Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Boots move to 5 days a week is a step back for workplace equality

687 replies

Vistada · 08/03/2024 11:54

Boots HQ, a predominantly female workforce - has been told they are to be back in the office five days a week from September with no debate and no real solid reasoning (in my view)

https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/boots-to-end-hybrid-working-for-office-workers/

I think the move to hybrid working is amazing for everyone, not just women, in terms of helping to achieve the work/life/parenting balance that has eluded us for so long, but we can't deny women shoulder this juggling act more.

I think this move, and any move back to 5 days in the office (where its really not needed) is a huge step back for workplace equality - and for a male CEO to enforce this just shows how out of touch he is.

Boots to end hybrid working for office workers

Boots has told thousands of staff that from September they will have to work in the office five days a week.

https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/boots-to-end-hybrid-working-for-office-workers

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 13:09

AgainYes · 08/03/2024 13:04

I am sorry he is like that. I worked on the wards during Covid and my husband took over all the cooking. I would not have tolerated less.

Sorry for what? He literally does everything!

I was making the point that “popping a wash on” doesn’t have to be during the day when WFH.

PieAndLattes · 08/03/2024 13:08

I have zero problem with this. I’ve started going in most days voluntarily. It has had a huge impact on my engagement, productivity and mood. I’m not just ‘getting my jobs done’ anymore. I’m engaging positively with my work and enjoying it more. I’m not distracted by getting a laundry in and I’m sitting in a room where we’re all interested in each other’s work so it’s sparking new ideas. When I’m in the office I go into ‘work mode’ and am absorbed in it. I’m also eating a lot less because I can’t go to the fridge every time I get bored, so that’s a bonus.

Some people are still pushing for fully remote work, mostly because they applied for jobs during lockdown even though they lived far away and assumed things would stay online, but our contracts have always stated that employees should be living within 50 miles of the workplace (there is a relocation scheme to support moving) and that never changed. We can see that hybrid meetings are nowhere near as good as fully online or fully face to face, and face to face is better than online unless it’s a short operational meeting. Yes, hybrid/fully at home jobs make it easier to perform domestic duties and errands, but that’s really not the employer’s concern.

Pushtart · 08/03/2024 13:07

Fully WFH is detrimental in most jobs for most people as far as actual work is concerned.

I don't think thats accurate, are you basing this on any data? Because what I have seen is that it hasn't overall reduced productivity and in many cases colleagues feel like they know each other better as they are in their own homes and talk about the cats walking across the screen or the dog in the background etc its just created a different culture, and its a culture a lot of people prefer. I think companies should think about the happiness of their employees, the new culture created over the last almost 4 years and what benefits it brings not only to their company and workforce, but to wider society.

Ilikewinter · 08/03/2024 13:04

custardcreamed · 08/03/2024 12:15

I’ve name changed, for obvious reasons, but long time user.

I work for Boots, at this office. I am absolutely affected by this and getting my ducks in a row to leave.

Its totally driven by one woman who is stuck in the dinosaur ages, and asks senior staff to fly to Europe from Nottingham for a one hour meeting in person because she refuses to see the benefit of working over teams.

As for us one comment I’ve seen so far about us perhaps not being ‘productive’, considering we’ve worked bloody well remotely and then in a hybrid set up for the last 4 years, and still delivered better-than-expected growth year after year, I’d say that’s not the case here.

And to add to this joke of a company, we’ve been receiving emails all week about IWD and how ‘inclusive’ the company is 😂

They have also removed remote working and compressed hours from the flexible working policy and will no longer allow them to even be requested, let allow given as an option.

The entire office is in uproar, to say the least.

Ex Boots employee here! .... I was store based so obviously no option for hybrid or WFH BUT I stand in solidarity with you! .... Boots is honestly a shit show of a company and after 20 years service I skipped out of there. Good luck with your new job search

AgainYes · 08/03/2024 13:04

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 12:41

My DH is the default parent. Last 2 years I’ve been in a national role and away from home at least 50% of the time. Was in the NHS during Covid, working 16 hours a day 7 days a week on site to make sure people were safe. Now I’m away 3-4 days a week. He has WFH for years. Still doesn’t do housework during the day (washing goes in when he’s cooking dinner and out at bedtime).

I am sorry he is like that. I worked on the wards during Covid and my husband took over all the cooking. I would not have tolerated less.

piealhxiprshl · 08/03/2024 13:03

I have noticed with friends that wfh they are now starting to spend more time in the work place but with flexitime.

I've always had flexitime. Yes it's useful, but flexitime and WFH works better for me...

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 13:02

My employer can’t sublet office space for security reasons. (Crown estate.)

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 13:01

WFH keeps women in work, is therefore good for the economy

we have a men problem.

piealhxiprshl · 08/03/2024 13:01

Women did manage to work 5 days per week in an office, or indeed, other work places before Covid

And I've been promoted twice since Covid due to the ease in which I have been able to move jobs and increase responsibility as a result of the flexibility has given me. No that absolutely would NOT have happened to me pre covid.

LakieLady · 08/03/2024 13:01

But, I think it’s to do with empty office space as posters upthread have said. Why pay for office space that’s only being used 2-3 days a week?

My employers have sublet 25% of the office space. On midweek days, you can't get a room for a meeting and there have been times when people have rocked up only to find they can't get a desk. I've seen people working in the staff kitchen as a result.

They'd have to have a desk booking system if they enforced the 70% rule.

Goblinmodeactivated · 08/03/2024 12:57

innerdesign · 08/03/2024 12:04

I think we do need to move back to the office being the norm, mainly because it'll become difficult/impossible to recruit people to jobs which require FT face to face attendance. Why train as a teacher or doctor or dentist or pharmacist, when you could get a WFH office job that pays roughly the same and never have to commute etc? I wonder if Boots have had issues recruiting to store/pharmacy based positions as the WFH positions are more attractive.

The women of Boots should work in the office 5 days a week otherwise we won’t be able to recruit enough doctors? This is nonsense. The reason for the change as PP have said is boots is now owned by a US company, importing their toxic culture of presenteeism in the process. WFH keeps women in work, is therefore good for the economy (backed by recent research). Retrograde misogynist step backwards to roll this back now.

Switcher · 08/03/2024 12:55

What amazes me in these debates is the non acknowledgement of our country's housing problems and logistical mess. We've priced nearly everyone in a normal job with a family out of London, but all the jobs are in London, and the train services get worse every year. Then we start crazy white elephant infrastructure projects like HS2 that make Euston into an absolute shitshow, and then instead of seeing home working as part of the answer, at least for now, it's cast as this terrible aberration that saps productivity. What saps my productivity is the 4 hours I spend commuting each day. Like fuck am I going to put any extra hours in at work like I did when I was WFH.

custardcreamed · 08/03/2024 12:53

Vistada · 08/03/2024 12:51

Again, for the avoidance of doubt.

This debate is around hybrid working

Office days have value, but why do we need five?

And just to be clear - this is what Boots staff have been relatively happy with, and would prefer to keep.

We just want some degree of flexibility to allow us to have the best work/life balance we can whilst doing our jobs well and in a happy environment. 5 days a week in the office is not that.

Iamanunsafebuilding · 08/03/2024 12:52

@redalex261 totally agree with your post!

badrelationship · 08/03/2024 12:51

With my career WFH is very rare. I need to be physically in my work place to do the job. There are a few jobs the allow me to WFH and I did do this for while and I agree that work life balance is much better and managing other commitments is easier but I felt isolated and needed to get out the house. I was sick of looking at my own home and only seeing DH daily. My job was always long days and I hated 5 day weeks but now I do 4 long days and get an extra day off.

I have noticed with friends that wfh they are now starting to spend more time in the work place but with flexitime. Is this something that has been mentioned? This allows them to negotiate childcare etc with partners. I don't think going back to an office environment is going backwards but the traditional 9-5 is. Companies need to be more flexible with days worked or times worked. Either allowing people to do condensed days with longer shifts to allow an extra day off or flexible time so they have to be at the office between certain times and can then make up the hours outwith that eg 2 long days and 3 short or whatever works.

Likely with a company like boots they are maybe trying to ensure all jobs are equal, why should office staff get to stay home when customer facing positions needs to be in the office/store/pharmacy.

Vistada · 08/03/2024 12:51

Again, for the avoidance of doubt.

This debate is around hybrid working

Office days have value, but why do we need five?

OP posts:
redalex261 · 08/03/2024 12:50

Fully WFH is detrimental in most jobs for most people as far as actual work is concerned. Staff end up isolated, disengaged and unmotivated. People often work in unsuitable surroundings at home without proper equipment - dining chairs, no desk, off tiny laptops instead of full size screens. Distractions like pets, undone household chores and children - how on earth are people working at reasonable capacity with kids around for some or even all of the time?

