Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if schools can do this!

193 replies

LondonElle · 09/03/2024 12:54

My 12 year old son was due to go on a sports trip on Friday for the weekend.
We had paid in full for this (over £300.)

He stupidly got involved in a fight the day of the trip ( out of character ) after another boy called him names.

No excuses he was in the wrong and will be punished severely...

I am not minimising what he did.. he was an absolute idiot.

The school pulled the trip which has led to us being out of pocket and he is in isolation on Monday.

I have mixed feeling about this as I'm not sure the school had much of a choice and couldn't fill his place at short notice but part of me thinks due to the bad press the school has recently received and the lack of pastoral support in his year group that an example may have been made of him ( which may be a good thing)

Do I have to suck it up and accept this... don't hold back.. I need cold hard truths!

OP posts:
NotStylishOrBeautiful · 09/03/2024 19:30

Excellent post from @LividBath

Anyone who ever describes a school trip (especially a residential) as a jolly should have to learn it by heart.

Glass113 · 09/03/2024 19:29

LondonElle · 09/03/2024 19:06

I fully accept the consequences, I won't be making a complaint despite how frustrating is it.

I just needed to get different perspectives which I have gotten and appreciate.

My son has never been physical before but that being said he should not have reacted in the manner he did. It's a hard lesson to learn but a crucial one.

His record prior to this was a good one but he messed up badly and I accept this.

I actually wouldn't be too hard on him now. He can't go on the trip which is a punishment and I'm sure he's had a stern talking to at home and feels like shit.

A 12 year old boy letting emotions get the better of him and lashing out when provoked is hardly crime of the century. I'd just discuss with him that violence should only be used as a last resort to defend yourself and try and help him deal with his emotions.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 09/03/2024 19:26

LondonElle · 09/03/2024 19:06

I fully accept the consequences, I won't be making a complaint despite how frustrating is it.

I just needed to get different perspectives which I have gotten and appreciate.

My son has never been physical before but that being said he should not have reacted in the manner he did. It's a hard lesson to learn but a crucial one.

His record prior to this was a good one but he messed up badly and I accept this.

If this is out of character for your son, it might be good to check in with him in general- how he is feeling, has he been especially irritable recently, does he ever feel overwhelmed with his feelings etc.

I know pre-teen boys aren't always the most communicative, but I think it would be a good idea to try to help him know he can always communicate with you how he's feeling. Sudden outbursts of anger or increased irritability can be symptoms relating to mental health. I know you say the other boy had been winding him up for a while, but one doesn't necessarily not link to the other.

I do think it would be a good idea to speak to the school on Monday about keeping your son and this boy seperate in the future as well.

LondonElle · 09/03/2024 19:06

I fully accept the consequences, I won't be making a complaint despite how frustrating is it.

I just needed to get different perspectives which I have gotten and appreciate.

My son has never been physical before but that being said he should not have reacted in the manner he did. It's a hard lesson to learn but a crucial one.

His record prior to this was a good one but he messed up badly and I accept this.

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 09/03/2024 19:05

Muchtoomuchtodo · 09/03/2024 18:58

My dc is off to USA with school for a week over Easter. Would a parent really be expected to pick them up? They’d be home again before I managed to get enough money together and book return flights!

I suspect that it would depend on the trip, but I have known parents have to collect their children from international trips in Europe.

But on a USA trip I would have thought a teacher would have to fly back with the child.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 09/03/2024 19:01

Bushmillsbabe · 09/03/2024 18:55

Surely it would be on the parents to come collect rather than another teacher? The teacher wouldn't be insured to drive a child in own car, and couldn't be alone with a child for such an extended time period due to safeguarding rules.

I take children on trip (girlguiding) and its made very clear that a parent needs to be available to come collect their child in case of sickness or any other reason

Whilst I absolutely agree that violence is never ok, if the school was aware of the other child's behaviour if long term issue and did nothing there is an element that they are also accountable. Have you asked the school if any flexibility on this, for example could attend if you came as a parent helper? Probably not, but just a thought

Edited

Teachers can transport children in their own car with business insurance. Or it may be using the school minibus. I imagine two staff would do the drive home, but I may be wrong.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 09/03/2024 19:00

RatatouillePie · 09/03/2024 18:53

Sometimes a school don't have a choice if they're skating on thin ice over the grounds of refusing the trip.

If there was sufficient evidence that the boy was provoked then the punishment is too harsh but as I said, there probably wasn't time to investigate so offering a refund would be fair if the school feel the punishment was too severe.

Particularly if the other person that provoked them did have a history of poor behaviour.

I mean, the student's been in a fight, no one is denying that. I think there's sufficient evidence to say that going on a trip isn't appropriate.

They've punched someone. Today. Who's to say that if someone winds them up on the bus, they'd not punch that person as well, and potentially dangerously distract the driver?

It's about everyone's safety, regardless of provocation.

I agree they may not deserve another harsh punishment such as exclusion, but this is totally different.

When you say "thin ice" who is the parent actually going to complain to in this case?

Muchtoomuchtodo · 09/03/2024 18:58

Bushmillsbabe · 09/03/2024 18:55

Surely it would be on the parents to come collect rather than another teacher? The teacher wouldn't be insured to drive a child in own car, and couldn't be alone with a child for such an extended time period due to safeguarding rules.

I take children on trip (girlguiding) and its made very clear that a parent needs to be available to come collect their child in case of sickness or any other reason

Whilst I absolutely agree that violence is never ok, if the school was aware of the other child's behaviour if long term issue and did nothing there is an element that they are also accountable. Have you asked the school if any flexibility on this, for example could attend if you came as a parent helper? Probably not, but just a thought

Edited

My dc is off to USA with school for a week over Easter. Would a parent really be expected to pick them up? They’d be home again before I managed to get enough money together and book return flights!

Dacadactyl · 09/03/2024 18:55

I would be FUMING about this, but it would be with my son, not the school.

Bushmillsbabe · 09/03/2024 18:55

Topofthemountain · 09/03/2024 13:25

It is often in the T&C of the trip. A harsh lesson for all though.

My DD is due on a college trip soon to London, a mix of 16, 17 and 18 year olds. Apparently there is a teacher on standby in the NE to drive down and collect any pupils breaking rules, including drinking. Schools take behaviour on trips very seriously.

Surely it would be on the parents to come collect rather than another teacher? The teacher wouldn't be insured to drive a child in own car, and couldn't be alone with a child for such an extended time period due to safeguarding rules.

I take children on trip (girlguiding) and its made very clear that a parent needs to be available to come collect their child in case of sickness or any other reason

Whilst I absolutely agree that violence is never ok, if the school was aware of the other child's behaviour if long term issue and did nothing there is an element that they are also accountable. Have you asked the school if any flexibility on this, for example could attend if you came as a parent helper? Probably not, but just a thought

RatatouillePie · 09/03/2024 18:53

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 09/03/2024 18:46

My concern with this would be that if the behaviour was so out of character and violent, it could be a symptom of something more serious. Violence/lashing out/losing control can be a symptom relating to mental health issues, especially in teenagers, especially in teenage boys.

Can your school really just afford to suck up a £300 loss?

Sometimes a school don't have a choice if they're skating on thin ice over the grounds of refusing the trip.

If there was sufficient evidence that the boy was provoked then the punishment is too harsh but as I said, there probably wasn't time to investigate so offering a refund would be fair if the school feel the punishment was too severe.

Particularly if the other person that provoked them did have a history of poor behaviour.

FrippEnos · 09/03/2024 18:52

All the trips that I have ever seen run have had behaviour clauses in them.

HaPPy8 · 09/03/2024 18:50

I wouldn’t be happy about this. You’ve essentially paid for something and not received it. £300 is a lot of money and I think this is a disproportionate response based on the information given. I’d want my money back.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 09/03/2024 18:46

RatatouillePie · 09/03/2024 18:37

If it was a child I knew well and this was extremely out of character and a one off then yes I'd have no issues taking them.

I'm guessing there was not enough time to investigate but given the excellent track record the school should probably offer to refund the £300 less an admin fee if there was no prior policy about behaviour.

My concern with this would be that if the behaviour was so out of character and violent, it could be a symptom of something more serious. Violence/lashing out/losing control can be a symptom relating to mental health issues, especially in teenagers, especially in teenage boys.

Can your school really just afford to suck up a £300 loss?

adviceneeded1990 · 09/03/2024 18:45

MrsMurphyIWish · 09/03/2024 16:03

Although I’m a member of the Mr P’s podcast group (for teachers) and someone sent a story in that the police turned up at their school to investigate a claim that a teacher had stolen their child’s PE kit so there are people out there who do follow bonkers advice.

Teacher here - people are batshit 😅 and definitely agree that they follow bonkers advice! I once had a parent with a boy who had racked up 24 violent incidents towards myself, the LCA and multiple other children in a ten week term and other kids were crying in fear when he came to school. Upper primary! Mum attended meeting about next steps and told myself and my head teacher that her neighbour told her to get a solicitor and “sue the arse off us for sexism.” She felt he clearly had all these issues because we preferred teaching girls…

FrippEnos · 09/03/2024 18:38

Brightredtulips · 09/03/2024 17:21

Does the school not have insurance against this? Will a teacher take his place and go on a jolly? Your son was sticking up for himself. I'd be furious and I work in a secondary school.

You "work" in a school and still put forward that its a "jolly" .

adviceneeded1990 · 09/03/2024 18:38

Viviennemary · 09/03/2024 14:56

The school are out of order and should repay the cost of the trip. Take them to the small claims court. It's cheeky.

😂😂😂

RatatouillePie · 09/03/2024 18:37

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 09/03/2024 18:27

Would you really, truly, take a 12yo on a trip on the day they'd been in a fight?

I'd (maybe) agree if the fight had been a week or two ago and child had had a chance to calm down etc, and genuinely was a one off. But not the day of. That child isn't in the right frame of mind to be spending the weekend away from home, for all sorts of reasons.

It's not just about punishment, it's also about safeguarding. If a colleague suggested this, I'd genuinely question their judgement.

Also, I'm not sure OP actually states anywhere that his behaviour record is otherwise absolutely perfect.

Edited

If it was a child I knew well and this was extremely out of character and a one off then yes I'd have no issues taking them.

I'm guessing there was not enough time to investigate but given the excellent track record the school should probably offer to refund the £300 less an admin fee if there was no prior policy about behaviour.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 09/03/2024 18:37

Can anyone show me an example of the T&C’s that you agree to when signing up for school trips?

ours are in years 13 and 11 and I can honestly say that I’ve never been made aware of anything like this.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 09/03/2024 18:27

RatatouillePie · 09/03/2024 18:24

@LondonElle

I'm a teacher and I think the punishment is over the top.

He was clearly provoked and this behaviour was very out of character. And the other boy wasn't even going on the trip!!

I'd be wanting a full refund from the school unless they can show the school policy that you were made aware of regarding this.

We have banned kids from trips before but only because they had a history of poor behaviour and they hadn't met the behaviour standard.

Would you really, truly, take a 12yo on a trip on the day they'd been in a fight?

I'd (maybe) agree if the fight had been a week or two ago and child had had a chance to calm down etc, and genuinely was a one off. But not the day of. That child isn't in the right frame of mind to be spending the weekend away from home, for all sorts of reasons.

It's not just about punishment, it's also about safeguarding. If a colleague suggested this, I'd genuinely question their judgement.

Also, I'm not sure OP actually states anywhere that his behaviour record is otherwise absolutely perfect.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 09/03/2024 18:26

Organising and running a school trip is one of the most exhausting and stressful experiences of my whole life. It's a specific part of my role, but I'd actually pay NOT to go on one.

RatatouillePie · 09/03/2024 18:24

@LondonElle

I'm a teacher and I think the punishment is over the top.

He was clearly provoked and this behaviour was very out of character. And the other boy wasn't even going on the trip!!

I'd be wanting a full refund from the school unless they can show the school policy that you were made aware of regarding this.

We have banned kids from trips before but only because they had a history of poor behaviour and they hadn't met the behaviour standard.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 09/03/2024 18:24

How many posters on this thread would like to be responsible for taking a child on a trip who has been physically violent THAT DAY. He obviously wasn't in the right place mentally to go on the trip if he lashed out at another student. It's a safeguarding thing as much as anything- they can't guarantee his safety or that of other students if he goes on the trip.

OP is not out of pocket, she has already budgeted for the money. If the school refund OP, they will be out of pocket. Okay, £300 is not that much to a school but it will e.g. pay for a supply teacher for a couple of days, or pay for class resources such as mini whiteboard pens across the subject, or it will pay for a number of science experiments. State school budgets are finely balanced- should other children lose out because OP's child was violent.

Yes, perhaps the name calling should have been dealt with earlier by the school, but OP says it was relatively minor, and it's clear this wasn't the case of eg just one push or one retaliation. The other child may have been injured. They may also have been punished, but that's not for the school to share with OP.

Parents moan about lack of trips, too, but this is why schools/school staff don't want to run them! You can't have it all ways!

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 09/03/2024 18:20

Will a teacher take his place and go on a jolly?

FFS. You try going on a residential trip with a load of school kids and being responsible for them 24 hours a day and tell me afterwards if it felt like a jolly. Angry