Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give up potty training and wait for DS to say he wants to wear pants / use the toilet?

820 replies

Comeandeat · 08/03/2024 08:10

We’ve been trying since November and it’s obviously now march.

I’ve put pull ups on him because I’ve run out of clean trousers. I think with that I’ve decided to leave it. I don’t ever want to initiate it myself again. It’s destroyed me. AIBU just to wait for DS? I don’t even care when that is any more.

He is 3 years and 3 months.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
pinkstripeycat · 09/03/2024 04:01

My eldest DS not dry at night until 7yrs old. I remember at cubs on a sleepover the boys in bedtime pants shared a dorm so not to get embarrassed or even be aware what other boys did

pinkstripeycat · 09/03/2024 03:59

I tried with DS for 6 months and then stopped. He’d wet his trousers the second we walked away from the toilet. Tried months later aged 3yrs 6 mth and he was dry within 2 weeks.

DS2 didn’t bother until 3yr 6 and he was also dry in 2 weeks.

Boys often don’t get the sensation to do a wee until they’re older. When mine were little the aged to train was 2yrs and some of my friends girls were dry at 2yrs

DottyLottieLou · 09/03/2024 03:18

Have a break. Try again over the summer.

BeckiBoBecki · 09/03/2024 02:51

He’s 3. Your mental health is not an excuse.

Threeboysadogacatandakitten · 09/03/2024 02:45

My two older boys were toilet trained just after their second birthdays and ds2 was dry at night then too. Ds3 was totally different. I tried, my childminder (who had toilet trained dozens of kids) tried. He just wasn’t interested or didn’t get it. He started nursery in pull ups and they did try to make me feel bad about it. By the time he was 3.5 he was ready and dry and clean within days. I can count the number of accidents he had on one hand. He was still wet at night until he was 7 and then suddenly dry and has never had an accident. He was later diagnosed with Autism although it’s difficult to say if the two are related. Some children just take longer.

Jnrmum · 09/03/2024 02:32

Sorry you’re having a tough time. You are right to leave it for now. Stress is not good for anyone and if it’s not working, then a break is the right thing.
I’ve got 3 boys and they were all different. DS3 in particular point blank refused to be potty trained at 3. He was 3.5 when he realised he needed to wear pants and we never looked back.
No point in pushing it especially after what you’ve experienced

duckcalledbill · 09/03/2024 02:22

Comeandeat · 08/03/2024 08:30

Yes. No advice that has helped. I really think there is either special needs or more,likely I’ve just thoroughly arsed it up, but either way it’s done now.

NO MORE PANTS. Feels quite liberating.

It’s not liberating at all the be changing nappies though.

crack on and involve the HV if necessary.

WotNoUserName · 09/03/2024 01:30

I've got 5 boys - grown up now, but I've always said potty training is the worst part of parenting youngsters. And that's when it's an easy job!

My mum was very much "you and your brother were out of nappies at 18 months" conveniently forgetting all the accidents my brother had, and that he was a bedwetter till he was 10.

My youngest was a nightmare to toilet train. It took him over a year to finally be reliable for both wee and poos, he was in reception by then and I was called in to deal with it quite a few times. Not helped by him being terrified of flushing toilets, and then some workmen setting off a drill next door to the school loos. He's 16 and still opens the bathroom door before he flushes so he can escape quickly!

His preschool were really good at encouraging both him and me with the training.

I wouldn't take your son out of preschool. No one is going to think he's smelly. I couldn't have told you which kids were in nappies or not at my kids preschools, and I wouldn't have cared.

Give it a break and try later. Summer holidays is a good time because (hopefully) the weather is nice for lots garden activities with not many clothes on.

Vonesk · 09/03/2024 01:15

You can do potty training in one day.
Buy a potty and put it in a conspicious place in the house. A lways leave in same place.
Buy it six months before you intend to use it.
You can maybe sit a doll on it leading up to the day ' of training'
Choose a day to train when you will be doing nothing else but stay home to train.
Buy a bag of child's favourite treats.
Put some pants on child that are easy to pull up and down.
Get some tasty drinks to give lots to child on day of training.
Start at 8 am.
Hover around the potty, sit the doll on the potty.
When the child sits on potty, give a treat straight away ,and lots of praise .
Keep giving lots of drinks, then a treat each time.
Its a great game, they love the game.
The game goes on all day.
At the end of the day the training is finished theyve learned!!!!!??
Next day put the easy up and down pants on ( not nappy or pull ups, but cotton pants)
Pull ups will make for laziness. When at home.
If when GOING OUT for the first few weeks you can put on a proper nappy if wished it will not confuse , in case of accidents. Or when visiting friends.

