Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mothers Day should be banned

432 replies

DinnaeFashYersel · 08/03/2024 12:26

Thread after thread on here with Mothers Day drama and grief

Partners who haven't made any plans
Partners whose plans aren't WOW enough
Mothers v MILs
Mothers v Mothers and MILS
Partner isn't making plans for mother of unborn baby
Blended family dramas
The list goes on and on

Post Mothers Day will have the threads

He forgot
It was rubbish compared to the elaborate day he got for Fathers Day
MIL spoiled it
Etc

Its not worth it. It seems to be make so many people unhappy and angry and we'd be better off without.

YABU: its a cherished and important day, how dare you even ask
YANBU: ban it and save us all from the grief and drama

Full disclosure: I celebrate it to the extent that my kids will serve me tea and (burnt) toast in bed. Otherwise its a normal day. And of course I know it won't actually be banned. Its just a discussion.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blondebrunette1 · 13/03/2024 09:45

Lorralorr · 13/03/2024 06:43

Oh yes I don’t mean that at all!

yes I do have a mother in law and we see her on Mother’s Day, I get my kids to do cards for both their grannies and if I had grannies still alive I’d do cards for them.

what I mean is on Mother’s Day I’m not manufacturing my own day out from my husband and kids just to put on instagram - I’m not focusing on me on Mother’s Day, I’m focusing on my mum/MIL.

in ref to the original post, so many posts on mumsnet are basically complaining that Mother’s Day was not ‘special enough’ for THEM - but I always wonder how much thought did they put it to making it special for anyone else? I have a lot of friends that go out for family meal on Mother’s Day… WITHOUT their mum/MIL!

and no I don’t have a daughter in law yet, but when my sons are bigger and if I ever have daughters in law yes it would be nice if they’d send a card or include me in their plans.. can’t force them to but hopefully as they’ve grown up with me thinking about my mum, as I grew up with my mum doing the same, they will…

I understand what you mean, I find the social media stuff really tactless tbh I have many friends who don't need to see an over share about how lucky I am on mother's day. Many have lost their mums, some have lost their children, some are having fertility issues and some have terminal illnesses and are preparing their family for the future some are just scarily broke financially....it's a heartbreaking eye opener into how no one knows what is going on for others and my ego can live without people thinking I'm adored and spoilt by my children.

I say all this but I do feel that not all people who complain about not having enough fuss are being shallow, if they feel under appreciated in their marriage and by their children and in life in general, its not a good place to be. Whilst there are undoubtedly bigger problems to have, no one should have to settle if they aren't aligned with their partner and don't feel happy. Totally a private matter though x

WandaWonder · 13/03/2024 06:46

Isn't it what people make of it and their expectations?

Lorralorr · 13/03/2024 06:43

Blondebrunette1 · 12/03/2024 23:45

🤔 have you not got a nice daughter in law?

It doesn't have to be either or, of course we definitely all should be giving thanks and making a fuss of our own mothers, but in our family we lead the way on mother's and father's days and make an effort to show up for each other as well. We buy for and visit our mom's and also take our grandparents a card and gift. Every mother/father (including ourselves) get recognised in our house because they deserve it. , it's not Your Mother Only Day.

Oh yes I don’t mean that at all!

yes I do have a mother in law and we see her on Mother’s Day, I get my kids to do cards for both their grannies and if I had grannies still alive I’d do cards for them.

what I mean is on Mother’s Day I’m not manufacturing my own day out from my husband and kids just to put on instagram - I’m not focusing on me on Mother’s Day, I’m focusing on my mum/MIL.

in ref to the original post, so many posts on mumsnet are basically complaining that Mother’s Day was not ‘special enough’ for THEM - but I always wonder how much thought did they put it to making it special for anyone else? I have a lot of friends that go out for family meal on Mother’s Day… WITHOUT their mum/MIL!

and no I don’t have a daughter in law yet, but when my sons are bigger and if I ever have daughters in law yes it would be nice if they’d send a card or include me in their plans.. can’t force them to but hopefully as they’ve grown up with me thinking about my mum, as I grew up with my mum doing the same, they will…

Blondebrunette1 · 12/03/2024 23:45

Lorralorr · 12/03/2024 12:42

I am always amazed at the number of mums who think Mother’s Day is all about them - and get upset when their kids and partners don’t do loads of stuff for them.

Mother’s Day is about YOUR OWN MOTHER - you should be buying her flowers and taking her for lunch. And be happy if your kids made you a card at school or thought to buy you a pressie when they’re a bit older. But it’s not for your partner to set you up a whole day when you and he should be doing something nice for your own mums!

