Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Joiner charging £15 for invoice

187 replies

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 08:15

Had someone come out a couple of weeks ago to do a small job.

Quoted £55. Came and did it, all good.

Asked after if he needs my email for the invoice. Crickets.

2 weeks later he’s come back and said it’s £55 cash or £70 with an invoice. “Let me know which works best for you”

I think it’s bullshit. He obviously doesn’t want to declare his income (again, bullshit – pay your taxes) and if he wanted to charge £15 for an invoice he should have said so in advance.

OP posts:
taxguru · 09/03/2024 19:14

Itloggedmeoutagain · 09/03/2024 18:32

Paying by cash is not illegal.
Not declaring it is another matter.
I'm self employed.
I accept BACS and cash whatever is easier for the client.
I have a mix of both.
I declare it all.

Do you offer a 20% reduction for "nudge nudge wink wink" cash??

No, I thought not!

Magnastorm · 09/03/2024 19:07

I would not pay a tradesman without some sort of paper trail - a written invoice stating what work was carried out and for how much. OP not unreasonable at all to request one and ANY decent tradesman would provide one.

Once paid I would then expect a receipt to prove that I had actually paid, by whatever means that was.

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 19:04

Createausername1970 · 09/03/2024 18:51

My immediate reaction was its two weeks later, you haven't paid him, so he is giving you fair warning that if you don't pay up, he will invoice you and you will be paying for his extra time to chase a payment that should have been paid already.

It's nothing to do with VAT, it interest on late payment and wasting his chargeable time

Just pay what you owe FFS.

LOL 🤦🏻

I hadn’t paid him because when I asked him about payment (immediately after the job) he didn’t reply to my message for 2 weeks. He didn’t ask for cash or indeed any payment at all – I initiated the conversation about payment. He didn’t reply.

He hasn’t had to chase anything.

Interest on late payment 😂 You literally haven’t even read the OP or any of the numerous follow ups stating really clearly what has happened

OP posts:
CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 09/03/2024 18:59

Createausername1970 · 09/03/2024 18:51

My immediate reaction was its two weeks later, you haven't paid him, so he is giving you fair warning that if you don't pay up, he will invoice you and you will be paying for his extra time to chase a payment that should have been paid already.

It's nothing to do with VAT, it interest on late payment and wasting his chargeable time

Just pay what you owe FFS.

Have you read the OP's posts? She wasn't there on the day (which the guy knew in advance and was fine with) so couldn't give cash. She emailed asking for the invoice, which would have included the bank details she needed, and he took 2 weeks to get back to her.

How could she have paid earlier?

Createausername1970 · 09/03/2024 18:51

My immediate reaction was its two weeks later, you haven't paid him, so he is giving you fair warning that if you don't pay up, he will invoice you and you will be paying for his extra time to chase a payment that should have been paid already.

It's nothing to do with VAT, it interest on late payment and wasting his chargeable time

Just pay what you owe FFS.

Thisisnotarehearsal · 09/03/2024 18:47

AbbeFausseMaigre · 09/03/2024 08:41

I would never use a tradesperson who even suggested a cash price. They are telling you who they are right there i.e. someone who is happy to lie.

And don't forget that is isn't just about avoiding paying taxes to the evil, faceless HMRC. Not declaring income enables parents fathers to avoid paying CMS, as anyone who regularly reads MN knows only to well.

Quite.

It always astonishes me that Mumsnetters will rail against lack of spending on services, but on the other hand are quite happy to see trades people steal money from the Treasury and hence these very services. White van man costs this country a fortune.

And there's always some wazzock who tries to make paying out paying tradies the second they finish is somehow moral. I used to work in construction and you should NEVER pay immediately. You've got no leverage if something goes wrong. Most of the time it's difficult to get them back even if you are holding a percentage retention. It's hardly worth their while, so they certainly aren't coming back if you've paid in full.

Decent tradespeople aren't scraping by. If they've got a good reputation, they never go short of work.

Nw22 · 09/03/2024 18:45

I can’t believe so many peopel are defending tax evasion. No wonder public services are so bad if so many peopel think it’s ok to not pay tax

Nevermindtheteacaps · 09/03/2024 18:45

taxguru · 09/03/2024 08:33

Illegal tax evasion costs the country tens of billions of pounds in evaded tax, and VAT evasion is a large component of that, by small businesses/tradesmen illegally not charging VAT when they are required to do, typically by accepting cash payments that don't go through their books. Not only are they evading VAT, they're also evading income tax and NIC, and many may also be illegally claiming more benefits than they're entitled to because of underdeclared income. It's a massive, growing problem. For £55/£70 it doesn't sound too bad, but if this guy is doing that every day for "small jobs", it soon mounts up to hundreds and thousands evaded in tax each year for just one person. Trouble is it becomes "the norm" and he'll start doing it for bigger jobs too. I had a car repaired after an accident and was openly quoted "£1800 but £1500 for cash vat free", and a few months earlier offered scaffolding for our house (all sides) for "£2,400 or £2,000 cash without VAT". It's endemic now, and often for far more than the odd tenner here and there.

Give over. It's tax evasion by billionaires that's costs us, not by people just trying to scrape by under the sociopathic government who enable their billionaire tax dodging friends

Mumma2024 · 09/03/2024 18:38

On jobs for less than a £100 I always offer cash. Life is tough for small businesses

Itloggedmeoutagain · 09/03/2024 18:32

Jaxhog · 09/03/2024 12:07

Exactly. While it might seem 'nice' to do a cash payment, it IS illegal. Also remember, that if people don't pay the tax they are supposed to, whoever they are, WE will end up paying more instead.

Paying by cash is not illegal.
Not declaring it is another matter.
I'm self employed.
I accept BACS and cash whatever is easier for the client.
I have a mix of both.
I declare it all.

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 18:11

Scarletttulips · 09/03/2024 08:28

If he is claiming the extra is for 'VAT' then he is a CF as 20% of £55 is £11 not £15

Plus the time for writing the receipt. And that’s cheap considering he’s having to chase for payment m.

He’s not having to chase for payment!

I wanted to pay him immediately but he didn’t reply for 2 weeks

OP posts:
HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 17:26

tigerpyjamas · 09/03/2024 17:13

But in this instance the trader is no better of worse off whether you pay cash in hand or £70 on record. It is either the tax man wins or you do!

He is in the long term, though, as he will probably get a lot more work than honest traders who include/make allowance for tax and/or VAT in their quoted prices and thus look significantly more expensive than he is for the same thing

He only quoted the £55 initially, with no mention of VAT/tax and a higher price to legally include it, so he was obviously expecting to undercut his honest competitors from the start.

Morals aside, it might have been different if he'd given OP the two different price 'options' from the start, so they both knew where they stood. Indeed, if OP were dishonest, she could have taken the £55 as the legitimate baseline price, all-in, and then asked him to accept £45 for cash, to avoid the taxman, without realising he'd already allowed for it!

tigerpyjamas · 09/03/2024 17:13

But in this instance the trader is no better of worse off whether you pay cash in hand or £70 on record. It is either the tax man wins or you do!

HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 17:05

Picklestop · 09/03/2024 15:03

A big business probably won’t care about whether VAT is included or not as they are going to be VAT registered themselves and therefore it makes no difference to them.

They will if they're led to believe that the quoted price already includes VAT, so they've budgeted less as a total cos to them.

And they'll definitely not be happy if the tradesperson isn't VAT registered but has still tried to charge them an extra 20% for spurious 'VAT' that obviously cannot be claimed back.

Picklestop · 09/03/2024 15:03

HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 14:34

To be a pedant, only in a consumer setting. Business to business and commercial quotes may exclude VAT.

True, but a great many sole-traders and small businesses who almost exclusively deal with individual consumers do regularly rely on pulling the VAT hoodwink.

Call me a cynic, but if anything, I'm guessing that companies that do work for businesses are probably much more diligent at making clear upfront whether extra VAT is due or not - as they know the big businesses won't just shut up and pay it when it was deliberately skated over and not stated/included in the first place, in the way that Hilda in Cheam who's just had her gutters cleaned out might not feel able to question them or object.

We already know that a great many dishonest tradies will charge as much as they think they can get from the customer - especially if they are elderly or perceived as vulnerable - without any relation to the true cost of the work.

A big business probably won’t care about whether VAT is included or not as they are going to be VAT registered themselves and therefore it makes no difference to them.

HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 14:34

To be a pedant, only in a consumer setting. Business to business and commercial quotes may exclude VAT.

True, but a great many sole-traders and small businesses who almost exclusively deal with individual consumers do regularly rely on pulling the VAT hoodwink.

Call me a cynic, but if anything, I'm guessing that companies that do work for businesses are probably much more diligent at making clear upfront whether extra VAT is due or not - as they know the big businesses won't just shut up and pay it when it was deliberately skated over and not stated/included in the first place, in the way that Hilda in Cheam who's just had her gutters cleaned out might not feel able to question them or object.

We already know that a great many dishonest tradies will charge as much as they think they can get from the customer - especially if they are elderly or perceived as vulnerable - without any relation to the true cost of the work.

skyeisthelimit · 09/03/2024 14:29

If he is vat registered then he is adding on more than the vat. Vat of £15 would be on a £75 job not £55.

He is clearly not wanting to declare the income.

He is very wrong to quote a price for the job then add on more when you want an invoice.

I would report him to trading standards and HMRC. How many other people is he ripping off? What if this was someone elderly or vulnerable?

cakeorwine · 09/03/2024 14:28

Itloggedmeoutagain · 09/03/2024 14:26

If i didn't need an invoice for my own tax i would have just asked for bank details and done a transfer

I wonder if he has a business bank account or if it's all one account?

Of course, he may not even use an accountant and just declares his income. So no one actually checks the receipts, invoices and matches up payments to work done.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 09/03/2024 14:26

If i didn't need an invoice for my own tax i would have just asked for bank details and done a transfer

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 14:23

SerendipityJane · 09/03/2024 14:14

If you are quoted a price for goods or services, it is by default VAT-inclusive unless specified otherwise.

To be a pedant, only in a consumer setting. Business to business and commercial quotes may exclude VAT.

I realise I may have been a bit harsh on Joe Soap about understanding VAT. After all, Gordon Brown forgot to include VAT when he priced the 2012 Olympics up. We've all done it.

That’s why it doesn’t make any sense to quote a non-VAT price to an individual for a job on a residential property.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 09/03/2024 14:20

SerendipityJane · 09/03/2024 14:14

If you are quoted a price for goods or services, it is by default VAT-inclusive unless specified otherwise.

To be a pedant, only in a consumer setting. Business to business and commercial quotes may exclude VAT.

I realise I may have been a bit harsh on Joe Soap about understanding VAT. After all, Gordon Brown forgot to include VAT when he priced the 2012 Olympics up. We've all done it.

That was in my old job - when I was given my first real budget, I had to ask clearly - does that include or exclude VAT

That seemed to be a hard question for them to answer

SerendipityJane · 09/03/2024 14:14

If you are quoted a price for goods or services, it is by default VAT-inclusive unless specified otherwise.

To be a pedant, only in a consumer setting. Business to business and commercial quotes may exclude VAT.

I realise I may have been a bit harsh on Joe Soap about understanding VAT. After all, Gordon Brown forgot to include VAT when he priced the 2012 Olympics up. We've all done it.

HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 14:08

Also, I understand that tradespeople like to be paid immediately on completing the work - who wouldn't? - but even people working PT on NMW have to wait until the end of the month to receive their pay, so I don't see why tradies should feel entitled to immediate settlement.

It makes me think of occupations like waiters/waitresses, taxi-drivers, hairdressers and others who widely get/expect tips - with people justifying that they 'need' them to survive as they are so low-paid - but nobody has an answer as to how cleaners, care workers, McDonalds workers, Amazon delivery drivers etc. are expected to be able to survive without having their pay boosted by regular tips.

HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 14:03

Often the only way these small businesses manage to survive is by doing a certain amount of cash in hand jobs. Remember millionaires manage to avoid paying huge sums of tax 'legally' whilst us PAYE idiots are paying every single penny.

The tax-avoiding millionaires, whilst infuriating, are a complete red herring. The fact that some people commit murder doesn't make it perfectly fine for you to go around 'just' punching people in the face. Lots of people earn low incomes but still pay their taxes (if they earn over the tax-free threshold).

Like any business, if you can't survive on the prices that you're charging customers, you need to increase your prices. It's not like people will suddenly stop needing tradespeople and you'll go out of business.

I also wonder how many of these businesses are below the threshold to be VAT registered, but still regularly try it on to get an extra 20% themselves on the pretext of (non-due) VAT. Either way, I think it's disgusting to give somebody a price, with no mention of VAT, and then spring it on them after you've done the work. Just because it's money that you have to hand straight to the government, it's still part of the price that your customer has to factor into the cost of the work, before deciding whether to go ahead.

Like with estate agents, there are lots of very honest, diligent, law-abiding tradies out there; but the many dishonest ones bring shade on the whole profession.

Knackeredandalsotired · 09/03/2024 14:00

If you are quoted a price for goods or services, it is by default VAT-inclusive unless specified otherwise.

so if he didn’t tell you £55+VAT then he doesn’t have a leg to stand on. He cannot just add on a figure for VAT. It is up to him to account to HMRC for the VAT from the £55 he gets from you.

Do not pay him more, no matter what method you pay by!

Swipe left for the next trending thread