Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To butter both slices when making a sandwich ?

132 replies

ThankGodImAnAtheist · 09/03/2024 19:08

DH only butters one side and says I am doing it wrong, but will accept the results of a MN vote.

YABU: You should only butter one side
YANBU: You should butter both sides

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rubyupbeat · 23/03/2024 06:48

I always butter both sides, but my husband only one side and son neither. Its how you prefer it.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 23/03/2024 06:25

Concestor · 09/03/2024 19:46

Your use of the phrase "a sandwich which is going to have a filling" implies that you have sandwiches that do not have fillings. Are you a complete heathen?

My brother was such a heathen. He loved tomato sauce sandwiches as a child. He did butter both slices of bread, Im not sure that makes it any better though.

Zanatdy · 23/03/2024 04:39

Growing up we always buttered one side, now I do two, but I don’t tend to use butter / marg now but cream cheese instead (both sides of my bagel thin)

ohdamnitjanet · 23/03/2024 04:37

Helfs · 09/03/2024 19:18

Because it’s butter

Not heroin

😆

gillefc82 · 23/03/2024 04:35

I have exactly the same argument with my DH. He’s a one slicer, whilst I am a generous butterer of both.

Honestly, you can’t beat some fresh, crusty bread/baguette with nothing on it but lashings of salted butter. Not good for the figure but it tastes so good.

Scarlettpixie · 10/03/2024 09:25

I don’t butter usually as I include mayo, salad cream or hummus which helps hold it all together.

The exceptions are crisp or banana sandwiches which need butter and for those I usually do both sides.

i am not fussed about tasting butter on most sandwiches.

SpringSprungALeak · 10/03/2024 09:25

What a stupid thread to open as a low carber!

Sunday morning, I should be eating Avocado on sourdough!! I want toast!!!

Butter on both slices, mayo, mustard, jam are NOT substitues. But right now I'd take it in buttered if I could eat the bread.

Waitrose olive bread is to die for,

one slicer butterers are WEIRD

Anxiulyyy · 10/03/2024 09:17

You must butter both slices otherwise its known as Ian Beale-ing the sandwhich

Comms · 10/03/2024 09:14

It's a personal preference.
I always butter both slices for myself, husband prefers just one slice buttered, one of the kids can't stand butter so doesn't butter either slice.

KattyBoomBoom95 · 10/03/2024 09:08

Heronwatcher · 10/03/2024 09:07

The one side butterers have fundamentally misunderstood the scientific mechanics of a sandwich. One has to butter both sides because bread is porous and dry. The non buttered side won’t stick to the sandwich if you don’t butter it (has anyone tried sticking a dry piece of bread to a slice of ham or cheese), or, worse will absorb the juices of anything wet, like tomato, chutney, pickle or cucumber and the whole thing will fall apart and you’ll end up with an open sandwich (buttered side) and a soggy mess on the side. In a proper sandwich you need something oily and moist on both sides to act as an adhesive and a barrier to wet stuff if the thing is not going to be a tasteless disaster. The only possible exception I can see is if you are using mayo in place of butter, as it serves the same purpose, but it still isn’t quite the same.

Plus butter tastes lovely and you only need a thin layer to perform its function.

Hear hear. 🤣

Heronwatcher · 10/03/2024 09:07

The one side butterers have fundamentally misunderstood the scientific mechanics of a sandwich. One has to butter both sides because bread is porous and dry. The non buttered side won’t stick to the sandwich if you don’t butter it (has anyone tried sticking a dry piece of bread to a slice of ham or cheese), or, worse will absorb the juices of anything wet, like tomato, chutney, pickle or cucumber and the whole thing will fall apart and you’ll end up with an open sandwich (buttered side) and a soggy mess on the side. In a proper sandwich you need something oily and moist on both sides to act as an adhesive and a barrier to wet stuff if the thing is not going to be a tasteless disaster. The only possible exception I can see is if you are using mayo in place of butter, as it serves the same purpose, but it still isn’t quite the same.

Plus butter tastes lovely and you only need a thin layer to perform its function.

DinnaeFashYersel · 10/03/2024 08:58

Both sides ✅

GnomeDePlume · 10/03/2024 08:55

Only one slice buttered sounds like a British Rail sandwich from the 80s - dry and disappointing.

The first BLT I had was a British Rail one. Just bacon, lettuce and tomato. I couldn't understand why DF raved about them until I tried a not BR one. Sandwich bars took a long time to get to my corner of Hertfordshire.

AlwaysGinPlease · 10/03/2024 07:39

Both sides always and edges completely covered.

queenmeadhbh · 10/03/2024 07:33

Flin · 10/03/2024 07:22

It’s not about calories or cost. I just don’t see the point of buttering both slices.

I guess if I was making a sandwich to eat a few hours later and it had something like tomato in, then it would make sense to add butter on both slices to stop the tomato making the bread soggy. I never make sandwiches to eat later though. So for me there’s no point buttering both slices.

I can see from the thread that my butter habit (or lack-of-butter habit) is unusual though. I thought it was fairly normal until now! 😂

I’m still baffled tbh 😂 if you don’t see the point of buttering both, what’s the point of buttering one?!

JudgementalRaccoon · 10/03/2024 07:24

JPWG · 09/03/2024 19:51

I could’ve written this
my DH only butters one and thinks I’m weird
but I think he’s insane

Mind you, he also eats crumble without custard or ice cream or anything so he’s not the best person to ask

I’m sorry, what? Crumble without custard?! How can you live with this monster!?!

Flin · 10/03/2024 07:22

queenmeadhbh · 10/03/2024 06:36

Why use half the quantity, as you do? Why is using less butter better? If it’s about cost or calories, why use it at all?

It’s not about calories or cost. I just don’t see the point of buttering both slices.

I guess if I was making a sandwich to eat a few hours later and it had something like tomato in, then it would make sense to add butter on both slices to stop the tomato making the bread soggy. I never make sandwiches to eat later though. So for me there’s no point buttering both slices.

I can see from the thread that my butter habit (or lack-of-butter habit) is unusual though. I thought it was fairly normal until now! 😂

Picklestop · 10/03/2024 06:59

HoldingTheDoor · 09/03/2024 19:17

Assuming that by sides you mean the two pieces of bread and not both sides of one slice.

Well obviously! It would get a bit messy otherwise.

queenmeadhbh · 10/03/2024 06:36

Flin · 09/03/2024 19:15

I butter one slice. Why use double the quantity of butter?

Why use half the quantity, as you do? Why is using less butter better? If it’s about cost or calories, why use it at all?

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 10/03/2024 00:17

To me it depends on what’s in the sandwich. If it was bacon I would do one side butter, one side brown sauce or ketchup. Likewise if there was pickle involved. If it was a “wet” filling like tuna mayo or hummus I wouldn’t use any butter at all.

DP would do butter under pickle or mustard which makes me heave. I would never put butter under peanut butter on toast either, but DP would die on that hill.

ManchesterLu · 10/03/2024 00:08

If you mean one side of each slice YANBU.

If you mean both sides of one slice, YABU.

CarolinaInTheMorning · 10/03/2024 00:06

I'm American. I've never put butter on a sandwich.

Gowlett · 10/03/2024 00:06

Both sides. Maybe one side butter, other side mayo.

ThinWomansBrain · 10/03/2024 00:05

depends what is in the sandwich

mondaytosunday · 10/03/2024 00:03

No butter. 😁