🤔 have you not got a nice daughter in law?

It doesn't have to be either or, of course we definitely all should be giving thanks and making a fuss of our own mothers, but in our family we lead the way on mother's and father's days and make an effort to show up for each other as well. We buy for and visit our mom's and also take our grandparents a card and gift. Every mother/father (including ourselves) get recognised in our house because they deserve it. , it's not Your Mother Only Day.

Needmorelego · 12/03/2024 22:21

@Julimia there's a difference between valuing people and treating them properly (which I agree - should be always if they are good people) and having a celebration once in a while.

Julimia · 12/03/2024 22:13

Yes where people value and treat people properly every day. Nothing boring about that.

Needmorelego · 12/03/2024 22:05

@Julimia yes but it's nice to have variety. Do you really want to live in a society where every day is exactly the same?
Boring!
It's nice to change with the seasons and have celebrations and events to look forward to. Otherwise what's the point of life really?

Julimia · 12/03/2024 22:02

Surely the other 364 days in the year are just as important?

SillySausage53 · 12/03/2024 18:44

DinnaeFashYersel · 08/03/2024 12:26

Thread after thread on here with Mothers Day drama and grief

Partners who haven't made any plans
Partners whose plans aren't WOW enough
Mothers v MILs
Mothers v Mothers and MILS
Partner isn't making plans for mother of unborn baby
Blended family dramas
The list goes on and on

Post Mothers Day will have the threads

He forgot
It was rubbish compared to the elaborate day he got for Fathers Day
MIL spoiled it
Etc

Its not worth it. It seems to be make so many people unhappy and angry and we'd be better off without.

YABU: its a cherished and important day, how dare you even ask
YANBU: ban it and save us all from the grief and drama

Full disclosure: I celebrate it to the extent that my kids will serve me tea and (burnt) toast in bed. Otherwise its a normal day. And of course I know it won't actually be banned. Its just a discussion.

Going by your logic you would have to ban Christmas and Birthdays or any family get together because they’re all full of drama and disappointment.

Happyasapiginmuck1 · 12/03/2024 13:29

I spent all weekend in hospital, not what I was planning on but at least I got breakfast in bed!

Lorralorr · 12/03/2024 12:42

I am always amazed at the number of mums who think Mother’s Day is all about them - and get upset when their kids and partners don’t do loads of stuff for them.

Mother’s Day is about YOUR OWN MOTHER - you should be buying her flowers and taking her for lunch. And be happy if your kids made you a card at school or thought to buy you a pressie when they’re a bit older. But it’s not for your partner to set you up a whole day when you and he should be doing something nice for your own mums!

DasAlteLeid · 12/03/2024 12:17

DinnaeFashYersel · 08/03/2024 12:43

Is MD really a Christian Festival? Hadn't heard that one before.

PS - don't agree we are a Christian country but that's another debate (runs away and hides behind the sofa 😂)

It’s not really up to you to agree or not, the King is the head of state and head of the Church of England, ergo it’s a Christian country. I’m always amazed that people don’t seem to know this!

T1Dmama · 12/03/2024 11:51

I think it’s fine not to celebrate it.
my neighbours are JW so don’t celebrate Christmas, Easter, mothers/Father’s Day etc…
I also think it’s fine for others to celebrate it. i saw a
post on Facebook which at first glance confused me… it said “My husbands wife bought me X for Mother’s Day, it’s exactly what I wanted in the size I wanted!”…… I think if women have expectations but don’t have partners or children that bother then they treat themselves! And return the favour on Father’s Day / birthdays etc

Vonesk · 11/03/2024 22:31

I dont even remember Mothers day when I was a child !!!!
Prob It was a normal day , with mum in the kitchen cooking a Sunday Roast with all the trimmings, and dad Down '; the Lane,' then club.

Cat1313 · 11/03/2024 22:21

Got to agree, my mum barely acknowledged my existence when I was growing up, unless she wanted me to do something or to complain that my cleaning wasn't good enough. Yet here I am wasting money on getting her a gift because I feel guilted into it because she has no one else (the golden child emigrated to nz and barely speaks to her) and I spend more on her than is spent on me and she will likely not appreciate it because everything I have got her in my life she later decides she no longer likes or is now allergic to it (jewellery, smellies, thing for house that she already collects, candles, plants, books, clothes) and will only ever except books or puzzles from me without drama, which then disappear into the masses she already has.

Sage71 · 11/03/2024 19:10

Love this, problem is everyone has to post the amazing day they had on socials and everyone obsesses about everyone else’s day because it looks better. We are moving soon so we cleared out the shed then ate things from the freezer as we want to defrost it before we move so three different meals for 4 of us 😂😂😂. It has become way too commercial a homemade card and a cup of tea in bed makes a nice change to normal.

Londonscallingme · 11/03/2024 18:48

My view (if anyone gets to page 17!) is that most of these posts are about shit partners, nothing to do with Mother’s Day. If you have a good partner and you get wound up about Mother’s Day you should have a word with yourself (imo). If you don’t have a good partner, get rid.

naiina · 11/03/2024 18:34

If we went that way, there would be no holidays or events. Truth is, people who have family drama have it most of the time not just on holidays. And unhappy people post online more often than happy people.

Blondebrunette1 · 11/03/2024 17:58

It's not really "mothers day" in school anymore, it's your "special grown up" as not to offend anyone. I've no problem with it, I get the reason for it, not everyone has their mum, my DH always says it's sad father's day is never a thing in school as a very hands on father I get he feels like Dads are the second class parent but he gets it again, not everyone has a Dad.

I think it's pretty commercialised and too much strain for some financially but it's nice for some of us, I personally love it but I'd give it up if it meant others who are missing their mum could feel a little less s* that day, although I can imagine it's not really going to change much for them if we abolish it completely. We will always miss those we've lost. X

Ruminate2much · 11/03/2024 17:08

Allfur · 11/03/2024 10:03

Aren't over worked, undervalued mums allowed one day for themselves?

With the very greatest respect, sincerely, motherhood in the western world is generally a choice. Whereas childlessness often isn't.
Absolutely mothers should be valued immensely; but so should all women. Mothers don't have the monopoly on being overworked, or indeed undervalued.
I just think International Womens Day is a better one, as it unites rather than divides. Also, it doesn't trigger acute anguish in those who've recently lost their mums, as Mothers Day does.
I had a Romanian friend who said International Womens Day is the more celebrated day there, and I hope we follow suite; and leave the archaic Mothering Sunday in the past.
Unchosen childlessness is utter agony at times, and Mothers Day is one such time. Please spare a thought for those who've not enjoyed the same blessings you have.

TheNinny · 11/03/2024 12:25

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/03/2024 10:48

ladyvimes · 08/03/2024 12:33

It’s a Christian ‘festival’ and we’re a Christian country so if we ban Mother’s Day then might as well ban all the other things too: Christmas, Easter, Shrove Tuesday, etc.
Good luck with that”

Is it? I thought it was invented by a Victorian greetings card manufacturer?

“Christmas” and “Easter” festivals are far older than Christianity.

Read some of the previous pages of this thread. This has already been answered/explained several times over. It does have links to Christianity as the day where you’d ’return to your mother church’. Also in the uk, it’s held on the 4th sunday of lent, which explains why the day it’s held in the uk moves around between march/april.

It certainly pre-dates card manufacturing but as to being stolen from pagan festivals is anyone’s guess.

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/03/2024 10:48

ladyvimes · 08/03/2024 12:33

It’s a Christian ‘festival’ and we’re a Christian country so if we ban Mother’s Day then might as well ban all the other things too: Christmas, Easter, Shrove Tuesday, etc.
Good luck with that”

Is it? I thought it was invented by a Victorian greetings card manufacturer?

“Christmas” and “Easter” festivals are far older than Christianity.

pontipinemum · 11/03/2024 10:40

ParrotParrot · 08/03/2024 12:35

Can’t believe how bothered people are about Mother’s Day and it’s not just MN it’s all if we Facebook. Try being a lone parent I will get fuck all on Mother’s Day and really couldn’t care less, seem to be the only one that doesn’t care about it though.

Some day your child might give you something nice. My mam was a sort of lone parent (her parents helped a lot). I sent her a card, covered in pics of me/her and my DS, and a very nice coffee cup for mothers day.

My son is 1.5yrs old he made me a card at nursery and got some daffodils in the garden (yes he did have help 😂) he was very proud of his little card though and I love it

You're right though some of the absolute and upper crap posts I saw in SM would make you roll your eyes

Allfur · 11/03/2024 10:03

Aren't over worked, undervalued mums allowed one day for themselves?

RainbowNinja77 · 11/03/2024 09:58

My step father died yesterday. Just afterwards, me and my mum sat downstairs and just said, “Happy fucking Mother’s Day”. I didn’t really see my own kids.

I don’t think Mother’s Day needs to be gotten rid of. I think the attitude of, “It’s all about meeee” needs to go. The whining posts are from people who make bridezillas because of this attitude. We don’t need to cancel weddings - we just need to chill the f out about times we think we should be the centre of attention and sulk if we arent.