Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours keep asking for favours!

513 replies

Popcornlassie28 · 09/03/2024 23:12

My husband and I live in a village around 15 minutes from the local shops etc. We currently have two children and I’m pregnant with our third. We both work (I work shifts) and I’m also studying at uni so I’m always constantly busy being a mother, at work or as a student.

My neighbours are middle aged with no children. One drives and the other doesn’t. Recently due to medical reasons the one who drives has had to stop driving until a health clear.

Since then, I will be home with the children before/after school, getting ready for work or coming off a night shift that morning and SO ready to sleep and my neighbour will come knocking asking to be taken to work often because she’s ’missed the bus’, ‘bus doesn’t run at this time’ etc. They do not take no for an answer and she will return two, three times plus until I answer as she knows I’m home as my car is in the driveway. She is very forceful.

I haven’t minded up until this point helping where we can but it’s getting a bit much. There is never any offer for fuel money either and it’s a 30 minute round trip to drop her to where she needs to go.

In the warmer weather, they will put their heads over the fence while I’m relaxing in my garden to ask for things and ask my children ‘Go and grab Mummy/Daddy’ so they can ask for more lifts/favours. My garden should be a safe haven where my children can play and we should relax without being bothered? Or am I wrong here? I would knock the front door and if they don’t answer I wouldn’t dream of being that pushy.

I have been polite to keep the peace but they are now asking my husband to give lifts at 8am into work on Sunday morning as ‘bus isn’t running’ and even though I’m pregnant ‘Can you pick up the 2 litre bottles of water from the shop for me? They are heavy for me to carry on the bus’. My husband is saying it’s going too far and to start pushing back and being forceful with her.

How can I be forceful but polite? Am I being unreasonable? I am terrified when the baby comes she will be banging the door down to be taken out when I’ve just got them settled and I don’t want to fall out but I know I will lose my temper at this point.

OP posts:
Snazzysausage · 10/03/2024 13:22

Branleuse · 10/03/2024 00:17

'sandra can I just stop you there, I can't help but notice that we have landed in the position of unpaid taxi service. I'm not sure how this has come about, but i want this stopped, as it's a lot now and not just the occasional favour. I'm afraid you're going to have to sort your own transport out from now on.

See this is a sensible approach. You have to stop this now in plenty of time before baby arrives. If not she'll be expecting you to load baby into the car at a moments notice and that will be your tipping point.The last thing you need when you've just given birth is the stress of an almighty argument with next door Nora. Sort it now so it allows the situation time to settle down.

Beautiful3 · 10/03/2024 13:21

Wow just seen your update! She's really rude! I'd actually say, "please stop knocking on my door, asking for lifts." If she carried on I'd tell her, go away. You've been far too nice and polite.

Todaynottomora · 10/03/2024 13:21

This is simply not working anymore so my answer from now on is no.

hard face on.

I could explain because I understand your situation but you are not understanding of our situation so my answer from now on is no.

door closes

good luck!

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 13:10

Tell her you have explosive diarrhoea so there is no way you are going anywhere.

Harrysmummy246 · 10/03/2024 13:09

Just say no, it doesn't work for us. CLose door. Repeat. Stop being wet about it

Local taxi service flyer print out and hang over

weaseleyes · 10/03/2024 13:07

I completely get why you don't want to deal with the awful, aggressive atmosphere when you say no. I'd be exactly the same. The thing is, you're already dealing with a perpetual awful atmosphere when you say yes. You feel frustrated, exploited, unhappy and used and are constantly living in anticipation of the next time she puts you on the spot. It's not like when you help her everything's rosy, because you're just living in dread of the next time and you've made that next time more likely by saying yes and setting expectations.

So if you're going to be miserable either way, say no forcefully. That way, there's a horrible atmosphere, but you're not inconvenienced - which is a big win - and there's a chance it will settle into a slightly frosty no contact, which would be fab.

BarbieDangerous · 10/03/2024 12:59

MsVestibule · 09/03/2024 23:27

I think this is one of these situations where you have to be forceful - I really can't believe their brass neck! A simple 'no, I can't do that, hope you get something else sorted' and then close the door should do the trick. They are so rude, you do not have to be polite back.

I absolutely agree with this. They sound incredibly selfish and don’t sound like nice people at all. I can understand asking the odd favour when they catch you in the car on the way to the shops but even THEN, you really aren’t obliged to do anything at all. Stop being nice!

Folklore9074 · 10/03/2024 12:59

Just read a few more of your replies and it makes my blood boil for you, I would absolutely dispense with being polite. Be as shitty with her as you want, it will feel cathartic... I'd not be polite when answering the door at all 'you've interrupted me, what do you want?', if she bothers you in the garden tell her to go away etc. Create an atmosphere right back. People like this count on you being frightened of confrontation.

ffsgiveitarest · 10/03/2024 12:55

Next time she asks, tell her there’s an app that can help. It’s called Uber they deliver food and groceries, and she can also order a taxi.

Tell her you’re more than happy to show her how to use it, as you can no longer be her personal taxi and delivery service.

Hopefully she’ll be Uber grateful or Uber pissed off 😂

Folklore9074 · 10/03/2024 12:54

Why are you worrying about being polite? They aren't. You need to put your foot down.

Oncetwicethreetimesalady · 10/03/2024 12:50

I’d try to avoid any tension but be a smiley and polite broken record.
“Unfortunately I can’t do that because I don’t have the energy. Actually, while you’re here you can just mind the children/do an errand/random unreasonable request for me thanks”
unfortunately sounds an apology but isn’t one. And only you can say if you have the energy or not so it can’t be argued with. If you put in a counter request every single time I’m sure their requests will soon dry up. it will take a while but persisting with the exact same phrase is usually very effective.
Also mention how much help you’ll be needing when the baby arrives, so they know you’ll step it up if they don’t back off.

SantaBarbaraMonica · 10/03/2024 12:49

Look them straight in the eye and say 'You've asked far too many times. Its expensive and hugely disruptive to be your driver. I'm won't be doing any more lifts you will have to find alternative plans'.

If they seem to huff and argue just say 'We are very busy with young children and jobs and another baby on the way. We did it because its important to us to be good neighbours but you have completely taken advantage. When did you ever even offer to pay petrol. Its embarrasing that you haven't and just continue to expect others to so what you ask for nothing'.

Look them straight in the face, dont be agressive or apologetic, just completely honest. Try end it on a note of 'We will always try to be polite and pleasant neighbours for you but you cannot use us anymore like this. Ok, it was good talking to you and important to be clear'. Then walk away.

Sleeptastic · 10/03/2024 12:47

That classic Friends line from Phoebe would work well here.

"Oh I wish I could but I don't want to."

Honeybeebuzz · 10/03/2024 12:41

Just saw someone mention ring door- great idea you can just answer the doorbell on your phone"I'm actually in the middle of something at the moment so no cant take you out, hope you get sorted" then dont answer it again

Honeybeebuzz · 10/03/2024 12:40

Dont say "Sorry I can't" you dont need to apologise. A simple no unfortunately that doesn't suit us now.
Just be short and clear.
Overtime they should get the message
The new baby may actually help as you can say baby is napping/due a nap/ feeding
They are taking advantage of you, i notice they never do you any favours. You really need to be firm but polite. Id also look at raising your fence on their side/getting some trees, we have a massive hedge between us and our neighbour cant imagine them being able to pop their head over when they want so rude

Sureaseggs44 · 10/03/2024 12:31

definitely put trellis up . Your garden should be your sanctuary.

get a ring doorbell .

and then yes keep saying no .

Maia77 · 10/03/2024 12:29

OP I empathise with you, but I think you need to ask yourself why you have been tolerating this kind of behaviour. Your neighbour is obviously someone who is so selfish and self-centred and only thinks about her needs.

It's very hard for some people to set boundaries with others and this could be for many different reasons - upbringing, fear of conflict, not knowing how to set boundaries, feeling guilty etc.

I think when you figure out what has been preventing you from protecting yourself and your family from this harassing behaviour, it'll be easier to say no and feel ok about it.

nosleepforme · 10/03/2024 12:25

No one can force you to tell her no. But if you don’t, imagine this behaviour from her shortly after birth when you’re resting!

InvisibleBuffy · 10/03/2024 12:17

Someone like this, you can't be nice and make an excuse as all they hear is "Try again in five minutes".
Same with the awful atmosphere. That's on purpose. It's manipulative, punishing you for trying to say no.
You need to stop worrying about her glaring at you. You said you didn't want to be a bitch, but sometimes that's exactly what you should be.
I've had people like this. Your only choice is to either be that bitch or have them walk all over you.
Next time she asks, I recommend "No, I'm not going to do that. I was happy to do the occasional favour but you've taken the piss with it, so no more."
And any time, she asks again, just go with "I already told you no".
If she gets your five year old to call you, "I told you I wasn't going to do more favours, stop hassling my child".
And if she starts complaining about other stuff in retaliation, just say "Nonsense" and walk away.
As soon as she realises she's getting nowhere, she'll start annoying someone else to do things for her. Unfortunately some people need a hard no

pavedwithgoodintentions · 10/03/2024 12:12

I strongly advise you to put a camera at your doors or a ring doorbell today, and one in your back garden as she likes to 'talk at' your children over the fence. You need to cover yourself here.

And then tell her you will no longer be giving rides or doing errands for her. She can use the bus, call a taxi, Uber, etc, but it won't be you. Tell her you would like her to not talk to your children over the fence or approach them as it's inappropriate as you are not friends and she is asking small children to do favours for her. Not acceptable.

If she persists, log a harassment complaint with the police and go from there.

MeridianB · 10/03/2024 12:12

You’ve been way too helpful. And you’re worryingly too much about being polite. time to set some boundaries.

Dont wait for another demand. Your DH should go round this weekend when they are both there, so her husband can hear and just state very clearly that there won’t be any more lifts or shopping or favours from this weekend onwards. And they are not to knock or lean over the fence.

Better not to be dreading the next time and how to manage the confrontation- just head it off. Because this woman sounds despicable. 🌺

WhatWhereWho · 10/03/2024 12:09

How can I be forceful but polite?

You cannot be. Both your DH and yourself have to be upfront, blunt and clear. She's harassing both of you and will likely continue. It's really difficult when dealing with someone like this but if you do not say something it will just continue. Be prepared for her tantrums and worst attitude.

MrsSunshine2b · 10/03/2024 12:04

You don't have to be polite anymore. That's not to say be rude, but you do need to stand up for yourself.

"Sorry, that's not possible, bye." That's it.

If she knocks again,

"I have told you that I will not be taking you to work/ fetching your shopping, and I am busy. If you knock again I will not answer the door."

butterpuffed · 10/03/2024 12:02

Just make out you misunderstand everything she says..

I've come round for a lift

We don't have one , there's only two floors

In the car I mean

Oh, you've learnt to drive , can I come ?

I mean, take me to work

You're not qualified to work where I work

She'll soon give up , job done .

Loubelle70 · 10/03/2024 12:01

My neighbour was a nightmare...if i went in garden...he was out...im sure he waited for door to go and whoosh!! There he was. Not a hello and go...but trying to talk for hours! Id get nothing done..and hes the most misogynistic, negative person ive ever met.
I had enough...said ' im going to say hello but now im going to relax in my garden, have a good day'. Off i went. I heard tutting...then 'did i tell you....' i ignored it as if couldnt hear. He was a nightmare..hang washing out..there ..weeding..there...greenhouse..there..glass wine on patio...there!
Was getting where i didn't go in garden ..so i put stop to it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread