Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Joiner charging £15 for invoice

187 replies

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 08:15

Had someone come out a couple of weeks ago to do a small job.

Quoted £55. Came and did it, all good.

Asked after if he needs my email for the invoice. Crickets.

2 weeks later he’s come back and said it’s £55 cash or £70 with an invoice. “Let me know which works best for you”

I think it’s bullshit. He obviously doesn’t want to declare his income (again, bullshit – pay your taxes) and if he wanted to charge £15 for an invoice he should have said so in advance.

OP posts:
HoneyWogan · 11/03/2024 17:08

Missamyp · 11/03/2024 14:37

What on earth did he do for £55. Fit a door hinge.
The issue is he's obviously had, is customers asking for a discount for cash.
Now he's made the mistake of assuming offering that to all customers and in your case threatening to remove whatever work he has done.
All rather unsavoury.

Quite possibly, but it's clearly his choice to run his business that way.

All he has to do when giving a quote and/or if asked about payment methods or terms, all he has to say is "I would do the job as agreed for £X and I ask for payment on completion. I accept either cash or bank transfer, whichever is easier for you; it makes no difference to me, everything goes through the books."

That's a very clear, straightforward way of telling people that he's honest and that there will be no 'discounts for cash' - and then any dishonest customers can know in advance and accept or decline it, according to their circumstances and morals.

HoneyWogan · 11/03/2024 17:01

clothearedpotatohead · 11/03/2024 14:22

The funny thing is that just before this he wrote something along the lines of believing me to be at fault for not asking his preferred payment method in advance.

The ‘at fault’ got me – which system is he working to?! 🤦🏻😆

He also complained I had not asked the person who put me in touch with him (another tradesperson) about payment method, despite the fact they’re separate businesses, and he and I spoke directly on the phone to arrange the job, and I mean – who is the other guy? His Dad?

Anyway, hopefully that is the last of him!

Hmmm, I'm guessing he isn't one of those tradespeople who expects to get endless repeat business and numerous recommendations from delighted customers...

SummerFeverVenice · 11/03/2024 16:57

I usually just pay by bank transfer, most small trades are well below the VAT threshold. My window washer, he comes by and I transfer £30 when he’s done the windows. I dont see the point of a formal invoice for £55 job? You can’t avoid income tax if the money is going by bank transfer, HMRC can look into all our bank accounts,

Missamyp · 11/03/2024 16:23

clothearedpotatohead · 11/03/2024 15:11

What on earth did he do for £55. Fit a door hinge.

Something along those lines – v small job. Took well under an hour.

Find it interesting as well the few posts upthread talking about there being not enough money in trades, no one wanting to pay a fair amount, how can someone make ends meet and pay tax if they’re only charging £55 (or whatever) an hour.

But there are so many self-employed occupations where many people charge way less per hour – psychotherapists (start at £45), PTs (starting at £30, which in my opinion is too low), massage therapists, translators, graphic designers, physiotherapists, driving instructors (most where I am charge around £34, which also covers petrol and vehicle maintenance costs).

£55 for less than an hour’s work (and that’s a service charge, not a wage – it takes into account unpaid hours and the costs of running a business) is decent.

I should also make really clear here that I’ve happily paid more than £55 for other similar small jobs when it’s been agreed at the outset, and recently opted for someone charging £400 more for a 2-day job than a competitor because they were more professional – so is not a case of wanting to pay anyone less.

Just don’t understand the disproportionate concern for tradespeople and the misapprehension that they can’t catch a break.

Dp runs a business related to a trade his charges are £120 hr plus vat-daily rate is £550 plus vat. Plus mark up on all materials.
Payment terms are on the digital quote/estimate-invoice. Smaller call outs are immediate payment-invoices are issued digitally in front of the customer. Payment is taken via a card machine.
Although his business turnover £500,000 a year.