MrsMigginsesPieShop · 09/03/2024 00:43

You're absolutely doing the right thing. Stop and try again when you feel strong enough to give it another go. My youngest was nearly 4 when he stopped using nappies. I tried for 6 months, and ended up really stressed about it. He went back into nappies, then a couple of months later, just before his 4th birthday decided he'd had enough of them and that was that. Please don't worry about accidents at school/nursery either - I worked as a classroom assistant in P1 and changed kids on more than a daily basis. In fact the days where I didn't have to visit the spare pants cupboard multiple times were the unusual ones. I know it seems all encompassing at the moment, but 3 and a half is still well within the normal range. Give yourselves a break, and give it another go when you've both recuperated.

User3456 · 09/03/2024 00:20

OP have you tried training pants? They're cotton so they will feel when they're wet but should hold leaks. Washable too.
This sort of thing

To give up potty training and wait for DS to say he wants to wear pants / use the toilet?
Isittimeforbedyetsos · 09/03/2024 00:16

Our daughter - 3 years and 5 months has only just “got “ it.

it felt like she never would.

definitely no special needs etc. generally bright and understands a lot.

lost count of the pairs of knickers needed to wash or even through away!

we spoke to the nursery about it - but we were told it was very common and many of the other children in the same boat. Poo seems more of an issue for many of them.

I too worried whether she had a food intolerance or something.

doesn’t now seem like that is the case though. Think she was just holding it in.

your DS will get there.

entirely a personal decision, but I wouldn’t withdraw him from preschool / nursery - will make it harder on you both.

try a reward chart or similar (it may be that you have already) and just keep going. If he goes to preschool / nursery then that’s going to be extra hours that others can help too so it’s not all on you / your husband

TMess · 08/03/2024 22:33

In my experience there’s a window where it’s easy (easier. easy-ish) and I think you’ve missed that, which is too bad, but it has to happen anyways so I’d take a short break to regroup and then try again. One of mine was more difficult than the rest…not only did we not leave the house for quite some time, we didn’t even leave the toilet. Just sat in there with quiet activities and constant potty access while I tried not to cry, and it was totally my fault because when they first showed interest at early 2 I was about to give birth and just couldn’t be bothered. Sympathies - I have five dc and potty training is thus far my absolute least favorite part.

badhappenings · 08/03/2024 22:32

Stop panicking.
It WILL happen when he's ready and not before.

RichinVitaminR · 08/03/2024 22:21

Also @wordler 's advice is spot on. I think in the meantime, do this for sure! Don't give up, just change pace Flowers

RichinVitaminR · 08/03/2024 22:18

Comeandeat · 08/03/2024 08:43

There’s absolutely no way we’d have had any luck by starting earlier. I honestly don’t think he gets it. I don’t think he understands what a wee or poo feels like until he’s done it so he just wees and poos in his pants. If you take him to the toilet regularly he does wees there but if you forget or get distracted for a bit he just wets himself.

What method are you using to teach him? Sorry, just read up to this point in the thread. I get toilet training must be really challenging, I'm not there yet as my DD is 6 months old but I'm not looking forward to it.

What I will say is that I don't think you have the option to just stop. Sorry, I know it must be really difficult and stressful. Could you talk to Dad about ways to tackle this? Because I have worked in primary schools, exclusively lower school and a lot of my roles have taken place in Nursery/Reception. I can't speak for private nurseries but I can tell you that school based nurseries are not equipped to potty train your son for you. I know you haven't said you want that but I'm just putting that out there. We do not have the staff or resources. There is a large volume of SEN children nowadays who are not potty trained and they often require huge amounts of support. Even then, many school based nurseries will refuse to take him full time if he isn't toilet trained. In my experience, anyway. If you think that your son might have SEN, you need to talk to your GP and get some support, OP. For your own sanity. Get that ball rolling.

Northernlass13 · 08/03/2024 17:58

Devonshiregal · 08/03/2024 15:50

Enable? Wow.

How doesn’t it benefit the kid? What “damage” do you worry is going to occur by being out of nappies in a few months time rather than right now?

Ahhh I know - maybe he’ll be 10 and his best friend will ask “what age did you potty train?” and he’ll reply “3 years 7 months and 2 days.” And his best friend will ditch him for being a potty training loser.

And then later on, he’ll be 29 and he’ll meet the girl of his dreams. He’ll want to propose but her father will stand in the way of their marriage stating no daughter of his shall marry a late potty trainer!

Oh and, of course, at every job he ever goes to he will be asked to submit the date he last wore pull ups alongside his CV. It’s common knowledge no employer takes a man who potty trained after the age of 2 so he’ll be screwed. He’ll never get past first stage interview and will be destitute forever.

He’ll live a sad, lonely life and all opportunities will be closed to him forever.

OR… he’ll potty train just fine in a few months when his language and understanding skills have advanced - and the OP will save herself a lot of unnecessary washing, and them both a lot unnecessary stress, in the meantime.

Yaasssss…. This made me chuckle but is 💯 right!!! Xx

Infinity234 · 08/03/2024 17:36

Only read the first page but some of the replies have infuriated me. If you’ve been trying since November, he isn’t ready. I work at a nursery, all children are different, we’ve had just gone 2 year olds get it quickly and we’ve had almost 4 year olds not. Our advice is always don’t do it if they aren’t ready because it just stresses everyone out. It’s not laziness as people are implying 🙄

wordler · 08/03/2024 17:18

Comeandeat · 08/03/2024 10:14

Sometimes. And say I’m wet. But other times he says nothing. Depends on how big the wee is I think.

Instead of giving up completely why don't you go back to him wearing pull-ups under his trousers but still take him to the toilet on a regular basis.

You'll have fewer problems with the clean up if there's an accident, but will still be reinforcing that the toilet is where you are supposed to go.

And you can use pullups in a similar way to underwear - pulling them up and down when trying to go to the toilet, so it's a transition between nappies and underwear.

During the next three to four months don't have any expectations that he is 'training' but just use a lot of positive reinforcement for anytime he goes in the toilet.

It's also a weird position for people to get used to - we aren't as humans really supposed to poop in that sitting position with legs hanging down, so it might be worth getting something that lets him be more in a crouch/'frog' position which might make his body feel more familiar about letting go.

Something like this: https://www.amazon.com/GrowthPic-Toddler-Toilet-Training-Trainer/dp/B07Q55H8JW

Don't even worry about night training yet - that's a completely different issue with toilet training based around hormones and bladder growth etc. My DD was toilet trained in the day at 2.5 but she couldn't wake up or hold it at night until she was 6.5 and then one day she was just ready.

While doing this for the next few months see if you can note a pattern on what time of day he is pooping - if it's at all regular then make sure you are taking him to the toilet at that time.

https://www.amazon.com/GrowthPic-Toddler-Toilet-Training-Trainer/dp/B07Q55H8JW?tag=mumsnet&ascsubtag=mnforum-am-i-being-unreasonable-5023884-to-give-up-potty-training-and-wait-for-ds-to-say-he-wants-to-wear-pants-use-the-toilet

Ggttl · 08/03/2024 16:58

Most of the comments on here are not very helpful. I would stop, wait a few months and then try again. Good luck!

MummaMummaJumma · 08/03/2024 16:52

@mirro Relax and enjoy your little guy.

And this 👆 takes priority. So do what you need to do OP. Sending big hugs your way.

MummaMummaJumma · 08/03/2024 16:48

Honestly, if this post came up after potty training my DD, I probably would have posted a really preachy post, telling you to persevere and keep going. DD was done in three days and I felt like I was the potty training Guru.

BUT, DS was completely different. Started at 2.5 months and took me 6 months to successfully potty train him. It pushed me to every limit possible! Behind closed doors, I’d cry often and feel like a failure. My DS is incredible headstrong and it turned in a real power struggle between him and I. I watched a YouTube video (can’t remember the name) and I the Dr send something to the effect of “they will use the toilet when they’re ready, and not a second before that “. From then on I used my big white board in the back room and wrote “poo” and “wee”, left the markers somewhere accessible and didn’t say anything. I explained to him that I’m not taking him to the toilet anymore but if he wanted a squishy, from the big tube of squishies, he’d have to use the bathroom on his own. This worked wonders for us.

With that said OP, if I had have stopped, I wouldn’t have been surprised, this was my last attempt as I too had tried EVERYTHING. Children can only truly control three things: What they eat, when they sleep and when they use the toilet. If a child wants control, they’ll usually express it in these areas. Be gently with yourself, its a massive challenge if you have been/are going through it. You are certainly not lazy, you’re overwhelmed and out of juice. Relax, recharge and take care xx

cherish123 · 08/03/2024 16:40

YANBU
wait a few months. I would not leave it past 4yrs, though.

PrincessTeaSet · 08/03/2024 16:34

Howabsolutelyfanfuckingtastic · 08/03/2024 13:42

Same, the earlier the better. Thinking of a child in nappies is horrible, just sitting in their wee or poo. I don't understand why people leave it so late then wonder why it's so difficult. All my 7 were trained day and night before 2 and they took less than 2 weeks to catch on fully and have prerty much no accidents. That certainly can't be coincidence! Put your babies in underwear once they are steady and confident walking and never go back to nappies even if it takes longer than you expect. I feel very strongly on this subject, it's so important.

Have to state the obvious here that just because your kids were clean and dry before 2 that doesn't mean all kids can do this. All the ones I know of who trained before 2 had accidents and regressions along the way even though they seemed to be doing great at first.

If you had read the OP's posts you would know that she did actually start trying when her son was much younger than he is now. It's not helpful or true to suggest that it would have been straightforward if done earlier.

mirro · 08/03/2024 16:24

American grandmother here adding my opinion. I would just take a month off to reset the agenda. I actually trained my sons to urinate standing up into a tall can. Once that was mastered they would stand on my feet to reach the toilet and use their "waterguns" try to hit floating cereal [cheerios] which i put into the bowl. Poo came last of all. One got it straight away..the younger one was almost 4. Just take the pressure off both of you for a bit. He will master it. I also bought my guys underwear with characters on them when we were ready for poos. their goal was then not to get the cartoon friend dirty. Relax and enjoy your little guy.