Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Boots move to 5 days a week is a step back for workplace equality

687 replies

Vistada · 08/03/2024 11:54

Boots HQ, a predominantly female workforce - has been told they are to be back in the office five days a week from September with no debate and no real solid reasoning (in my view)

https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/boots-to-end-hybrid-working-for-office-workers/

I think the move to hybrid working is amazing for everyone, not just women, in terms of helping to achieve the work/life/parenting balance that has eluded us for so long, but we can't deny women shoulder this juggling act more.

I think this move, and any move back to 5 days in the office (where its really not needed) is a huge step back for workplace equality - and for a male CEO to enforce this just shows how out of touch he is.

Boots to end hybrid working for office workers

Boots has told thousands of staff that from September they will have to work in the office five days a week.

https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/boots-to-end-hybrid-working-for-office-workers

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
innerdesign · 09/03/2024 11:37

Vod · 09/03/2024 11:13

I'm 100% on topic, in fact. The post of mine that you replied to was in response to someone talking about remote workers needing less childcare whilst she had to spend a fortune on childcare. That was the root of the conversation.

Which means if you're going to tell people who don't have your access to full sick pay from their employers that they can just fund it themselves so it doesn't matter, either you do the same for those needing to pay more childcare than a remote worker who doesn't need wraparound, or you're applying a double standard.

I'm completely uninterested in whether you want a link or not. The NHS pension scheme, explained in detail at the link below regardless of whether you care to click on it or not, is better than mine. It's really a mark of how good it is that you think it having got worse over the last few years in any way addresses the pension point. All of these employer contribution rates from each of the schemes, see below, are better than mine, and that of lots of other employers.

https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/nhs-pension-scheme-proposed-policy-changes-for-april-2024/nhs-pension-scheme-member-contributions-phase-2-and-miscellaneous-amendments

And how do the employee contributions compare?

ZebraDanios · 09/03/2024 11:37

Theunamedcat · 09/03/2024 11:34

And a big money saver I remember paying more in wraparound childcare than my rent and panicking because I knew I couldn't afford 6 weeks holidays worth of full time childcare

I know someone who was able to afford a second home with the money they saved on commuting and wraparound care once they started WFH.

Theunamedcat · 09/03/2024 11:34

EsmeSusanOgg · 09/03/2024 11:30

Not commuting means you pick up from wrap around/ school earlier. That you can do school drop offs etc. That means more time with your children, whilst still working full hours. The removal of the commute is a big time saver for many people..

And a big money saver I remember paying more in wraparound childcare than my rent and panicking because I knew I couldn't afford 6 weeks holidays worth of full time childcare

ZebraDanios · 09/03/2024 11:34

Bringtheweatherwithyou · 09/03/2024 11:20

But what about when no one wants to do the essential f2f jobs?

Let it happen. Then those are interested in the roles will apply and changes will be made for alternatives.

You are assuming that if a F2F employee leaves, they will easily get a WFH job. They are in for a rude awakening when they find out what competition for jobs looks like in the private sector!

That’s working on your assumption that everyone in a f2f role is too thick to do any other job though (“teachers only teach because they couldn’t get their 1st/2nd/3rd choice career”). I know plenty of people who have left teaching and gone into wfh jobs, because they have qualifications and skills and stuff like that.

EsmeSusanOgg · 09/03/2024 11:30

Overtheatlantic · 08/03/2024 12:12

But if you are WFH you shouldn’t be spending time with your son.

Not commuting means you pick up from wrap around/ school earlier. That you can do school drop offs etc. That means more time with your children, whilst still working full hours. The removal of the commute is a big time saver for many people..

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 09/03/2024 11:27

thevegetablesoup · 09/03/2024 11:16

But what about when no one wants to do the essential f2f jobs?

No doubt there need to be changed for essential jobs in terms of both pay and conditions. I don’t doubt that for a moment.

But I don’t think sour grapes is at all helpful - making others who could or even will do their jobs better wfh go into offices every day , wasting time and money, wont help those in necessarily f2f jobs.

What’s needed is much higher public sector pay and recruitment drives to fill in the numbers (once pay and conditions are improved)

Goforitagainandagain · 09/03/2024 11:26

Not everyone likes wfh, I put up with it for about 5 weeks and 4 of that was my notice, I was stuck in our spare room which meant I couldn't use it for my own stuff, it was one of the sadder episodes of my life.

EasterIssland · 09/03/2024 11:25

thevegetablesoup · 09/03/2024 11:16

But what about when no one wants to do the essential f2f jobs?

is that how it works? We will choose jobs that are wfh rather than f2f even if we have no interest in them ? Do you think a doctor would swap themselves with an IT technician just because the latter one can wfh? Very much doubt it

Bringtheweatherwithyou · 09/03/2024 11:25

Vod · 09/03/2024 11:19

But do you actually think we can oblige employers to try and get remote/hybrid staff to be in the office more, in the hope that employers in completely different sectors can get the staff they need without having to pay more?

This has come up a few times, and I just wonder how on earth do people think it would work?

Exactly. It’s like saying it’s not fair that bus drivers, painters and decorators, chefs, taxi drivers aren’t able to work from home. It’s a ridiculous argument.

CoffeeWithCheese · 09/03/2024 11:24

Bringtheweatherwithyou · 08/03/2024 21:33

I know a lot of nurses. They don't want to work from home. The reason they enjoy their jobs is because it is varied, they meet a lot of people and spend a lot of time talking and walking to people. There is no way they all want to sit at home doing data entry instead just because they can work from home.

Doctors and dentist do not want to sit at a desk job. They aren't being forced to do their roles. They wanted to be dentists and doctors and studied incredibly hard to achieve that.

Teachers presumably chose their careers too although so many are seemingly unhappy in it, the role is not what they thought it would be and they don't like teaching. . I can't understand why they chose to be teachers and presume that its because they didn't get high enough results to do their first, second or third choices. If they can get a job working from home, as private tutors, then they should absolutely go for it. Or get a customer service based role from home if they want something entirely different.

I'm community NHS. I work with a lot of nurses. Of all of them, I can think of one who runs her life around being in the office 9-5 unless she's out on visits because that suits her way of working.

Most of the others work in a similar way I do - if we're out seeing patients we'll work in and out of the nearest available office base, but if we're slogging through a day of writing up discharge reports - we'd much rather do that WFH in comfy slippers with less distractions (especially since our shared office has the printer for the building so people are in and out constantly). We all have work mobile phones so clients can contact us easily, and Teams so colleagues can get hold of us and with the way my profession is organised - I wouldn't ever even pre-covid have been consistently working out of an office with my professional colleagues anyway - we're set up with a one clinician per local area kind of system.

It doesn't suit everyone - and there are a few people who start, use the post as their first step on the career ladder and move on quite quickly - but it suits a lot of us who enjoy working that way. It takes effort to make sure people are still feeling part of the team - we have a lot of discussion and "I'm seeing this chap and I know it's a condition you were interested in if you want to come along as well" type arranging, and there are days where people are more likely to be in offices to cross over with colleagues, but it's still a very close knit team considering the huge geographical area we cover. We also have recruitment issues in the career in general and have a fair few colleagues with insane commutes so on a day they'd just be sat in the office doing admin - WFH suits them. Seems to suit the Trust as well as they're condensing down buildings to save costs.

As for the domestic stuff - because I'm often in and out during the day, and can be on quite late evening visits - DH does the laundry, school runs and shopping.

The one bit of the move to WFH that does piss me off is the assumption that was made (particularly during lockdown) that everyone was set up at home in a way where they could decamp into a quiet spare room, with decent wifi and an obligingly situated desk and that they had kids who would dutifully sit at the dining table doing their own school work with minimal supervision... and that during that period a lot of stress and burden did fall on me as the mother - and we were in a very cramped house without a spare room so I was juggling a uni degree, the kids home school work and trying to keep things quiet while DH was wittering on about last night's telly on a Teams chat. Once I got this post - we made a point of moving to a house where both me and DH have spaces we can WFH undisturbed if required and the kids are that bit older for the hour they're home after school while I'm still working. Couldn't do it in our old long-since outgrown house this way and I think employers embracing hybrid/remote working do need to make sure that they're not making assumptions about employee's domestic arrangements and that there are decent office spaces available for those who would prefer to work in the traditional 9-5 in the office manner.

Bringtheweatherwithyou · 09/03/2024 11:20

But what about when no one wants to do the essential f2f jobs?

Let it happen. Then those are interested in the roles will apply and changes will be made for alternatives.

You are assuming that if a F2F employee leaves, they will easily get a WFH job. They are in for a rude awakening when they find out what competition for jobs looks like in the private sector!

Vod · 09/03/2024 11:19

thevegetablesoup · 09/03/2024 11:16

But what about when no one wants to do the essential f2f jobs?

But do you actually think we can oblige employers to try and get remote/hybrid staff to be in the office more, in the hope that employers in completely different sectors can get the staff they need without having to pay more?

This has come up a few times, and I just wonder how on earth do people think it would work?

thevegetablesoup · 09/03/2024 11:16

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 09/03/2024 11:13

I don’t think people should be brought back to offices just because some essential roles in society have to be f2f. That makes no sense. Each workplace needs to decide what works for them.

But what about when no one wants to do the essential f2f jobs?

Vod · 09/03/2024 11:16

Worth pointing out that we're also facing recruitment issues in a lot of sectors where people are working remotely and hybrid too. Indeed, sometimes the recruitment problems are why people are able to work remotely. This thread has talked about customer service staff at home, and they're a great example of that.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 09/03/2024 11:13

I don’t think people should be brought back to offices just because some essential roles in society have to be f2f. That makes no sense. Each workplace needs to decide what works for them.

Vod · 09/03/2024 11:13

innerdesign · 09/03/2024 10:50

I don't want a link, I want you to actually tell me how NHS staff's contribution and benefit compares to private. Since you think it's so relevant.

You're getting off topic now, my point wasn't anything to do with paying for childcare etc. It's to do with the absolutely shite working conditions in essential f2f roles, when you've got lots of the workforce happily sitting at home for the same money.

I'm 100% on topic, in fact. The post of mine that you replied to was in response to someone talking about remote workers needing less childcare whilst she had to spend a fortune on childcare. That was the root of the conversation.

Which means if you're going to tell people who don't have your access to full sick pay from their employers that they can just fund it themselves so it doesn't matter, either you do the same for those needing to pay more childcare than a remote worker who doesn't need wraparound, or you're applying a double standard.

I'm completely uninterested in whether you want a link or not. The NHS pension scheme, explained in detail at the link below regardless of whether you care to click on it or not, is better than mine. It's really a mark of how good it is that you think it having got worse over the last few years in any way addresses the pension point. All of these employer contribution rates from each of the schemes, see below, are better than mine, and that of lots of other employers.

https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/nhs-pension-scheme-proposed-policy-changes-for-april-2024/nhs-pension-scheme-member-contributions-phase-2-and-miscellaneous-amendments

NHS Pension Scheme: member contributions phase 2 and miscellaneous amendments

https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/nhs-pension-scheme-proposed-policy-changes-for-april-2024/nhs-pension-scheme-member-contributions-phase-2-and-miscellaneous-amendments

ZebraDanios · 09/03/2024 11:06

It's to do with the absolutely shite working conditions in essential f2f roles, when you've got lots of the workforce happily sitting at home for the same money.

Have to agree on this. I can’t remember the last time I ate lunch on a work day, and I have to limit how much and when I can drink because I don’t have time to go to the loo: my sympathy for people who find WFH “boring” is a bit limited.

And before anyone says “if you don’t like it then do something else” - that’s exactly what lots of teachers are doing, and it’s why lots of kids are in huge classes or have had a supply teacher teaching them for entire terms.

EasterIssland · 09/03/2024 11:02

innerdesign · 09/03/2024 10:50

I don't want a link, I want you to actually tell me how NHS staff's contribution and benefit compares to private. Since you think it's so relevant.

You're getting off topic now, my point wasn't anything to do with paying for childcare etc. It's to do with the absolutely shite working conditions in essential f2f roles, when you've got lots of the workforce happily sitting at home for the same money.

Do you think many of those sitting at home are happy ? Because we can be miserable in our works as well.

innerdesign · 09/03/2024 10:50

Vod · 09/03/2024 10:42

Hopefully you'll find more information at the link below.

https://www.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/sites/default/files/2023-03/NHSPensions_RetirementGuide_%28V26%29_202303.pdf

Do you know what my employer's pension contribution is? Those of other remote workers?

And really, telling people that they can just pay out of pocket for a benefit your employer gives you is proving my point. NHS workers and nurses can pay out of pocket for childcare too (and unlike with critical illness cover, there's some state help available for this). They can also pay for being around for their DC more by dropping hours and drawing a lower salary. But clearly you don't think just cough up and suck it up is a sufficient answer for those working in person when they talk about their views, or you'd have said the same to them. Rightly so actually, because it's a stupid way to look at the issue. Again though, double standard.

I don't want a link, I want you to actually tell me how NHS staff's contribution and benefit compares to private. Since you think it's so relevant.

You're getting off topic now, my point wasn't anything to do with paying for childcare etc. It's to do with the absolutely shite working conditions in essential f2f roles, when you've got lots of the workforce happily sitting at home for the same money.

Vod · 09/03/2024 10:42

innerdesign · 09/03/2024 10:34

Can you tell me what the NHS pension is please? Thanks. And if you don't have full sick pay, that's what critical illness cover is for.

Hopefully you'll find more information at the link below.

https://www.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/sites/default/files/2023-03/NHSPensions_RetirementGuide_%28V26%29_202303.pdf

Do you know what my employer's pension contribution is? Those of other remote workers?

And really, telling people that they can just pay out of pocket for a benefit your employer gives you is proving my point. NHS workers and nurses can pay out of pocket for childcare too (and unlike with critical illness cover, there's some state help available for this). They can also pay for being around for their DC more by dropping hours and drawing a lower salary. But clearly you don't think just cough up and suck it up is a sufficient answer for those working in person when they talk about their views, or you'd have said the same to them. Rightly so actually, because it's a stupid way to look at the issue. Again though, double standard.

https://www.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/sites/default/files/2023-03/NHSPensions_RetirementGuide_(V26)_202303.pdf

Vod · 09/03/2024 10:35

I think in person retail jobs will stay poorly paid and the size of the workforce will shrink. There's a thread now about by a shop worker about customer behaviour and how hard they're increasingly finding the job, and it's an interesting read. I'm not sure how sustainable the current model is, in the longer term.

innerdesign · 09/03/2024 10:34

Vod · 09/03/2024 10:30

It really won't do to pretend these things aren't better than what exists in other sectors. They are. That's not a matter of opinion.

The NHS pension, even not being as good as it was, is without question much better than a lot of what's available in the private and charity sectors. And paid sick leave is a huge benefit because, well, people do get ill. If, heaven forbid, you're in an awful accident this weekend and will need months to recuperate, you at least know the bills get paid while you're doing it. The same won't be true of someone who only gets a couple of weeks full pay, or nothing at all. And after all, people are in these situations all the time. It's going to happen to somebody today.

It's therefore a significant double standard to focus only on the things you (general) perceive to disadvantage you, whilst having nothing at all to say about the ways in which your terms and conditions significantly exceed those of some of the people you compare yourself to.

Can you tell me what the NHS pension is please? Thanks. And if you don't have full sick pay, that's what critical illness cover is for.

EasterIssland · 09/03/2024 10:32

Ncncncworkywork · 09/03/2024 10:28

In the (very) long term, we could actually see a shift in the pay balance: so workers on the shop floor could have higher salaries than the WFH office staff.

I very much doubt that this will be the case. Really doubt that someone in boots will ever have the same salary as IT technician for boots. Right now a boots software developer that probably is wfh is earning around 40-50k

https://www.glassdoor.co.uk/Salary/Boots-Software-Developer-Salaries-E327390_D_KO6,24.htm

retail manager is around 25-40k

https://www.payscale.com/research/UK/Employer=The_Boots_Company_PLC/Salary

sunglassesonthetable · 09/03/2024 10:31

Tbh I think there's also downsides to WFH and there will always be people who want to do other face to face jobs for other reasons.
Sometimes just for the jobs themselves. It's swings and roundabouts.

Vod · 09/03/2024 10:30

innerdesign · 09/03/2024 10:16

I suspect the NHS pension isn't as great as you think. They changed the terms in 2015, before that yes it was excellent, but now it's not really. Because it's tied to state pension age, I'll be tied into work until I'm late 60s (realistically, given I'm early 30s now it'll likely be 70s, if the pension exists in its current form at all). So no, something that may benefit me in 40 years (if I live that long) doesn't make up for current crappy conditions. Paid sick leave is only a benefit if you're ill, most of us don't actually benefit from that, although it is psychologically nice to know it's there.

It really won't do to pretend these things aren't better than what exists in other sectors. They are. That's not a matter of opinion.

The NHS pension, even not being as good as it was, is without question much better than a lot of what's available in the private and charity sectors. And paid sick leave is a huge benefit because, well, people do get ill. If, heaven forbid, you're in an awful accident this weekend and will need months to recuperate, you at least know the bills get paid while you're doing it. The same won't be true of someone who only gets a couple of weeks full pay, or nothing at all. And after all, people are in these situations all the time. It's going to happen to somebody today.

It's therefore a significant double standard to focus only on the things you (general) perceive to disadvantage you, whilst having nothing at all to say about the ways in which your terms and conditions significantly exceed those of some of the people you compare yourself to.