Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Joiner charging £15 for invoice

187 replies

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 08:15

Had someone come out a couple of weeks ago to do a small job.

Quoted £55. Came and did it, all good.

Asked after if he needs my email for the invoice. Crickets.

2 weeks later he’s come back and said it’s £55 cash or £70 with an invoice. “Let me know which works best for you”

I think it’s bullshit. He obviously doesn’t want to declare his income (again, bullshit – pay your taxes) and if he wanted to charge £15 for an invoice he should have said so in advance.

OP posts:
ohdamnitjanet · 09/03/2024 11:12

Just pay him, £55 cash or £70 if you think he’s avoiding tax and you don’t agree with him doing that. What’s the problem?

Universalsnail · 09/03/2024 11:08

I would just pay cash unless you need the invoice for something. Not worth the drama.

If you need the invoice for something I'd point out that you know he's tax dodging and like whatever but your not paying extra so when he sends you his invoice you will send him the £55

I don't care he's offered a cash option but he should have offered that as the cheaper option in the first place.

MonopolyTrading · 09/03/2024 11:04

I couldn't get worked up over it. You managed to find a joiner that would come out to such a small job and didn't rip you off. Most won't come out for such little money.

Bearbookagainandagain · 09/03/2024 10:58

He isn't charging you £15 for an invoice, he is just adding the VAT which is totally normal. Most traders will give you a quote without VAT, it's better to double check with them.

If you pay cash he doesn't charge the VAT, and as he said it's up to you to decide.

GrainOfSalt · 09/03/2024 10:46

Some of these responses are bizarre. I had to have a gardener in to do a small job, we agreed 50 quid. Family friend for years. Offered bacs or cash on the day and he said bacs was easier for him. Had an invoice saying paid a week later. That's how you do business.

This guy is screwing the system and the twat put in writing. Why are so many people happy to give him a pass?

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 10:44

Jk8 · 09/03/2024 10:32

Surely you could have just sent the money & asked for a receipt???? Why do you need an invoice to pay/why does anybody need an invoice to pay a personal expense ... ?

I get that your self employed so obviously have a differnt mind set around businesses but still it was a personal expense ?

Just pay the money - even if you report it/complain the money should have been paid on the day if you had it & a invoice if you wanted it should have been requested first & seems very pedantic for what will ultimately be you just paying him £55 for work he's already done & obviously moved onto other jobs

I have not delayed payment!

As soon as the work was done I asked if he needed my email for the invoice – not thinking anything of it. I always pay immediately.

He just didn’t reply, and has popped up 2 weeks later for a new price if I want evidence of the work done or to use bank transfer

OP posts:
snoopyfanaccountant · 09/03/2024 10:33

SerendipityJane · 09/03/2024 09:38

You can be paid by BACS or PayPal or whatever and still not declare it as income

You can do whatever you like - HMRC (and now DWP) will know. Although whether they have the capacity, competence and political will to do anything is another matter.

A house a few doors down had there roof done recently. The roofer wanted cash which neighbour drew from their bank. Who asked what it was for and recorded the details of the roofer. Not sure if that's a new initiative, something to do with looking after more vulnerable customers (as is neighbour). But either way it makes for an interesting future.

Banks are definitely more wary of allowing large cash withdrawals and bank transfers. I replaced my car last year and needed to transfer the funds between my own accounts. The funds were in a recently opened savings account (it was an inheritance) so I had to find a bank branch to do the transfer. The branch had to put me onto their fraud department who asked me what the money was for, the reg number of the car, its make and model and colour.

Jk8 · 09/03/2024 10:32

Surely you could have just sent the money & asked for a receipt???? Why do you need an invoice to pay/why does anybody need an invoice to pay a personal expense ... ?

I get that your self employed so obviously have a differnt mind set around businesses but still it was a personal expense ?

Just pay the money - even if you report it/complain the money should have been paid on the day if you had it & a invoice if you wanted it should have been requested first & seems very pedantic for what will ultimately be you just paying him £55 for work he's already done & obviously moved onto other jobs

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 09/03/2024 10:24

I won't pay cash for anything like that.

I want my invoice for proof the work was done and for a paper trail if thr job was done poorly and needs repair.

Get quotes in writing to prevent it happening again.

cakeorwine · 09/03/2024 10:10

It's tax dodging.
Not VAT - unless he meets the threshold.
I'd pay £70 and then report to HMRC. HMRC are busy but tax dodging, cash in hand does cost the UK money.

BobbyBiscuits · 09/03/2024 10:09

It seems a bit shifty on his part, he could have just said pay me in cash, I prefer it. A lot of them do say that, but most invoice if they are an actual Ltd Co.
I'd say cash is fine. Unless you want to pay more?
Just don't use him again I guess. £55 doesn't sound much for a tradesman to come and do joinery, even if a small job.

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 10:04

CranfordScones · 09/03/2024 09:47

Neither of you is acting with distinction. He's probably not registered for VAT (all legal and fine) but wasn't going to put it through the books if you paid cash (sketchy, but common).

He quoted you a price and did the work, and you should have paid him there and then.

I did want to pay him there and then – we were in touch by text, I told him I wasn’t going to be there in person, as soon as he said the job was done, I asked if he needed my email to send the invoice, as this is what every other tradesperson has done.

He didn’t ask for cash – he just didn’t reply and disappeared for 2 weeks. I have not delayed on paying. He literally texted like an hour ago with a new price if I want to pay by bank transfer / have an invoice/receipt.

I have not refused or delayed payment at any point.

OP posts:
clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 09:51

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 09/03/2024 08:21

I couldn't get excited about this personally. Often the only way these small businesses manage to survive is by doing a certain amount of cash in hand jobs. Remember millionaires manage to avoid paying huge sums of tax 'legally' whilst us PAYE idiots are paying every single penny.
It's a very small amount of money, just choose the £70 if you want to make sure he is paying all his tax

I run a small business (sole trader) my qualifications cost more, I charge substantially less per hour than the joiner, advertise my prices honestly, pay my taxes honestly (I quite like hospitals and public services) and make a very decent living.

Also no other tradesperson has asked me to pay cash in hand (from about 5 other jobs this year) so it’s not the norm.

There’s also a massive shortage of tradespeople and it’s really common for people to quote then just disappear, etc. because they feel like they can take or leave the work.

So I don’t think it’s a very strong argument to say cash in hand is essential to make ends meet

Also to add – I have not refused to pay or delayed paying. He’s literally just replied 2 weeks later with a new price.

OP posts:
CranfordScones · 09/03/2024 09:47

Neither of you is acting with distinction. He's probably not registered for VAT (all legal and fine) but wasn't going to put it through the books if you paid cash (sketchy, but common).

He quoted you a price and did the work, and you should have paid him there and then.

Meadowfinch · 09/03/2024 09:42

@AbbeFausseMaigre ' This isn't really about paying in literal cash. It's about whether the job is on the books and declared as income'

I realise that. But if paid into a bank, there is a paper trail. If the CMS do an investigation and can see hundreds of BACs transfers, the man concerned can't claim he doesn't have an income.

That's the whole point. That's why they always ask for cash.

SerendipityJane · 09/03/2024 09:38

You can be paid by BACS or PayPal or whatever and still not declare it as income

You can do whatever you like - HMRC (and now DWP) will know. Although whether they have the capacity, competence and political will to do anything is another matter.

A house a few doors down had there roof done recently. The roofer wanted cash which neighbour drew from their bank. Who asked what it was for and recorded the details of the roofer. Not sure if that's a new initiative, something to do with looking after more vulnerable customers (as is neighbour). But either way it makes for an interesting future.

anyolddinosaur · 09/03/2024 09:36

He could owe the bank money and not want it to disappear entirely into servicing a debt.

I'd have asked how he wanted to be paid before the job and bank details to pay online - but I always get quotes in writing.

AbbeFausseMaigre · 09/03/2024 09:33

Meadowfinch · 09/03/2024 09:12

Tell him you don't need an invoice and ask for his bank details, to do a BACs transfer.

This isn't really about paying in literal cash. It's about whether the job is on the books and declared as income (and everything that entails), or not. You can be paid by BACS or PayPal or whatever and still not declare it as income (although it would be more risky to hide large amounts of income paid this way).

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 09:29

SerendipityJane · 09/03/2024 09:26

Is it £55 cash or £55 without invoice ?

Just do a bank transfer or write a cheque.

Without an invoice how does any guarantee work ?

same difference I think? £55 cash, for an invoice (and I assume a receipt) it’s £70. I guess he won’t be interested in a bank transfer either

OP posts:
user1471505356 · 09/03/2024 09:28

This may be quite common an invoice means vat needs to be declared.

SerendipityJane · 09/03/2024 09:26

Is it £55 cash or £55 without invoice ?

Just do a bank transfer or write a cheque.

Without an invoice how does any guarantee work ?

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 09:26

sleepyscientist · 09/03/2024 09:13

Just give him the £50 cash and walk away from it. You know to ask up front in future. The £50 is going straight back into the economy anyway as it's cash so the government will have already got its cut of anything he is saving.

tbf I’m not even in the same city as this guy right now, so I couldn’t give him cash today even if I wanted to, but that is not really the issue – and obviously if we’d agreed cash I would ensure he had cash immediately on completion of the job!

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 09/03/2024 09:26

It's decades since a tradesman offered me a cash price. They nearly all want a proper transfer because they have mortgages and bills to pay like everyone else and need to run a business. Even my odd job man asks for a bank transfer rather than cash.

However @clothearedpotatohead you are unreasonable not to pay straight away and the joiner is unreasonable to charge you more than quoted for raising an invoice. I'd just suck up the invoice and pay £70. You've made your point and £15 isn't worth the hassle.

If his work was good, the one thing that's guaranteed is that he won't be doing any more work for you or recommending any of his reliable tradesman mates.

I hope you offered him a cup of tea.

People who won't work more than 16 hours when work's available, because it impacts their UC (state benefit money) piss me off far more than tradesmen nickle and diming the revenue.

paintingvenice · 09/03/2024 09:22

Herdinggoats · 09/03/2024 09:20

Pay the £70 and then send his message and invoice onto HMRC https://www.gov.uk/report-tax-fraud 🤷🏻‍♀️

Serve him right for being so stupid as to put it in writing 😅

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 09:21

solongandthanksforallthedish · 09/03/2024 09:13

By paying "cash", or rather by allowing this to be black market, you're potentially dodging VAT, his income tax, NI etc, enabling him to obtain benefits he isn't really entitled to, AND potentially robbing his children of child maintenance.

This is anti-social behaviour.

Don't kid yourself, PP, that "everyone does it"- decent people don't. PAYE people pay their tax, child maintenance, etc. They don't claim universal credit unless they're entitled to it. They pay child maintenance. What makes this joiner so special he's exempt, and can take undeclared income?

Thank you, I agree!

I’ve had to arrange for loads of different bits of work done recently, ranging from 1 hour jobs to large jobs in the 1000s. And everyone else has just quoted, done the work as arranged, popped over an invoice and I’ve paid immediately. No fuss.

I need a record and receipts for all the work done.

Why is it suddenly my problem that he doesn’t want to declare his income. If he’d just quoted £70 in the first place I could take it or leave it – he secured the job based on the price he offered.

I think Amazon not paying taxes is bullshit, I think Rishi Sunak and Jimmy Carr not paying taxes is bullshit, and I think the joiner not paying taxes is bullshit.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread