Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it right the biggest winners im budget

91 replies

SortUKproblemsfirst · 08/03/2024 17:35

So the biggest winners in the recent budget were a couple both earning £60,000. Gaining £5229.

Working parents on £20,000 gained by £594.

Pensioners forgotten.

Seems topsy-turvy.

Aibu to say the Tories really are for putting people down and the leveling up was lies.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fluffykittens208 · 12/03/2024 15:08

WhatShallIdo11 · 09/03/2024 20:06

I'm surprised that people think it's unfair that us pensioners have more disposable income - we have been where you are now but our children are now grown, have families of their own, so are no longer dependent on us. When we got our first house, it was entirely furnished from family cast-offs and secondhand shops. We moved out of London to a much cheaper place 30 minutes up the M1 - replaced stuff as and when money allowed. In those days mortgage interest rates were 16/17%. Cars were old bangers. Didn't have a holiday for many years - we were poor. I think expectations are much higher now - I don't feel bad for not having a mortgage - I've been paying one off for nearly 50 years - I don't feel bad for getting a state pension - I've been paying into it for 50 years - should have got it at 60 but had to wait until 66 after the government changed the rules that were in place when I started my working life doing a very demanding job with some very long days - I still drive an old thoughb

I bought my flat in London (2 bed) in 2019, same age as my mother in law and her ex husband. I was 27, DH was 29 and we bought it with the deposit we saved from cramming in a 2 up 2 down terraced with my MIL and his sisters.

Our income was £75k combined in those days and we bought a flat for 392k so it was 5 times our combined income. my MIL and her ex- they were on combined £22k in 1989 and their London flat was £70k so a little over 3 times combined income. You can see the generational difference from that. My MIL and her ex were a secretary and a legal executive so were in very ordinary jobs.
I was in a junior financial services role and DH worked for an investment bank, was also very junior but the salary was the key to us being able to afford to buy.
We have had pay rises since so we are on combined £120k now and our mortgage is now 2.25 times combined household income but we would have to take a mahoosive mortgage to afford MIL's terraced house (worth £600k today) which she bought 7 years after buying the flat.

Also the sad part- we are the only one of MIL's kids to be able to do this and alot of it was down to luck i.e. meeting early at a young age and being able to stay with family due to our life stage.

mydogisthebest · 10/03/2024 16:49

SgtJuneAckland · 10/03/2024 13:44

@mydogisthebest my parents bought their first house in 1982 and it was almost 4 times my dad's salary, but he worked in a low paid manual job (factory/basic machinist type work) my mum did some secretarial work but was able to give that up when she had me because they could afford to live on just my dad's salary albeit things were tight. When me and DB were both in school she started working again initially cleaning jobs, playgroup assistant etc party time to fit around us.
You couldn't afford a mortgage now with that level of work. We lived in East London.

I am very surprised that your mum could afford not to work if your dad was in a low paid manual job. My mum certainly could not afford not to work. Even with them both working things were very very tight.

When me and DH bought our house in 1981 we could not afford to buy in London and had to move out to Kent. We both had pretty well paid jobs. The mortgage we could get was not even enough for a small 2 bed in Kent even with a decent deposit and we had to borrow from family.

Then, of course, we had all the fun of the mortgage rate going up and up and up and we struggled massively. We were eating beans on toast for our main meal. Your parents were lucky if they did not struggle on only one wage

SgtJuneAckland · 10/03/2024 13:44

@mydogisthebest my parents bought their first house in 1982 and it was almost 4 times my dad's salary, but he worked in a low paid manual job (factory/basic machinist type work) my mum did some secretarial work but was able to give that up when she had me because they could afford to live on just my dad's salary albeit things were tight. When me and DB were both in school she started working again initially cleaning jobs, playgroup assistant etc party time to fit around us.
You couldn't afford a mortgage now with that level of work. We lived in East London.

mydogisthebest · 10/03/2024 12:53

SgtJuneAckland · 08/03/2024 21:42

Most pensioners I know acknowledge that housing was more affordable, it was financially much easier to choose if you had a SAHP because you didn't need two full time salaries to cover costs and therefore didn't need paid childcare, they've also benefited from huge growth in house prices and I'm from a working class, pretty poor background, so people where one person worked in a factory and the other did a bit of cleaning and worked as a dinner lady, could buy a house and go on holiday. 3-4 times one average salary could get you a mortgage, council housing wasn't a pipe dream, your mortgage would likely be paid off by the time you were fifty, you retired at 60/65. Life isn't like that for people now, my parents, aunts, uncles, grandparents all pensioners recognise this.

What period of time are you talking about exactly? Yes houses where cheaper but my mum and dad both worked (mum worked evenings so she could be at home for me and my siblings) and could not afford to buy a house.

We went on holiday a total of 4 times and they were all cheap holidays in the UK.

The only people in my family who bought a house was an aunt and uncle who had a win on the pools.

My dad worked until he was 63 and mum until she was 66.

When me and DH bought our first house in 1981 mortgages were 2 times one salary and 1 and a half times the other so not 3-4 times.

mydogisthebest · 10/03/2024 12:25

T0ASTER · 08/03/2024 18:17

I mean the payments they get for cost of living and fuel. It's not entirely free but they get free money

It ranges between £250 and £600 depending on your circumstances, and this is all tax-free. This amount includes a pensioner cost of living payment, which is between £150 and £300. This is an additional sum for winter 2023/2024 to help pensioners pay for heating bills as the cost of living crisis continues.

Pensioners only got the cost of living payment last year. The normal fuel allowance is only a couple of hundred which doesn't go that far.

It was not only pensioners who received cost of living payment but I assume that is ok with you. My neighbours, neither of whom work even though they could and have 4 children, received far more in cost of living payments than pensioners did. If they continue not to work, which they most likely will, they will still receive benefits when they reach retirement age even though they have never paid a penny into the system. He does work cash in hand 5 days a week though.

I worked 48 years with no break and DH has so far worked 51 years (still working) for our amazingly high state pension (one of the lowest in Europe).

As for the pathetic 1 in 4 pensioner is a millionaire rubbish. Only because their houses are worth a lot so unless they sell up and buy something much cheaper (not feasible for many) it is totally irrelevant.

Not sure where all these rich pensioners are anyway. Where I live there are quite a lot of pensioners living in terraced houses which are worth less than £200,000

JackNoMiddleNameReacher · 10/03/2024 11:47

londonmummy1966 · 09/03/2024 22:26

That's an income before tax etc of £105000 but if each of you earned 55k (an income of £110000 you'd be a lot better off - how can that be fair?

The only alternative in this scenario is to have a single tax rate for everyone and for every penny earned.
We don’t do that and we also have a tax free amount.

londonmummy1966 · 09/03/2024 22:26

T0ASTER · 08/03/2024 20:26

I think with an income of 105k you'll be alright ffs

That's an income before tax etc of £105000 but if each of you earned 55k (an income of £110000 you'd be a lot better off - how can that be fair?

MotherOfRatios · 09/03/2024 21:35

Justpontificating · 09/03/2024 00:46

Ok.@JackNoMiddleNameReacher and @MotherOfRatios
just googled
I was thinking of this scheme.

Shared ownership has a lot of issues, I wouldn't touch it in its current form

WhatShallIdo11 · 09/03/2024 20:06

I'm surprised that people think it's unfair that us pensioners have more disposable income - we have been where you are now but our children are now grown, have families of their own, so are no longer dependent on us. When we got our first house, it was entirely furnished from family cast-offs and secondhand shops. We moved out of London to a much cheaper place 30 minutes up the M1 - replaced stuff as and when money allowed. In those days mortgage interest rates were 16/17%. Cars were old bangers. Didn't have a holiday for many years - we were poor. I think expectations are much higher now - I don't feel bad for not having a mortgage - I've been paying one off for nearly 50 years - I don't feel bad for getting a state pension - I've been paying into it for 50 years - should have got it at 60 but had to wait until 66 after the government changed the rules that were in place when I started my working life doing a very demanding job with some very long days - I still drive an old thoughb

Justpontificating · 09/03/2024 00:46

JackNoMiddleNameReacher · 09/03/2024 00:42

Oh really.
Im clearly not up to date on that then..thanks.
I

Ok.@JackNoMiddleNameReacher and @MotherOfRatios
just googled
I was thinking of this scheme.

Is it right the biggest winners im budget
Is it right the biggest winners im budget
JackNoMiddleNameReacher · 09/03/2024 00:42

MotherOfRatios · 09/03/2024 00:32

HTB worsened the housing market and thankfully it no longer exists

Oh really.
Im clearly not up to date on that then..thanks.
I

MotherOfRatios · 09/03/2024 00:32

Justpontificating · 09/03/2024 00:25

As an aside.
May not be relevant to you.
However
Have you tried the help to buy introduced in 2013.

HTB worsened the housing market and thankfully it no longer exists

HRTQueen · 09/03/2024 00:28

its to hopefully to win over a few voters

and the next government to deal with having to raise taxes

it’s not to help anyone out but the party

Gagagagagaga · 09/03/2024 00:27

According to a rough calculation we will be £2.5k better off a year. Which will go towards private education for our SEN children let down by the state system.

Justpontificating · 09/03/2024 00:25

MotherOfRatios · 08/03/2024 22:00

Budget after budget there's nothing for young people, we are struggling to get on the housing ladder, but you never get headlines about 'nothing for young people' like we have with pensioners.

We have declining fertility rates, we can't afford to have families it's about time younger people got something!

As an aside.
May not be relevant to you.
However
Have you tried the help to buy introduced in 2013.

JackNoMiddleNameReacher · 09/03/2024 00:16

Caravaggiouch · 08/03/2024 21:28

I’m not that poster, but here you go. It was over 1 in 4 in 2022, could well be more now.

https://www.if.org.uk/research-posts/3-million-pensioner-millionaires-identifying-the-numbers/

Yep.
So it’s homes not cash in the bank then.

JackNoMiddleNameReacher · 09/03/2024 00:14

Badgerandfox227 · 08/03/2024 21:51

Pensioners have triple lock. They are about to get a 8.5% increase so they’ve already been looked after. Many are wealthier and get more in pensions than working families.

Middle earners contribute tax, and have been getting very little in return. I think they should be getting child benefit. The cap should have been going up each year in the first place.

Agree.
Middle earners are often left out

A person earning £24,000 with kids is on the same take home as a person on £52,000 with kids when you consider benefits and UC not including housing top ups on rent.

Raising the child benefit limit will support those who have lost out on this for years.

JackNoMiddleNameReacher · 09/03/2024 00:09

T0ASTER · 08/03/2024 17:50

Pensioners are some of the most well off people in the country. More than one in four is a millionaire. They get so much free stuff, I've no idea why you would be saying that is topsy turvy

The figure of 1 in 4 is based on the value of their homes. Not money in the bank though.

PawsisShady · 09/03/2024 00:01

@Moreorlessmentallystable not everyone on a low wage gets so much support as you said
I keep seeing this, but if you don't have children and you earn min wage then no, you don't get "so much support"

T0ASTER · 08/03/2024 22:46

NHStoPrivate · 08/03/2024 21:15

I don't think 1 in 4 pensioners are millionaires either 🧐.

They are

T0ASTER · 08/03/2024 22:46

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 08/03/2024 21:31

@T0ASTER
I'm sorry that you feel it's so unfair that someone who has paid into the system all their lives gets a bus pass. Oh and help with fuel so they don't freeze to death.
Are there no workhouses?

Yes some need it but a massive number do not, they are very rich

INeedToClingToSomething · 08/03/2024 22:32

The child benefit changes were long overdue. And I'm pleased they will be consulting on removing the unfair way it's calculated. It should be on joint income, not one person's income.

I would also have liked to see charges to the 60% "tax trap" for those earning over £100k. Again because it's an unfair way of collecting tax.

The government have been helping the lower paid and on benefits with the Cost of living payments, inflationary increases to benefits (wages haven't done the same) and they are about to increase local housing allowances to bring them more in the line with actual rents which will increase the amount of help with rent people are getting. They've also improved the deduction you get when you work and claim benefits, so you get to keep more of your income. Plus they've increased the help you can get towards childcare costs.

I am NOT a Tory voter and their record on supporting the sick and disabled and other vulnerable members of society is less good but they've done a fair bit to try to support the working poor/lower earners. But you do need to help the middle earners too, they've been increasingly squeezed for a long time now and the cost of living crisis is affecting everyone, and many middle earners have been struggling, It's also important that tax is fair so I support the changes even though I don't benefit. Very aware though that these are blatantly being done to try to win votes!.

MrsDooDaa · 08/03/2024 22:01

Scottishskifun · 08/03/2024 20:39

It needed re-examined as it unfairly hit single parents too. It hadn't gone up since it's introduction which means it was way behind and much less.

It's actually a pretty smart move and will probably generate more tax bizarrely as people less likely to cut hours or not go for promotions because the pay rise tipped them into the bracket and extra tax plus losing CB wasn't worth it to many including critical workers.

This.

The change is not about who needs it most. Obviously those on 60k don't. But the issue is that the CB clawback makes the marginal tax so high its disincentivizes taking on extra work. It you're around the £50k mark, why take on extra stress/hours if you receive so little pay in return?

The high income CB charge was a really poorly thought out policy from the offset for a number of reasons and should be abolished.

MotherOfRatios · 08/03/2024 22:00

Budget after budget there's nothing for young people, we are struggling to get on the housing ladder, but you never get headlines about 'nothing for young people' like we have with pensioners.

We have declining fertility rates, we can't afford to have families it's about time younger people got something!