Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Boots move to 5 days a week is a step back for workplace equality

687 replies

Vistada · 08/03/2024 11:54

Boots HQ, a predominantly female workforce - has been told they are to be back in the office five days a week from September with no debate and no real solid reasoning (in my view)

https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/boots-to-end-hybrid-working-for-office-workers/

I think the move to hybrid working is amazing for everyone, not just women, in terms of helping to achieve the work/life/parenting balance that has eluded us for so long, but we can't deny women shoulder this juggling act more.

I think this move, and any move back to 5 days in the office (where its really not needed) is a huge step back for workplace equality - and for a male CEO to enforce this just shows how out of touch he is.

Boots to end hybrid working for office workers

Boots has told thousands of staff that from September they will have to work in the office five days a week.

https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/boots-to-end-hybrid-working-for-office-workers

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Vod · 10/03/2024 10:26

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 10:23

Setting people up at home has huge costs. Companies will not request people back in the office to make a loss or drive up their costs.

Presumably that's a no to you paying more for what you feel entitled to then! What was that about privilege...

But to get back to our previous point, what are organisations supposed to do if they're not able to get the staff they need when they try and enforce office based working? We've already established that they're not supposed to be held to ransom, so what then?

WaterWeasel · 10/03/2024 10:24

Some people on this thread seem to assume that working in an office equals working in a call centre speaking to members of the public all day

🙄

Vod · 10/03/2024 10:23

These discussions always seem to descend into vague, vehemently hopeful 'you'll see' schtick from people who don't like remote working.

ThisHonestQuail · 10/03/2024 10:23

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/03/2024 10:01

But that’s you. I had a very competent colleague in a former workplace that gave up her job because she couldn’t stand working in a noisy open plan office. She was working on highly complex documents for hours on end and the background noise and constant interruption from those around her was too much and destroyed her concentration. It was seriously affecting her mental health so she handed her notice in.

Not really comparable..

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 10:23

Vod · 10/03/2024 10:18

What you have just written here stems from a place of privilege in itself.

Are you going to pay more in order to make it worth those staff's while to pay commuting and childcare costs, or perhaps even to allow them to move to less cramped accommodation since apparently having space for a laptop and headset isn't sufficient for you?

Setting people up at home has huge costs. Companies will not request people back in the office to make a loss or drive up their costs.

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 10:21

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/03/2024 10:15

What is your problem? Why take a swipe at me? I am showing that they have a recruitment problem for this particular role. Almost all of these type of roles in other organisations are offered in a hybrid or full remote basis.

I am replying to you thinking there is an issue because you didn’t take a job. Clearly they think they need and want somebody in the office. They are sticking out for that because they can and are not crumbling because they choose to do so. Companies and service a will decide if they need people onsite, like any job if you feel it’s not for you jog on by. For every person who thinks it’s a deal breaker there will eventually be others who don’t or who at the very least will take the job as it is because they want to pay their bills.

Vod · 10/03/2024 10:21

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/03/2024 10:15

What is your problem? Why take a swipe at me? I am showing that they have a recruitment problem for this particular role. Almost all of these type of roles in other organisations are offered in a hybrid or full remote basis.

It's because the example you provided was inconvenient.

ismu · 10/03/2024 10:20

@Candl3Stix I can't even begin or be bothered to explain all the different jobs that exist in the world. They do not all service your needs.

Vod · 10/03/2024 10:18

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 10:16

Yes yes to this. I frankly don’t want to use services or companies that use people wfh in ever more cramped housing with kids in the background because staff think they can save on childcare .I also don’t want my data in that environment.

What you have just written here stems from a place of privilege in itself.

Are you going to pay more in order to make it worth those staff's while to pay commuting and childcare costs, or perhaps even to allow them to move to less cramped accommodation since apparently having space for a laptop and headset isn't sufficient for you?

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 10:16

Ncncncworkywork · 10/03/2024 10:06

Your privilege is showing, with all this talk of working from the farmstead or work spaces attached to ones (presumably sprawling) house.
Back in reality, most people today live in accommodation that is too small.

Yes yes to this. I frankly don’t want to use services or companies that use people wfh in ever more cramped housing with kids in the background because staff think they can save on childcare .I also don’t want my data in that environment.

ismu · 10/03/2024 10:16

@Ncncncworkywork I don't agree with your point about accommodation being too small.
We don't see anything wrong with expecting students to study and work in their rooms with optional trips to libraries etc if they want a change.
So for young people starting out in offices most of whom have been in uni, wfh is an easy transition.
In-office days need to add value, and be something that can't be done alone at a desk ( including calls and teams meetings).
if you're paying someone to do written tasks that require concentration you need to provide a quiet comfortable and distraction free environment- and wfh does that very effectively.

