Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Joiner charging £15 for invoice

187 replies

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 08:15

Had someone come out a couple of weeks ago to do a small job.

Quoted £55. Came and did it, all good.

Asked after if he needs my email for the invoice. Crickets.

2 weeks later he’s come back and said it’s £55 cash or £70 with an invoice. “Let me know which works best for you”

I think it’s bullshit. He obviously doesn’t want to declare his income (again, bullshit – pay your taxes) and if he wanted to charge £15 for an invoice he should have said so in advance.

OP posts:
clothearedpotatohead · 10/03/2024 08:26

MonopolyTrading · 10/03/2024 07:50

I agree it's really easy.

OP was saying there is a shortage of decent tradespeople. That's because people aren't willing to pay these days. They all say but tax dodger down the road can do it for £55. Its not worth the drama of a 6 page mumsnet thread.

Disagree completely.

I had some plastering work done recently. I went with the people who quoted £400 more than the other guy, because they seemed more professional.

There is very good money in trades. There are lots of reasons for the shortage (I happened to write a report for someone in this area recently so had cause to research it), poor pay is not what’s driving it.

OP posts:
MonopolyTrading · 10/03/2024 07:50

cakeorwine · 10/03/2024 06:58

Invoicing is really easy nowadays. There are many tools avail;able.

I guess you've seen the advert for Quikbooks Details go in, email out, invoice paid and your accounts are also done.

Of course, if you don't bother with keeping accounts and paying taxes, that could be a problem for you.

But it's not difficult

I agree it's really easy.

OP was saying there is a shortage of decent tradespeople. That's because people aren't willing to pay these days. They all say but tax dodger down the road can do it for £55. Its not worth the drama of a 6 page mumsnet thread.

Ihearditfrommyradio · 10/03/2024 07:15

Trades people that are tax dodgers are showing you they are dishonest.

I assume you wouldn't get a receipt for work if there was a fault shortly after.

I know a couple that paid for a huge building job in cash - so much money they quite rightly got the third degree from the bank before withdrawing - just to get a discount. They had absolutely no paperwork to protect them if anything went wrong.

cakeorwine · 10/03/2024 06:58

MonopolyTrading · 09/03/2024 23:59

I meant the reason there is a huge demand like you said in your previous post. The reliable, professional tradespeople who can handle the organisational side as well as the practical are still there. They are just no longer willing to work for the likes of you.

Edited

Invoicing is really easy nowadays. There are many tools avail;able.

I guess you've seen the advert for Quikbooks Details go in, email out, invoice paid and your accounts are also done.

Of course, if you don't bother with keeping accounts and paying taxes, that could be a problem for you.

But it's not difficult

MonopolyTrading · 09/03/2024 23:59

I meant the reason there is a huge demand like you said in your previous post. The reliable, professional tradespeople who can handle the organisational side as well as the practical are still there. They are just no longer willing to work for the likes of you.

ThisHonestQuail · 09/03/2024 23:55

Tbh if I knew in advance that a job was only going to cost £55 I’d just give cash on the day, or ask for bank details on the day. I def wouldn’t be asking for an invoice for such a small thing 😅

blacksax · 09/03/2024 23:49

Tax evasion is a crime. Businesses and traders dodging their VAT should be sent to prison for fraud.

For all those saying 'who cares?', where do you think the government gets its money from to pay for things like the NHS, pensions, the armed forces and education?

Tax dodgers like this aren't just defrauding HMRC, they are defrauding YOU.

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 23:49

MonopolyTrading · 09/03/2024 23:47

The issue is that you're not willing to pay professional wages. £70 to come out to you to quote the job, do the job, pay for materials and invoice you. Others aren't willing to pay either. This why most decent qualified tradesman no longer bother quoting the small jobs because they're a pain in the ass for peanuts. So you're left with the tax dodging unqualified handy men.

Nope, that’s not the issue.

OP posts:
MonopolyTrading · 09/03/2024 23:47

The issue is that you're not willing to pay professional wages. £70 to come out to you to quote the job, do the job, pay for materials and invoice you. Others aren't willing to pay either. This why most decent qualified tradesman no longer bother quoting the small jobs because they're a pain in the ass for peanuts. So you're left with the tax dodging unqualified handy men.

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 23:40

QueenCamilla · 09/03/2024 13:06

If there weren't any issues with the tradie and his work then I'd happily pay his preferred way - whether someone declares all of their income is the least of the problems with the building trade these days. I don't think it's worth making a stance over such a small job.

I've actually taken to offering cash bonuses for workers if a job is started and completed within agreed timescales and to budget. I paid £300 cash on top of a 1.5k job (on the books) and it's the first time in a loooong time that the tradesmen were there on the agreed day, finished on time and exactly per quote. Cash is king.

That’s fucking awful (that that’s the first time any of the above has happened).

Hopefully more people will cotton on that there’s huge demand for reliable, professional tradespeople who can handle the organisational side as well as the practical. You’d clean up.

OP posts:
MonopolyTrading · 09/03/2024 23:32

I declare all of my income as does tradesman DH. But I do think you're cutting off your nose to spite your face. Small cheap job that you're presumably happy with. Tradesman willing to come out for such small jobs are incredibly rare. Good luck with that.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 09/03/2024 23:28

taxguru · 09/03/2024 19:14

Do you offer a 20% reduction for "nudge nudge wink wink" cash??

No, I thought not!

No i don't
But my post was aimed at the person who said paying in cash was illegal.

redalex261 · 09/03/2024 21:00

The “admin” costs of issuing an invoice (next to nothing) should be built in to the price. If a tradesman wanted cash on the day I would expect them to say when quoting/arranging date so i had money ready but would much rather pay by bank transfer. Would never pay anything significant in cash like roof repair - need to have some proof of what they’ve done in case of a botch.

Taxguru upthread is right - everyone thinks this small scale tax evasion is ok but it’s not. Costs public purse a fortune in revenue needed for essential services. Allows those doing it to avoid their responsibilities like CMS, PAYE and national insurance. Do you think someone working like that has liability insurance? Not a chance. Paying their own NICs or pension contributions? Nope. Some of them will be claiming in-work benefits like tax credit based on vastly under reported earnings. Many will employ others on a cash in hand basis, with no employers’ liability insurance.

What they often do is spend every penny they get during their working life. Reach state pension age with hardly any contributions and no private pension. Claim means tested top ups till they die. They contribute fuck all and take anything they can get off the state.

So when your car/kid/granny is struck by a roof tile dropped by your uninsured cash-in-hand workman tough luck.

caringcarer · 09/03/2024 20:35

Always ask for a written quotation.

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 20:32

SkankingWombat · 09/03/2024 20:12

It's not right, and I don't do it myself (I'm SE, everything goes through my books, and cash is a PITA for me as it necessitates a trip to the bank so I can use it to pay my bills), but I am more comfortable with the cash-in-hand people than the billionaire tax avoidance lot. The former's cash will go straight back into the local economy, whilst the latter's will sit hoarded and unused in offshore accounts.

OP, you aren't wrong, as you are entitled to an invoice if you want one, but are an anomaly as a trade person's customer. I have a trade. Most customers send me a text after the job to thank me and ask for my bank details, although some will do this verbally on my way out or pay cash before I go. They may ask for clarification or a reminder of the cost in case things have changed from the original quote (rare it has, and from my part this has always been clear at the time of doing the work, but it's always appreciated customers ask rather than assume I do all the extra out of goodwill). I send my details and am paid 90% of the time within 12hrs, as terms are payment upon completion. I write maybe 3 invoices a year. Usually it's only when I've worked for a business or landlord, but possibly one a year is a regular householder. I have never had it requested for such a small job where is it a personal expense in 18 years of self-employment.
For a small £50 job, as a SE person whose admin time is limited and who has essentially already formed an audit trail with text messages and a bank transfer, I would provide an invoice but not rush to return to work for you, as it isn't worth the extra work (particularly as I have often already come out to look at and quote the job for free). I would be much happier if I could justify charging an extra £15 for providing the invoice, as it accurately reflects the additional work of writing and delivering it (I do so few, mine are still paper-based), but as I don't charge extra for them, I would either avoid you in future, or build a 'PITA cost' into any future quotes.
Were the original communications by text? If so, I'd just pay the £55 by bank transfer and be done with it.

I get it, I’m self-employed!

Admin costs me time.

I would be happy with bank transfer but he wants cash. I just asked for the invoice as every other tradesperson I’ve used in the last 3 years has always wanted to send me an invoice, so I just offered my email for the invoice and payment details without thinking too much about it.

Besides the fact I don’t support tax dodgers (or those avoiding child maintenance), I also just don’t like the way he’s gone about things.

I wouldn’t be in a hurry to call him again so it’s no worries if he feels the same!

OP posts:
SkankingWombat · 09/03/2024 20:12

taxguru · 09/03/2024 19:17

Black economy tax evasion (that's "normal" people) could cost the country up to £40 BILLION yearly according to some reports.

It's not right, and I don't do it myself (I'm SE, everything goes through my books, and cash is a PITA for me as it necessitates a trip to the bank so I can use it to pay my bills), but I am more comfortable with the cash-in-hand people than the billionaire tax avoidance lot. The former's cash will go straight back into the local economy, whilst the latter's will sit hoarded and unused in offshore accounts.

OP, you aren't wrong, as you are entitled to an invoice if you want one, but are an anomaly as a trade person's customer. I have a trade. Most customers send me a text after the job to thank me and ask for my bank details, although some will do this verbally on my way out or pay cash before I go. They may ask for clarification or a reminder of the cost in case things have changed from the original quote (rare it has, and from my part this has always been clear at the time of doing the work, but it's always appreciated customers ask rather than assume I do all the extra out of goodwill). I send my details and am paid 90% of the time within 12hrs, as terms are payment upon completion. I write maybe 3 invoices a year. Usually it's only when I've worked for a business or landlord, but possibly one a year is a regular householder. I have never had it requested for such a small job where is it a personal expense in 18 years of self-employment.
For a small £50 job, as a SE person whose admin time is limited and who has essentially already formed an audit trail with text messages and a bank transfer, I would provide an invoice but not rush to return to work for you, as it isn't worth the extra work (particularly as I have often already come out to look at and quote the job for free). I would be much happier if I could justify charging an extra £15 for providing the invoice, as it accurately reflects the additional work of writing and delivering it (I do so few, mine are still paper-based), but as I don't charge extra for them, I would either avoid you in future, or build a 'PITA cost' into any future quotes.
Were the original communications by text? If so, I'd just pay the £55 by bank transfer and be done with it.

OooohHowIMissThe90s · 09/03/2024 20:01

I'm in the process of divorcing a guy who went from being an employed electrician to being self employed. It's all come out in the divorce that he was likely doing a lot of cash in hand jobs, because his declared income isn't anything like expected or what he was clearly earning.

Obviously in my situation this affects just me. We didn't have kids together. But it makes you wonder how many of these cash in hand guys are wriggling out of paying fair child maintenance.

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 19:40

HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 19:30

Billionaires aside, I'm amazed at the number of people on here - many of whom are themselves presumably not stinking rich and are 'average' earners, losing a large chunk of their income in taxes - are trying to make excuses for busy, well-earning tradesmen seeking to keep all of their income. They aren't little kiddies trying to get a few more sweeties with their pocket money.

Quite! Especially when people get in such a froth about benefits claimants – which is tiddling by comparison in terms of the burden on taxpayers.

OP posts:
HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 19:30

Billionaires aside, I'm amazed at the number of people on here - many of whom are themselves presumably not stinking rich and are 'average' earners, losing a large chunk of their income in taxes - are trying to make excuses for busy, well-earning tradesmen seeking to keep all of their income. They aren't little kiddies trying to get a few more sweeties with their pocket money.

Reugny · 09/03/2024 19:28

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 19:22

That’s not what’s going on here (although appreciate it might be relevant in some cases) – he literally said if he invoices it he puts it through his accounts (ie records it) and that’s why it’s more

If he has been stupid enough to send you this information by SMS or email then he has left a paper trail.

I have spoken to a couple of trades and they use SMS and email as a paper trail to deal with non-paying customers.

Though at the moment he's unlikely to be dealt with by HMRC as they don't have enough staff.

HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 19:26

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 19:22

That’s not what’s going on here (although appreciate it might be relevant in some cases) – he literally said if he invoices it he puts it through his accounts (ie records it) and that’s why it’s more

No, absolutely not - your 'chummy' here is definitely dishonest and trying to fiddle his income - whether to be able to offer more competitive illegally-low prices or avoid income tax, VAT, child maintenance and/or anything else.

I (with others) was just responding to the suggestion from PP that anybody who asks for payment in cash is clearly on the fiddle, when this is not always the case.

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 19:22

HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 19:20

Yes, indeed. Whilst a lot of people do specifically ask for cash so that they can avoid paying their fair taxes, a great many just prefer the flexibility of cash.

Also, if you're a sole trader/small business holder, with your income (after costs and taxes) being effectively your wages, you can perfectly legitimately and legally avoid paying earned cash into your business bank account and then withdrawing it again, and thus avoid unnecessary business transaction charges. All entirely above board, as long as you declare all your earnings to the taxman.

This why some honest traders/small businesses prefer cash and may give a (small) discount for cash: to save paying bank and card transaction charges.

That’s not what’s going on here (although appreciate it might be relevant in some cases) – he literally said if he invoices it he puts it through his accounts (ie records it) and that’s why it’s more

OP posts:
HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 19:22

It's also a very good point made upthread that, without paperwork, not only do you have no guarantee or comeback for faulty work, but the trader could very easily point-blank deny that he's ever met you, let alone done work for you.

HoneyWogan · 09/03/2024 19:20

Itloggedmeoutagain · 09/03/2024 18:32

Paying by cash is not illegal.
Not declaring it is another matter.
I'm self employed.
I accept BACS and cash whatever is easier for the client.
I have a mix of both.
I declare it all.

Yes, indeed. Whilst a lot of people do specifically ask for cash so that they can avoid paying their fair taxes, a great many just prefer the flexibility of cash.

Also, if you're a sole trader/small business holder, with your income (after costs and taxes) being effectively your wages, you can perfectly legitimately and legally avoid paying earned cash into your business bank account and then withdrawing it again, and thus avoid unnecessary business transaction charges. All entirely above board, as long as you declare all your earnings to the taxman.

This why some honest traders/small businesses prefer cash and may give a (small) discount for cash: to save paying bank and card transaction charges.

taxguru · 09/03/2024 19:17

Nevermindtheteacaps · 09/03/2024 18:45

Give over. It's tax evasion by billionaires that's costs us, not by people just trying to scrape by under the sociopathic government who enable their billionaire tax dodging friends

Black economy tax evasion (that's "normal" people) could cost the country up to £40 BILLION yearly according to some reports.