Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughters don’t want to join in family gatherings

237 replies

Thebirdlady · 08/03/2024 23:56

I have two daughters ( 20 years and 18 years) who dress in unconventional clothes (nothing shocking,just lots of dark colours and clumpy Dr Martens etc.)They always look smart and clean.
We get invited out for family meals with my in-laws and my husband’s niece,nephew and their very young children.
My issue is that every time we meet , someone finds it necessary to pass comment on my girls appearance,normally along the lines of ‘what are those shoes?Can you walk in them? Or
some other comment.Then someone else chips in and they have a conversation over the girls appearance.They are polite kids and so don’t respond in the way that I would if someone was commenting negatively about my appearance.
Now I’m having to persuade them to attend these functions because they don’t really want to come.
But we don’t see we them very often and they seem offended if my girls aren’t there.
I just bite my lip and change the subject but I don’t really enjoy these occasions because I know they make my girls uncomfortable.
What ,if anything,is the answer?

OP posts:
Buffs · 10/03/2024 17:54

You describe your daughters’ clothes as unconventional. Surely if that’s the case it’s fair enough for frumpy, old relatives to comment if they’re not being malicious?

dalecooper · 10/03/2024 17:50

Why don’t you say anything to your family? Also are your family living on the moon? Teenagers have been wearing DM’s and black since the 80s.

NewName24 · 09/03/2024 15:42

I think the vote is quite split, because it isn't clear from your OP what you are asking.

I think Y have been VU to just "bite your lip" whilst adults make your dc feel so uncomfortable
I think YWBU to try to make them go. They are adult. It is up to them if they go. If they enjoyed spending time with their Grandparents, then they'd want to go. (Or should this be YANBU to not make them go ?).

I also think Y have BU to bring your dc up with so very little self resilience, or confidence in their choices. They aren't 13 yr olds experimenting and probably getting it not quite right. They are adults.
People on here disagree about when a bit of family banter becomes unkindness - that line will be different in different families - but every generation has worn their own fashions which are not liked or understood by those from their parents or grandparents generation and the overwhelming majority of us have managed to carry on with life with a bit of an eyeroll at those who feel the need to verbalise their thoughts.

BroughttoyoubyBerocca · 09/03/2024 15:02

YAVVVU in letting this happen, where’s your voice, I would calmly call them out for discussing your DD’s appearance, if they then continue let your DD’s not attend and explain why they are not there. I’m furious on your DD’s behalf

Dontcallmescarface · 09/03/2024 14:09

Your DD's are well within their rights not to attend but I think they should one last time. When the comments start they should reply with " well I'd like to wear (whatever the person making the comments is wearing), but it just makes people look sooooo old/drab/boring whatever word they choose, and follow it up with their sweetest smiles.

Obeast · 09/03/2024 14:01

Is @Thebirdlady not bothering to reply?

MobileStationery · 09/03/2024 13:34

BeaRF75 · 09/03/2024 13:07

I'm not surprised they don't want to attend! Family "gatherings" are grim at the best of times, but why should they have to talk to these unpleasant people? They are ADULTS - they can choose for themselves whether they want to attend.

As soon as I was old enough to refuse to go, I stopped going.

Always a nightmare of creepy uncles, grabby granddad's and moist lipped nans. Euch.

FictionalCharacter · 09/03/2024 13:33

Why are you persuading them to go and see people who are rude to them? They’re adults, they don’t have to be dragged along like children to visit horrible family members. Though it’s bad enough to drag the children.

You should have their backs.

phoenixrosehere · 09/03/2024 13:33

AdrianaLola · 09/03/2024 13:02

"No one should have to 'laugh off' someone taking the piss out of their appearance/fashion choices."

Nobody? Ever? Come on, some fashion choices really are laughable!

Fine to think it in your head- no need to say it out loud lol. Not every thought you have needs to be verbalised- the world doesnt revolve around your opinion I'm afraid. I think a LOT of things in my head but I wouldnt say them out loud because, well, why? What does it achieve except make the other person feel rubbish? what are you expecting the reaction to be- "omg ok I'll get rid of the coat then if you don't like it!".

People dress the way they like to dress- if they didnt like it, they wouldnt be wearing it- thats patently obvious to most people with half a brain so commenting negatively on it is pointless because they clearly DO like it. They wouldnt have bloody bought it otherwise. If someone asks you what you think fine to say its not really my style and I'm not keen on the collar or whatever, but unsolicited negative comments are mean spirited and they say way more about the person making them than the person on the recieving end.

Edited

Well said!

Amazes me how many people think it is perfectly ok to comment negatively because THEY don’t like someone’s choice of clothes because it’s not to their taste. No one asked them to wear it or for an opinion in the first place. I doubt they would be happy if someone came up to them and negatively commented on their choice of clothing.

I also don’t know how doc martens are not normal. All ages wear them and there are plenty of styles that suit different personalities. They also last ages so usually a good investment.

AdrianaLola · 09/03/2024 13:11

I'm not surprised they don't want to attend! Family "gatherings" are grim at the best of times

Amen to this too. I remember when I was that age I hated family gatherings- endless questions about who I was dating, comments on my appearance, questioning why "all" young people did this, did that (but of course if I made similar generalisations about older people it would be suddenly wrong) etc. They were boring, tedious and unpleasant and akin to having a root canal.

I stopped going in the end and I think your daughters should do the same.

BeaRF75 · 09/03/2024 13:07

I'm not surprised they don't want to attend! Family "gatherings" are grim at the best of times, but why should they have to talk to these unpleasant people? They are ADULTS - they can choose for themselves whether they want to attend.

AdrianaLola · 09/03/2024 13:02

"No one should have to 'laugh off' someone taking the piss out of their appearance/fashion choices."

Nobody? Ever? Come on, some fashion choices really are laughable!

Fine to think it in your head- no need to say it out loud lol. Not every thought you have needs to be verbalised- the world doesnt revolve around your opinion I'm afraid. I think a LOT of things in my head but I wouldnt say them out loud because, well, why? What does it achieve except make the other person feel rubbish? what are you expecting the reaction to be- "omg ok I'll get rid of the coat then if you don't like it!".

People dress the way they like to dress- if they didnt like it, they wouldnt be wearing it- thats patently obvious to most people with half a brain so commenting negatively on it is pointless because they clearly DO like it. They wouldnt have bloody bought it otherwise. If someone asks you what you think fine to say its not really my style and I'm not keen on the collar or whatever, but unsolicited negative comments are mean spirited and they say way more about the person making them than the person on the recieving end.

Maudeslittleredshoes · 09/03/2024 12:58

I would stop pressuring your girls to go, that would be the first thing. The second thing I would do is shut down immediately any comments around your girls’ appearances by telling your family members that it’s inappropriate and rude to make such comments.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 09/03/2024 12:56

Let them swerve it.
If someone comments on them not being there, tell them why they do not want to come.

PinkArt · 09/03/2024 12:20

'No need to comment on Eva and Maisie's appearance, thanks. Would anyone like more tea?'.

'Eva chose not to come today as her appearance was criticised by three of you last time she visited and that wasn't fun for her. Have you been watching Celeb Big Brother'.

Loads of ways to point out their bad behaviour, and the consequences, without it becoming what I think you think would be confrontational.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 09/03/2024 12:17

Well, firstly they are just at the age for finding such family gatherings a bit boring, especially if there are younger kids present and no cousins their own age. I remember having a few years where I turned down invites to family gatherings, or only went for a short time to be polite, as I just wanted to spend time with people my own age. It’s a normal developmental stage, I think, when you’re still seen as not quite a fully fledged adult by wider family. By early to mid 20s I was happy to attend family events again, as an adult and an equal. If your relatives’ children are only young they won’t understand this as they’re in thr middle of “our kids come everywhere with us” stage.

I would not be making your children attend things they don’t want to attend unless important like a wedding or funeral or someone’s big birthday. (Where it’s usually easy to find a quiet spot or other relatives a similar age). They do need to learn that some events are just non negotiable in families and unless there is a huge rift they need to learn to suck it up and show up.

I also think they are old enough to be standing up for themselves regarding the comments, with you as their “cheerleader”, on their side and modelling ways to respond eg you should laugh and say “oh, FIL, no-one wears X type of shoes anymore, haven’t you noticed all the young ones wearing Y? Isn’t that right, DD? What’s the name of that tik toker again, who started that trend off?”

or, alternatively, “yeah, DD finds the current trend of everyone wearing X item of clothes a bit boring, it’s no fun to look like a clone of everyone else, is it? They prefer this look as it fits in with their musical tastes, doesn’t it, DD? Tell Uncle Pete what the name of that band is that you like, to see if he’s heard of them.”

you want to make the point to the relatives that there is a generation gap there and by constantly commenting in what I assume is a disparaging way about their outfits they’re just showing up how old fashioned and stuck in their ways they are! They’ll soon shut up when they’re made to feel past it 😆

MrBojnokopffsPurpleHat · 09/03/2024 12:14

.... scathing inditement on their past judgments.

If your daughters choose to see them again, they are now adults who can give their own opinions without enduring parental censure.

Noseybookworm · 09/03/2024 12:11

I think it's fine for your daughters not to go - if anyone passes comment I'd just say they're adults, they're busy, they have their own lives. I'm surprised you've not said anything to your relatives about their rude behaviour though. I'd definitely have said something!

MrBojnokopffsPurpleHat · 09/03/2024 12:09

The fact that you and your DH have let these comments slide for years is unconscionable. Now that they are adults, they get to choose who they socialise with, and if you feel you must say something if questioned about their absence, you can simply say "Oh, they're off doing their own thing".

TBH, after all these years, it would be kind of hypocritical of you to deliver a some sort of

momager1 · 09/03/2024 12:07

I had inlaws like this and the same thing happened to my daughter when she found her own "style". (funny enough our sons also had the same type style, and they were never commented on. Funny that) When she was 18 she decided no more monthly sunday lunches out with them because of it. I asked her to go to two more. First one I told her we would take two cars to and she would eat then leave in the car with an excuse of needing to be somewhere. When she left I waited until the bills were asked for, Then I simply said "ok family. The reason she left early is because I needed a word. She had decided not to come anymore and I asked her to give it a chance if I talk to you. " I then explained politely how she was feeling. PIL and BIL families where mortified that they had hurt her feelings. Next monthly lunch came up and she came, felt akward at first but it went well. She continued going until she was married with her own kids. PIL are both gone now so lunches ended several years ago. If even ONE of them had commented on her appearance at the second lunch, the deal was that our family of five would get up (pay if we had already ate, or box up our meals) and leave together and start our own sunday lunch out tradition. Having our kids with us was more important than the others at that table. But as reasonable and nice people they changed their behavior

mydamnfootstuckinthedoor · 09/03/2024 12:03

Why don't the girls respond? Why don't you give them "permission" to respond (not that they need it, they are both grown adults clearly trying to be polite) I don't think you need to speak for them. I also think they can respond without being TOO rude ... e.g."oh, it's a modern trend", "what did they wear in your day?"

Toastcrumbsinsofa · 09/03/2024 11:49

@Thebirdlady you and your DH need to stick up for your children. There’s no need to be rude but you do need to be assertive to shut it down.

Your daughters need to be told that it’s ok to say ‘please stop with the comments about how I look. It’s unkind and I don’t like it’

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 09/03/2024 11:49

The answer is …they get to choose and if they choose no, your explanation to the family members who comment should be that they weren’t made to feel welcome.

LatteLady · 09/03/2024 11:47

Frankly, both of your daughters are old enough to make up their own minds, so let them. If anyone asks, then you tell them that the comments about their appearance, at previous get togethers made them uncomfortable, hence them not being there. Done and dusted.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 09/03/2024 11:47

Allfur · 09/03/2024 11:44

I can't understand why the girls take it seriously, the mockers are the ones who look bad

Because it's not nice to sit there and have your appearance picked at and criticised, no matter what the circumstances.

I also know I would never have had the guts to speak up to an older relative at that age. Yes, I was an "adult" but at family gatherings you're often still treated as a child. It's not as easy as saying "don't take it seriously" or "why don't they just say something".

Swipe left for the next trending thread