Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours keep asking for favours!

513 replies

Popcornlassie28 · 09/03/2024 23:12

My husband and I live in a village around 15 minutes from the local shops etc. We currently have two children and I’m pregnant with our third. We both work (I work shifts) and I’m also studying at uni so I’m always constantly busy being a mother, at work or as a student.

My neighbours are middle aged with no children. One drives and the other doesn’t. Recently due to medical reasons the one who drives has had to stop driving until a health clear.

Since then, I will be home with the children before/after school, getting ready for work or coming off a night shift that morning and SO ready to sleep and my neighbour will come knocking asking to be taken to work often because she’s ’missed the bus’, ‘bus doesn’t run at this time’ etc. They do not take no for an answer and she will return two, three times plus until I answer as she knows I’m home as my car is in the driveway. She is very forceful.

I haven’t minded up until this point helping where we can but it’s getting a bit much. There is never any offer for fuel money either and it’s a 30 minute round trip to drop her to where she needs to go.

In the warmer weather, they will put their heads over the fence while I’m relaxing in my garden to ask for things and ask my children ‘Go and grab Mummy/Daddy’ so they can ask for more lifts/favours. My garden should be a safe haven where my children can play and we should relax without being bothered? Or am I wrong here? I would knock the front door and if they don’t answer I wouldn’t dream of being that pushy.

I have been polite to keep the peace but they are now asking my husband to give lifts at 8am into work on Sunday morning as ‘bus isn’t running’ and even though I’m pregnant ‘Can you pick up the 2 litre bottles of water from the shop for me? They are heavy for me to carry on the bus’. My husband is saying it’s going too far and to start pushing back and being forceful with her.

How can I be forceful but polite? Am I being unreasonable? I am terrified when the baby comes she will be banging the door down to be taken out when I’ve just got them settled and I don’t want to fall out but I know I will lose my temper at this point.

OP posts:
CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 10/03/2024 10:36

Moveoverdarlin ·

The new baby is a great excuse. Get DH to say to them ‘Look as of now we are going to have to knock the lifts on the head, Jane is struggling being so heavily pregnant and when the baby comes, we can’t have the door bell going all the time and waking the baby. If you need to get hold of us ungently, use WhatsApp.’

If they ask again, say ‘No can do Julie, Jane is exhausted and I have to take her for an appointment in a bit. Try TF taxis, they’re great! Cheerio’.

When the baby is born and you bump in to them you should say… ‘Hi Julie, Hi Mark! Baby’s born, it’s a lovely little boy! We’ll call on you for babysitting, you owe us after all those lifts!!!

Theyll shit themselves and run a mile.

This ^ is a good response. Minus the WhatsApp bit, of course. And get that lattice top for the fence so no more looking over into yours. Doorbell goes, answer and say we're resting, can't help this time, ask someone else. Any repeated knocking should be met with a cross 'we said no!' Maybe get a Ring doorbell and a padlock on your front gate which you lock on Saturday evenings so no more 8am Sunday morning demands.

LittleRedYarny · 10/03/2024 10:34

This is just crazy and awful. I really don’t know what you can do, but here are some silly suggestions:

  1. drive her but dress as a clown and keep leaning out the window and shouting “make way for Mrs (Annoying Neighbours name) the most Magnificent, erudite and beautiful chicken whisperer in all the land!
  2. When you drop her off get out the car and loudly call after her “I hope the cream clears up that awful fanny rash!”
  3. Eat beans and artichokes for every meal fart disgustingly all the time your driving her - child lock the windows.

In all seriousness, this needs to stop before baby arrives.

TheFancyPoet · 10/03/2024 10:31

We have an older neighbour with some OCD or Aspergers, is always out, inspecting the road, bins, moving things, sweeping leaves and sometimes tried to tell me what to do with an angry voice. Only once I shouted at him to go away from me and that he is not my husband to talk to me like that and that I will call the police. So he said: oh ok, allll riggghtttt with a sarcastic voice and stopped indeed. This is all you need to do. To tell them to fucking leave you alone. You are not interested, you are no one to them and that is that.

NaomhPadraigin · 10/03/2024 10:28

Instead of opening the door, can you open an upstairs window and shout down
.... Whatever it is that you want this time, the answer is No!

Then just close the window and refuse to engage further.

TheFancyPoet · 10/03/2024 10:28

Tell her to stop fucking harrassing you or you will report her to the police. Do it in an angry and fed up voice - she will stop.

BreatheAndFocus · 10/03/2024 10:26

She sounds horrible. She doesn’t give a shit about you or your family. You’re just objects to use. She sees your kindness as weakness. She’s not grateful and she doesn’t care how much she inconveniences you or interrupts you.

If you don’t want to cause a scene, simply say “No, neighbour. We’ve shifted our work hours round now due to the imminent arrival of baby, so we won’t be available to do any lifts at all. Also, due to the work change and loss of income, we don’t have spare money to cover extra petrol anyway. Here are the numbers of local taxi firms and a driving instructor who we’ve heard is really patient with older people like yourself who never learnt to drive.”

As for her looking over the fence and summoning you via your children, tell your children to say Mummy/Daddy is busy, and if she asks you yourself just say the same - you’re busy. If you happen to be relaxing and she replies that you’re not busy, then say Yes, I am. Also, raise the fence so she can’t intrude on you like this.

frequentlyfrazzled · 10/03/2024 10:12

OP this woman sounds quite intimidating and it can be very difficult to be assertive with people like that. But unfortunately you do need to gather the strength to be firm and tell her that her requests for help have to stop. She is bullying and harrassing you. Remind yourself of that when you are feeling bad about saying no to her. The time for worrying about good neighbourly relations have long gone. She does not care about you, or your wellbeing or your family. She does not care about making unreasonable demands of you. She does not care if she is inconveniencing you or upsetting you or causing you extra stress in your pregnancy. She is not a nice person. She is not a good neighbour. She is a very unpleasant bully and from now on you need to have cast iron boundaries and be crystal clear about asserting them. Remember you do not have to think up excuses, she has no right to that information.
So use the next time she comes around as an opportunity. Take a deep breath before you answer the door, then say very firmly, "No we can't help you, we won't be able to help any more in the future, and from now on I would like you to stop calling around." You will find your own words but there needs to be no explanations and no apologies. Practice this to yourself in advance so you are ready when she calls. Repeat again and again. Speak to her husband and give him the same message. Make sure your husband is on the same page. From now on it is a blanket NO to all requests.
It is empowering to be assertive, it does not make you a bad person. You will also be modelling good boundaries and assertiveness to your children which is an excellent life lesson.
Oh and arrange to get a bigger fence. You are entitled to your space and your privacy. Good luck.

everythinglooksbetterpaintedblack · 10/03/2024 10:07

Literally just say no!
No explanation, no excuses, just no and close the door

whatdidshedotogetahillnamedafterher · 10/03/2024 10:02

Try this,,knock on door you open it and say Oh not today lady do fuck off I am not in the mood.Close the door smile to yourself and get on with your day. With any luck you will have left her totally confused and bewildered at the unexpected outburst! If she picks her jaw up off the floor and knocks again ignore do not answer her. A short sharp shock is whats needed her.

DriftingDora · 10/03/2024 10:02

Popcornlassie28 · 09/03/2024 23:12

My husband and I live in a village around 15 minutes from the local shops etc. We currently have two children and I’m pregnant with our third. We both work (I work shifts) and I’m also studying at uni so I’m always constantly busy being a mother, at work or as a student.

My neighbours are middle aged with no children. One drives and the other doesn’t. Recently due to medical reasons the one who drives has had to stop driving until a health clear.

Since then, I will be home with the children before/after school, getting ready for work or coming off a night shift that morning and SO ready to sleep and my neighbour will come knocking asking to be taken to work often because she’s ’missed the bus’, ‘bus doesn’t run at this time’ etc. They do not take no for an answer and she will return two, three times plus until I answer as she knows I’m home as my car is in the driveway. She is very forceful.

I haven’t minded up until this point helping where we can but it’s getting a bit much. There is never any offer for fuel money either and it’s a 30 minute round trip to drop her to where she needs to go.

In the warmer weather, they will put their heads over the fence while I’m relaxing in my garden to ask for things and ask my children ‘Go and grab Mummy/Daddy’ so they can ask for more lifts/favours. My garden should be a safe haven where my children can play and we should relax without being bothered? Or am I wrong here? I would knock the front door and if they don’t answer I wouldn’t dream of being that pushy.

