Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inherited pearl necklace ruined by repairers

106 replies

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 09/03/2024 16:34

I inherited a pearl necklace from my grandmother.
It needed to be repaired as the clasp wasn't attached. I took it to a jewellers who sent it off for repair. It's come back and I am really upset with what they have done. It's been strung so tightly it no longer fits in the original box, doesn't even hang straight and is now an extremely tight chocker.
My husband collected today and I'm so upset, I've called the jewellers who were dismissive told me I have the wrong original box, I explained it isn't because I have the matching earrings.
That these things are always done tight and I need to wear it to soften the silk it's been threaded with.
I've told her I totally disagree, they've destroyed my Nana's necklace and it needs to be redone. She said they'll request it's done loser but it will never fit the box it did when I gave it to them.
I cannot express how snotty she was, telling me I am wrong and they've done it right.
Please look at these pictures, has anyone had similar?
One picture is me holding it from the top so you can see how it curls because it's been done so tight
The other is in the original box so you can see how much has been lost.

Is this to be expected? Are my expectations unrealistic?

Inherited pearl necklace ruined by repairers
Inherited pearl necklace ruined by repairers
OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
MinervatheGreat · 09/03/2024 17:24

Im so sorry that you’re going through this whilst you are still in mourning. I hope advice on here will be helpful to you.

I’m a big lover and wearer of pearls.
Ive got lots of strings in different lengths with beautiful clasps etc.

I’ve recently had a double string with a diamond clasp restrung and made into an opera length necklace so you could say I have experience!

The silk will, with wear, soften and the length will definitely stretch a tiny bit. This will alleviate the kinks but only if you wear them regularly. (I can see they have been knotted individually.)

It might be that your Nan wore them a lot and you hadn’t realised quite how much they’d loosened and stretched? However, the box is quite telling about the original length. I’d wager some pearls have gone missing which is why I count and photograph my strings prior to restringing but hindsight is a wonderful thing.

Yours have been strung far too tight so take it back and ask for a refund so you can go elsewhere, or, tell them to use a different stringer next time.

Go into the shop with confidence and be absolutely certain about what you want the outcome to be. Go early in the day if you can, when minds are fresh. You could do a belt and braces and ring in advance to make sure the decision maker is at work.

Don’t be brow beaten. Offer them a choice, refund or re-do. Any decent jeweller with integrity will sort this out. IF it’s a jewellery chain, Google the head office and write to the CEO if you are not satisfied. Send pics. I’ve done that in the past and got something sorted out. Leave no stone unturned.

Good luck OP.

LadyPoison · 09/03/2024 17:13

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 09/03/2024 17:04

It looks like it's been knitted every 5th pearl, until you get to the central 10 pearls
I've asked my Mum if there any any photos. The biggest difficulty will be working out which pearl necklace. My Nana adored jewellery, and there was a pearl necklace for every grandchild and great grandchild so finding a photo with this specific one may not be so easy, but I am going to see if I can find one on eBay as a comparison as the box is labelled Lotus Pearls

It should be knotted between every single pearl - that is a very shoddy job.

The price of £75 isn't unreasonable but for that it should be done properly.

Dogdilemma2000 · 09/03/2024 17:12

Wholettherabbitsout · 09/03/2024 16:37

Have you counted the pearls to see if there’s still the same number?

Exactly my question - also any chance any were missing before you took it in?

LastRites · 09/03/2024 17:09

I have a pearl necklace my husband bought brand new and it was never that tight. I have had it about 14 years and not noticed a significant loosening of the silk so the difference over time will be negligible - not a huge tightening to loosening! They are definitely having you on!

TonTonMacoute · 09/03/2024 17:05

I would expect it to be a bit tighter and stiffer than before, but that looks like an utterly crap job. There is no way it should hang the way it does in your first picture, it should be flexible!
If it’s too tight to wear comfortably it’s never going to get better.

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 09/03/2024 17:05

Trying to get a close up, not easy!

Inherited pearl necklace ruined by repairers
OP posts:
WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 09/03/2024 17:04

It looks like it's been knitted every 5th pearl, until you get to the central 10 pearls
I've asked my Mum if there any any photos. The biggest difficulty will be working out which pearl necklace. My Nana adored jewellery, and there was a pearl necklace for every grandchild and great grandchild so finding a photo with this specific one may not be so easy, but I am going to see if I can find one on eBay as a comparison as the box is labelled Lotus Pearls

OP posts:
LadyPoison · 09/03/2024 16:58

That is a dreadful job.

It needs to be redone. The silk does stretch a bit but not that much. I would ask for a refund and take them elsewhere.

Was it a chain or an independent?

BeaLola · 09/03/2024 16:58

I have several pearl necklaces - all are knotted between each pearl and none have ever looked like your first picture.

I would check if there's a knot between each one , if not when you take back get a full refund (as they have not done as promised) and take it somewhere else for a proper restring

Amberlady · 09/03/2024 16:57

Are they knotted in between? It's hard to tell in the photo but you should be able to see the knots if they are there. And they definitely should drape and hang straight.

NorthCliffs · 09/03/2024 16:56

Count the pearls now so you have a record. Have you got any pictures of it being worn?

ohdamnitjanet · 09/03/2024 16:53

It’s hard to tell from the photo if each pearl is knotted as it should be? It doesn’t look like it, which would explain why it’s so short.

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 09/03/2024 16:50

I have told them I'm bringing it back Monday and they will be given one chance to do it right (because she scoffed and said they don't work Sundays and closing soon). The problem was her continuously telling me I was wrong, it was right and yes they'd send it off and ask for it looser but I'm asking for it to be done badly and there won't me much extra give.

I am pleased others on here agree it's done too tightly because as you can tell I'm a bloody amateur whose never had to have jewellery repaired.
It's a small independent jewellers and was £75 to have restrung

OP posts:
waterlellon · 09/03/2024 16:48

Omg that's awful I'm so sorry

CoraPirbright · 09/03/2024 16:48

That’s absolutely abominable! Just a shot in the dark but I recently had some jewellery valued and they measured my string of pearls. Might there be an old insurers document anywhere that would list this? Then you could perhaps have an idea if any pearls had been lost. That gap in the string when shown in the case does seem rather large. And the photo showing the almost curly string is a joke. Yes, silk will relax and stretch over time but I have never in all my years seen such a poor stringing job.

TimetoPour · 09/03/2024 16:48

I wouldn’t trust them again. I would request my money back and go elsewhere.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/03/2024 16:48

She assured me there is the same amount of pearls

They said similar to me, OP, when I took a treasured 18ct gold chain in for repair and they swapped it for a 9ct one

I guess all you can do is insist they redo it, but this time make sure they sign a receipt detailing exactly what it is

Cantalever · 09/03/2024 16:46

That's awful work OP. It looks totally amateur and uncaring about the very poor standard of work. I wouldn't let them near it again but find another professional to do it right. Show them the photos and explain the problem. No idea what this costs, but pay again and get the money back from the original jeweller (plus damages for distress if possible) - go to the county court if necessary.

LydiaPoet · 09/03/2024 16:46

Go on with your husband and just don’t leave until they offer to Recify and refund - just no - it looks much too tight and also like they have just removed some. Get a photo of it on your grandma l’s neck etc but I d hit the roof

Alwaystransforming · 09/03/2024 16:45

Have you got a photo of it before? Did it have significant gaps before.

it has been strung too tight. But that’s a huge size difference.

Lazypeopledrivemecrazy · 09/03/2024 16:43

Maybe the person you spoke to didn't really understand the problem OP, as you were on the phone and not there in person. In your shoes I would go into the store, ask for the manager, and explain calmly what the problem is. Hopefully when they see the necklace in person they'll realise that you are in fact correct, and the job hasn't been done properly. Naturally pearl necklaces do stretch a bit with wear, but it does look like it's been done far too tightly, and should just hang nicely and not be all bent out of shape like it is in your picture. I too would be wondering if any of the pearls have actually gone missing, but you may not have thought to count them beforehand. I think it likely that the job just hasn't been done properly, and would ask them to re-do it.

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 09/03/2024 16:42

@RogersOrganismicProcess no :(
My Mum wanted us to all wear some of my Nana's jewellery for her funeral, I was given this within a few days of her passing and honestly I was just too upset to think, I just knew I needed it done and didn't think to take before photos or count pearls.
They also announced that it was ready for collection 2 days after her funeral...but that's another matter

OP posts:
YoureWinningAtLife · 09/03/2024 16:42

I had a similar issue, although the opposite way around. They were so loosely knotted they now sat so much lower they looked a silly length and they scratched the gold clasp.
I did get a refund for the fee I’d paid and took them elsewhere for a better job. It was 20+ years ago and I’m still mad about it, even though the new place did their best to polish the scratch out.

I’d ask if they would just cut the thread and give you a refund so you can get it redone.

RogersOrganismicProcess · 09/03/2024 16:40

Do you have a picture of how it was before?

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 09/03/2024 16:39

@Aydel they said they would use fresh silk and have each pearl knitted between so if it ever broke you wouldn't lose pearls.
@PaperCrane555 I didn't think to count prior so can't say either way. She assured me there is the same amount of pearls.

OP posts: