Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it right the biggest winners im budget

91 replies

SortUKproblemsfirst · 08/03/2024 17:35

So the biggest winners in the recent budget were a couple both earning £60,000. Gaining £5229.

Working parents on £20,000 gained by £594.

Pensioners forgotten.

Seems topsy-turvy.

Aibu to say the Tories really are for putting people down and the leveling up was lies.

OP posts:
T0ASTER · 08/03/2024 20:26

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 08/03/2024 20:24

What about when one earns 75k and the other 30k and don't get CB? That's not fair

I think with an income of 105k you'll be alright ffs

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 08/03/2024 20:24

What about when one earns 75k and the other 30k and don't get CB? That's not fair

platypusweek · 08/03/2024 20:18

hagchic · 08/03/2024 19:57

Household savings by age UK financial wealth
Average Median
20 to 24 £2,600 £200
25 to 29 £3,800 -£100
30 to 34 £14,500 £1,000
35 to 39 £28,400 £2,800
40 to 44 £76,100 £5,000
45 to 49 £50,100 £5,300
50 to 54 £59,700 £5,100
55 to 59 £81,700 £10,600
60 to 64 £116,900 £22,500
65+ £113,600 £25,700
All persons £73,100 £8,000

The difference between the median and average shows just how unequal the UK is. That's wild.

hagchic · 08/03/2024 19:57

Household savings by age UK financial wealth
Average Median
20 to 24 £2,600 £200
25 to 29 £3,800 -£100
30 to 34 £14,500 £1,000
35 to 39 £28,400 £2,800
40 to 44 £76,100 £5,000
45 to 49 £50,100 £5,300
50 to 54 £59,700 £5,100
55 to 59 £81,700 £10,600
60 to 64 £116,900 £22,500
65+ £113,600 £25,700
All persons £73,100 £8,000

Lifebeganat50 · 08/03/2024 19:41

T0ASTER · 08/03/2024 17:56

They get hundreds for fuel every year, bus passes, free tv license

And all the pensioners I know have big houses and way more income than us

Bitter, much? (No I’m not a pensioner)

WhatShallIdo11 · 08/03/2024 19:19

waterlellon · 08/03/2024 18:08

Pensioners have the triple lock. They are fine

Yep - £200 per week will rise to £217 in April after working full time for 50 years and still working PT - think I'll tray myself to a new car and a world cruise!

Ilovemycar77 · 08/03/2024 18:34

Well
my Pensioner MIL is def doing alright!

Never paid a penny into the system her entire life as always looked after by her husband, she was a shit mother to her son.

She receives: HB, state pension, pension credit, free council tax, cost of living payments, extra electric and gas payments and free prescriptions because she lives down the chemist.

I effin hate people who bleed the system dry like her, so pensioners are not all hard done by….she has thousands in the bloody bank.

My husband and I are high earners and pay 10s of thousands in tax every year

I will never vote Labour, ever and quite frankly not interested in Tory right now either.
they can all get stuffed!

REFORM UK for me, or may not bother voting tbh…
as I cannot wait until my kids have finished their education so we can get the hell out of this hell hole country and reside elsewhere.

Even told my children the same, as soon as they have their degrees to move abroad.

This country has become a cesspit of grabbers from the state! And useless councils who have no idea what they’re doing.

T0ASTER · 08/03/2024 18:31

AccountantMum · 08/03/2024 18:26

It was needed - When my wages first went over 50k I was worse off than when earning 50k - when you factor in student finance repayment, income tax, NIC, tapering off of UC childcare payments which makes no sense. In some circumstances for every extra £1 you would earn you need to pay over an addition £ in tax/similar.

50k does not equate to a big take home pay and people earning just over usually don't get the same support as those on low wages. If at every budget the benefit was bigger to those on lower wages than those on fairly normal wages then it would end up that people would be better off to earn less..

Hmm I earn 26k and don't receive any benefits. I don't feel poor. I think 50k is loads but then this is Mumsnet!

Mummame222 · 08/03/2024 18:29

KvotheTheBloodless · 08/03/2024 18:25

We earn similar amounts, and think that whilst we don't need it, single parents definitely do - it's such a crude instrument to use the higher earner's income and ignore their partner/spouse. The newer system coming in in 2026 will be better.

Mind you, we're not going to turn it down. We pay loads in pension contributions so we'll get £200 per annum under the new rules, which is worth having.

Mind you, we're not going to turn it down. We pay loads in pension contributions so we'll get £200 per annum under the new rules, which is worth having.

Yeah, I can understand that.

AccountantMum · 08/03/2024 18:26

It was needed - When my wages first went over 50k I was worse off than when earning 50k - when you factor in student finance repayment, income tax, NIC, tapering off of UC childcare payments which makes no sense. In some circumstances for every extra £1 you would earn you need to pay over an addition £ in tax/similar.

50k does not equate to a big take home pay and people earning just over usually don't get the same support as those on low wages. If at every budget the benefit was bigger to those on lower wages than those on fairly normal wages then it would end up that people would be better off to earn less..

KvotheTheBloodless · 08/03/2024 18:25

Mummame222 · 08/03/2024 18:22

out of curiosity how do you feel about that? My first thought at seeing them numbers is you definitely don’t need it? Am I wrong?

We earn similar amounts, and think that whilst we don't need it, single parents definitely do - it's such a crude instrument to use the higher earner's income and ignore their partner/spouse. The newer system coming in in 2026 will be better.

Mind you, we're not going to turn it down. We pay loads in pension contributions so we'll get £200 per annum under the new rules, which is worth having.

Mummame222 · 08/03/2024 18:22

StedeBonnet · 08/03/2024 17:52

The child benefit changes don't affect us as we earn 75 and 85 respectively but I'm glad to see the changes as it wasn't right before.

out of curiosity how do you feel about that? My first thought at seeing them numbers is you definitely don’t need it? Am I wrong?

KvotheTheBloodless · 08/03/2024 18:22

StedeBonnet · 08/03/2024 17:52

The child benefit changes don't affect us as we earn 75 and 85 respectively but I'm glad to see the changes as it wasn't right before.

How much do you pay in pension contributions? If it's a reasonable amount it will likely take you under the £80k threshold so you'd get something (not loads though).

Caravaggiouch · 08/03/2024 18:19

I’m not convinced by the argument that pensioners have lost out because they’re not getting the reduction in NICs because they don’t pay it. I’m no fan of this government and would rather the tax reduction funding had gone to support local government instead, but if there are going to be tax cuts it’s right that they’re aimed at taxes on income earned through work. And the CB threshold has long needed increasing.

T0ASTER · 08/03/2024 18:17

Bluevelvetsofa · 08/03/2024 18:14

I didn’t know pensioners have free fuel. We certainly haven’t. I do know that the free TV licence for over 75 was abolished. A bus pass is fine if there are buses that go where you need to go.

I mean the payments they get for cost of living and fuel. It's not entirely free but they get free money

It ranges between £250 and £600 depending on your circumstances, and this is all tax-free. This amount includes a pensioner cost of living payment, which is between £150 and £300. This is an additional sum for winter 2023/2024 to help pensioners pay for heating bills as the cost of living crisis continues.

londonmummy1966 · 08/03/2024 18:16

I do think that the changes this time were fair. Pensioners are already well looked after by the tripe lock. Cutting NIC rather than taxes means that the benefit goes to working people who often seem to get a raw deal. The real benefit for the higher rate tax payer is the increase in the CB threshold - we are looking at a working population decline in the medium term if we don't make it more financially viable for people to have children so it makes sense to help the "squeezed middle" during the years they need to support a family as well as themselves.

Bluevelvetsofa · 08/03/2024 18:14

I didn’t know pensioners have free fuel. We certainly haven’t. I do know that the free TV licence for over 75 was abolished. A bus pass is fine if there are buses that go where you need to go.

avocadotofu · 08/03/2024 18:12

Pammela2 · 08/03/2024 18:02

I don’t think you should be framing it as an ‘us or them’. There’s a huge issue with fiscal drag because of the freeze on income tax thresholds, and, whether you like it or not, some people on 50k will be struggling.

Pensions and benefits have increased much more in line with inflation than wages have.

We need more productivity and there needs to be incentives to work more and not to be penalised by losing benefits which would de-incentivise people to go for promotions etc.

We need more growth to fund benefits and these should hopefully encourage more activity in the workforce- same with the VAT change.

I second this. It isn't a race to the bottom.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 08/03/2024 18:10

SortUKproblemsfirst · 08/03/2024 17:45

So support those on higher earnings more and not those on lower earnings?

As I said topsy-turvy

Why not? People on low wages get SO much support despite -sometimes- being their choice to work part time. Besides £50k is far from well off. Btw I make under £40k so not even benefiting from that but I think is fair.

jolies1 · 08/03/2024 18:10

Child benefit has effectively been frozen for years, we weren’t entitled as DP earns £60k (and works 60 hour weeks). I’m on SMP so the change will be a real help. When I work FT I’m on £35k. Mortgage is £1300 for a small 3 bed house. Realistically the proposed household income makes the most sense in the long run so single parents earning a decent wage are not penalised and families with one higher earner / one lower are not penalised compared to 2 x earning £49k.

Its the only thing we are entitled to, we don’t qualify for any childcare hours until DC is 3 as in Scotland. It’s the only benefit I will have ever claimed.

Parents happily say they have had it good, both were on average wage salaries their working lives but paid off their mortgage in their 50s, have excellent pensions & got a nice top up of winter fuel + cost of living payment last year which they openly admit they did not need,!

waterlellon · 08/03/2024 18:09

ThisHonestQuail · 08/03/2024 17:52

The state pension is index linked at least, so the pensioners all got a 10% bump last year. Salaries on the other hand are not guaranteed inflationary increases!

This. Their income is the least affected

waterlellon · 08/03/2024 18:08

Pensioners have the triple lock. They are fine

Wakeywake · 08/03/2024 18:05

Those lower earners are already in receipt of child benefit, though. And help with childcare via UC. Middle earners have been shafted for long enough, the changes to child benefit are long overdue.

Barleypilaf · 08/03/2024 18:04

Pensioners have more disposable income on average than working families and massively more wealth. And they have received inflation busting pension increases for years because of the hugely unfair triple-lock. The need to fund the triple lock and the increased NHS costs due to more elderly people has meant below inflation pay rises for public sector workers and very high tax burdens on families.

Of course it is fair that some of the disproportionate burden on working families is reduced.

Pammela2 · 08/03/2024 18:02

I don’t think you should be framing it as an ‘us or them’. There’s a huge issue with fiscal drag because of the freeze on income tax thresholds, and, whether you like it or not, some people on 50k will be struggling.

Pensions and benefits have increased much more in line with inflation than wages have.

We need more productivity and there needs to be incentives to work more and not to be penalised by losing benefits which would de-incentivise people to go for promotions etc.

We need more growth to fund benefits and these should hopefully encourage more activity in the workforce- same with the VAT change.