Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the government are on a hiding to nothing with their drive to get people back to work?

503 replies

molokoco · 08/03/2024 10:33

On the Today Programme in Radio 4 this morning they had a segment where they were talking about "worklessness" in the UK and the number of unfilled vacancies and how the government wanted to push two large groups back into the work force the 18-24 year olds who are not working due to mental health issues and the over 50's who have dropped out of work in the past four years for a variety of reasons and who perhaps have the funds not to have to to work anymore.

They had a man on in his early 60's who was made redundant from what sounded like a highly paid business / finance type career in the city 4 years ago, he had initially applied for 100's of jobs over the next few years and was rejected he seemed to suspect due to his age. He work as a postman for a spell before he finally mentally came round to the idea of retirement. Obviously this man had the funds but so do a lot of the people retiring in their 50's either have that or their health is so poor they can no longer work while they wait endlessly for hospital appointments and treatment.

When I try to look at the kind of jobs that have the most vacancies in the UK the information I am seeing is things like hospitality, construction, manufacturing, agriculture workers and so on. It doesn't seem likely to me that someone who was previously in a high flying career but now feels pushed out due to ageism or someone with health issues is likely to want to take a job in any of those areas which likely involve some mix of heavy work, anti-social hours, low pay and a degree of precarity and perhaps not much in the way of long term prospects.

The man on the radio had applied for 100's of jobs within his field of experience and he would have kept working if he had landed one but it seems like well paid, jobs with good career prospects are still over subscribed with lots of people applying for that kind of work so employers will have their pick and ageism in recruitment is a known issue.

They had a Doctor on to discuss the mental health crisis in the young but he wasn't very coherent, he did mention about improving nutrition, exercise and prescribing gardening to people with mental health issues and suggested that when people go on the sick with poor mental health and spend a few weeks at home watching daytime TV then they will feel worse. I am sure he had a point but gardening isn't a substitute to getting proper mental heath treatment, it is part of that sure but I think young people need more than that and that the things that seem to be behind the rise in depression, anxiety and hopelessness need to be addressed more widely. I also think that while younger people in good health may be more able to do the kind of work in hospitality or construction where the vacancies actually are the problems with these jobs still remain that they are often hard, heavy jobs, they can be low paid, antisocial hours and with fewer prospects in the long term.

It is sad to see people, especially young people drop out of the workforce right at the time their lives should be starting or for older people to feel pushed out due to their age or poor health but a few tax breaks isn't going to make an ex-executive or ex-teacher suddenly want to take a job on a building site or as a chambre maid and a few gardening sessions isn't going to make up for the utter lack of mental health care and magically cure young people of their anxiety or despair in a world where a home and a family seem so far out of reach.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
pointythings · 08/03/2024 11:03

The 'economically inactive' situation is complex and there isn't a simple fix.

18-24 year olds are often still in full time education - and many do work part time jobs to to up student funding. If you want to address those who are NEETs, you need to be supportive rather than punitive, because this group will contain a disproportionately large number of people who need extra help.

Over 50s will often be dealing with health issues - sorting the NHS out would be a good start to addressing that group. Many over 50s will also be caring for older parents and will still have children at home.

Ultimately, if you want people to work you have to make it possible for them to work. That means offering emplyers tax breaks for providing flexibility and job sharing, and for taking on people with disabilities or health conditions. It means making sure there is high quality, affordable childcare. It means paying people properly so that they can afford to live and it means dealing with the cliff edges in the benefits/work relationship.

It means completely restructuring British society to be less neoliberal and more social democratic. Not going to happen any time soon.

molokoco · 08/03/2024 11:03

@Cordeliacordyline

"If I was looking a quick fix mine would be to go back to an old proposal by the Labour Party the there should be a ratio for companies over a certain threshold, where the ratio between the top earners and lower earners can’t be too big. So the better the company does, the better all employees do, but you still have a financial incentive for the higher skilled roles."

This seems like a great idea, I think its been shown that the more unequal society becomes the less invested we all feel in it.

I am in my 40's and work part time at something I love and I probably would be considered economically under active but like you I value my quality of life more than earning more.

OP posts:
Cordeliacordyline · 08/03/2024 10:50

I agree. So complex that there are no quick fixes. One thing that really struck me was that a lot of the vacancies are in roles considered ‘essential key workers’ during the pandemic. Also that lots of the vacancies are jobs that pay low but might create revenue and wealth for others.

If I was looking a quick fix mine would be to go back to an old proposal by the Labour Party the there should be a ratio for companies over a certain threshold, where the ratio between the top earners and lower earners can’t be too big. So the better the company does, the better all employees do, but you still have a financial incentive for the higher skilled roles.

At the moment those unskilled jobs decrease health and well-being due to the nature of them, and there is no ‘out’.

I am 50. I work part time because I worked very hard to get my current career and my part time salary is enough. We are comfortable. Few luxuries and basic car and a low cost holiday every now and then. But my time is worth more to me than money at this age. You only get one life. There is no way on earth that I would now work as a waiter or cleaner etc. I do t have the energy and I don’t need to.

We need to pay for our workforce well, treat them well and look after everyone, rather than treating them like work horses and keep them wearing their bodies out and heading for poor health and premature mortality. We need to actually value those roles and the people that do them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread