Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inherited pearl necklace ruined by repairers

106 replies

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 09/03/2024 16:34

I inherited a pearl necklace from my grandmother.
It needed to be repaired as the clasp wasn't attached. I took it to a jewellers who sent it off for repair. It's come back and I am really upset with what they have done. It's been strung so tightly it no longer fits in the original box, doesn't even hang straight and is now an extremely tight chocker.
My husband collected today and I'm so upset, I've called the jewellers who were dismissive told me I have the wrong original box, I explained it isn't because I have the matching earrings.
That these things are always done tight and I need to wear it to soften the silk it's been threaded with.
I've told her I totally disagree, they've destroyed my Nana's necklace and it needs to be redone. She said they'll request it's done loser but it will never fit the box it did when I gave it to them.
I cannot express how snotty she was, telling me I am wrong and they've done it right.
Please look at these pictures, has anyone had similar?
One picture is me holding it from the top so you can see how it curls because it's been done so tight
The other is in the original box so you can see how much has been lost.

Is this to be expected? Are my expectations unrealistic?

Inherited pearl necklace ruined by repairers
Inherited pearl necklace ruined by repairers
OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Dontforgetthesalamander · 11/03/2024 16:10

If you engage someone for a service you should expect it to be carried out with reasonable care and skill and they haven't done so. You could contact citizens advice and trading standards.

pavedwithgoodintentions · 11/03/2024 16:04

Name and shame.
Dispute the charges on your card.

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 11/03/2024 15:38

@LadyPoison I must say the second Jewellers who now have the necklace were unbelievably wonderful. I said that I know they aren't valuable and one of the ladies responded "no, these are priceless because of whose they were"
I think it says everything and any nerves I had of leaving them with someone else left at that point

OP posts:
LadyPoison · 11/03/2024 15:27

Please post the review whatever the outcome to save any one else going through this. The pearls may not have much monetary value but much of the value in jewellery is sentimental and every half way decent repair jeweller knows this and takes great care even with costume jewellery.

I'm glad the second jeweller is sorting this out for you.There's a knack to knotting pearls but it's not difficult. They really didn't save much time or effort by cutting corners

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 11/03/2024 15:17

@Lumiodes Thank you for the suggestion, we've filed a charge back and should hear from the bank within 14 days
@MabelMaybe They may well contest it - I have the photo evidence of what they have supplied. I can show I called them on Saturday when I saw the item and that I went in today to show them.

In terms of what was written down, the slip we were given was taken back when my husband collected but I am sure it was restring of pearls - nothing at all about every 5th pearl. The shop person was adamant that was agreed and I said no, I asked you to restring you've decided how it should be done and you've done it every 5. I explained everything i've read and the second opinion I had stated it needed to be done individual and it stops them rubbing, that was the point she said they aren't even real so it doesn't matter

I am going to wait until the claim is accepted or rejected before I post any public reviews

OP posts:
MabelMaybe · 11/03/2024 14:19

You can do chargeback on your card, but they'll argue that they have completed the work. Maybe look into small claims, or into the company you used to see if any other staff are available and speak to them. With regards to the 5 pearl knots, surely she'll have that written down as you had your discussion with her, won't she? What notes does she have?

Lumiodes · 11/03/2024 13:16

Name and shame on local Facebook groups, Google reviews, Trustpilot etc. Contact your bank and ask if they can do a chargeback on your debit card. If not then take the jeweller to small claims court.

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 11/03/2024 13:09

Update
Please excuse any typos, im a mix of shaking and crying

so, before I went to the jewellers I went to another in town, asked their opinion as they could see them in person and could tell me if I was being unreasonable. They agreed with everyone here, should have been every pearl knotted and they said whilst it will be tighter until worn which warms and softens the silk the knotting is causing the issues and the kinks

I then go to the jewellers who did it
from the start she had attitude, im wrong shes right - every 5 pearls is fine, thats what I asked for (no, i went there upset asking for them to be restrung for my Nanas funeral, she decided how it would be done)
it went on and on - I said is she even going to send them back to be reknotted every pearl, she said no.
to send them back would be an insult to the repairers!
I said she needed to refund then, I even said you can cut the string and i'll go elsewhere. She laughed and said she would not do that
They arent even real pearls it doesnt matter

I said if they are refusing to rectify the fault and refusing to refund then ill be very public in my reviews and opinions at which point she said id be stupid to do that. I managed to walk out without crying in front of her, got to the first jewellers and promptly burst into tears.

They are going to restring and tie every knot for me. They do it in house, the lady that does it spoke to me and they only charge £35, unlike the £75 the first ones charged

so, Mumsnet
I paid £75, it was paid for on a debit card - what if any recourse do I actually have?
Is my only option name and shame?
They do not have a facebook page with much content, last posting was December, they have 28 likes and 33 followers so a Facebook review isnt the way to go. The website is one page website

or should I simply walk away?

OP posts:
Mementomorissons · 10/03/2024 19:37

They've absolutely messed that up and can't know what they're doing. Of course they should've knitted between every one...why would anyone trust incredibly valuable tiny beads on the strength of a piece of silk?! It would be so easy to snag those and see a bunch of pearls go down a drain

tittybumbum · 10/03/2024 18:50

This is the same number of pearls. Knotted vs strung. The length is massively affected.

Inherited pearl necklace ruined by repairers
CoraPirbright · 10/03/2024 16:53

The snotty attitude you have been met with is appalling. Ask for a refund (with a cut if necessary - like your style!) and then I would be telling everyone in the vicinity what a bloody shoddy job they did and how badly you were treated.

Shetlands · 10/03/2024 11:03

I agree that they're simulated pearls because real pearls would usually have a gold or platinum clasp. The monetary value isn't important though because they have huge sentimental value. They've done a terrible job with the stringing and you're quite right to take them back.

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 10/03/2024 10:48

Thanks for everyone's feedback, I have said previously I wouldn't say they have lost/taken pearls partially because I have zero proof but also it's not valuable - I trusted them and wouldn't have thought of counting them before. We live and learn.
I really hope the issue is the knotting every 5 pearls as has been suggested.

They came recommended for repairs they'd done for other people, although to my knowledge it wasn't pearls but other jewelry.

I am going in tomorrow with the intention of allowing them the opportunity to rectify BUT if she looks at it and maintains it's right then I'll be clear I have no belief that they are able to remedy the problem.
They should be embarrassed it's left their shop like this, and if she continues with the attitude I'll request a refund and be prepared for them to cut the silk (so they know I'm not just looking for a free job) and go elsewhere

OP posts:
Yellowroseblooms · 10/03/2024 10:42

Those are almost certainly simulated pearls so the idea of the jeweller making off with a few can be discounted. I have handled and seen a lot of pearl necklaces and if they are knotted, then it's each single one. I have never seen them knotted in groups of five, even with simulated pearls they are either not knotted at all or singly knotted. The number of knots affects the length - the more knots, the longer the necklace. I think it's the knotting in groups of five which has reduced the length rather than any missing pearls. I have handled a newly restrung necklace which was stiff and I was told it would soften and it did but probably not as tight as yours. It's not ruined. I'd demand a refund and get them restrung properly with single knotting.

Anonmousse · 10/03/2024 09:54

I'm a jeweller and it makes me really sad and annoyed that jewellers are often seen as untrustworthy (but understand why when people have had bad experiences)
Stringing pearls is not sonething all jewellers do (I've never strung pearls in 25 years) ...but I wouldn't attempt it at the risk of ruining something, I would simply advise that I'm unable to do that.
Having said that the pearls and the clasp are the main components so while it looks like they've made a bad job of it (I would also expect that it would be knotted between each pearl and that there may be a slight difference in length - if some had been lost or they needed to supply more to make the correct length, that should have been explained) I don't think is unresolvable if done by someone competent .

HoneyButterPopcorn · 10/03/2024 09:41

Wholettherabbitsout · 09/03/2024 16:37

Have you counted the pearls to see if there’s still the same number?

I was wondering too - maybe you have a photo?

are the pearly just strung together or are there any type spacers in between them?

it does look like a bad job.

Dogdilemma2000 · 10/03/2024 09:36

Soontobe60 · 09/03/2024 22:42

Have you placed it in the box actually fastened? The gap could be because youve not fastened it!

No those boxes are rigid early plastic - the necklace should fit perfectly around it without stretching. The necklace is clearly too short now to do so.

Stringagal · 09/03/2024 23:21

Surely if the silk is going to relax / stretch a bit, the every-5-pearl gap will just get bigger?

pavedwithgoodintentions · 09/03/2024 23:10

As everyone has said, it's a very unprofessional job and they should be embarrassed they're trying to pretend otherwise.

There should be a knot between every pearl.

I have my grandmother's pearls and they are individually knotted to protect them from rubbing and from being lost should the strand break.

BarbieDangerous · 09/03/2024 23:03

Jovacknockowitch · 09/03/2024 22:59

Eh?

F = Following. As in following the thread. I’m not sure why people still do that as you can watch a thread without having to comment

Jovacknockowitch · 09/03/2024 22:59

Confusedmeanderings · 09/03/2024 21:37

F

Eh?

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/03/2024 22:50

Whoa!

Far far too tight! Pearls are knotted between every pearl, or they will rub on each other and scratch and take off the lovely soft shine!! This is basic Pearl Stringing 101!

They should not be so tight that the strand won't hang straight down when held at one end either.

So this is a crap job and whilst its not ruined as they can be re-strung, leaving them like that and worse, wearing them like that as they have advised, will in a fairly short time frame, damage each pearl that is touching another.

It isn't unusual that they might be knotted with a bigger or smaller gap between them than they were originally, and thus not exactly fit the box, but that difference is shocking and a direct result of them cramming five in a row and knotting so tight they can't move.

Soontobe60 · 09/03/2024 22:42

Have you placed it in the box actually fastened? The gap could be because youve not fastened it!

Lumiodes · 09/03/2024 22:33

They are far too tight. The string of pearls shouldn’t be bending like that. I wouldn’t trust them to fix it - get a refund and go elsewhere.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/03/2024 22:24

All cultured pearls are not the same. Some are very valuable

Very true, @tittybumbum; however it was Lotus specifically I was referring to, and I'm pretty sure they're at the more modest end of things