Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend winding me up with advice- cancer

35 replies

Francisflute · 09/03/2024 22:28

I have a fairly recent cancer diagnosis. The prognosis is neither outright terrible nor worry-free.

I've had surgery and have radio and chemo lined up.

My AIBU is AIBU to want advice on how to head one friend off who considers herself a mine of wisdom?

She means well but is quite sheltered in some ways. She keeps saying quite annoying or upsetting things such as that i should try and learn from this, see the positives or otherwise imply that there is a good side of this.

I am not moaning to her or asking her advice. I only provide health updates when asked and mainly text about her, and other things.

She has been supportive but these last couple of days it's been quite upsetting being pushed to be positive and all this mindfulness stuff. I have never asked about her spiritual approach. She asked if I wasn't quite enjoying the time out. Well no, I'm not. It's scary, uncertain, lonely and I didn't choose it.

I'm getting on with treatment and recovery and having this diagnosis but I don't have to like it and I don't need or want a self appointed, untrained counsellor.

I'm finding it really tone deaf and upsetting as though I'm being judged and told what to do when she knows nothing about the situation first hand.

Would anyone have any advice on how to kindly head her off and stop the silly questions and forced positivity/ motivational stuff? In don't want to lose her as a friend, this is coming from a kind piece. I've tried gently saying it's not for me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FiftynFooked · 11/03/2024 13:09

Oh OP I feel your pain. I got cornered at a party over Christmas by one of these people. I have a tumour which is luckily benign but will likely grow again and require some more treatment. I know this lady through my social circle and I was aware that she was a mindfulness practitioner so we got chatting. I was saying how much meditation and mindfulness had helped with the anxiety around my condition which is when she totally changed! Said I'd been focusing on the wrong things and I should have been concentrating on curing my tumour through the power of my mind! Turns out she believes that all illness is created by negative thoughts and that by changing our thinking we can cure ourselves.

Luckily she is not a friend so I just gave her a "yeah, whatever" with a Confused face and scurried off!!

Stupidliefromfriend · 11/03/2024 12:50

I think you have been INCREDIBLY restrained in dealing with her. I've had cancer three times and I wouldn't dream of assuming I understand somebody else's experience. How dare she?

And as for the insisting you see the positives? You sound like a resilient person (as am I) and while I did actually find the positives being told to by a third (totally clueless) party would have enraged me. It is as you said arrogant but worse imo while you're going through such an immensely challenging time highly dismissive.

I have a tell you should feel about everything friend. She was terrible and I'm glad we are no longer friends. It's not supportive. It's controlling. She also knew more than the consultants and me. When I was told my treatment hadn't worked in the way they hoped I was devastated. She said "are you surprised... I'm not" and beamed as if she expected praise. I wanted to slap her hard. I finally finished treatment and having gone into an abrupt menopause found myself in ongoing pain. She cheerfully told me (I should also note I was previously a regular runner unlike her) about an article she read in a magazine from a woman in menopause who ran straight through it. "Get a pair of runners on and hit the streets" she told me and changed the subject.

Honestly you don't need someone stressing you out. You need people letting you wallow when necessary but cheering you on when you're pushing forward and making you laugh when you need distraction.

I wish you all the best with your treatment by the way. I am fully out the other side and feel as good as I ever did so it does pass.

SierraSapphire · 11/03/2024 12:37

Have you found the Mumsnet cancer thread in the general health section? It's the most supportive place I've come across, I abandoned some of the Facebook groups, but you don't seem to get the same nuttiness here!

Francisflute · 11/03/2024 12:25

Thanks, will definitely have a think about support forums. I had my fingers burnt a bit when I went on one for my type of cancer and similar. Someone asked about life expectancy in a really insensitive way. I think it was a researcher. Not sure if the ethics of that. Some of the responses were reassuring actually but Christ, the wording of that original question knocked me for six!!

I really appreciate all the responses here. I worried I was being too sensitive as well as not being resilient or positive enough so im very glad I posted. Don't get me wrong, I'm quite stoical, try and face things with good humour as far as I can but I'm not going to turn this into some wonderful spiritual experience it isn't. My friend was on about how I should find acceptance. I bloody well have!! This is what's infuriating and patronising. Just throwing these words around so she feels she's helping.

I think I'll just stay away for a bit then if she raises anything similar again address it directly but kindly as suggested. Then I'm going to say in front want to discuss my treatment for the time being.

OP posts:
ChocoChocoLatte · 10/03/2024 09:51

Every twat in the world comes out the woodwork and offers unsolicited 'advice' constantly when you get a cancer diagnosis.

It is as annoying as f*ck.

Please reach out to online forums where you will find people to give excellent support and advice without YOU needing to manage THEIR emotions - which is what's happening here.

And if she keeps doing it, just reiterate you're taking the advice of your exceptionally well trained and qualified medical team.

I am sorry to hear of your diagnosis but I PROMISE the beginning is simply the worst part and you will get stronger, more confident and less tolerant of 'well meaning' folk Flowers

PoochiesPinkEars · 10/03/2024 09:47

Can you say to her
"I need you to stop having any conversations with me about anything relating to my cancer diagnosis it is not helping me. Please go and Google toxic positivity so you know what I mean, but it's not up for discussion.
Instead, can we talk about other things, work, the USA elections, What's on in the cinema... Anything but nothing to do with that. Thank you."

Kitkatcatflap · 10/03/2024 09:45

I only told a few people, not my in-laws, siblings not my mother in a nursing home. Just a few friends who were brilliant. I couldn't have handled the 'think positive' 'if you drink roasted yaks milk' 'we will fight this together' comments. That was three years ago and I am still happy with my choice.

I think the 'I know you mean well but stop' suggestion is a good one. If she asks for a health update, you can say. 'It's going well, but I don't want to talk about it'

littlegrebe · 10/03/2024 09:40

She's taken to saying whether she has a 'good or bad feeling' about mine and other people's outcomes who have serious illnesses

I know you don't want to lose the friendship but honestly fuck that 1000%, what on earth does she think she's playing at?

If you want an actually helpful shoulder to lean on I highly recommend a visit to a Maggie's Centre.

Feelingstrange2 · 10/03/2024 09:32

Some of these short but sweet replies are good.

I'm so sorry you are going through this on top of cancer.

My DH always says "There are always people worse off" and it drives me nuts. Its like an auto reaction to a situation where he doesn't know what to say. Its a failing of that person, and I'm sorry your friend cannot think before she speaks.

I will continue to pull my DH up on it and will emphasise he needs to articulate a thoughtful reply to difficult situations.

Baldieheid · 10/03/2024 09:30

MinnieMountain · 10/03/2024 08:07

”I know you’re trying to help me, but you’re actually making me feel worse. Please stop.”

This is perfect.

Bartholomewphilipswasrobbed · 10/03/2024 09:27

I'm afraid I'd have to hugely distance myself too. I had a similar experience when I lost someone very close to me in a road accident. This friend had very strong religious beliefs and kept telling me I should forgive and love the person who killed my loved one. Erm, no, just no. They literally wouldn't listen to anything I said, even when I told them that they might feel differently if they had been bereaved.

We are no longer friends.

I hope your recovery goes well.

ThePerfectDog · 10/03/2024 09:25

MinnieMountain · 10/03/2024 08:07

”I know you’re trying to help me, but you’re actually making me feel worse. Please stop.”

This sounds perfect (I’d be tempted to add ‘so piss off’ at the end).

<I wouldn’t because I’m a people pleaser but I’d be tempted to>

Hope the treatment goes OK OP

Burningthroughthesky · 10/03/2024 09:20

I think some people (particularly ones who describe themselves as an empath but lack any actual empathy to put themselves in someone else's shoes for two seconds) just cannot accept that some situations are shit. Sometimes there isn't a silver lining to something traumatic like a cancer diagnosis. A lot of the time it's just shit and unfair, not what you would have chosen but have no choice to go through, and being expected to go through it "gratefully" is another kick in the teeth. Maybe years down the line people reflect back on experiences and see some silver lining, but I doubt anyone does at the time, and even when you do see a "positive" there will be mixed feelings as in an ideal world it wouldn't have happened.

I had a friend like your friend when I was going through a partial molar pregnancy last year; I had a missed miscarriage at 12 weeks and then had to be monitored for 3 and a half months to be sure I didn't need chemotherapy, which luckily I didn't. I had to stop speaking to her, because of her "see the bright side!!" attitude (erm, about losing my baby and now having the potential of chemotherapy hanging over my head?!). I wish I had said something to her at the time, but I didn't have the energy. When things had settled down, I saw her and told her how her toxic positivity had made me feel worse and almost guilty, and she apologised. She's not a horrible person, she's actually quite nice, but she has little emotional intelligence to "sit" with "negative" feelings.

I think a lot of people want to say something to make it better, but sometimes you can't. It's better to say "that's really shit and I'm sorry you are going through this".

Hope you have some more supportive friends OP.

DrJoanAllenby · 10/03/2024 09:02

'Friend, some of the things you say regarding my having cancer are upsetting to me. I know you're trying to find positivity in it but quite quite frankly it sucks, really sucks.'

MinnieMountain · 10/03/2024 08:54

If she’s a good friend normally, I’d give her 1 chance.

Fraaahnces · 10/03/2024 08:25

Honestly, I would bin her, but that’s me. If she texted wanting an explanation, I would tell her that she should “Take this as a learning experience.”
If you can’t speak to her face to face, text her and explain that you are not up to having this conversation in person. Suggest that she googles how to speak to cancer patients or people with life-altering diagnoses. Let her know that unless she is a medical professional with an oncology specialty or has cancer herself, she is not entitled to have opinions about what you should be doing, how you should be thinking or feeling or sharing her fucking intuition. Nobody died and appointed her the expert on everything. Cancer is not a “learning experience” it’s a horrible disease that randomly manifests in babies as well as kids and adults. Would she tell a baby that it was a learning bloody experience??? It’s not helpful, it’s patronizing and cruel. You have a team of qualified professionals looking after you and you can’t afford to spend your precious energy on people who are not supportive.

Meadowfinch · 10/03/2024 08:17

YANBU. It's a lot to get your head around and the last thing you need is forced joliness.

I only told my boss and two sisters. I had to stop one sister broadcasting it on Facebook, so she got cut out of the loop pretty quickly. Then I carried on working as usual. I have the advantage of working from home 4 days a week so was able to pace myself, and we were in lockdown for part of the time which helped.

I think you need to stop telling her anything. Cut her off from the drama. Minimise the situation, just keep saying 'I'm fine thanks' and changing the subject.

Then choose a more sensitive friend to confide in.

Good luck with it all. I'm 2.5 years on from diagnosis. DM me if you need any insights or want to chat.

Borgonzola · 10/03/2024 08:10

'You're being very insensitive, please stop'

MinnieMountain · 10/03/2024 08:07

”I know you’re trying to help me, but you’re actually making me feel worse. Please stop.”

EnterFunnyNameHere · 10/03/2024 07:59

I think you might as well tell ger directly that her approach, whilst well intentioned,is pretty crass and insensitive. Or find a mutual friend to support the conversation?

If your other option is phasing her out, at least you're giving her a chance this way. If she responds badly, well, you were thinking of losing her from your life anyway because of this?

Wishing you well OP, and hope it resolves quickly so you can focus on what's important x

Francisflute · 10/03/2024 07:51

Happy to move to the cancer board I was also happy to receive some AIBU decisiveness as feeling quite pissed off!

OP posts:
Francisflute · 10/03/2024 07:36

Thanks all for understanding and the great suggestions on what to say.

I think something along these lines will be it.

She's taken to saying whether she has a 'good or bad feeling' about mine and other people's outcomes who have serious illnesses (a couple of older mutual acquaintances have diagnoses too).

I can't believe the insensitivity of putting herself and her supposed perception in the centre of everything.

My (rather avoidant) instinct is to phase her out but she is a good person in other ways. There's an arrogance about this that is maddening but I suppose it comes of not knowing what to say.

OP posts:
Bigcoatlady · 09/03/2024 23:14

Agree re cancer boards. And was going to say support groups generally.

I had cancer many years ago and had some similar experiences. I think it's very common. Alongside the people who don't know what to say are the people who are full of advice. I lost a lot of weight due to chemo and the number of women who told me at least that was something to be grateful for was unbelievable.

I have no answers but fellow travelers will at least empathize.

LaviniasBigBloomers · 09/03/2024 23:12

Can someone run interference for you? You shouldn't need to be dealing with this nonsense. When my sibling was diagnosed he just used to murmur 'PMA approaching' (positive mental attitude) and I'd go to town. It actually really helped me deal with my rage, so don't think you're putting a tough job onto someone else!

ThursdayTomorrow · 09/03/2024 23:08

OP you might want to ask MN to move this to the Cancer Boards where you will get advice from others going through the same thing.