Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Boots move to 5 days a week is a step back for workplace equality

687 replies

Vistada · 08/03/2024 11:54

Boots HQ, a predominantly female workforce - has been told they are to be back in the office five days a week from September with no debate and no real solid reasoning (in my view)

https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/boots-to-end-hybrid-working-for-office-workers/

I think the move to hybrid working is amazing for everyone, not just women, in terms of helping to achieve the work/life/parenting balance that has eluded us for so long, but we can't deny women shoulder this juggling act more.

I think this move, and any move back to 5 days in the office (where its really not needed) is a huge step back for workplace equality - and for a male CEO to enforce this just shows how out of touch he is.

Boots to end hybrid working for office workers

Boots has told thousands of staff that from September they will have to work in the office five days a week.

https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/boots-to-end-hybrid-working-for-office-workers

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
OneNightWasShitWhereWasTheTwist · 08/03/2024 14:30

innerdesign · 08/03/2024 12:04

I think we do need to move back to the office being the norm, mainly because it'll become difficult/impossible to recruit people to jobs which require FT face to face attendance. Why train as a teacher or doctor or dentist or pharmacist, when you could get a WFH office job that pays roughly the same and never have to commute etc? I wonder if Boots have had issues recruiting to store/pharmacy based positions as the WFH positions are more attractive.

Those jobs will need to pay more. Nurses/teachers etc should be paid more anyway but the less attractive jobs like retail, shelf stacking etc should pay better than they do anyway.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 08/03/2024 14:30

To those who say people can’t be monitored WFH. Surely there’s a job op/business op right there, obviously not too hard core but enough to monitor effectively.

A NDN/friend works for Barclays Bank as a cashier/teller/greeter and wasn’t happy (rightly so) as on her one day wfh she was monitored like a hawk. She’s now happy to be in the office full time.

I’m 52 and me and my 2 best friends of the same age, 2 of us prefer hybrid, ideally 3 or 2 days at home and the other prefers wfh all the time. We’ve been in the office and commuted since we were young so have done all the office culture thing and socialising so it’s not really relevant to us now.

And if slackers, people who use wfh for baby/childcare want to ruin it for most of us, that’s up to them, but impacts on those who do wfh effectively.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/03/2024 14:30

ThisHonestQuail · 08/03/2024 13:49

Why is it better for women to work from home? So that they have more time to clean, cook, do life admin?? Why aren’t the men doing these?? I think what should be said is that it suits parents to work from home more.

FWIW I am a woman and hate wfh.

I think this is an issue with some parents (could be either sex, but mothers do more childcare) expecting the other to be at home for certain tasks. It is a bit of a return to the kitchen for some women.

I live in a country where there is no school on Wednesdays and most of the mothers wfh on Wednesdays. Many of the fathers too, but it's noticeable with mothers, even those with teenagers.

Vod · 08/03/2024 14:29

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 14:27

there haven’t been mass above-inflation pay rises for anyone.

Didn't say there had been. I said some organisations will actually be paying their staff more, occasionally even in real terms, but that doesn't mean they'll be able to get them back into the office without coughing up for the privilege.

IWouldRatherBeOnHoliday · 08/03/2024 14:29

VestibuleVirgin · 08/03/2024 12:00

Women did manage to work 5 days per week in an office, or indeed, other work places before Covid

I think this comment doesn't really cover the nuances.

Yes, some women with caring responsibilities did work 5 days in an office pre-covid. Others worked part time, and others felt they couldn't work at all.

WFH has given many women (and men) the chance to claw back their lunch hours and commuting time to fit in caring responsibilities and household jobs.

I don't have a baby yet, but our plan was always for me to go back 3 days a week. With WFH 2 days a week, and the other flexibilities my job offers, I would be able to work 32 hours over 4 days (FT is 37hrs). This will make a massive difference to take home pay and also give me more opportunities to carry on progressing my career. Part of this is also based on my husband working from home two days a week and therefore being available for childcare before 9am and after 5pm on those days.

I am sure many others will tell you that life will be a more difficult, or they will have to reduce hours/change jobs if their WFH options were taken away.

Progress in modern society is facilitating a happier and more fulfilling life for everyone. Job flexibility is a key part of this for many people.

Vod · 08/03/2024 14:28

innerdesign · 08/03/2024 14:26

@Vod But what that means is that jobs that need to be done in specific times and places will have to pay more or go unfilled,

@GwenhwyfarThen pay more for the in person ones.

The jobs I listed are education and healthcare. Public sector, essential workers. Jobs that cannot go unfilled but also realistically will not be paid more due to being government funded.

Realistically, jobs that can be done remotely now to the agreement of both employer and employees are not going to move back to the office so the state finds it easier to recruit sufficient teachers without paying them more, though. That is not one of the options that we are choosing from.

Which does in fact mean we pay more or do without, because this is a capitalist society and that's how supply and demand works. Unless you were planning a move to a command economy, which I think is rather unlikely.

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 14:27

Vod · 08/03/2024 14:07

Inflation.

But it's about supply and demand really. Some organisations can get people back into offices without paying any more. Others can't. For the latter group, they've got a choice to make, and it's not going to make any difference that they haven't reduced salaries themselves. Some will even have increased them.

there haven’t been mass above-inflation pay rises for anyone.

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 14:26

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 08/03/2024 14:24

Exactly. Companies want their staff to think it’s okay to say “Well, this was the contract you signed in 2017, so we’re simply enforcing it” - but there’s a principle known as Custom and Practice of which these companies should be aware. Or more likely, of which they ARE aware, but hope their employees don’t understand.

I doubt C+P would stand up given the motivator was lockdown and companies had no choice.

Tangled123 · 08/03/2024 14:26

I have one day a week at home and don’t want any more. However, I would not want to go back to the office full time. Being set up for WFH means I can still work if I’m sick, there’s bad weather or I have to do childcare because my daughter’s nursery is closed. I get an extra 30 minutes for myself per WFH day, and I feel more rested/productive when I go back to the office. My workplace is also very rural, so I prefer being at home anyway due to the better lunch options. I also get to keep my house as warm as I want, keep the windows shut and work in silence if that’s what I want. I think one day a week is perfect.

innerdesign · 08/03/2024 14:26

@Vod But what that means is that jobs that need to be done in specific times and places will have to pay more or go unfilled,

@GwenhwyfarThen pay more for the in person ones.

The jobs I listed are education and healthcare. Public sector, essential workers. Jobs that cannot go unfilled but also realistically will not be paid more due to being government funded.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 08/03/2024 14:24

Vistada · 08/03/2024 12:26

regardless of what contract you signed, a shift in working pattern of this magnitude for four years cannot be ignored, peoples lives have organically changed around hybrid and home working - it would be impossible for it not to.

Exactly. Companies want their staff to think it’s okay to say “Well, this was the contract you signed in 2017, so we’re simply enforcing it” - but there’s a principle known as Custom and Practice of which these companies should be aware. Or more likely, of which they ARE aware, but hope their employees don’t understand.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/03/2024 14:21

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 12:27

Oft trotted out. Presumably on the basis of fewer cars on the road.

nobody ever considers the environmental impact of running offices for 20-50% of staff whilst the other 50-80% are heating their individual homes.

Yes, and many offices don't have flexible enough systems to only have heating and light on in certain rooms.
There is also the need for cloud servers etc. for people working from home.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/03/2024 14:18

custardcreamed · 08/03/2024 12:21

I would say we are definitely not lazier.

The majority of people work longer because we aren’t stuck in traffic, or having to work 15 minutes from the car park to the office because the main car park is full 🤷🏼‍♀️

Well that is an argument AGAINST working from home, not FOR it!

JackNoMiddleNameReacher · 08/03/2024 14:17

Our Boots now shut for an hour after lunchtime due to staff shortages.
Maybe they are not making as much money as before.

Technically the only difference is not having to travel to work as WFH still have to put in the hours.

Maybe they have noticed a reduction in productivity.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/03/2024 14:17

KnittedCardi · 08/03/2024 12:12

The UK is, as usual, out of step with the rest of Europe and the world in general, where everyone is back to "normal" pre-Covid working patterns. Yes, to flexible working when it is sustainable, and reasonable, and on a case by case basis, but the blanket wfh has to cease.

How do you mean?
The rest of Europe has teleworking just the same as the UK.

Piscosourr · 08/03/2024 14:16

If you can't trust your employees not to skive when working from home then you have an employee issue and that needs to be managed on a case by case basis. The same any other competency issues. I WFH permanently and I would never work in a job again that was full time in the office. Luckily the organisation I work for us very forward thinking with flexi and WFH. We have casework based work so I am responsible for my own clients. It would be clear to management if I wasn't doing my work. I am definitely more productive at home and my stats prove this.

I don't get the networking and team building being an issue. I have a good working relationship with both my team and the wider team. Some of these people I have never met face to face.