What people fail to comprehend is the costs of running a business.
Most employed trades are on anywhere from £15 per hr upwards with brand new vehicle- fully fueled and all power tools supplied.
All administration is done by the business, re admin and finance depts.
So taking that into consideration £55 per hr is very low for a business sector that has very high fixed and variable costs.
Dp does wish that trades weren't an option for the non-academics and that the courses for technical trades were uprated to minimum diploma with a business module included.
This would cut out the rogues and raise the profile and image of trades.

GasPanic · 11/03/2024 16:18

Depends whether he did a good job and was good value for money or not and I wanted to use him in the future.

Getting decent trades in these days is hard work, so I wouldn't mess around with that sort of money.

MonopolyTrading · 11/03/2024 16:14

clothearedpotatohead · 11/03/2024 15:11

What on earth did he do for £55. Fit a door hinge.

Something along those lines – v small job. Took well under an hour.

Find it interesting as well the few posts upthread talking about there being not enough money in trades, no one wanting to pay a fair amount, how can someone make ends meet and pay tax if they’re only charging £55 (or whatever) an hour.

But there are so many self-employed occupations where many people charge way less per hour – psychotherapists (start at £45), PTs (starting at £30, which in my opinion is too low), massage therapists, translators, graphic designers, physiotherapists, driving instructors (most where I am charge around £34, which also covers petrol and vehicle maintenance costs).

£55 for less than an hour’s work (and that’s a service charge, not a wage – it takes into account unpaid hours and the costs of running a business) is decent.

I should also make really clear here that I’ve happily paid more than £55 for other similar small jobs when it’s been agreed at the outset, and recently opted for someone charging £400 more for a 2-day job than a competitor because they were more professional – so is not a case of wanting to pay anyone less.

Just don’t understand the disproportionate concern for tradespeople and the misapprehension that they can’t catch a break.

I wasn't saying tradesman can't catch a break, most decent ones I know have a 6 month to 1 year waiting list. I was saying most no longer entertain these crappy little jobs, because most people would rather pay the cheap dodgy bloke, like you have done. It's not worth the hassle of competing for less than £100.

I'm not sticking up for this guy but obviously £55 isn't his hourly rate. That's the overall cost. You said he quoted the job so presumably came out to you twice, plus the cost of any materials.

Comefromaway · 11/03/2024 15:35

Createausername1970 · 09/03/2024 18:51

My immediate reaction was its two weeks later, you haven't paid him, so he is giving you fair warning that if you don't pay up, he will invoice you and you will be paying for his extra time to chase a payment that should have been paid already.

It's nothing to do with VAT, it interest on late payment and wasting his chargeable time

Just pay what you owe FFS.

If that was the case he would have to follow the legally defined) process for being able to charge interest (which is different depending on whether your client is a domestic or business customer). This process involved first having issued an invoice with payment terms on it.

Jk8 · 11/03/2024 15:15

clothearedpotatohead · 11/03/2024 11:58

Update: joiner got back to me this morning. Asked him for bank details for transfer, I said don’t worry about invoice. He said this will also cost £15. Explained I am not in the same city as him right now (I am not). He said ok there will be a charge to come and collect cash from you. (Don’t think this is really a very fair suggestion considering he’s only come back to me 2 weeks later to say he wants cash immediately). I pointed out he’d only just communicated any of this – I did try to arrange payment 2 weeks ago. He then said right just send me the 55 via bank transfer, then followed this with no actually, I’m going to come and break into your home and remove the work. Then blocked me.

So besides being a thug he’s also pretty daft if he goes round telling people he dodges taxes and then threatening to break into their homes, all in writing.

Eventually spoke to the person who passed on his name who said please don’t think this is how I run my business or assume I am also dodgy and unprofessional like this. He kindly offered to pass on the cash if I sent him the money over. A friend sent it on my behalf as I don’t want any of these people having my details.

So whoever pointed out that dishonest, shady people are usually dodgy in other ways – the theory holds!

Edited

He sounds batshit - I was all on his side about the hassle of invoices for small jobs & taxes are pretty much reliant on the honor system when it comes to being self employed but making it difficult to get paid & threatening to come back ?

I'd report him just for being a nuisance

clothearedpotatohead · 11/03/2024 15:11

What on earth did he do for £55. Fit a door hinge.

Something along those lines – v small job. Took well under an hour.

Find it interesting as well the few posts upthread talking about there being not enough money in trades, no one wanting to pay a fair amount, how can someone make ends meet and pay tax if they’re only charging £55 (or whatever) an hour.

But there are so many self-employed occupations where many people charge way less per hour – psychotherapists (start at £45), PTs (starting at £30, which in my opinion is too low), massage therapists, translators, graphic designers, physiotherapists, driving instructors (most where I am charge around £34, which also covers petrol and vehicle maintenance costs).

£55 for less than an hour’s work (and that’s a service charge, not a wage – it takes into account unpaid hours and the costs of running a business) is decent.

I should also make really clear here that I’ve happily paid more than £55 for other similar small jobs when it’s been agreed at the outset, and recently opted for someone charging £400 more for a 2-day job than a competitor because they were more professional – so is not a case of wanting to pay anyone less.

Just don’t understand the disproportionate concern for tradespeople and the misapprehension that they can’t catch a break.

OP posts:
Missamyp · 11/03/2024 14:37

What on earth did he do for £55. Fit a door hinge.
The issue is he's obviously had, is customers asking for a discount for cash.
Now he's made the mistake of assuming offering that to all customers and in your case threatening to remove whatever work he has done.
All rather unsavoury.

clothearedpotatohead · 11/03/2024 14:22

HoneyWogan · 11/03/2024 13:43

Wow, what an absolute horror he is. Thanks for the update.

I think you've hit the nail on the head there, though: all the people saying "Oh, he's just a low-paid tradie trying to save himself a few quid here and there" - it's the thin end of the wedge deciding to defraud your taxes.

And whilst a lot of them no doubt 'just' stop at that, if you are a person who will merrily and flagrantly ignore the law and how society functions in one aspect, why would you not go on and do so in any other respects where it works out beneficial for you? If paying taxes is 'not for you', why would 'not threatening people with violence' necessarily be any different?

The funny thing is that just before this he wrote something along the lines of believing me to be at fault for not asking his preferred payment method in advance.

The ‘at fault’ got me – which system is he working to?! 🤦🏻😆

He also complained I had not asked the person who put me in touch with him (another tradesperson) about payment method, despite the fact they’re separate businesses, and he and I spoke directly on the phone to arrange the job, and I mean – who is the other guy? His Dad?

Anyway, hopefully that is the last of him!

OP posts:
HoneyWogan · 11/03/2024 13:43

Wow, what an absolute horror he is. Thanks for the update.

I think you've hit the nail on the head there, though: all the people saying "Oh, he's just a low-paid tradie trying to save himself a few quid here and there" - it's the thin end of the wedge deciding to defraud your taxes.

And whilst a lot of them no doubt 'just' stop at that, if you are a person who will merrily and flagrantly ignore the law and how society functions in one aspect, why would you not go on and do so in any other respects where it works out beneficial for you? If paying taxes is 'not for you', why would 'not threatening people with violence' necessarily be any different?

anyolddinosaur · 11/03/2024 13:39

If there is a break in at your home you will, of course, report this to the police as well as the tax people.

Reugny · 11/03/2024 13:39

He then said right just send me the 55 via bank transfer, then followed this with no actually, I’m going to come and break into your home and remove the work. Then blocked me.

He's a nutter and a thug.

A couple of the trades I've used have explained to me that once they have done something on a customer's house it belongs to the customer.

This is why they always give an estimate before hand using text message as their paper trail and request the customer pays in cash on the day. Most of their jobs are under £1K. (One of them was looking at how to take card payments but realised it would put their costs up.)

I have had a plumber who issued receipt on the day. He asked for cash also and like the rest estimated by text.

taxguru · 11/03/2024 13:35

@clothearedpotatohead

He then said right just send me the 55 via bank transfer, then followed this with no actually, I’m going to come and break into your home and remove the work. Then blocked me.

I think that warrant a report to the police via their non emergency number and sending them a photo/screenshot of his text. That's threatening behaviour and it needs to be reported in case the idiot does actually turn up at your house, either threatening you or indeed trying to break in.

Mummame222 · 11/03/2024 12:08

clothearedpotatohead · 11/03/2024 11:58

Update: joiner got back to me this morning. Asked him for bank details for transfer, I said don’t worry about invoice. He said this will also cost £15. Explained I am not in the same city as him right now (I am not). He said ok there will be a charge to come and collect cash from you. (Don’t think this is really a very fair suggestion considering he’s only come back to me 2 weeks later to say he wants cash immediately). I pointed out he’d only just communicated any of this – I did try to arrange payment 2 weeks ago. He then said right just send me the 55 via bank transfer, then followed this with no actually, I’m going to come and break into your home and remove the work. Then blocked me.

So besides being a thug he’s also pretty daft if he goes round telling people he dodges taxes and then threatening to break into their homes, all in writing.

Eventually spoke to the person who passed on his name who said please don’t think this is how I run my business or assume I am also dodgy and unprofessional like this. He kindly offered to pass on the cash if I sent him the money over. A friend sent it on my behalf as I don’t want any of these people having my details.

So whoever pointed out that dishonest, shady people are usually dodgy in other ways – the theory holds!

Edited

Wow. I’m not all that surprised as he was clearly dodgy.

clothearedpotatohead · 11/03/2024 11:58

Update: joiner got back to me this morning. Asked him for bank details for transfer, I said don’t worry about invoice. He said this will also cost £15. Explained I am not in the same city as him right now (I am not). He said ok there will be a charge to come and collect cash from you. (Don’t think this is really a very fair suggestion considering he’s only come back to me 2 weeks later to say he wants cash immediately). I pointed out he’d only just communicated any of this – I did try to arrange payment 2 weeks ago. He then said right just send me the 55 via bank transfer, then followed this with no actually, I’m going to come and break into your home and remove the work. Then blocked me.

So besides being a thug he’s also pretty daft if he goes round telling people he dodges taxes and then threatening to break into their homes, all in writing.

Eventually spoke to the person who passed on his name who said please don’t think this is how I run my business or assume I am also dodgy and unprofessional like this. He kindly offered to pass on the cash if I sent him the money over. A friend sent it on my behalf as I don’t want any of these people having my details.

So whoever pointed out that dishonest, shady people are usually dodgy in other ways – the theory holds!

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 10/03/2024 10:52

snoopyfanaccountant · 10/03/2024 09:57

OP has stated that she is self-employed. Perhaps this job was related to her work and she needs an invoice for her own tax return.

It’s a legal requirement for VAT registered traders to give a VAT invoice/receipt if asked.

snoopyfanaccountant · 10/03/2024 09:57

ThisHonestQuail · 09/03/2024 23:55

Tbh if I knew in advance that a job was only going to cost £55 I’d just give cash on the day, or ask for bank details on the day. I def wouldn’t be asking for an invoice for such a small thing 😅

OP has stated that she is self-employed. Perhaps this job was related to her work and she needs an invoice for her own tax return.

clothearedpotatohead · 10/03/2024 09:51

Teajenny7 · 10/03/2024 09:39

I had this once with a tradesman.
I pointed out that

  1. I don't keep cash in the house
  2. I need an invoice/ receipt
  3. Said receipt would need his vat number if applicable.
I told him number 3 was most important as I worked for HMRC.

Had to laugh at this 😄😄

OP posts:
Teajenny7 · 10/03/2024 09:39

clothearedpotatohead · 09/03/2024 13:47

I don’t think I’d have the heart to report him to HMRC

I had this once with a tradesman.
I pointed out that

  1. I don't keep cash in the house
  2. I need an invoice/ receipt
  3. Said receipt would need his vat number if applicable.
I told him number 3 was most important as I worked for HMRC.
clothearedpotatohead · 10/03/2024 09:23

taxguru · 10/03/2024 09:17

It's always been easy! Back in the day (and you can still buy them), "small" traders would simply by a challenge carbonated invoice pad from WH Smith or any other stationery shop. You just write the invoice by hand, give it to the customer, and you've a carbonated copy left in the pad for your own records. I've literally worked through hundreds of those books when preparing accounts and tax returns for all kinds of small businesses from window cleaners through to tv repairmen through to guest houses, etc. For those who didn't want to keep writing their own name and address on the top of each invoice, they'd have a rubber stamp made and stamp several pages in advance.

Nowadays, you can print off "empty" invoices and just write in the blanks, made by your own PC/smart phone and a cheap printer, so you can just write in the amount of the job on a small piece of paper, drop it through the letter box, and it has the traders bank details for you to send payment by BACS. It's what our window cleaner and milk man do so they're not having to keep going back to customer's homes to collect cash, especially for workers who aren't at home all day.

Anyone trying to justify a charge for an invoice is insane. It's part of being self employed! "Small" jobs like this just need something (anything) small and simple to confirm price, trader's details, and payment instructions. That doesn't have to be an all singing all dancing formal invoice, (although generating something formal in Quickbooks or Xero is literally a couple of minutes and click of a button), but using a photocopied proforma or carbonated book is absolutely fine!

lol thank you, yes even our window cleaner sends an invoice with bank transfer details

OP posts:
taxguru · 10/03/2024 09:17

cakeorwine · 10/03/2024 06:58

Invoicing is really easy nowadays. There are many tools avail;able.

I guess you've seen the advert for Quikbooks Details go in, email out, invoice paid and your accounts are also done.

Of course, if you don't bother with keeping accounts and paying taxes, that could be a problem for you.

But it's not difficult

It's always been easy! Back in the day (and you can still buy them), "small" traders would simply by a challenge carbonated invoice pad from WH Smith or any other stationery shop. You just write the invoice by hand, give it to the customer, and you've a carbonated copy left in the pad for your own records. I've literally worked through hundreds of those books when preparing accounts and tax returns for all kinds of small businesses from window cleaners through to tv repairmen through to guest houses, etc. For those who didn't want to keep writing their own name and address on the top of each invoice, they'd have a rubber stamp made and stamp several pages in advance.

Nowadays, you can print off "empty" invoices and just write in the blanks, made by your own PC/smart phone and a cheap printer, so you can just write in the amount of the job on a small piece of paper, drop it through the letter box, and it has the traders bank details for you to send payment by BACS. It's what our window cleaner and milk man do so they're not having to keep going back to customer's homes to collect cash, especially for workers who aren't at home all day.

Anyone trying to justify a charge for an invoice is insane. It's part of being self employed! "Small" jobs like this just need something (anything) small and simple to confirm price, trader's details, and payment instructions. That doesn't have to be an all singing all dancing formal invoice, (although generating something formal in Quickbooks or Xero is literally a couple of minutes and click of a button), but using a photocopied proforma or carbonated book is absolutely fine!

Joiner charging £15 for invoice
cakeorwine · 10/03/2024 08:32

clothearedpotatohead · 10/03/2024 08:29

I just assumed he’d send the payment details in an invoice, as that’s what every other tradesperson I’ve dealt with recently has done (about 5 in the last year). He knew I wasn’t going to be there in person on the day.

I agree - I have had some small jobs done and the invoice has arrived by Quikbooks.

Dead easy.

Even giving bank details for a transfer isn't difficult.

clothearedpotatohead · 10/03/2024 08:29

ThisHonestQuail · 09/03/2024 23:55

Tbh if I knew in advance that a job was only going to cost £55 I’d just give cash on the day, or ask for bank details on the day. I def wouldn’t be asking for an invoice for such a small thing 😅

I just assumed he’d send the payment details in an invoice, as that’s what every other tradesperson I’ve dealt with recently has done (about 5 in the last year). He knew I wasn’t going to be there in person on the day.

OP posts: