Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is with childless people parking in family spots!!!

517 replies

Asher09 · 08/03/2024 07:00

I have a toddler and a baby - so thats 2 car seats and a double pram. I genuinly need a fair bit of space when parking and recently I've seen so many people without children parking in the family spots - its so frustrating!

Surely family spots are there for a reason - they're closer to entrances and allow more space to get in and out. Its so helpful to a parent!
When inconsiderate people park there without thinking it leaves me driving around with a screaming toddler and a crying baby trying to find a decent spot where I have some room - some car parks have such narrow spots its impossible to get my kids in and out without hitting a car.

I've caught some people in the act, and have confonted them 'Hey I think you've left your kids in the car' but no one thinks they sre doing anything wrong or should move.

I think family spots should have the same rules as disabled spots. Just don't know how that would be implimented.

OP posts:
unicornpower · 09/03/2024 13:49

Simonjt · 08/03/2024 19:42

Parent and child spaces absolutelt shouldn’t have the same importance or legislation as blue badge spaces.

We have a civic, so not huge, not small, its fine getting our two in and out, when our two year old was younger it was also fine getting her out as car seats should remain in the car, not taken out as a pushchair as the position isn’t suitable for a small baby to be in for long periods. Using a sling or a proper pushchair is what people should be doing, rather than choosing to repeatedly take a huge plastic seat in and out of the car when they don’t need to.

Sometimes though, taking your car seat out of the car is necessary? For example, I would do the nursery run (10mins in car) baby falls asleep, I nip into Tesco on way home, baby still asleep. Rather than wake her when I’m only going to be a few mins, take the car seat out and put it on the designated trolley and put it back in after, all whilst baby stays asleep. Shes only been In her seat a short while and not exceeded 30m.

unicornpower · 09/03/2024 13:43

It infuriates me too when I can’t get a P&C spot with 2 under 2. Especially at our local Aldi when the ordinary spaces are TINY. no issue with people with mobility issues using them obviously, but when able bodied people park in there because they CBA walking (which, they do! Not everyone has a hidden disability, some people are just selfish) it’s very annoying. I’d be up for them being further away from the store for sure! Also, it’s very annoying when parents park there with children who aren’t in car seats as surely that’s the whole point of wider bays? Teenagers can get in and out as adults. No need to park there. I saw this x3 this morning.

LadyKenya · 09/03/2024 13:41

Zodfa · 09/03/2024 12:53

Is it offensive to disabled people if I support both child benefit and disability living allowance?

I am not quite sure what you mean by that, but disabled people have individual thoughts on things, so there we are.

Sirzy · 09/03/2024 13:40

qunari · 09/03/2024 13:23

It's nuts to me that P&C spaces are closer than BB spaces.

We have a newly built shopping complex near us, the P and C spaces are right outside the shops. The blue badge spaces are across the road. If I have to take Ds (15) with me I park in P and C because it’s safer for him than the blue badge space.

i find it unbelievable that developers are prioritising p and c over disabled spaces!

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 13:38

Megifer · 09/03/2024 13:20

Shes not fully mobile but doesn't qualify for a blue badge either (not that it matters I'd still use the p&c spaces as they are closer)

If your mum has limited mobility I don’t think reasonable people would deny her use of one of these spaces.

But your attitude is clearly that you’ll park where you like regardless.

This is why we can’t have nice things.

ZoeCM · 09/03/2024 13:32

I think the problem is that there are already far, far too many people out there who think disability is comparable to parenthood. Look at virtually any thread about prams in wheelchair spaces on buses: there are countless posts about how parents with prams shouldn't have to get off the bus for a wheelchair user. "It should be first-come, first-served. What if the mum's had a stressful day and the kids are screaming? What if she has a doctor's appointment and the wheelchair user is only going to the shops? What if she has PND?"

The entire world is set up for able-bodied people, yet disabled people are constantly expected to justify their right to the few spaces that were created specifically for them (and that THEY had to fight for in the first place.) It gets exhausting. If you put P&C spaces on a par with disabled spaces, it blurs the lines and just adds to the idea that the two situations are remotely comparable.

As others have said, it would make far more sense to put P&C spaces at the back of the car park. Then people would be unlikely to use them unless they actually needed more space.

qunari · 09/03/2024 13:23

Megifer · 09/03/2024 13:20

Shes not fully mobile but doesn't qualify for a blue badge either (not that it matters I'd still use the p&c spaces as they are closer)

It's nuts to me that P&C spaces are closer than BB spaces.

Todaynottomora · 09/03/2024 13:23

I always park furthest away because it’s a lot quicker, calmer and easier and don’t understand why others don’t spread out whenever it’s possible. It’s more peaceful as I don’t have someone with a running engine waiting for me. If the children are playing up it’s also easier not having everyone coming and going around you too. For my older child I’m also finding it a useful time to help them understand safety too.

I particularly like one store that has extra space lines for all users and so if it’s a busy time it really helps us all particularly on days when I would find it difficult without the extra space when I don’t even have any children with me. I think your AIBU should be shouldn’t all stores provide adequate parking spaces for all their users and especially hospitals!

Megifer · 09/03/2024 13:20

tittybumbum · 09/03/2024 13:13

If your mum is fully mobile but just old you should drop her at the front then park your car

Shes not fully mobile but doesn't qualify for a blue badge either (not that it matters I'd still use the p&c spaces as they are closer)

tittybumbum · 09/03/2024 13:13

Megifer · 09/03/2024 13:05

They're great when I take my mum shopping. Close to the doors so she doesn't have as far to walk and nice wide spaces so she can get in and out easily 😃

If your mum is fully mobile but just old you should drop her at the front then park your car

UpsideLeft · 09/03/2024 13:12

Learn to manage your expectations and anger OP

Megifer · 09/03/2024 13:05

They're great when I take my mum shopping. Close to the doors so she doesn't have as far to walk and nice wide spaces so she can get in and out easily 😃

tittybumbum · 09/03/2024 13:03

@fakeprofile

Fwiw, car seats are not commonly used in Indonesia, and there aren’t parent and child parking spaces either - we manage fine. If I’m not driving, our driver drops us off at the store entrance. They are not really comparable situations, so not sure what your point is.

Oh bless. If there aren't P&C spaces it's ok because your driver drops you off.

Ok

I rest my case

tittybumbum · 09/03/2024 13:00

@enchantedsquirrelwood

It's not for the rest of the world to make allowances for chosen lifestyle decisions.

Suggesting procreation is merely a lifestyle choice is bordering on idiotic.

We are a society. Societies should behave in ways that benefit the whole and yes of course we accommodate children because they are the youngest members of our society.

Geneti · 09/03/2024 12:57

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 11:49

I agree with everything you said about the rights of disabled people. I agree that their rights are crucial, hard-won and often insufficient.

If there is a case where disabled people are competing for limited space with parents (eg on a bus), of course disabled people should have those spaces.

But OP wasn’t talking about any sort of situation where p&c spaces take away from disabled people. She was using a comparison with the way spaces are (or should be) regulated.

If p&c spaces were regulated (as some posters have said they actually are in their area) then that would a) make things easier for parents and b) have no impact on disabled people.

Clearly it’s a fairly unworkable idea though. The bb scheme is very (rightly) tightly controlled. I can’t actually see how you could have a similar badge scheme for parents really.

But that’s not really the point. OP made a passing comparison alluding to the way spaces are regulated according to who they’re for. She didn’t put forward a detailed proposal for enforcement.

Anyone who read that with an ounce of critical thinking will have (I hope) assumed that OP was working on the assumption that a) disabled spaces remain unaffected and b) disabled people would of course be welcome to the p&c spaces as now.

Some posters, it seems, were ready to pounce just because of this completely undeveloped comparison. To me, that smacks of posters looking for a reason to pile on.

It also offered a nice excuse for those who just can’t wait to have a go at mothers. There are some who scorn any and all measures put in place to help mothers. This scorn comes from a bad place. And that place is called misogyny.