My DM WFH yet every month she has to go into a city Centre for an area team meeting. As the job covers a wide area she has to allow a 2 hour commute....that is 4 hours that could have been spent working when they would be perfectly capable of having the meetings over Teams. I think this is madness.

At the end of the day it is the efficient hardworking staff that know their worth that will likely quit the companies that treat their staff like this. They will be the ones motivated enough to seek out alternative WFH employment. Leaving the companies that feel they can't trust their staff and therefore treat them like children to limp on with the deadwood that remains. It is just as easy to slack off work in the office as it is WFH. I am sure we have all worked with colleagues like this in offices before.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/03/2024 14:15

Iamanunsafebuilding · 08/03/2024 12:09

My manager has just mandated that we're to go to the office one day a week where we had no enforcement before. It's nothing to do with presenteeism or checking up on the volume of work anyone is doing, it's because the collaboration of team members is dropping away and some people are really disengaged. People are making mistakes and not working in a consistent way because they won't reach out to colleagues when they wfh.

I honestly believe coming into the office regularly is a good thing and if some people refuse to engage with their team then more places will mandate it

I agree, but the post isn't about that. It's about every day being compulsory at the office.

UnbelievableLie · 08/03/2024 14:14

Interesting people said it's to reduce headcount without redundancies. Because the absolute stupidity of that is that it will be mostly their top performers who leave and they'll be stuck with the others having to pick up... Redundancies instead allow you to get the lower performers or non essential roles out of the business. But creating a shit workplace to reduce costs is insanity.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/03/2024 14:14

innerdesign · 08/03/2024 12:04

I think we do need to move back to the office being the norm, mainly because it'll become difficult/impossible to recruit people to jobs which require FT face to face attendance. Why train as a teacher or doctor or dentist or pharmacist, when you could get a WFH office job that pays roughly the same and never have to commute etc? I wonder if Boots have had issues recruiting to store/pharmacy based positions as the WFH positions are more attractive.

Then pay more for the in person ones.

butterpuffed · 08/03/2024 14:14

The main inequality I see is that workers in the Boots shops are probably paid less than the office workers and obviously have never had the choice of being able to work from home .

5YearsLeft · 08/03/2024 14:13

Vistada · 08/03/2024 12:28

omg nine consecutive quarters of LUCK! How lucky can one company be!

Do me a favour.

I swear, I’m not trying to be funny, but I looked at their accounts on Company House. Their clean and clear profit for 2021 was NEGATIVE £111 million. So, over £100m in the red. So all you have to do is earn a dollar more for each of the next nine quarters to accomplish this “luck.” I appreciate they PR-washed it, but… they had nowhere to go but up or bankruptcy. That said, their clear profit for 2022 was only £15m; not so good. There is no way this is a healthy company - a healthy company doesn’t need to close 300 stores. And I think the CEO’s statement is absolute BS; I’m sure all their workers know it. They’re trying to force people into the office out of fear that they’re not wringing every last drop of productivity out of them and that they the financial stats be recovering faster if they did. As they said at the end of that article, most offices that are forcing their workers back are doing it out of some belief in productivity - it DOES NOT mean they’re right, but that seems to be what they believe.

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 08/03/2024 14:11

@Vistada sorry but parenting should not ever come into it!! you are either working or your are parenting outside working hours. you cannot work while looking after children. this is not fair on the employer because you are only half paying attention to your work!

Vod · 08/03/2024 14:07

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 13:55

If companies want to send everyone back into offices full time they'll need to stump up realistic salary increases to cover the costs of travel.

Who reduced salaries?

Inflation.

But it's about supply and demand really. Some organisations can get people back into offices without paying any more. Others can't. For the latter group, they've got a choice to make, and it's not going to make any difference that they haven't reduced salaries themselves. Some will even have increased them.

Terraria · 08/03/2024 14:07

May be they will reconsider if they can not find people to fill those roles.

That's what happened in companies I worked/work for.

OneMoreTime23 · 08/03/2024 14:06

ismu · 08/03/2024 14:00

@OneMoreTime23 they didn't increase them proportionately to cover increased costs... people have accepted this as it's still cheaper to wfh ( clothes, home food) but more than a couple of days hybrid will need serious pay rises.
How many people have worked from home with any allowance from their employer to cover electricity, wifi and heating ?
No wonder there are so many people in this country who have retired early or left work altogether, employers are taking the piss.

Salaries have never been set to include commuting costs though.

Costs me £100s every month to travel because I choose to live far from where I now work. I don’t expect work to pay more than the job is worth to cover that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread