Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours keep asking for favours!

513 replies

Popcornlassie28 · 09/03/2024 23:12

My husband and I live in a village around 15 minutes from the local shops etc. We currently have two children and I’m pregnant with our third. We both work (I work shifts) and I’m also studying at uni so I’m always constantly busy being a mother, at work or as a student.

My neighbours are middle aged with no children. One drives and the other doesn’t. Recently due to medical reasons the one who drives has had to stop driving until a health clear.

Since then, I will be home with the children before/after school, getting ready for work or coming off a night shift that morning and SO ready to sleep and my neighbour will come knocking asking to be taken to work often because she’s ’missed the bus’, ‘bus doesn’t run at this time’ etc. They do not take no for an answer and she will return two, three times plus until I answer as she knows I’m home as my car is in the driveway. She is very forceful.

I haven’t minded up until this point helping where we can but it’s getting a bit much. There is never any offer for fuel money either and it’s a 30 minute round trip to drop her to where she needs to go.

In the warmer weather, they will put their heads over the fence while I’m relaxing in my garden to ask for things and ask my children ‘Go and grab Mummy/Daddy’ so they can ask for more lifts/favours. My garden should be a safe haven where my children can play and we should relax without being bothered? Or am I wrong here? I would knock the front door and if they don’t answer I wouldn’t dream of being that pushy.

I have been polite to keep the peace but they are now asking my husband to give lifts at 8am into work on Sunday morning as ‘bus isn’t running’ and even though I’m pregnant ‘Can you pick up the 2 litre bottles of water from the shop for me? They are heavy for me to carry on the bus’. My husband is saying it’s going too far and to start pushing back and being forceful with her.

How can I be forceful but polite? Am I being unreasonable? I am terrified when the baby comes she will be banging the door down to be taken out when I’ve just got them settled and I don’t want to fall out but I know I will lose my temper at this point.

OP posts:
billybear · 10/03/2024 11:48

im a push over as well. i have neighbours who knock every other weekend to borrow something a brush/wire cutters etc, i get fed up, i now hear knock ast door freeze and dont answer, my dog barks but i could be in shower etc, every 3rd week i get a text at 7pm , she will leave the key hiddem =n for me to let her dog out in back garden between 12 and 1pm, she is going to london for business meeting, last 3 times i have been out rushed back for her dog, while they are in their back garden they dont evan have a wee. so have dec eided next time they demand i do it, i will say a firm no .be strong some people use people .

Daffodilsandtuplips · 10/03/2024 11:47

Don’t worry about saying no or appearing rude. “No, I can’t do that. I can’t give you a lift, carry heavy bottles of water, pick or drop you off.
Tell that Tesco or Asda deliver (insert shop of choice).”
She isn’t worried about being a cheeky fecker is she?

Give her the number of a local taxi.
Dont go running when she calls the kids over.
I had a neighbour like this, she would ask me to give her a lift to the shops or into town or to her mothers house, the dentist, hospital.
The final straw was when she asked me to take her to another town to look at a puppy she was interested in, I waited outside the house for over an hour while she was looking at this puppy. I learned later that while me and my own dd and her dd were
sweltering in the car she was having tea and cakes with the dog breeder.
The next time she asked I flat out said “No, I can’t, the library has the bus timetables” and she never asked again.

Saz12 · 10/03/2024 11:39

Dont give her any reasons - that just allows her to negotiate.

A clear, simple "no, I can't". Then immediately start a general chat, something like "arent the daffodils looking nice" or "isnt it a shame about Mr Smiths guinea pig," or whatever.
She'll either say something rude "fuck the guinea pig! I want a lift!" At which point you can tell her "no" again. Or she'll say "hmm, yes, a terrible shame" at which point you IMMEDIATELY jump in (before she can ask for a lift again) and say "Anyway, I gotta go, nice chatting" and shut the door quickly.

Every time. If it doesnt work, keep with the "no, I cant" and follow with "nice to see you, but I better let you get on" and shut the door quick.

If she sulks, either enjoy the peace or be very thick skinned and determined "hello! Ooh, HELLO-O! How are you Mrs Neighbour?" If shes rude in reply then thats great because the next time she asks for a favour you can say "no...the last time I said hi to you you swore at me".

Alternatively, tell her to fuck off.

DriftingDora · 10/03/2024 11:37

JackNoMiddleNameReacher · 10/03/2024 11:27

Personally I wouldn’t wait until you get the next knock on the door.
I think this needs to be treated more seriously and warrants a special visit to their house.

I would go around to theirs with your dh and both of you point out that you are no longer in a position to help.
Give your neighbours local taxi numbers and tell them which stores deliver food.
Then explain you’re having work done on the garden, including raising the fence height with trellis and hope the work doesn’t disturb them.
Apart from raising the fence you can also buy pregrown hedging up to 1.2m.it will take a while to get higher but at least you can look forward to being left alone in your garden in the future.

There is no need to explain why you can no longer help, if you give an excuse of ‘ I’m pregnant’ etc. then they’ll just wait till you aren’t. Some people need to just be told.

Agree with this, except for giving them local taxi numbers and which stores deliver food. Let them do their own work - otherwise they'll be full of excuses about taxis not being available, stores not able to deliver when they want, etc. etc. People like this only understand bluntness - 'no' is the response. You don't have to defend yourself - let them sort their lives out. They should have considered the possibility of the driving half of the partnership becoming incapable of driving before they bought the house - it's not rocket science. Or she should learn to drive.

mbosnz · 10/03/2024 11:36

What Mum had to say to a person who had taken to asking far too much, was, very bluntly, 'I am not, cannot be, and will not be, your support person'.

Giggorata · 10/03/2024 11:33

I don't think that you should get your husband to go round and give her the message, as it makes you look weak. This kind of CF will wait until he is out and then still come round and bug you, as an easy touch.

I also agree that any excuse or reason you give for not doing what she wants, will be seen as an opening for her to suggest ways round whatever the obstacle is.

Although I also like the What? What do you want now? reply, it won't be enough to make her pause and consider that she's being a CF, as she's so oblivious and selfish.

A firm and unembellished NO is the only way to stop her in her tracks.
No is indeed a complete answer.

Mydietstartstomorrow · 10/03/2024 11:33

Walkingwashingmachine · 10/03/2024 07:51

You may not have read that post properly?

I read the post fine! I read the original post of op asking if she was being unreasonable to tell the neighbour she wouldn’t be doing it anymore, not if she was unreasonable having started helping in the first place 🙄
Seems to be a lot of people that wouldn’t even consider helping out their neighbours in the first place on here. I think the OP should get some 👏🏻 for helping out initially, but now, no, neighbours are cf taking the absolute piss

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 10/03/2024 11:33

It's going to be harder for you to put up boundaries now since they are used to taking you for a ride. Probably they will really rail and push back at the boundaries. You need to be firm and stand your ground, even if it leads to awkwardness/ this difficult and odd neigbhour being annoyed with you.

"This has all got a bit much, honestly. We're not in a position to keep offering free lifts all the time."

"We're beginning to feel a bit put upon by all of these demands. We need to step back and prioritise our own family."

"We're not going to be available for lifts any more. You're going to have to find a different solution to your problem."

She is banking on you not wanting to feel awkward. You have to allow there to be an awkwardness and hold your ground.

JackNoMiddleNameReacher · 10/03/2024 11:27

Personally I wouldn’t wait until you get the next knock on the door.
I think this needs to be treated more seriously and warrants a special visit to their house.

I would go around to theirs with your dh and both of you point out that you are no longer in a position to help.
Give your neighbours local taxi numbers and tell them which stores deliver food.
Then explain you’re having work done on the garden, including raising the fence height with trellis and hope the work doesn’t disturb them.
Apart from raising the fence you can also buy pregrown hedging up to 1.2m.it will take a while to get higher but at least you can look forward to being left alone in your garden in the future.

There is no need to explain why you can no longer help, if you give an excuse of ‘ I’m pregnant’ etc. then they’ll just wait till you aren’t. Some people need to just be told.

Mydietstartstomorrow · 10/03/2024 11:27

Untethered · 10/03/2024 07:50

feeling isn’t saying OP should carry on, just that OP and her DH shouldn’t have started in the first place.

But that wasn’t the question as to whether she was being unreasonable! I’m sure she realises they shouldn’t have started it but to be deemed unreasonable because they did, when they were just initially trying to help out people in need

WhamBamThankU · 10/03/2024 11:24

Tell her you too pregnant to drive unnecessarily, you shouldn't be driving after a night shift, and going forwards you can no longer give lifts/collect shopping etc. especially once baby is born you can't have the disruption.

Davros · 10/03/2024 11:21

Do not do anything formal like reporting to the Police unless it gets really out of hand, you would have to disclose it if you decide to sell. I bet her other half is just watching her do her usual thing and expecting it to go tits up any time. It's a shame you ever said yes but I agree to let your DH be "bad cop". Good luck, you don't deserve this

Bettyfromlondon · 10/03/2024 11:19

Dealing with this brusquely and efficiently will set you up for the future if/when CFs try to take advantage when your children are at school etc.
See it as a development opportunity which will save you a world of pain and nuisance if you practise the no-nonsense boundary-setting skills now! Good luck!

Fushia123 · 10/03/2024 11:16

I would second @frequentlyfrazzled response.
Equally both you and your husband go round to theirs and say it all in front of her husband too.
Be clear, be straight and don’t get involved emotionally with any responses.
You will feel so much better when it’s done and will be able to make a strong response, referring back to your joint conversation if any future requests are made.

Estpencle12 · 10/03/2024 11:16

@Popcornlassie28 you shouldn’t have to do this but if you have a number of local Taxi just hand it over saying “I can’t take you but here you go”.

You have been more than helpful.

CoraPirbright · 10/03/2024 11:14

Do you have other neighbours? Do you know them? Would you feel comfortable talking to them about this issue? I bet they have also been hit up for favours and will have found a way to tell this nutcase to do one. You are simply her next victim! I think that you will feel massively better that others have also had this issue and if you know how they dealt with it, perhaps could deploy the same ways. They will be behind you all the way and that will give you the strength/courage to deal with the situation (hint: it may be time to tear her off a serious strip. She doesnt give a toss about upsetting you so why should you bother about upsetting her?!)

Thriving30 · 10/03/2024 11:01

"No, I can't"

If she asks why "I'm really busy, I can't keep doing favours for you"
Be really blunt with her.

ReallyDesperate · 10/03/2024 10:59

I don’t understand ‘she won’t take no for an answer’? Just dont answer the door ? Or if you do say no once and tell her to get the Uber app

user1984778379202 · 10/03/2024 10:57

This would be my idea of a nightmare! Just say no and keep saying no. She's a bully.

KomodoOhno · 10/03/2024 10:56

I have a feeling if you tell her no she might finally go away and on to the next person. I feel for you having to not feel comfortable in your own home. I have a neighbor like this. She once called me at work because she wanted me to help her off the toilet. I finally lost my rag with her and she bothers us no more. At this point nearly all the neighbors have told her off too. Sadly her husband is the sweetest man.

KvotheTheBloodless · 10/03/2024 10:53

PinkArt · 09/03/2024 23:16

The old MN classics that no is a complete sentence and that doesn't work for me very much apply here. And I'd say to them, please stop asking when I've said no, it's becoming rude.
They don't sound like people you'd want to be friends with so just meet their pushiness with as firm a no as is needed to get your point across.

I found this advice an absolute revelation a few years ago - the notion that I did not, in fact, have to do inconvenient things I didn't want to do was extraordinary, I bloody love MN! Sometimes having a consensus that you're allowed to say no can give your backbone a helpful stiffening.

amitoooldforthisshit · 10/03/2024 10:51

act like a doormat and you will definitely be treated like one

Hakunatomato · 10/03/2024 10:49

Get a Ring/blink doorbell. When you see it’s her , just say I’m busy, please go away. You can do that from your phone, so you don’t even need to go to the door.

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 10/03/2024 10:39

Quite honestly, I would get some kind of restraining order. I agree with others that this is harassment - they need to move closer to where they need to be or use taxis/ food delivery services.

LittleRedYarny · 10/03/2024 10:38

Mnk711 · 10/03/2024 09:57

I think YABU but because you have been too nice for too long! I'd start by putting a sign on the door that says please don't knock/ring the doorbell at the times when you are resting/about to be and do not answer the door at all. You could also get a Ring door bell so you can see if it's them and not answer or tell them through the doorbell you're busy. I'd tell the kids to say mummy says sorry she's busy if the neighbours try to get them to get you to do things. And if they do manage to actually grab you in person I'd just say I'm so sorry, we've got a lot on at the moment and can't help. If they argue just keep repeating and say sorry I have to go now and go.

Current version of ring doorbells allow you to have a preset message play like “we’re too busy to answer” and it’s a generic computer voice so that might help.

Also ring doorbells will obviously record every time she does this and builds up a picture of harassment. (Are ASBOs still a thing?)

Swipe left for the next trending thread