There is reduced collaboration too, and it is (let’s face it) a lazy bastard’s charter. How often do you call someone (always the same someones) who is green on teams and there’s no reply?

Hybrid is a great balance - around 40% in office is ideal to foster collaboration and engagement, and complex work can be focussed on in peace at home (if you get peace at home).

It will be ruined though. Those who started bleating as soon as asked to return to office a percentage of their working week will ruin it for everyone. You know who they are - all have sudden impediments to coming in two days a week when they managed five a couple of years ago. They have anxiety, have one-legged grannies with dementia requiring care, neurodiverse kids, neurodiverse themselves (recent diagnosis via internet of course) hampering their ardent desire “to come in just like everyone else, it’s not that I don’t WANT to come to the office…..” It’s also hard to manage - folks on my office complain about those who make excuses/just don’t come in. Managers have to discuss this with complainants and perpetrators, and rnd up policing attendance.

Anyway, I digress. People are right. The Boots CEO probably does think some staff are skiving at home and want bums on seats to ensure they get value for money. They will be right in a small but significant number of cases. It’s not fair, but not really surprising.

Vistada · 08/03/2024 12:50

The only green shoot here is that from April the onus will be on the employer to prove why they cant accommodate a flexible working request rather than on the employee to prove why they need it.

And an answer of "because we'd have to do it for everyone" won't be allowed to stand, as everyones circumstances need to be taken in isolation

OP posts:
DarkGlassesAndHat · 08/03/2024 12:49

Everyone claims to be more productive when WFH but the reality is the vast majority of individuals are not, coupled with the fact that collaboration and team work suffers hugely, regardless of what employees claim.

I work in consulting and the number of companies wanting help to recover their productivity losses since WFH became such a 'thing' is incredible.

We see it across industries and all over the world; WFH is not good for output.

Yes there are some 'soft' benefits in terms of incentivising high value employees and retention rates, etc. but for the majority of businesses it's detrimental.

Trying to portray this as an attack on women is, frankly, a bit pathetic.

Badburyrings · 08/03/2024 12:46

Overtheatlantic · 08/03/2024 12:12

But if you are WFH you shouldn’t be spending time with your son.

I am pretty sure they mean spending the time with their son INSTEAD of using that time to commute.

custardcreamed · 08/03/2024 12:46

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 12:42

Most of those could be dealt with by a flexible working request.

Right, and Boots have limited this further though. There are also a good few examples of people putting (considerate, and justified) requests in and having them rejected.

The only other option is reducing hours, which may not be financially viable for a lot of us considering how much we’re paid (or not).

EasterIssland · 08/03/2024 12:45

Overtheatlantic · 08/03/2024 12:12

But if you are WFH you shouldn’t be spending time with your son.

But if I was in the office then I’d be leaving home at 7 and getting home at 6.
wfh I can drop him off school. Start work at 9 and pick him up by 5ish. So it’s 2hours extra I spend with him or doing whatever I want rather than commuting

spookehtooth · 08/03/2024 12:44

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 12:27

Oft trotted out. Presumably on the basis of fewer cars on the road.

nobody ever considers the environmental impact of running offices for 20-50% of staff whilst the other 50-80% are heating their individual homes.

Is shrinking office size that unreasonable, or other creative ideas to pool resources between companies? That's what BP were busy doing about a decade ago, along with providing very high quality hybrid meeting rooms for a combination of in person and remote attendees in their offices. A lot of people hate hybrid meetings, but that's almost certainly because they're subjected a ad-hoc attempts using inappropriate facilities or crap equipment.

Someone else mentioned less interaction between colleagues, that's a culture thing. My team is fully remote but very chatty and more than enough meetings 🤣 What companies are finding, in my opinion, is that it's not magic, it doesn't happen organically because people aren't used to it and the challenges are different. They need to understand the challenges and tackle them

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 12:42

custardcreamed · 08/03/2024 12:41

Also aside from the obvious impact that this has (disproportionately) on women, there’s also those who are ND and focus better at home to avoid burnout, those who are caregivers who have caring responsibilities they have to fit in around work, parents (both women and men) who aren’t able to use or afford wrap around childcare, and junior colleagues who don’t get paid enough (especially now with COL increasing) to cover the increase in fuel costs or public transport that this is going to cause.

The world has changed a lot in 4 years, but it seems like they don’t want to. This is why we’re angry.

Most of those could be dealt with by a flexible working request.

roundcork · 08/03/2024 12:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.