Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughters don’t want to join in family gatherings

237 replies

Thebirdlady · 08/03/2024 23:56

I have two daughters ( 20 years and 18 years) who dress in unconventional clothes (nothing shocking,just lots of dark colours and clumpy Dr Martens etc.)They always look smart and clean.
We get invited out for family meals with my in-laws and my husband’s niece,nephew and their very young children.
My issue is that every time we meet , someone finds it necessary to pass comment on my girls appearance,normally along the lines of ‘what are those shoes?Can you walk in them? Or
some other comment.Then someone else chips in and they have a conversation over the girls appearance.They are polite kids and so don’t respond in the way that I would if someone was commenting negatively about my appearance.
Now I’m having to persuade them to attend these functions because they don’t really want to come.
But we don’t see we them very often and they seem offended if my girls aren’t there.
I just bite my lip and change the subject but I don’t really enjoy these occasions because I know they make my girls uncomfortable.
What ,if anything,is the answer?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Topseyt123 · 12/03/2024 16:56

Thebirdlady · 11/03/2024 22:49

I’m gobsmacked by how many people have commented.
I agree with a lot of the comments saying we should have spoken sooner but it’s not my family (unfortunately I have no close family members still alive) and therefore they are the only family my daughters have ever known.
I also don’t drag them there kicking and screaming - just encourage them to attend when they aren’t busy.

You are putting some pressure on them to attend. "Encouraging them when they aren't busy" is exactly that. Why can't they just be left in peace?

Them being DH's family makes no difference. You can still speak up for your DDs and explain why they have chosen (with your blessing) not to attend.

MassiveOvaryaction · 12/03/2024 15:53

Thebirdlady · 11/03/2024 22:49

I’m gobsmacked by how many people have commented.
I agree with a lot of the comments saying we should have spoken sooner but it’s not my family (unfortunately I have no close family members still alive) and therefore they are the only family my daughters have ever known.
I also don’t drag them there kicking and screaming - just encourage them to attend when they aren’t busy.

Now you've seen the replies will you be honest with those relatives asking why your dc haven't attended?

MassiveOvaryaction · 12/03/2024 15:52

ilovebreadsauce · 10/03/2024 19:42

People don't dress unconventionally if they don't expect their attire to be commented on

Not necessarily. And dark clothes plus Doc Martens is hardly unconventional, especially in the late teen population.

monsterflake · 12/03/2024 07:45

I haven't read all the comments yet but I wanted to share my experience with older relatives growing up. Some of my relatives seemed to have a strange obsession with how 'tall' I was. I don't mean relatives we saw every couple of years so obviously a child's growth is very noticeable, but those we saw at least on a monthly basis. I wasn't tall, I've never been taller than average but the comments were so frequent it made me feel like a circus freak. I was tall and my younger brother was small (he was smaller than me as he was two years younger, normal development of a child etc). I even had one aunt who seemed obsessed with my weight, in the puppy fat stage pre growth spurt aged about 11.

This was absolutely excruciating for me, I hated being the centre of attention (turned out I'm neurodivergent) but I remember wishing so hard that they would just ask me about school or my hobbies and friends and things rather than going on about what I looked like and my size. My wonderful grandma would sit with me in the kitchen and talk to me about anything I wanted, I used to love asking her about what my dad was like when he was younger.

If these relatives care so much about seeing your daughters that they would get offended if they didn't come then they need to be told in no uncertain terms that there is more to your girls than how they dress, they are adults and I can imagine they could contribute to a normal adult conversation rather than being made a spectacle of. As a result of this I've taught my children never to comment on someone's appearance unless paying them a compliment and even my 6 year old understands this so I would hope an adult could comprehend it too! I really feel for your girls, I hope it doesn't stop them from expressing their own style.

Ihearditfrommyradio · 12/03/2024 07:03

It's a great age when you realise you have the agency to decide not to meet up with rude and unpleasant family members that you simply don't like.

I have memories of going to my aunt, uncle and cousins every month with no-one really enjoying it , when the kids got old enough it was, 'nope we've got better things to do than carry on this charade '.

Grandparents obviously different, they can have played a significant practical part in your upbringing so there's a 'duty' aspect there, but again if they are continously offensive they need to be told.

rookiemere · 12/03/2024 06:47

It doesn't need to be a big confrontation though.
When MIL or whoever comments "Look at those clumpy old boots you should be down the mines with those fellas" OP can cough loudly and say something like "DD is happy and comfortable in her outfit. Now how has your Angina been over the last few weeks ?"

It's possible to be assertive without being rude.

Alwaystransforming · 12/03/2024 06:42

Thebirdlady · 11/03/2024 22:49

I’m gobsmacked by how many people have commented.
I agree with a lot of the comments saying we should have spoken sooner but it’s not my family (unfortunately I have no close family members still alive) and therefore they are the only family my daughters have ever known.
I also don’t drag them there kicking and screaming - just encourage them to attend when they aren’t busy.

Your daughters are your family though. They have been kids while this has been going on. You said you wouldn’t let anyone speak to you like it, but you have allowed it to happen to your daughters and now trying to encourage them into a situation they don’t want to be in.

So what if they are the only extended family they have known? They have you and your husband. They don’t family that makes them feel like shit.

I think you feelings about not having extended family are really influencing your thoughts here. You don’t have it, on your side, so you think that they should hold to it at all costs. But that’s just damaging.

I get it. My mum is dead. Sometimes I read threads or hear people moaning about their mum and I want to tell them to ignore the shit, suck it up and appreciate having a mum. Because I would give anything to have my mum, even along with all her shit. But I have to remember my feelings about missing my mum are mine. It doesn’t mean other people should give everything and put up with shit.

Fraaahnces · 12/03/2024 02:28

I am sorry you’re getting a pasting here @Thebirdlady. I think you need to let these relatives know that your daughters are young adults and that you will no longer be facilitating their relationships for them. If they wish to see them, they are welcome to try and contact them themselves, but given that both your daughters have expressed how humiliating it is to be expected to share a meal and quietly accept being continually picked at for their choices in clothing and humiliating them, not to be surprised if the girls refuse to entertain any future invitations. I would let them know that just as they are also adults, they are also capable of self-reflection, apologizing and changing their behaviour, but you will not be their go-between.

MariaVT65 · 12/03/2024 01:57

Thebirdlady · 11/03/2024 22:49

I’m gobsmacked by how many people have commented.
I agree with a lot of the comments saying we should have spoken sooner but it’s not my family (unfortunately I have no close family members still alive) and therefore they are the only family my daughters have ever known.
I also don’t drag them there kicking and screaming - just encourage them to attend when they aren’t busy.

It doesn’t matter if they are your daughter’s only family. It doesn’t make them any less nasty. You shouldn’t be enouraging them to attend at all until an apology is issues, or you let your daughters know it’s ok to call the family out on their behaviour.

Thebirdlady · 11/03/2024 22:49

I’m gobsmacked by how many people have commented.
I agree with a lot of the comments saying we should have spoken sooner but it’s not my family (unfortunately I have no close family members still alive) and therefore they are the only family my daughters have ever known.
I also don’t drag them there kicking and screaming - just encourage them to attend when they aren’t busy.

OP posts:
NewName24 · 11/03/2024 17:53

Sorry, fat thumbs, "18 and 20"

NewName24 · 11/03/2024 17:52

biscuitsnow · 11/03/2024 06:52

Because, in normal loving families, people enjoy seeing other members of the family

Nah, this really isnt true. I loved my grandparents but still found family events incredibly tedious and boring at that age. I wanted to hang out with my friends, not OAPs- thats completely normal. Doesnt mean I didnt love them but the conversation was boring and so far removed from what I was interested in as a teen that I used to "endure" them, not enjoy them.

Well, we can all only speak as we find from our own experiences.

I have 3 dc in their 20s who are very peeved if they aren't available when we go for a meal with their Grandparents and cousins and Aunts and Uncles, I and can think of about 6 or 7 other families that I know well enough to know this to be true of, with dc currently ranging from 14 to 32, where all of the d"c" enjoy getting together 2, 3 or 4 times a year with extended family. (Different families).

I'm aware that around 13, many teens want to just hibernate in rooms, but the OP's dc are 19 and 20 and most teens have usually come out the other side of that tunnel by then.

toomuchfaff · 11/03/2024 15:10

My issue is that every time we meet , someone finds it necessary to pass comment on my girls appearance.Then someone else chips in and they have a conversation over the girls appearance.
Now I’m having to persuade them to attend these functions because they don’t really want to come. ... then they seem offended if my girls aren’t there.

You're answering your own question here. You call out the people who are making the girls feel unwelcome by their constant comments of their clothes and style - "their" actions are the reason your girls do not want to visit - so as a consequence to "their" actions, my girls do not want to visit anymore, and i wont force them. If you want the girls here - then you need to address "their" actions - make it known that its their problem to solve.

Missamyp · 11/03/2024 14:23

Are they not wanting to go because of the comments?
Or because they're actually young women and feel stifled by the twee gatherings?
I have to admit the current baggy look isn't my favourite. But I wouldn't comment on it.

IStandWithACrutch · 11/03/2024 14:15

I was that teenager who was the target of comments about how I dressed. Not only did my mother not stand up for me, she would agree with the piss taking. Dented my confidence.
Stand up for your daughters.

Nipsmum · 11/03/2024 14:07

I wouldn't want to see family or friends that behaved like that

TheYoungestSibling · 11/03/2024 12:23

Your girls may be staying silent because they hope you will step up and shut up these rude relatives.

Next time, on accepting the invitation you can say "my daughters will only come if you promise you won't comment on their appearances. As adults they are free to dress as they please and you will drive them away from you if you continue to be rude".

Address it politely in the room on the day if necessary: stop making personal comments about my daughters. They are exercising their right to make their own choices and we will choose to leave if you continue to be rude.

Mumkins42 · 11/03/2024 12:12

For people bashing OP - when you've grown up in a toxic family dynamic you are so often shut down and learn not to speak up. I imagine there will be unfair consequences for OP speaking up; punishment, gaslighting, undermining what you're saying and it goes on.

Basically, if your daughter's have zero interest and gain nothing from the interaction, don't make them go!

You can kindly and politely explain how they feel and ask for it to stop. I have a feeling the reaction will be like I've explained above. You then decide what you gain from a family who does not listen or care how you and your girls feel.

Third option is continue as it is and lose a piece of yourself every time you see them , plus teaching your girls to put up and shut up

KreedKafer · 11/03/2024 12:12

They're both adults and therefore I wouldn't be making them attend family gatherings anyway.

Your relatives are rude, though. Just because someone's younger than them, it doesn't mean it's OK to take the piss out of their appearance. Nobody would think it was OK for a 20-year-old woman to point out and mock their auntie's shoes, or their grandma's, or to tell their uncle/grandad that they think he's wearing an awful shirt, so why the fuck is it OK when it's the other way round?

Your daughters are grown women, ffs. They don't have to attend 'family gatherings' where their relatives treat them like children.

WYTrio · 11/03/2024 12:00

Simple decision tree. If there's another even ask your daughters. If they say no, and explain, listen. If they say no and don't: ask them. Then go without them and if anyone comments just say why they aren't there.

If they do decide to go, back them up if people make comments.

I mean Doc Martens were alternative when I was a teenager, they're pretty much mainstream now.

Thing about banter is, that it's both sides that decide it's banter. If the reciever isn't willing it's not banter its bullying. Also the thing about opinions is that everyone is entitled to one. You may be entitled to think that someones shoes look ridiculous, or even to say that. But other people are entitled to the opinion that your views are small minded and hurtful. And an a world where you can express your views, the people who think you are hurtful have equal right to express theirs.

I mean there's lots of comments about why didn't you say anything earlier.... but I think you want to deal with things as they are.

Pogue4Life · 11/03/2024 11:55

I don’t blame your daughters for not wanting to attend such events. Put yourself in their shoes, how would you feel about having. To sit and listen to people insult you as if you’re not even there. These girls need you to advocate for them and to show them and others that it’s not acceptable. If you can’t say anything nice to someone Don’t say anything at all.

2024theplot · 11/03/2024 08:43

OP why aren't you sticking up for your daughters? It's teaching them that they should just sit there and accept this behaviour.
One of my nieces dresses similarly, someone made a comment about it once and I asked them if they really thought it was okay to be so rude about someone else's attire, there was an awkward and probably insincere apology, but my niece beamed and thanked me for sticking up for her. They've not brought up her attire again since.

mrsg1981 · 11/03/2024 07:49

Your family sound awful. Why do you want to spend time with them? If they weren’t your family, would you?

ExpatAl · 11/03/2024 07:22

You have to speak up for your girls and say don’t be rude. Stop commenting on their style choices, it is making them uncomfortable.

biscuitsnow · 11/03/2024 06:52

Because, in normal loving families, people enjoy seeing other members of the family

Nah, this really isnt true. I loved my grandparents but still found family events incredibly tedious and boring at that age. I wanted to hang out with my friends, not OAPs- thats completely normal. Doesnt mean I didnt love them but the conversation was boring and so far removed from what I was interested in as a teen that I used to "endure" them, not enjoy them.