I have been polite to keep the peace but they are now asking my husband to give lifts at 8am into work on Sunday morning as ‘bus isn’t running’ and even though I’m pregnant ‘Can you pick up the 2 litre bottles of water from the shop for me? They are heavy for me to carry on the bus’. My husband is saying it’s going too far and to start pushing back and being forceful with her.

How can I be forceful but polite? Am I being unreasonable? I am terrified when the baby comes she will be banging the door down to be taken out when I’ve just got them settled and I don’t want to fall out but I know I will lose my temper at this point.

Ask her if she's ever heard of such a thing as cabs (I know, I know, cabs don't like coming out to rural areas - but the answer to this is 'tough').

People like this only understand bluntness, I'm afraid. They don't pick up on nuances. You just say 'no can do' and that's it. If they get narky, they're no loss, as these people just get more and more encroaching on your time and you'll end up as their servant. Not even offering petrol money's a bloody cheek as well - the nerve of some people is amazing!🙄

edited for typo

violetcuriosity · 10/03/2024 10:01

Fraaahnces · 09/03/2024 23:59

Write them a letter from you and DH. Explain very clearly that your family has a legal right to PEACEFUL enjoyment of your own home and they need to realise that by offering them the occasional favour, they have taken the proverbial mile and begun to expect more and more from you. They are overstepping the normal neighbourly relationship by a long shot. Your family is becoming increasingly resentful of their entitlement and continual intrusion.

Explain that you are pregnant and tired enough running around after your own family. It is not just intrusive, but completely inappropriate for them to demand anything of your children, and any demands issued are to cease immediately. None of your family are their staff members.

Their transport/work situation their own responsibility to sort, not yours. They haven’t ever offered to contribute to the running costs of your vehicle or pay for your time. If they knock looking for a lift, you will only agree to it only if you are paid X amount (at least twice the going Uber rate) - up front.

Also state that they are to consider this letter a formal cease and desist and that you will consider continued intrusion harassment and treat it accordingly.

Came on to say this. Completely understand that for some people it isn't easy to say no to someone's face so do this, post it through late at night and then (if it was me hide/avoid them for a few weeks 😅) act like everything is normal when you see them again.

fancyfrogs · 10/03/2024 09:59

Absolutely insane and well beyond CF'ery. I'm hate confrontation and would also find this initially difficult but you/DH need to be firm and say NO with no apology, so bloody rude of them and id be getting a taller fence up asap. And getting my kids to sit at an upstairs window with a water pistol when she comes

forrestgreen · 10/03/2024 09:58

Maybe answer when she ms on the ring doorbell. You might feel braver?

Can I ....

No sorry, I'm busy. I've got the number for a taxi if you need it. Or have you tried getting online shopping, that's what we do.

Basically direct her on, so she can't complain that she's 'stuck' with no help.

Mnk711 · 10/03/2024 09:57

I think YABU but because you have been too nice for too long! I'd start by putting a sign on the door that says please don't knock/ring the doorbell at the times when you are resting/about to be and do not answer the door at all. You could also get a Ring door bell so you can see if it's them and not answer or tell them through the doorbell you're busy. I'd tell the kids to say mummy says sorry she's busy if the neighbours try to get them to get you to do things. And if they do manage to actually grab you in person I'd just say I'm so sorry, we've got a lot on at the moment and can't help. If they argue just keep repeating and say sorry I have to go now and go.

WorkingFromHomeShite · 10/03/2024 09:57

Oh don’t be so mean to her. She’s your neighbour! I think you should do the errands, £2 per mile, cash in advance, and you’ve got a free slot two weeks on Thursday at 1pm, right?!

#bekind 🤣

Spuddy58 · 10/03/2024 09:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BMIwoes · 10/03/2024 09:56

I think you should take the initiative here. Both you and your husband knock on their door and ask to speak to both of them together. Say that you will not be offering any more lifts and that if they persist in hammering on your door when you've said no the you will report her to the police for harassment. I'd do it with her husband there so that he is also clear what she's been doing and to make him feel a sense of joint responsibility. Say your piece, then leave. If they're spluttering and asking questions, say "we don't want to be rude or have any bad feeling but you have to stop. That's all there is to say." Then leave. And never answer the door to her again.

Toastcrumbsinsofa · 10/03/2024 09:54

You need to be really direct with people like your neighbour. I agree with pp who said don’t explain, apologise or discuss it - just ‘no, I can’t’ or slightly more polite’ no, it isn’t convenient’ and immediately close the door (even if she’s still talking). If she’s over the fence and continues to ask ‘like I’ve already said it’s no’ then ‘what part of no don’t you understand?’ followed by ‘I consider this to be harassment’. She’ll probably give up once you’ve said no a few times.

@Popcornlassie28 is the medical condition that stops her driving called being a cheeky fucker? Smile

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/03/2024 09:52

BarrelOfOtters · 10/03/2024 08:55

disconnect your doorbell.

Why - OP perhaps needs the door bell for the postie, visitors, tradesman? Let's not revert to the Mumsnet trope of hiding and never ever answering the doorbell. Just say no m, no explanation required

Collywobblewobbles · 10/03/2024 09:52

slore · 10/03/2024 09:09

Oh no OP, this is criminal harassment. This is way beyond cheeky fuckery.

She's a deeply unpleasant, rude and invasive person who deserves no favours or politeness whatsoever. She surely can't react any worse than she already does?

You really need to STOP answering when she knocks. Gavin de Becker says that if a stalker calls you 20 times, and you pick up on the 21st call, all that teaches him is that he needs to phone you 21 times. It makes the behaviour worse!

When you avoid answering and let her keep knocking for 15 minutes straight multiple times, then you finally answer - all you're teaching her is that you'll give in eventually and she should keep trying as hard as possible!

If she comes again you'll have to say simply, "No. Leave my property. This is harassment".

I think you need to actively put a stop to this rather than waiting for her to beg yet again, and try to politely decline, yet again.

Get your husband to go around and request that she stop knocking on your door and entering your property. If she argues, just say that she's been asked to stop, and any continuation is harassment and trespassing.

If this doesn't work, escalate legally - call the police and make clear to them that you're pregnant and this harassment is causing you great distress and is massively affecting your mental health.

Plant tall bushes or trees (preferably spiky) where she likes to look over the fence. You can get mature trees or plants cheaply on eBay and gumtree.

Good luck with this, she's never going to be a pleasant neighbour, but she has been massively imposing on you and draining your precious time and money, and it is within your power to simply refuse to do what she asks of you, and refuse to engage with her at all.

💯 this is harassment and slore gives good advice.

Make sure you keep a record of every single incident too, as another pp suggested.

Don't bother with excuses anymore, just a clear no and to stop with her behaviour. Then involve the police from the first time she goes against what you've said

Combattingthemoaners · 10/03/2024 09:49

HowToSaveAWife · 10/03/2024 09:48

"I said no, please don't ask again." Repeat a few times.

Then get an injunction.

Or put good old pregnancy hormones to use and...

"I said NO you mad bat now fuck off and don't ask me again!"

Or a middle finger from your living room when she's poking her face over the fence could work either.

🤣

Combattingthemoaners · 10/03/2024 09:49

The absolute brass neck of some people! You’re clearly very polite and have been very patient. Don’t even say sorry at the start of any sentence or end as you have nothing to be sorry for. A simple “no, I can’t” and leave it at that. They’re grown adults and can get deliveries or get themselves to work without calling on the help of a neighbour!

HowToSaveAWife · 10/03/2024 09:48

"I said no, please don't ask again." Repeat a few times.

Then get an injunction.

Or put good old pregnancy hormones to use and...

"I said NO you mad bat now fuck off and don't ask me again!"

Or a middle finger from your living room when she's poking her face over the fence could work either.

Bridgertonned · 10/03/2024 09:47

Just tell them your car is broken. Every time. Even if they've seen you just come back in it. It was fixed before but it's broken again now. Every time.

Any other reason - you're busy/tired/don't want to - they'll have a work around, and it sounds like you're too tired to withstand the manipulation! Take the car out of the equation - no car available, no lift.

Viviennemary · 10/03/2024 09:46

Just say no. They are incredibly cheeky. Sorry it's not convenient and you don't have time.,