Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if schools can do this!

193 replies

LondonElle · 09/03/2024 12:54

My 12 year old son was due to go on a sports trip on Friday for the weekend.
We had paid in full for this (over £300.)

He stupidly got involved in a fight the day of the trip ( out of character ) after another boy called him names.

No excuses he was in the wrong and will be punished severely...

I am not minimising what he did.. he was an absolute idiot.

The school pulled the trip which has led to us being out of pocket and he is in isolation on Monday.

I have mixed feeling about this as I'm not sure the school had much of a choice and couldn't fill his place at short notice but part of me thinks due to the bad press the school has recently received and the lack of pastoral support in his year group that an example may have been made of him ( which may be a good thing)

Do I have to suck it up and accept this... don't hold back.. I need cold hard truths!

OP posts:
HappyHolidays22 · 10/03/2024 20:33

LondonElle · 10/03/2024 19:47

I did not say it was all the other child's fault.. I stated the facts.
I made it clear that I think my son was an idiot.
His behaviour up until this point has been good and I have accepted that the school did the only thing they could do. It was just a bit of a shock.

You don’t need to justify yourself @LondonElle . I think your reaction - and your question that started this thread - is totally natural; you’re both disappointed with and for your child. MN is a strange place on these kinds of threads; people seem to want to lynch each other rather than support.

dapsnotplimsolls · 10/03/2024 20:28

How has the OP subsidised the trip for other pupils?

Missamyp · 10/03/2024 20:27

Complete over reaction and inappropriate from the school.
Punishments should fit the crime, discipline should effect just the boys especially for one offs.
The op paid for a trip, in fact technically the op as subsided the trip for the other pupils.
The school has definitely over stepped.
Appallingly inappropriate.

dapsnotplimsolls · 10/03/2024 20:26

He chose to respond to goading with violence.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 10/03/2024 20:14

It’s really unfortunate timing. If he’d done this next week, your DS would have already been on the trip. Because of the timing, he has ended up receiving a greater punishment.
If I was him, I’d feel a sense of great injustice about this. But at least he’ll never do it again.

Pres11 · 10/03/2024 20:14

It’s harsh, for you and him and I know how you feel. My daughter in y11 got into trouble and was suspended for 1 day, the first time she had ever been suspended, and the rules were a suspension in y11 means no prom. So she couldn’t go to her prom, and I had already paid for her dress which was £280. 😔 I cried, she cried. We argued but it’s a lesson learnt to her, a harsh one yes but it will probably help her in life down the line.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/03/2024 20:04

starlight889 · 10/03/2024 18:18

A natural consequence to a fight is getting hurt. Not going on a school trip because of a fight is NOT a natural consequence because the two have no direct correlation.

I don't agree. A natural consequence of being unable to regulate your own behaviour is that others will want to distance themselves from that behaviour, and that they will not volunteer to be responsible for that behaviour when they don't have to be.

Getting hurt might be one natural consequence but it certainly isn't the only one.

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 10/03/2024 19:58

The school were right but I just want to say I really feel for your DS. Don't know what trip it was but if that was me at that age, I'd be so disappointed and sad.

It sounds like this has been building for ages and I expect he will feel a victim as much as he feels an out-of-line aggressor. It's so easy to snap with this kind of teasing; while I agree he needs to learn his lesson, his post-aggression low could be quite significant with the loss of the trip compounding it.

I'd push for some support from the school with regards this other boy. Names scratch away at your self-esteem and then before you know it, you're bleeding quite a lot from many small wounds. It's not OK.

CagneyAndLazy · 10/03/2024 19:53

Calamitousness · 10/03/2024 18:56

ill buck the trend. I think for a one off with another child involved not having the same sanction that it is unreasonable. Fair enough if this wasn’t his first infraction and if it had been one sided. But not allowing him on the trip when both boys were fighting, after the other child goaded him is unfair I feel.

The other child isn't on the trip.

OP told us that.

LondonElle · 10/03/2024 19:47

I did not say it was all the other child's fault.. I stated the facts.
I made it clear that I think my son was an idiot.
His behaviour up until this point has been good and I have accepted that the school did the only thing they could do. It was just a bit of a shock.

OP posts:
Motherofacertainage · 10/03/2024 19:41

RatatouillePie · 09/03/2024 18:24

@LondonElle

I'm a teacher and I think the punishment is over the top.

He was clearly provoked and this behaviour was very out of character. And the other boy wasn't even going on the trip!!

I'd be wanting a full refund from the school unless they can show the school policy that you were made aware of regarding this.

We have banned kids from trips before but only because they had a history of poor behaviour and they hadn't met the behaviour standard.

If you really are a teacher then you'll be aware that parents are usually biased towards their own children and the report that this child is usually very well behaved and it was all the other kids fault is almost definitely not quite how the school sees the situation.

Noodles1234 · 10/03/2024 19:26

This is standard practise, sadly as close to the date yes could be you’re out of pocket. Schools have to set a precedent even if sadly it’s out of character, or it would be one rule for one.
I would be annoyed deep down - at everyone as has cost you a lot of money, it could be a good learning curve (I hope) for your son. However being goaded will be difficult for him I’m sure if the other lad isn’t going on the trip so he’s not lost out.

wishing strength and peace for your son.

dapsnotplimsolls · 10/03/2024 19:22

I wouldn't want to take a kid who's just hit another kid on a trip.

Missingpop · 10/03/2024 19:19

The school won’t pay you back but I’d make it very clear to your son that he is going to pay back every penny & will do extra chores & will be grounded until it’s paid.
i would also be contacting the school Monday to express to them that I feel their attitude towards him was over the top as the other child (presumably) didn’t get the same level of punishment yet both were guilty if the same crime & therefore should have had equal punishments.

JayJayj · 10/03/2024 19:01

I disagree with most of the points on here.

he was being bullied and finally snapped. He is being punished by the school and for you because he stuck up for himself. This is showing that he if defends himself or sticks up for himself he will be in trouble. You may make him a pushover.

As someone who witnessed how hard my sister had it until she snapped and beat up her bully I think good on him.

You said it’s out of character for him. He clearly had enough and isn’t just going round beating random people up.

stick up for your son. You can explain that yea he went too far but you understand why he did what he did.

Calamitousness · 10/03/2024 18:56

ill buck the trend. I think for a one off with another child involved not having the same sanction that it is unreasonable. Fair enough if this wasn’t his first infraction and if it had been one sided. But not allowing him on the trip when both boys were fighting, after the other child goaded him is unfair I feel.

dapsnotplimsolls · 10/03/2024 18:56

HappyHolidays22 · 10/03/2024 18:53

Reduced Christmas presents @dapsnotplimsolls? for something he has done in March? Oh behave! It’s not the crime of the century - sounds like not going on the trip is punishment enough, especially if it hasn’t happened before and doesn’t happen again.

His parents are down £300 because of his actions. There should be some kind of paying back.

HappyHolidays22 · 10/03/2024 18:53

Reduced Christmas presents @dapsnotplimsolls? for something he has done in March? Oh behave! It’s not the crime of the century - sounds like not going on the trip is punishment enough, especially if it hasn’t happened before and doesn’t happen again.

VerbenaGirl · 10/03/2024 18:37

Yes, schools can do this. They have to, both as a behaviour sanction and because they can’t afford to give refunds if balances have been paid and are not reclaimable via insurance (which they wouldn’t be in these circumstances). The school’s policy should clearly set this out and probably also letters about the trip.

Caravaggiouch · 10/03/2024 18:19

Sounds like a logical consequence. Unless he’s primary school age he shouldn’t really need forewarning that getting in a fight will result in loss of privileges like a school trip; it’s obvious that’s what would happen.

starlight889 · 10/03/2024 18:18

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/03/2024 16:27

It's a natural consequence of his actions. He showed that he was unable to regulate his behaviour appropriately by getting into a fight, so the school don't want the responsibility of taking him on a trip. Fair enough. Hopefully he will learn from it.

A natural consequence to a fight is getting hurt. Not going on a school trip because of a fight is NOT a natural consequence because the two have no direct correlation.

starlight889 · 10/03/2024 18:15

LondonElle · 09/03/2024 12:54

My 12 year old son was due to go on a sports trip on Friday for the weekend.
We had paid in full for this (over £300.)

He stupidly got involved in a fight the day of the trip ( out of character ) after another boy called him names.

No excuses he was in the wrong and will be punished severely...

I am not minimising what he did.. he was an absolute idiot.

The school pulled the trip which has led to us being out of pocket and he is in isolation on Monday.

I have mixed feeling about this as I'm not sure the school had much of a choice and couldn't fill his place at short notice but part of me thinks due to the bad press the school has recently received and the lack of pastoral support in his year group that an example may have been made of him ( which may be a good thing)

Do I have to suck it up and accept this... don't hold back.. I need cold hard truths!

I know I will be in the minority here but I would still expect him on the trip. You’ve paid hundreds for it so if they really didn’t want him on the trip, they should pay it back.

I get getting in a fight needs a consequence (but I believe in natural consequences so not going on a trip is unrelated and isn’t one to me) but what messaged does it send? You defend yourself against a bully and you’re punished? That to me just sends the message that school won’t help and when you try sort it yourself, you are the one punished.

Im a teacher and we would never use this type of consequence (although I am not in a state school)

RatatouillePie · 09/03/2024 19:48

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 09/03/2024 19:00

I mean, the student's been in a fight, no one is denying that. I think there's sufficient evidence to say that going on a trip isn't appropriate.

They've punched someone. Today. Who's to say that if someone winds them up on the bus, they'd not punch that person as well, and potentially dangerously distract the driver?

It's about everyone's safety, regardless of provocation.

I agree they may not deserve another harsh punishment such as exclusion, but this is totally different.

When you say "thin ice" who is the parent actually going to complain to in this case?

The thin ice depends on whether the school has a policy to ban a pupil from a trip given their previous impeccable record.

If the school trip was 2 weeks away, would they have been allowed to go? If no then fair enough. If yes then a refund should be given.

The punishment for the other child should also be comparable. Will they be banned from a future trip?

I've seen lovely kids lose it with someone as they'd said something vile to them to deliberately wind them up when they were down. Most kids will react if the right buttons are pushed. Adults too.

dapsnotplimsolls · 09/03/2024 19:44

The school certainly shouldn't expect to be out of pocket. I suggest your son has minimal birthday and Christmas presents or does a crapload of jobs around the house/garden to make up for it.

Henryhover · 09/03/2024 19:31

I understand that he's been wrong but so has that kid for bullying him!! They should both be punished and the school should have an anti bullying policy. I'd ask for the money back for the fact that the other kid hasn't been pulled up of bullying