Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is with childless people parking in family spots!!!

517 replies

Asher09 · 08/03/2024 07:00

I have a toddler and a baby - so thats 2 car seats and a double pram. I genuinly need a fair bit of space when parking and recently I've seen so many people without children parking in the family spots - its so frustrating!

Surely family spots are there for a reason - they're closer to entrances and allow more space to get in and out. Its so helpful to a parent!
When inconsiderate people park there without thinking it leaves me driving around with a screaming toddler and a crying baby trying to find a decent spot where I have some room - some car parks have such narrow spots its impossible to get my kids in and out without hitting a car.

I've caught some people in the act, and have confonted them 'Hey I think you've left your kids in the car' but no one thinks they sre doing anything wrong or should move.

I think family spots should have the same rules as disabled spots. Just don't know how that would be implimented.

OP posts:
Underhisi · 10/03/2024 11:26

I recommend reins for those with running off toddlers. We still use them with severely learning disabled teenage ds.

Underhisi · 10/03/2024 11:24

"Ultimately, if I am fit enough to shop, I am fit enough to walk a little further from a normal park."

People often use them because of needing extra space to get out rather than distance to shop.

GreenAppleCrumble · 10/03/2024 11:03

seasaltbarbie · 10/03/2024 07:44

Is there a reason why everyone in the car is screaming? 😆 sorry but it’s not that hard, I have a baby and a toddler and usually just find a space that doesn’t have a car parked next to it, literally every mother in the history of driving to supermarkets has managed, there are very rarely p&c spaces available. No offence but are you on the larger side? That could be why you struggle as I struggled when I was pregnant but it’s not hard to slip into a small space and grab an even smaller human get them out if your smaller.

Nicely done, but it’s clear you are trying to be offensive here.

Are you… fat, OP?

We see you.

Newbutoldfather · 10/03/2024 10:55

I don’t know why people don’t seem to understand the need for p&c spaces.

If the spaces are small (as they often are) and you have to lift a small child out, it is impossible without being able to open the door a certain amount.

Clearly parents with children above about 6 using them is not their purpose and I can see why it might annoy elderly less mobile people.

Of course, your local super centre may always have empty parks a bit further away, but some close to me are always chockablock and people queue for parks.

My children are teens now and it would never occur to me to use one, even sometimes when I had small injuries and was hobbling around. Ultimately, if I am fit enough to shop, I am fit enough to walk a little further from a normal park.

crochetcatsknitting · 10/03/2024 09:27

Not read the full thread because I got irritated very quickly. I was also indifferent to the reasons for parent and child parking spaces.

Until the day I tried to navigate my way across a busy parking lot with my two children. I was pushing a very heavy trolley laden with groceries and my baby son in a car seat - with one hand - while also trying to hold my toddlers hand who was straining hard to be released. Pushing a trolley with one hand while a child is going bonkers in the other hand and be alert to traffic and risk is very very hard.

She slipped my grasp and I had to choose between abandoning the trolley and my baby, or grabbing for her. I was trying to do both and failing. She came damn close to being knocked by a car and I managed with the help of a stranger. It all took seconds.

I see those spaces about safeguarding. Safeguarding is never about the majority who mostly are unaffected and who (frankly) come on threads judging and sneering. It's for the tiny minority who have moments like I did.

My children are much older now and do what they are told in the presence of cars. I NEVER park in those spaces, not because of princess mothers, but because it helps keep struggling excitable toddlers safe.

(... I now wait for the comments telling me I should have grown three hands, only gone shopping with a friend, been a better mother to a three year old so it knew how to behave properly, only shopped at midnight when there were no cars around, etc ... To which my response is 'Toddlers bored in supermarkets. Exhausted mothers. Life + kids routines. Etc'

seasaltbarbie · 10/03/2024 07:44

Is there a reason why everyone in the car is screaming? 😆 sorry but it’s not that hard, I have a baby and a toddler and usually just find a space that doesn’t have a car parked next to it, literally every mother in the history of driving to supermarkets has managed, there are very rarely p&c spaces available. No offence but are you on the larger side? That could be why you struggle as I struggled when I was pregnant but it’s not hard to slip into a small space and grab an even smaller human get them out if your smaller.

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 20:55

Tahinii · 09/03/2024 18:46

So sorry, I did quote the wrong person! I was agreeing with you 🙂 and disagreeing with them. I never get the quote function quite right.

Oh ok 😂I’ll stand down!

eatsleepfarmrepeat · 09/03/2024 20:52

tittybumbum · 09/03/2024 09:18

But that would remove one of the explicit purposes of P&C parking.

They reasons they are where they are is to reduce the distance small dc have to navigate around moving cars. Especially reversing cars and cars so tall they can't see small dc. Parents frequently have multiple children. One in a pram and one or two walking. Or a shopping cart and one or two walking.

It's a hazard.

If you cannot manage to get your child safely from one side of the car park to the other, you’ve got bigger problems than P&C spaces pal.

Tahinii · 09/03/2024 18:46

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 15:39

Yes, but your point has nothing to do with mine, so I not sure why you quoted me.

If you want to take this up with me, perhaps read where I’ve said, repeatedly, that there is no way disabled people should be impacted at all by p&c spaces (other than that they should be free to use them of course).

The post you’ve quoted was in response to a pp wondering what people would do if p&c spaces were full. My response: they’d cope.

So sorry, I did quote the wrong person! I was agreeing with you 🙂 and disagreeing with them. I never get the quote function quite right.

Catwench · 09/03/2024 17:23

I agree with you. I have a toddler and unless I can open my door fully I can’t get him out due to they style of my car however, I also have a mom who is awaiting an operation and struggles to go out. She can’t get a blue badge as it’s not permanent however she would be unstable on her own so I can’t just drop her off and park. When I’m with her I will use a parent and child space on the odd occasion I take her out. Things like this need to be looked into, however I agree I hate seeing people who don’t need them in any way using them. I’ve seen some just park in them to use there phone or wait for someone. This needs addressing.

Timeturnerplease · 09/03/2024 16:37

Whinge · 08/03/2024 07:13

I often wonder how many parents would use these spots if they were the furthest ones away from the store's entrance.

Mine are 2.5 and 5 now so less of an issue but back then I absolutely would have not cared one jot about distance from the store. What I cared about was not reducing mine or anyone else’s car to scrap metal while I wrestled a baby seat, buggy, buggy board, baby and toddler in and out.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 09/03/2024 16:25

It’s vital that disabled people have their rights protected in law, of course, but does that mean that no other group, whose needs might be distinct but not as serious, can never get anything protected in law because it makes laws for other groups look less important?

If the legal protection to the other group would lead to the legal protection being watered down, then no, legal protection should not be offered to the other group.

The PP you’re replying to gave great examples of what happens when companies/businesses are given the impression that parents have equal rights in law to disabled people. They merge the facilities provided and call them “accessible”. Then the disabled people find themselves without the legal protection which they’re due, because it’s all being used by parents.

The only way in which I’d support P&C spaces having legal protection is if said legislation required them all to be moved to the back of the car park (with roof-covered walkway). That way, there’d be no risk of them being merged with BB spaces. I’d also want there to be an increase in spaces for disabled people (not just BB-holders) at the front of the park, in recognition of the fact that moving P&C spaces adversely affects people who can’t use BB spaces but need to be closer to the store entry.

It’s not that no other group can be protected, but disabled people have a legal protection that parents do not have, and yes, the effect on the former takes precedence over the effect on the latter.

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 16:11

Geneti · 09/03/2024 16:09

Is it so wrong for a mother to expect able-bodied non-parents not too clog up all the p&c spaces? Really?

Not in the least, it would piss me off too. It’s thoughtless and inconvenient for parents.

The only thing that’s wrong is thinking that that experience of thoughtlessness and inconvenience is the same as the experience of disabled people.

Ok. I concede that.

Geneti · 09/03/2024 16:09

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 15:50

I appreciate what you’re saying and your post is very sensible. Thank you for explaining it.

I still don’t think this wholesale take-down of the OP was warranted in the slightest just because she made a (possibly thoughtless) comparison with the way another group’s spaces are guarded, and I’m not sure this sort of speculation is warranted on the strength of her comment:

although actually, if shops were told they had to provide spaces both for p/c and disabled people under the same legislation it’s extremely likely that they would start to label spaces as ‘accessible’ and allow people with kids and disabled people to use the same spaces, because it’s easier and cheaper for them-

OP wasn’t putting forward ideas for legislation!! She quite clearly meant just in the sense of ‘properly regulated’. As others have suggested, too, the disabled spaces on private land aren’t necessarily protected in the same way in law as council blue badge spaces.

I do take your point about ‘muddying the waters’ to some extent, but where does that end? It’s vital that disabled people have their rights protected in law, of course, but does that mean that no other group, whose needs might be distinct but not as serious, can never get anything protected in law because it makes laws for other groups look less important?

Is it so wrong for a mother to expect able-bodied non-parents not too clog up all the p&c spaces? Really?

Is it so wrong for a mother to expect able-bodied non-parents not too clog up all the p&c spaces? Really?

Not in the least, it would piss me off too. It’s thoughtless and inconvenient for parents.

The only thing that’s wrong is thinking that that experience of thoughtlessness and inconvenience is the same as the experience of disabled people.

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 15:50

Geneti · 09/03/2024 12:57

The problem with drawing parity in law between being disabled and having a child with you isn’t that it necessarily has a physical effect on parking spaces per say, as you said, it doesn’t necessarily imply that bb spaces would be removed or replaced by p/c spaces-

although actually, if shops were told they had to provide spaces both for p/c and disabled people under the same legislation it’s extremely likely that they would start to label spaces as ‘accessible’ and allow people with kids and disabled people to use the same spaces, because it’s easier and cheaper for them-

this is exactly what has happened with accessible toilets having baby changing in them,

and even with the large scale removal of luggage spaces on busses meaning disabled people are fighting for access (because the buses want bums on seats, and as many seats as possible- so if they are forced to leave empty space for wheelchairs they have taken it back in luggage space, but people still have luggage and prams)…

basically no profit driven entity is going to give up anything if they don’t have to, so the reality is that when one group gains, another loses- wheelchair bus spaces are gained by disabled people but parents with prams loose out-

The larger damage is in the change in mindset and beliefs of the population- disabled people are already bottom of the pile, with many people resenting any support we get: if the government starts legislating for parents with children in the same way they do for disabled people, then the resentment of and feelings of entitlement towards our provisions will be strengthened.

The message will be that nice to have convenience things (p/c spaces, space not to fold a pram etc) are as important as necessary to normal living things (bb spaces, accessible toilets), and people will be even bigger twats about it than they are already.

I appreciate what you’re saying and your post is very sensible. Thank you for explaining it.

I still don’t think this wholesale take-down of the OP was warranted in the slightest just because she made a (possibly thoughtless) comparison with the way another group’s spaces are guarded, and I’m not sure this sort of speculation is warranted on the strength of her comment:

although actually, if shops were told they had to provide spaces both for p/c and disabled people under the same legislation it’s extremely likely that they would start to label spaces as ‘accessible’ and allow people with kids and disabled people to use the same spaces, because it’s easier and cheaper for them-

OP wasn’t putting forward ideas for legislation!! She quite clearly meant just in the sense of ‘properly regulated’. As others have suggested, too, the disabled spaces on private land aren’t necessarily protected in the same way in law as council blue badge spaces.

I do take your point about ‘muddying the waters’ to some extent, but where does that end? It’s vital that disabled people have their rights protected in law, of course, but does that mean that no other group, whose needs might be distinct but not as serious, can never get anything protected in law because it makes laws for other groups look less important?

Is it so wrong for a mother to expect able-bodied non-parents not too clog up all the p&c spaces? Really?

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 15:39

Tahinii · 09/03/2024 14:49

Yes, that’s the point. It’s “annoying” if you can’t get parked with a baby/small child or multiple of them. People can and do park without the wider spaces as evidence by any children’s attraction. A person with a disability may need to go home if they cannot find a space. That is completely incomparable.

Yes, but your point has nothing to do with mine, so I not sure why you quoted me.

If you want to take this up with me, perhaps read where I’ve said, repeatedly, that there is no way disabled people should be impacted at all by p&c spaces (other than that they should be free to use them of course).

The post you’ve quoted was in response to a pp wondering what people would do if p&c spaces were full. My response: they’d cope.

Tahinii · 09/03/2024 14:49

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 12:18

I think it’s you who doesn’t understand the original meaning of ‘entitled’ to be honest.

If the spaces are legitimately full - no problem. If they’re full of people who aren’t entitled to them, it’s kind of annoying. That’s all.

