Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours keep asking for favours!

513 replies

Popcornlassie28 · 09/03/2024 23:12

My husband and I live in a village around 15 minutes from the local shops etc. We currently have two children and I’m pregnant with our third. We both work (I work shifts) and I’m also studying at uni so I’m always constantly busy being a mother, at work or as a student.

My neighbours are middle aged with no children. One drives and the other doesn’t. Recently due to medical reasons the one who drives has had to stop driving until a health clear.

Since then, I will be home with the children before/after school, getting ready for work or coming off a night shift that morning and SO ready to sleep and my neighbour will come knocking asking to be taken to work often because she’s ’missed the bus’, ‘bus doesn’t run at this time’ etc. They do not take no for an answer and she will return two, three times plus until I answer as she knows I’m home as my car is in the driveway. She is very forceful.

I haven’t minded up until this point helping where we can but it’s getting a bit much. There is never any offer for fuel money either and it’s a 30 minute round trip to drop her to where she needs to go.

In the warmer weather, they will put their heads over the fence while I’m relaxing in my garden to ask for things and ask my children ‘Go and grab Mummy/Daddy’ so they can ask for more lifts/favours. My garden should be a safe haven where my children can play and we should relax without being bothered? Or am I wrong here? I would knock the front door and if they don’t answer I wouldn’t dream of being that pushy.

I have been polite to keep the peace but they are now asking my husband to give lifts at 8am into work on Sunday morning as ‘bus isn’t running’ and even though I’m pregnant ‘Can you pick up the 2 litre bottles of water from the shop for me? They are heavy for me to carry on the bus’. My husband is saying it’s going too far and to start pushing back and being forceful with her.

How can I be forceful but polite? Am I being unreasonable? I am terrified when the baby comes she will be banging the door down to be taken out when I’ve just got them settled and I don’t want to fall out but I know I will lose my temper at this point.

OP posts:
madonnasbra · 10/03/2024 09:45

YABVU OP. You should be at her beck and call whenever she needs it. You should drop everything to cater for all her needs and whims. Drive her to Scotland if she wants, cook all her meals- she shouldnt have to lift a finger. Heck, if she needs a kidney at some point you shouldnt hesitate to give her one of yours- after all thats what "nice" people do isnt it?

At the niceness awards you will be sure to win- they will give you a trophy and maybe a bunch of flowers which will make it all worthwhile.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/03/2024 09:44

BusyMummy001 · 10/03/2024 08:26

You might want to get an injunction banning her from your property…

But first she has to tell her not to come round!!!!!!!

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/03/2024 09:41

FOJN · 10/03/2024 08:17

I think this has gone on to long for a tension free refusal now so you are just going to have to be firm and direct. I agree with other posters, never use the word sorry in your refusal.

"No I can't give you a lift, you'll have to find an alternative from now on."

Never give a reason for why you can't do something. People who ask for a reason when you have said no are just looking to start negotiating, refuse to engage, they do not and will never respect other peoples boundaries.

Lwrenn I love your post.

People who ask for a reason when you have said no are just looking to start negotiating

which is why all the 'oh I'm really busy' / 'about to give the kids tea' just doesn't work.

dont try to explain

MyFirstLittlePony · 10/03/2024 09:39

Why are you worried about inconveniencing her, by not running errands at the drop of a hat … when she has no regard for you?

why even THINK you should do anything for her?

ehy be such a doormat? Why why why

pinkstripeycat · 10/03/2024 09:39

*pile your kids in the car …

pinkstripeycat · 10/03/2024 09:38

When my 2 DC were little I wouldn’t have had the time to run people around! I didn’t have time to even sit in the garden! It was constant cooking meals, tidying up, household chores and entertaining & enjoying time with DC.

OP, with a job, being pregnant and having 2 DC already how on earth do you have half an hour to drive randoms around? Do you mobile your kids in the car and take them too? How strange.

Tell them no. You are tired, busy, cooking, not safe to drive as finished a shift, no money for petrol. All of those and more.

PinkIcedCream · 10/03/2024 09:38

Stop worrying about being nice, kind or polite as your neighbour has a brass neck as long as a chimney!

Allwelcone · 10/03/2024 09:38

Yes I'd be massively direct here "please leave me alone" and put up a tall fence.

Gettingbysomehow · 10/03/2024 09:33

I'm an NHS diabetes specialist podiatrist and one of my patients lived in the house opposite. She would forever be sending her kids over to say mum isn't well had cut herself, is having a hypo etc. I went round there are said in no uncertain terms that I am not a 24 hour podiatry call out service and I'm entitled to my time off. Any problems outside of normal service are dealt with by 111 or A&e and I made this very clear to her

Gettingbysomehow · 10/03/2024 09:29

For God's sake can't anyone say no any more? Id be saying LOOK neighbour. I work. I'm pregnant and I've got my hands full with the kids. I have enough to do and you ll have to ask someone else. I haven't got time to manage your life as well as my own. I'm afraid you will have to stand on your own two feet.

ffsgiveitarest · 10/03/2024 09:28

I’d say ‘my husband and I don’t run a taxi service. Here is the number for the local taxi company’ hand her the number and shut the door.

if she knocks again say, ‘look I’ve given you a number please use it, and if you continue knocking I’ve no option but to report you to the police. Now please kindly go away I’m busy’ and shut the door

comfyslippets · 10/03/2024 09:21

Just keep saying no. Don't have to be rude, can just say it's not convenient atm etc. Don't give reasons, it's none of their business. Absolutely stick to it, they'll soon get the hint and give up. You must stick to it though. If they're put out who cares, they certainly don't care about you and absolutely know they're taking the piss. This makes me so angry because I would have been like you a few years ago, too embarrassed to say no or doing it because they will go on and on until you do it. It's because you're kind and like to help. They sound horrible people. Say to yourself that from today that's it. Rude fuckers

Ariona · 10/03/2024 09:17

This is on YOU. Where is your voice, your mouth and you own ability to be an adult? I'm not being harsh, I'm being realistic. No one can be 'forceful' if you set your boundaries.

Answer the door, and say 'I have two babies and I'm heavily pregnant. Why do you think it's ok to ask this of me?' I guarantee you that will shock them enough to never ask again.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 10/03/2024 09:15

Bettyfromlondon · 10/03/2024 07:48

A lot of these suggestions are very wordy. Time to blast back with the minimum number of words possible:
Door knocks.
You fling it open and blast "What now?"
Request for lift.
"What!! When did I become your free taxi service! I'm fed up.of this nonsense. Don't ask me again!"
Close door.

Practise a few times to get the feel of it and get used to raising your voice a bit.
Good luck!

Yep, OP needs to find her inner voice. Try watching this OP, it’s still on Iplayer but you get the gist:-

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=c37lAV3QWSE

All the best bits from Two Doors Down Series 5 😂 - BBC

Subscribe and 🔔 to the BBC 👉 https://bit.ly/BBCYouTubeSubWatch the BBC first on iPlayer 👉 https://bbc.in/iPlayer-HomeMore from our favourite nosey neighbo...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=c37lAV3QWSE

BMW6 · 10/03/2024 09:14

OP you really have to stand up to her or be her bitch.

Take your pick.

AIstolemylunch · 10/03/2024 09:14

If this was me I'd refuse to confront them, write notes, send husband round etc- why should they push you into being confrontational? I'd go full on passive aggressive. When she ring for a lift, I'd cough in her face and say 'can't go out, got covid'. Then I'd develop long covid. This will.cover you for weeks. When she sees you driving your kids around etc, you're feeling better but still testing positive, better stand back. Then after the baby arrives, oh dear, you've unfortunately had a bottle of wine, can't possibly drive. About to feed baby etc. I'd basically enjoy saying no with a nonsense excuse every single time and see how long it took to get the message.

Also, get shutters or blinds so they can't peer in. Get a ring or Google doorbell so you can shout 'sorry, can't come to the door, on the loo I've got an upset stomach' through it.

I'd just resolve, right, no more lifts and then do this until they miss enough appointments, are late for things etc enough that they give up. I'd also turn off the doorbell in the evenings or when you're sleeping.

slore · 10/03/2024 09:09

Popcornlassie28 · 10/03/2024 08:22

@Collywobblewobbles She’s forceful in the way she will ring the ring doorbell, then bangs my other doorbell and then bangs the actual door. I was on the phone once with the midwife so couldn’t answer then anyways. But she stands there for about 10 minutes each time.

Then she will go away, come back and repeat the same within a 15 minute window. Then if I don’t answer she is in the garden putting her head over the fence and looking into my living room. Then she will be back on the door again and again and again. Then you will answer and be like ‘Right now, no sorry’ and she will not take the word NO.

She keeps begging and asking. Then if you still say ‘No’ she gets quite shitty and then moans about the children being loud and there is a really awful atmosphere. She will glare as you come and go for ages. Then when she wants something the above cycle repeats.

I was tidying my front garden last spring and she came out to ask why I was doing it and that I make her side look untidy. It’s so nuts. She’s nuts.

Oh no OP, this is criminal harassment. This is way beyond cheeky fuckery.

She's a deeply unpleasant, rude and invasive person who deserves no favours or politeness whatsoever. She surely can't react any worse than she already does?

You really need to STOP answering when she knocks. Gavin de Becker says that if a stalker calls you 20 times, and you pick up on the 21st call, all that teaches him is that he needs to phone you 21 times. It makes the behaviour worse!

When you avoid answering and let her keep knocking for 15 minutes straight multiple times, then you finally answer - all you're teaching her is that you'll give in eventually and she should keep trying as hard as possible!

