and knock, and she can come back and keep getting ignored until she learns.

We had a neighbour like this, if we ignored her knocking she let her dog off the lead into our front garden and he would bang on our door instead. It got to the point where I felt so uncomfortable we had shutters and cameras fitted and contacted the community support police officers. We flat out ignore her now even though she tries to have her "safe place" for parcels listed as our address; we don't accept them.

floppybit · 12/03/2024 00:29

Tell them to download the Uber app and leave you alone! They are taking the piss

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 11/03/2024 23:48

Madness. Just say you can’t help any more

Motherrr · 11/03/2024 23:26

Wow, they are behaving outrageously! I agree with the other poster saying invent a condition or something. Or just be honest and tell them no, you don't have the time. They need to get a taxi!

Ryah76 · 11/03/2024 23:25

Just say NO, the more you say it the less they will ask

pollymere · 11/03/2024 23:22

Be blindly sympathetic - just don't get what they're asking.

"Sorry I can't give you a lift. The buses not running IS really annoying. Tch You think the Council would do something about that. I'm just so sorry I can't help you but I'm so busy right now."

If she comes to the door, open it and then walk away and find things to do. Sort washing, peel potatoes - but just keep with the busy and the sympathy.

darthbreakz · 11/03/2024 22:58

Try: "are you literally fucking kidding me? You have some audacity asking a pregnany, night shift working mother of two to drive you about. Get a fucking uber and leave me alone!"

Or get some sort of doorbell that says "nope nope nope" repeatedly instead of ringing. I don't know if this exists, but it should.