The problem with drawing parity in law between being disabled and having a child with you isn’t that it necessarily has a physical effect on parking spaces per say, as you said, it doesn’t necessarily imply that bb spaces would be removed or replaced by p/c spaces-

although actually, if shops were told they had to provide spaces both for p/c and disabled people under the same legislation it’s extremely likely that they would start to label spaces as ‘accessible’ and allow people with kids and disabled people to use the same spaces, because it’s easier and cheaper for them-

this is exactly what has happened with accessible toilets having baby changing in them,

and even with the large scale removal of luggage spaces on busses meaning disabled people are fighting for access (because the buses want bums on seats, and as many seats as possible- so if they are forced to leave empty space for wheelchairs they have taken it back in luggage space, but people still have luggage and prams)…

basically no profit driven entity is going to give up anything if they don’t have to, so the reality is that when one group gains, another loses- wheelchair bus spaces are gained by disabled people but parents with prams loose out-

The larger damage is in the change in mindset and beliefs of the population- disabled people are already bottom of the pile, with many people resenting any support we get: if the government starts legislating for parents with children in the same way they do for disabled people, then the resentment of and feelings of entitlement towards our provisions will be strengthened.

The message will be that nice to have convenience things (p/c spaces, space not to fold a pram etc) are as important as necessary to normal living things (bb spaces, accessible toilets), and people will be even bigger twats about it than they are already.

Zodfa · 09/03/2024 12:53

Is it offensive to disabled people if I support both child benefit and disability living allowance?

PixieLaLar · 09/03/2024 12:46

I think family spots should have the same rules as disabled spots.

Oh look another entitled parent trying to compare disability to having children…

waterlellon · 09/03/2024 12:42

Daisysrblu · 09/03/2024 12:33

Just because disabled people need the bigger spaces more than parents doesn't mean that parents don't need them more than the general population. That's why these spaces exist.

It's like saying you shouldnt go to hospital and get your broken finger sorted out because other people might have a broken back.

Well put

OrwellsRoses · 09/03/2024 12:41

I'm disabled and parent to a (almost) toddler. I absoultely believe that there is a need for P&C parking spaces. Just because 'in their day' there wasn't P&C doesn't mean that is a good thing. Cars are enormous now and it isn't safe for parents to try and wrangle children out of busy carparks with cars parked cheek by jowl. It's safer to have bigger P&C spaces.

Non disabled people without young children who park in those spaces are imo selfish pricks.

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 12:35

Bottom line is, if you went into Tesco as a parent of a toddler and said ‘Am I entitled to use this p&c space’ they would say yes. They would say ‘no’ to the able-bodied non-parent. And possibly fine them.

This is the boundary OP wants to defend.

It’s entirely reasonable. But it’s brought out all the ‘not in my days’ and the closet misogynists. That’s why I will defend OP - because that toxic pile-on was not nice to watch.

Perhaps it would be better to have no p&c spaces 🤷‍♀️but since we do have them, can’t mothers, you know, have them instead of budging up for everyone else (not including disabled people)?

Daisysrblu · 09/03/2024 12:33

Just because disabled people need the bigger spaces more than parents doesn't mean that parents don't need them more than the general population. That's why these spaces exist.

It's like saying you shouldnt go to hospital and get your broken finger sorted out because other people might have a broken back.

Daisysrblu · 09/03/2024 12:30

"I do know that occasionally someone decides to park right next to someone in a completely/partly empty car park. But probably not on both sides, so you can still get in"

Nope
Happened to me when my twins were little. I could not get them in on either side of the car. And no I didn't have their car seats in the buggy. We had to wait 20 or so minutes for a traffic warden to come.along so I could ask her to stand with the buggy while I pulled out of the space to get them in because I wasn't going to leave 2 11 month (or thereabouts I can't remember exactly how old) babies alone in a buggy, while I got back in the car, shut the door and started to pull away. What do you think they'd have thought I was doing? I'm going to guess they'd have thought i was abandoning them right there.
There were no p and c spaces in that carpark.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 09/03/2024 12:29

It is not the same entitlement, however you choose to interpret it.

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 12:26

enchantedsquirrelwood · 09/03/2024 12:24

To clarify: parents are entitledto p&c spaces. Disabled peopleare entitledto bb spaces and p&c spaces

It should be parents of under 5s or of disabled children. Not drivers of SUVs who happen to have an under 18 in the car.

Yes - agreed.

waterlellon · 09/03/2024 12:25

Kwasi · 09/03/2024 11:29

And the only way to calm them down is to park in a parent and child space?

They probably park thinking they'll get out and have a lovely time then their kid meltsdown and so one parent just "nips out quickly"