If she comes again you'll have to say simply, "No. Leave my property. This is harassment".

I think you need to actively put a stop to this rather than waiting for her to beg yet again, and try to politely decline, yet again.

Get your husband to go around and request that she stop knocking on your door and entering your property. If she argues, just say that she's been asked to stop, and any continuation is harassment and trespassing.

If this doesn't work, escalate legally - call the police and make clear to them that you're pregnant and this harassment is causing you great distress and is massively affecting your mental health.

Plant tall bushes or trees (preferably spiky) where she likes to look over the fence. You can get mature trees or plants cheaply on eBay and gumtree.

Good luck with this, she's never going to be a pleasant neighbour, but she has been massively imposing on you and draining your precious time and money, and it is within your power to simply refuse to do what she asks of you, and refuse to engage with her at all.

Fountofwisdom · 10/03/2024 09:05

Your neighbour is a total user and unfortunately, people like that zone in on kind and accommodating people until a full stop is put to it. I think the suggestions to write a letter or put a note through their door are, frankly, ridiculous. A physical note is passive aggressive and gives them something to keep re-reading and seething over. You need to just brace yourself and have a calm face-to-face conversation next time she comes round, no matter how simple her request is. Just a calm but assertive response, look a bit irritated but not angry. “I’m afraid these favours have got out of hand. We’ve got our hands full here and we just can’t help you. Sorry. I’ve got to go, the grill is on.” She’ll go home and recount it to her husband, but it’s far better than giving them a letter to obsess over. She might be so indignant that she ignores you after that, or you may find you need to do the firm refusal 2 or 3 times. But face-to-face is ALWAYS better when dealing with a situation like this. If she continues to summon you via your children again, that also needs a firm ‘no’. Good luck, you’ll feel much better once you stand up to her.

PuppyMonkey · 10/03/2024 09:04

Being polite to “keep the peace” - what peace? Grin

Danikm151 · 10/03/2024 09:03

I wouldn’t dream of asking my neighbour for a lift even in an emergency.

tell her you can’t afford to drop her anywhere and give her a list of local taxi companies or an uber referral code.

Dontbuyaglasscoffeetable · 10/03/2024 09:02

Hello op!

I always try to polite, although sometimes it can come across as a bit passive aggressive when I’m fed up.

I‘d probably say something along the lines of…

We hope you’re sorted now or are getting there. I know it’s been tough and we haven’t minded helping out temporarily, however, we won’t be able to offer support anymore, as I’m getting very tired with the pregnancy and we’re getting ready for the baby. I won’t be able to gift lifts or run errands going forward.
I’d also appreciate if you didn’t knock the door, as I say, we can’t support but also are trying to minimise stress. We know you’ll completely understand and best of luck to you too”.

Whatever you decide it all sounds too intrusive to maintain and you are in no way being unreasonable putting a stop to this behaviour.

As for your daughter, if she approaches her again, I’d just say that you’d appreciate if she didn’t call your daughter as you’re teaching her not to go to people she doesn’t know very well or strangers. That she has been told to go with, or speak only to family she knows properly, and that calling her will confuse her. You know they’ll understand and if she wants to say hello to DD then it’s fine if a parent is with her. All part of raising children these days.

Best of luck.

BarbaricPeach · 10/03/2024 09:02

They can't "not take no for an answer" if you don't give in! Just say no and wait for them to go away. It literally is that simple, when they're being so far out of the boundaries of politeness themselves.

I think that's what you need to hear to feel able to stand up for yourself: these people are so far out of what is acceptable that I can't believe the cheek of them. Literally I can't fathom what is going on in their minds, other than them being bullies who know they're taking advantage and don't care.

I understand if you don't feel able to directly call them out for the rude and cheeky arseholes they are. But you can feel confident that standing up to them by saying no is more than acceptable.

whatdidshedotogetahillnamedafterher · 10/03/2024 09:01

The only way to stop this is for her to be too frightened to ask you in the first place. Get your fierce on and sort it today.

FOJN · 10/03/2024 09:00

Seeing your update, she does sound as though rational conversation isn't going to work....but equally, you don't want to completely alienate her because as and when you sell, you'd have to declare a dispute with them.

That could be summed up as neighbour doesn't speak to me because I refused to be her personal chauffeur.

It doesn't become a dispute just because one person is angry that the other person won't do what they want.

Anameisaname · 10/03/2024 08:59

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 10/03/2024 08:36

"Sorry neighbour but I've reached the stage with this pregnancy where I need to rest as much as possible so you will need to call a taxi from now on." If she persists say your midwife has ordered you to rest more. You could follow up with "its probably best to get in the habit now as obviously I will be too busy to help out once baby arrives. In fact I'm counting on asking you to return a few favours once we reach that stage" big smile and shut the door.

If you are really struggling with how to push back ... this is a very polite solution!

Swipe left for the next trending thread