Yes, that’s the point. It’s “annoying” if you can’t get parked with a baby/small child or multiple of them. People can and do park without the wider spaces as evidence by any children’s attraction. A person with a disability may need to go home if they cannot find a space. That is completely incomparable.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 09/03/2024 14:49

ZoeCM · 09/03/2024 13:32

I think the problem is that there are already far, far too many people out there who think disability is comparable to parenthood. Look at virtually any thread about prams in wheelchair spaces on buses: there are countless posts about how parents with prams shouldn't have to get off the bus for a wheelchair user. "It should be first-come, first-served. What if the mum's had a stressful day and the kids are screaming? What if she has a doctor's appointment and the wheelchair user is only going to the shops? What if she has PND?"

The entire world is set up for able-bodied people, yet disabled people are constantly expected to justify their right to the few spaces that were created specifically for them (and that THEY had to fight for in the first place.) It gets exhausting. If you put P&C spaces on a par with disabled spaces, it blurs the lines and just adds to the idea that the two situations are remotely comparable.

As others have said, it would make far more sense to put P&C spaces at the back of the car park. Then people would be unlikely to use them unless they actually needed more space.

I agree with this.

Megifer · 09/03/2024 14:38

JenniferBooth · 09/03/2024 14:31

A friend of mine has been waiting five years for a knee replacement. His mobility is so bad that he shuffles..........slowly. Cant park in a family spot and cant park in a disabled spot as his mobility issue is considered temporary despite the fact its already been FIVE YEARS waiting for the NHS to pull their finger out A lifetime of physical work and this is the thanks he gets.

Poor guy, he can use the p&c spaces though

JenniferBooth · 09/03/2024 14:31

A friend of mine has been waiting five years for a knee replacement. His mobility is so bad that he shuffles..........slowly. Cant park in a family spot and cant park in a disabled spot as his mobility issue is considered temporary despite the fact its already been FIVE YEARS waiting for the NHS to pull their finger out A lifetime of physical work and this is the thanks he gets.

AlpineMuesli · 09/03/2024 14:29

Private parking appears to be a free for all. I can only conclude that if you want to park someone in, you can do it as well.

Whilst it an offence to park in an on-street Blue Badge parking bay without displaying a valid Blue Badge, this does not apply to disabled bays on private land like a supermarket. Here, it is just down to how the land owner decides to police it.

unicornpower · 09/03/2024 14:25

Megifer · 09/03/2024 14:07

My attitude is ill park where its good (and legal) for mum.

Not quite parking where I'd like regardless, that would be right outside the door at the pick up bay, especially if it's raining 😬

I saw someone parked there the other day so you’d probably get away with it!

MrDobbs · 09/03/2024 14:21

It's not illegal for anyone to park in a parent and child space so people can do whatever they want if it's legal. Just as there's no law against farting in a crowded lift.

But it's indisputable that its just easier to get small children out of car seats when you have a little bit more space.

So if you're someone who decides to park in a P&C space in a busy car park because you can't be arsed to walk a bit further, and don't really care that you're making life a little bit more difficult for someone with small children, you're not breaking any laws but I think you're a bit of a cunt.

If you don't mind a little bit of negligible inconvenience on your part in order to make someone else's life a bit easier, I think you're OK and help make the world a bit of a better place. Luckily, this is most people.

Megifer · 09/03/2024 14:07

GreenAppleCrumble · 09/03/2024 13:38

If your mum has limited mobility I don’t think reasonable people would deny her use of one of these spaces.

But your attitude is clearly that you’ll park where you like regardless.

This is why we can’t have nice things.

My attitude is ill park where its good (and legal) for mum.

Not quite parking where I'd like regardless, that would be right outside the door at the pick up bay, especially if it's raining 😬

Babyboomtastic · 09/03/2024 14:04

Maybe we have more of the spaces and change them from being parent and child to being 'priority spaces'. To use one you do need to display a badge.

The badges are funded jointly by supermarkets etc, and available online or in store. They can be used for disability which falls short of a blue badge -perfect for injuries, recoveries etc. They can be used for children, pregnant women etc.

I have a child with mobility issues whose difficulties wouldn't be bad enough to get a blue badge but equally would make walking from the other side of the car park difficult. I also need to help her in/out, so need the doors to fully open. At the moment she is young enough that a P&C space is fine, but in 5 years it'll start getting funny looks...