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/03/2024 10:15

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 10:12

And the company is clearly not crumbling without you.

What is your problem? Why take a swipe at me? I am showing that they have a recruitment problem for this particular role. Almost all of these type of roles in other organisations are offered in a hybrid or full remote basis.

EasterIssland · 10/03/2024 10:15

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 10:12

And the company is clearly not crumbling without you.

But they’re understaffed and the people currently working there have to pick up the work load of this role that has been available for a year

Vod · 10/03/2024 10:13

Ncncncworkywork · 10/03/2024 10:06

Your privilege is showing, with all this talk of working from the farmstead or work spaces attached to ones (presumably sprawling) house.
Back in reality, most people today live in accommodation that is too small.

Yes, yes, subsistence farmers and people working in factories during the Industrial Revolution were profoundly privileged, and I fall into both of those categories apparently.

But your claim about most people living in accommodation that's too small to work remotely is the sort of thing that needs proving.

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/03/2024 10:12

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 10/03/2024 10:07

Doesn’t necessarily work for the consumer though, you getting the work done when it suits you.

But @Dibblydoodahdah has said nothing to indicate that she’s in a consumer-facing role. I get that if you’re in a role where you need to be available for customers and clients during set hours, it’s not practical to say “Yes, I know I wasn’t there at 4 when needed, but I did some filing at 7 to make up for for it”. But if you’re working on a project with a deadline, does it matter if you do the work to meet that deadline at 9am or 9pm - as long as you do it and meet it?

Exactly. I don’t have anything to do with consumers. My contract is for a number of hours per week. I don’t have fixed working hours in my contract because it requires flexibility working across multiple time zones. Some people on this thread seem to assume that working in an office equals working in a call centre speaking to members of the public all day. The rest of my core team are based in another continent. It’s not physically possible for me to
commute to them everyday!

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 10:12

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/03/2024 10:04

There may not be an epidemic but I applied for a role last year which was advertised as hybrid. In reality it was an option to work one day from home per week. They are still advertising for that role almost a year later.

And the company is clearly not crumbling without you.

Psyberbaby · 10/03/2024 10:11

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 10/03/2024 10:07

Doesn’t necessarily work for the consumer though, you getting the work done when it suits you.

But @Dibblydoodahdah has said nothing to indicate that she’s in a consumer-facing role. I get that if you’re in a role where you need to be available for customers and clients during set hours, it’s not practical to say “Yes, I know I wasn’t there at 4 when needed, but I did some filing at 7 to make up for for it”. But if you’re working on a project with a deadline, does it matter if you do the work to meet that deadline at 9am or 9pm - as long as you do it and meet it?

In my freelance work I've worked evenings/nights to hit a deadline the next morning, because I didn't want to work during the day. It is a massive risk though as if something goes wrong that prevents you progressing (someone's sent the wrong file, the system is inaccessible, you have a crucial question for the end client), there is nobody available to help and you can look like a dick

Ihearditfrommyradio · 10/03/2024 10:10

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 09:19

Waiting for a bus is real life. We’re seriously up shit creek if perfectly healthy people can’t wait for buses now. I have to get up at 6 and do a 45 minute commute every day. I don’t leap out of bed full of joy but think about what I have to be grateful for and enjoy the less sucky parts of my day even more. If waiting for a bus impinges your mental health you have mental health issues aside from WFH and that is a separate issue.

There's a difference between catching, reliable and regular public transport , and waiting on a whim and a prayer for a bus in a crumbling public transport era and not knowing whether you are going to get to work on time or not. Regular and consistent public transport can be quite pleasant, time to read or do a puzzle or chat with an aquaintance.

However, Yes, people do regularly wait an hour for a bus that never turns up..workplace is too far to walk and driving isn't an option either.. I am that person. If I left for work any earlier than I do now I might as well just camp there overnight.

It does cause stress and anxiety - mental health issues .

Public transport is just another part of our infrastructure that has collapsed over the last 10 years.

If I can have just 2 days a week respite from this stress then my health improves enormously.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 10/03/2024 10:07

Doesn’t necessarily work for the consumer though, you getting the work done when it suits you.

But @Dibblydoodahdah has said nothing to indicate that she’s in a consumer-facing role. I get that if you’re in a role where you need to be available for customers and clients during set hours, it’s not practical to say “Yes, I know I wasn’t there at 4 when needed, but I did some filing at 7 to make up for for it”. But if you’re working on a project with a deadline, does it matter if you do the work to meet that deadline at 9am or 9pm - as long as you do it and meet it?

Ncncncworkywork · 10/03/2024 10:06

Vod · 10/03/2024 10:03

Very much so. Most working humans going into a physical workplace away from their home to do their work is a pretty new development in the grand scheme of things. It didn't come about because its an inherently wonderful or superior model, it came about as more and more work required equipment and setups that couldn't fit in people's homes. There's no particular reason for it to continue to be the default when that's not the case.

I quite understand that some people have a preference for it and find they work better, which is fair enough. But far too many of the claims people are making go way beyond that. And honestly, a lot of this comes down to people not being happy that they're less able to buy other people's labour than they were 5 years ago because of significant structural changes.

Your privilege is showing, with all this talk of working from the farmstead or work spaces attached to ones (presumably sprawling) house.
Back in reality, most people today live in accommodation that is too small.

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/03/2024 10:04

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 09:45

Not seeing this epidemic in the world of work re companies and services unable to fill roles because people want to work from home and would rather be out of work and unable to pay bills than leave the house for work. That doesn’t sound mentally sound which is again an issue aside from WFH.

There may not be an epidemic but I applied for a role last year which was advertised as hybrid. In reality it was an option to work one day from home per week. They are still advertising for that role almost a year later.

Vod · 10/03/2024 10:03

ismu · 10/03/2024 09:58

I'm not sure how sitting in an office is more normal than wfh, in the scheme of things. For most of human history people have actually worked from home in some way, as farmers or creating things in a workshop attached to their home. We haven't had mass "offices " for more than about 150 years. It's a factory model which assumes that true work is only done under strict supervision and paid by the amount of time an employee is present. At best it treats employees like dependent children and relies on perks and good salaries to make it worthwhile.
If you think that this is a better model than working as a trusted and independent artisan creating a product that you sell to the highest bidder, you'll love being in offices.

Very much so. Most working humans going into a physical workplace away from their home to do their work is a pretty new development in the grand scheme of things. It didn't come about because its an inherently wonderful or superior model, it came about as more and more work required equipment and setups that couldn't fit in people's homes. There's no particular reason for it to continue to be the default when that's not the case.

I quite understand that some people have a preference for it and find they work better, which is fair enough. But far too many of the claims people are making go way beyond that. And honestly, a lot of this comes down to people not being happy that they're less able to buy other people's labour than they were 5 years ago because of significant structural changes.

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/03/2024 10:01

ThisHonestQuail · 10/03/2024 09:45

Yep, my MH nosedives if I’m not in the office regularly. Sitting in your spare room on your own all day is not normal!

But that’s you. I had a very competent colleague in a former workplace that gave up her job because she couldn’t stand working in a noisy open plan office. She was working on highly complex documents for hours on end and the background noise and constant interruption from those around her was too much and destroyed her concentration. It was seriously affecting her mental health so she handed her notice in.

Vod · 10/03/2024 09:59

Candl3Stix · 10/03/2024 09:45

Not seeing this epidemic in the world of work re companies and services unable to fill roles because people want to work from home and would rather be out of work and unable to pay bills than leave the house for work. That doesn’t sound mentally sound which is again an issue aside from WFH.

There are people who've talked about it in this thread. It doesn't matter whether you personally have seen it. None of us can possibly have sufficiently wide experience to know what's going on in every aspect of recruitment.

So again, what should a company do if they're faced with this situation? You clearly thought it was a realistic enough scenario to speak about what organisations should do.

ismu · 10/03/2024 09:58

I'm not sure how sitting in an office is more normal than wfh, in the scheme of things. For most of human history people have actually worked from home in some way, as farmers or creating things in a workshop attached to their home. We haven't had mass "offices " for more than about 150 years. It's a factory model which assumes that true work is only done under strict supervision and paid by the amount of time an employee is present. At best it treats employees like dependent children and relies on perks and good salaries to make it worthwhile.
If you think that this is a better model than working as a trusted and independent artisan creating a product that you sell to the highest bidder, you'll love being in offices.