Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give up potty training and wait for DS to say he wants to wear pants / use the toilet?

820 replies

Comeandeat · 08/03/2024 08:10

We’ve been trying since November and it’s obviously now march.

I’ve put pull ups on him because I’ve run out of clean trousers. I think with that I’ve decided to leave it. I don’t ever want to initiate it myself again. It’s destroyed me. AIBU just to wait for DS? I don’t even care when that is any more.

He is 3 years and 3 months.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
icklekit · 09/03/2024 07:48

Have been in your position with DS2. I tried when he turned 3, and nothing, tried again, and again nothing. I did start panicking as it had been relatively easy and quick with DS1.
Tried a third time when he was just over 3 1/3 and we got it. Different technique, (bribery worked in the end). It can take time, and every child is different. I really hate the pressure that is put on around toilet training. Feeling like a failure because little Johnny isn't out of nappies by 2. Take a break OP for your MH and your DS. He will get there.

Pickled21 · 09/03/2024 07:47

You need help for your mental health. Be it a dr, nurse you need to speak to someone because you sound very apathetic. Then look at it objectively, if you think your child has additional needs then get them assessed so you can go about supporting those needs correctly. Or if he is too young to be assessed at least speak to the hv about the process and what it involves, speak to preschool and see if they have any concerns re development.

Where is your partner in all of this? My dh took the lead in potty training our kids. He was much more on it than me and also found the whole thing less frustrating. We are due to start training our 2.5 year old soon and will take time off around each other to do it.

Singlespies · 09/03/2024 07:36

Have a break, for your own sanity. Sumner will be here soon and it may seem easier.

My youngest was completely continent but wouldn't use a potty. For a while she would put a nappy back on when she needed a wee (unsuccessfully). Eventually she would climb on the toilet. Basically she wanted to do it independently and privately. She was nearly 4.

johnd2 · 09/03/2024 07:35

Gosh I'm just sorry that you felt you had to persevere for so long when it obviously wasn't working. We had similar, and after a few days of being annoyed we gave up for 6 months and tried again.
Make sure you don't traumatise yourself or him!
Yes you have to lean into a bit of struggle with something new, but every single child is different so ignore all the people telling you how to parent your own child(either obliquely or directly)
We worried we would be in trouble for sending him to pre school in nappies as the child minder was talking about training him at 2 as soon as he was about 18 months. She bought him a toilet training book for his 2nd birthday! And mentioned it a few times after that. We first attempted when he was about 2y9m I think, he still wasn't trained until well over 3 though.
Good luck

Twobigbabies · 09/03/2024 07:32

Take a break you both need it. Do you have a garden? Wait for a sunny warm weekend at Easter when you can be at home all weekend then let him run around in the garden without a nappy and have the potty out. We don't bribe our kids as a rule but for potty training it worked a treat. One smartie/choc button for a wee, 2 for a poo. A little paw patrol toy for a day of no accidents. Both of mine were over 3, both trained in 48 hrs over a weekend at home. 1-2 accidents the week after then done. Waited a few months to tackle nighttime then both done easy peasy after a few days. No stress for anyone. I really don't believe it should be stressful it's just one of those things that comes naturally when they're ready.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 09/03/2024 07:32

If you wait for the demand to come from him, you could be waiting for a very long time.

My DH was the one who cracked it for my DS, who got very stressed sitting on the potty. DH just made it really relaxing, got him to sit on the potty for a minute at a time but if nothing happened, no problem. It was time intensive but looking back it only took a couple of weeks. The bonus was that DS could count up to 60 at the age of two! There was a song they would sing, but the counting was most popular.

PurBal · 09/03/2024 07:31

I’m not sure if this thread is a troll or what. But c’mon OP, you don’t want to put the effort in and you’re absolutely fine with him getting bullied if he’s not potty trained by school (and he will be, because kids are cruel). Yes you’ve tried, yes it’s okay to take a break. But potty training takes time, an average of 6 months (which means some take longer). Boys also take longer than girls. We started in October and this is the first week we’ve had more dry days than not. I’ve cried when we’ve had 5 accidents in 2 hours, turns out he had a UTI. You came here looking for support / advice and you’ve been dismissive.

Runary2711 · 09/03/2024 07:31

I remember this being one of the most stressful periods.....we started training our daughter as she turned 3 and it was hard on everyone, we once went through 6 changes in less than 2 hours when we were at a relative's house. She just wasn't ready and we left it a few months, was easier once pressure was off. Having a poo on the toilet took even longer, she'd hold it in all day and then go in her pull up at night. As long as he can go by the time he starts school. Go easier on you both x

Toptotoe · 09/03/2024 07:30

I don’t understand why you are posting if you have already decided? Are you looking for validation?
I took a week off work with all 3 of mine when they were around 2 and didn’t go out anywhere. I used a star chart and rewards. My 2 DD were easy my son took a bit longer and I discovered he preferred the toilet to a potty so I got him a stand to use the toilet.

ThisReallyDoesntAddUp · 09/03/2024 07:27

Comeandeat · 08/03/2024 08:43

There’s absolutely no way we’d have had any luck by starting earlier. I honestly don’t think he gets it. I don’t think he understands what a wee or poo feels like until he’s done it so he just wees and poos in his pants. If you take him to the toilet regularly he does wees there but if you forget or get distracted for a bit he just wets himself.

This is just like my son, it’s like he doesn’t get the sensation and he’s also stubborn. He is now 3 years 6 months but nursery agree he has no interest and to wait until he is ready. Our potty training attempts have failed despite him being quite a switched on kid.

My other son was trained at just over 2 years, they are all different. Ignore the sanctimonious posters on here, they likely had kids like my first born 😅

NewFriendlyLadybird · 09/03/2024 07:25

Rachie83 · 09/03/2024 07:11

Same situation here with DD similar age
we began at 2yr3m it went well she showed interest then she witnessed something at nursery and since then for a year we’ve had tears and screams of fear
We got a new potty, which she at least will let her teddies sit on (huge steps) but she still thinks it’s something “bad”
tried to go straight to toilet but she isn’t keen - tbh it’s separate to bathroom so darker and narrow so I get it.

we’ve tried books, cartoons, copying toys, watching me.
she’s v stubborn especially when scared.

at a new nursery now and they’ve had zero joy, but are trying.

I feel lost as well - your not alone - I’m gonna retry over Easter holiday.

problem is we get labelled as lazy parents, and older relatives blame “these modern nappies”
we tried no nappy and just let her get wet, she’s then so scared she will refuse to wee all day and “hold it in”
bedtime we then would put a nappy on (so 12-14 hours by this point) and she just does it then - But it’s got by that stage we are so worried about her getting sick we just want her to do it in a nappy 🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️

we asked health visitor when we very first began and they were useless
asked again 6m ago gave us the tips we were already trying ! - but actually did try help

The good news is that if she can hold it in she’s got good bladder control. You are more than halfway there.

Otherstories2002 · 09/03/2024 07:22

Comeandeat · 08/03/2024 08:22

I didn’t really use a method. I took him to the potty regularly, explained wees and poos went in the potty which he understands fine in theory but just doesn’t seem to actually put into practice. Whether he won’t or can’t I don’t know. But I got so angry then through sheer frustration.

and that’s the issue.

You need a consistent clear approach and you need to be supportive. He will never be ready for a shouty mess.

Nannyfannybanny · 09/03/2024 07:16

Goldx2, you are correct,in the 70s,80s,you started popping kids on the pot at one, they would be out of nappies around 2. Nurseries, playgroups didn't take children in nappies. They were also washable, with liners and plastic pants,no tumble dryers. No fancy padded pull ups, just pants. Two boys,2 girls (the girls were more difficult) but all out of nappies at 2yr 3mn. Got my DGS staying, his DS was 16 months old when he was born,he removed his own nappies,by 2. Had quite a few nighttime accidents.

PrincessOfPreschool · 09/03/2024 07:14

I wouldn't wait till he says he wants to, as that may never happen! I have a nearly 4yo where I work who isn't potty trained. His mum just can't be bothered I think, and he isn't asking because it's a lot easier to go in a nappy which I believe is just habit now. He can put his shoes and even socks on but he is still wearing a pull up. I'm going to try after Easter holidays but it's challenging when I only have 4 mornings a week and I'm not sure I'll manage. I am so angry with his mum. Imagine starting Reception in pull ups! The other kids will notice, it will annoy the teacher etc. I think if they don't need to use any bladder control and can just go in a pull up without getting wet, then they're not going to learn it.

Charlotte244 · 09/03/2024 07:13

Potty training can be really stressful! You’re not alone in that. We tried to potty train our daughter over the winter but had to stop because she attended an outdoor nursery in waterproofs and they just didn’t know when she had had an accident. We paused until the summer then tried again - it was much easier and successful quite quickly.
I think as long as a child is potty trained before they start school it doesn’t really matter how old they are. Take a break for a few months would be my advice 🥰.

mumof1879 · 09/03/2024 07:11

If you think he is not ready, stop. We tried multiple times with my son and it just didn’t work. I wasn’t as persistent as you (I mean that as a compliment) and stopped after a few days/a week. He was about 3y4m when we eventually got it for wee, poo was much longer but that’s ok. He had a nappy for bed or he would get one from the packet to indicate he wanted one on during the day to use. His speech was behind and he found the process really difficult. He started school at 4y5m and by then all was fine. A year is a long time that that age and alot can change.

After all the difficulties, I didn’t even start my younger daughter until she was the same age by choice. She picked it up much quicker, but I still didn’t regret waiting.

You know him best. ❤️

Rachie83 · 09/03/2024 07:11

Comeandeat · 08/03/2024 08:40

See that’s the thing, effort. We’ve been trying nearly four months. That’s an effort isn’t it? It’s nearly half a year. And I just can’t. I probably won’t send him to school in nappies anyway.

Same situation here with DD similar age
we began at 2yr3m it went well she showed interest then she witnessed something at nursery and since then for a year we’ve had tears and screams of fear
We got a new potty, which she at least will let her teddies sit on (huge steps) but she still thinks it’s something “bad”
tried to go straight to toilet but she isn’t keen - tbh it’s separate to bathroom so darker and narrow so I get it.

we’ve tried books, cartoons, copying toys, watching me.
she’s v stubborn especially when scared.

at a new nursery now and they’ve had zero joy, but are trying.

I feel lost as well - your not alone - I’m gonna retry over Easter holiday.

problem is we get labelled as lazy parents, and older relatives blame “these modern nappies”
we tried no nappy and just let her get wet, she’s then so scared she will refuse to wee all day and “hold it in”
bedtime we then would put a nappy on (so 12-14 hours by this point) and she just does it then - But it’s got by that stage we are so worried about her getting sick we just want her to do it in a nappy 🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️

we asked health visitor when we very first began and they were useless
asked again 6m ago gave us the tips we were already trying ! - but actually did try help

howaboutchocolate · 09/03/2024 07:10

OP I felt the same about the Oh Crap method as you until I read the bit about letting go of all control. That was what clicked. It sounds like you are frustrated with your son not getting it which he will pick up on and it will make it even more difficult for him. Going to the toilet is difficult when you're under pressure or being watched or overly stimulated. You need to be relaxed.

Could you take a break and then when you're ready and in the right frame of mind, try again but just totally take all the pressure off and be very very casual about it. As soon as I did that it literally took days. I just left a potty in the corner of the room so it was a bit more private, put some toys and stuff over there, and backed off.

VaccineSticker · 09/03/2024 07:08

Oh Crap! Potty Training: Everything Modern Parents Need to Know to Do It Once and Do It Right: Volume 1 (Oh Crap Parenting) https://amzn.eu/d/9voqHO6

read this while you’re giving him a break from PT. You need a method- the book is the best advice I got.
good luck

TeamGeriatric · 09/03/2024 07:03

My oldest (girl) got it pretty instantaneously at 2.5 both day and night, but my youngest (boy) really struggled with toilet training. He would basically only go on the toilet if sent him to use the toilet, so we'd have to send him every 45 minutes to an hour, otherwise he'd continue to play until his pants were wet. He turned 5 pretty much as he started reception and he would have to be changed multiple times at school because he wasn't taking himself to the toilet. Once or twice a week roughly he came out of school in wet clothes in Year 1 (they never seemed to notice even when I'd mentioned he was coming out wet sometimes) and by Year 2 he was basically fine, very occasional accidents, by this stage he was 7 and I could finally stop taking a change of clothes every time we went out. He's now 9 and still in nappies at night, we haven't figured out how to fix that yet. He has about 18 months to the Year 6 residential which worries me. Your son will get it eventually, sympathies op.

Bekind90 · 09/03/2024 07:00

Take a break from it for a month and try again. I say this as a mum who has just managed to train my daughter who is 3 years and two months. I have tried on and off since she was two years old and I finally decided to just leave it until I thought she was ready. In January, she just decided to have dry nappies and I began taking her to the potty / toilet every 45 minutes and since then it has just taken off. We bought character pants, we gave treats for each wee like a chocolate button etc… no judgement but we also have an iPad and she got ten minutes on there if she managed a poo. It’s a hard road but it sounds as though he isn’t ready yet. Take a small break and come back stronger. You got this 🤗

queenmeadhbh · 09/03/2024 06:54

Peanut91 · 08/03/2024 10:39

OP would you have given up if after 4 months of weaning you child still couldn't feed themself or use a knife or fork? I suspect not. Will you give up after 4 months if they can't read War and Peace? I suspect not.

Toilet training is no different. It is a skill that your child has to learn and this is done with routine and consistency and by taking responsibility for reminding your child and taking them to the toilet at regular intervals throughout the day. It is no one else's responsibility but your own and your child's father. You cannot expect anyone else to do this for you.

And I say this all as a parent of a child who has a chronic bowel condition who at nearly 6yrs.old is still doubly incontinent. I am currently doing toilet training with my two yr old and over the past 3 weeks we have been on him every hour to take him to the toilet and do a wee. These things take time...for some kids it's longer than others

But I didn’t teach my child to use a knife and fork. I provided toddler cutlery and used it myself as normal while eating. Now at 17 months he can feed himself with a spoon or fork because he learnt himself - watching me, and being given the opportunity to practise.

why can potty training not be the same? We show them what to do, and they do it when they’re ready.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 09/03/2024 06:49

Take a break, he’s obviously not ready yet. Until they recognize the signal from brain to bladder/bowel they aren’t really ready.

Night time dryness is different, it’s a hormone that kicks in to stop them weeing in their sleep.
Put him back into pull-ups for a month and try again. You sound overwhelmed and defeated, don’t be, this too shall pass.

Vettrianofan · 09/03/2024 06:46

My youngest is reliable aged 6. Before that he's had accidents. Not at night at all, but during the day. There's no rush.

DS may have undiagnosed autism though, he's on the list for assessment...

Justanothermum42 · 09/03/2024 06:45

Comeandeat · 08/03/2024 08:10

We’ve been trying since November and it’s obviously now march.

I’ve put pull ups on him because I’ve run out of clean trousers. I think with that I’ve decided to leave it. I don’t ever want to initiate it myself again. It’s destroyed me. AIBU just to wait for DS? I don’t even care when that is any more.

He is 3 years and 3 months.

I am genuinely shocked by all the replies telling you to persevere! Your child is clearly not ready. So leave it. There are no developmental issues, he is simply too young. My son potty trained at 3 years 10 months as the nursery suggested he was ready. It took a couple of days. Keep the pull ups and enjoy motherhood. You will see the dugns when he is ready.