Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely sick of the ‘natural menopause is good’ narrative!

159 replies

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 05:45

This article was all over the media yeaterday:
https://unherd.com/2024/03/has-hrt-propaganda-misled-women/

It makes me so angry! Why is it that suddenly seeking treatment for symptoms in menopause being framed like this? In no other area of health is it considered acceptable to not seek treatment if you have debilitating symptoms. It’s utter misogyny.

Its ok for men in mid life to get treatment for their erectile dysfunction but women, ‘battle on through with some yoga and vitamins and stop complaining’

It reminds me a bit of the slightly toxic NCT ‘natural births and breastfeeding’ are the best way making any women who had a medical birth and couldn’t breastfeed an utter failure.

How is this narrative acceptable for women’s Heath? Menopause is absolutely fucking awful for some women - if you sail through with no symptoms, all power to you, but HRT is a lifesaver for many women.

Has HRT propaganda misled women?

https://unherd.com/2024/03/has-hrt-propaganda-misled-women/

OP posts:
Barney16 · 08/03/2024 07:12

I had to go private to get HRT initially because my GP was useless. Im very happy on HRT because it relieves the symptoms that were really impactful on my life. All options should be available to everyone but I'm not sure that's the case.

JaninaDuszejko · 08/03/2024 07:11

I think both articles you've linked to seem perfectly reasonable and thoughtful discussions of complex issues.

WRT the menopause I'm one of the lucky ones, at 53 I still have regular periods and I've had no debilitating menopause symptoms. My Mum had a relatively late menopause and I'm clearly going to as well. But I've been told on here that I definitely should be taking HRT for preventative reasons even though I'm obviously still producing my own hormones and likely will be for longer than someone who has an early menopause will be told to take HRT. We are also constantly bombarded at work about the menopause and how debilitating it is. It feels like quite a negative narritive TBH, 'watch out for those middle aged women, they're all going a bit hysterical'.

I think it's important that debilitating menopause symptoms are treated appropriately. Doctors need to be better educated about women's health and there needs to be good quality research into the positives and negatives of every treatment. But the current popular narrative that suggests every woman over 45 needs medication is as bad as suggesting that we should put up and shut up.

TheHardyStork · 08/03/2024 07:11

I think that the idea not everyone needs or wants HRT seems to have been lost recently.
There has been a massive push on it (HRT as a cure all) my friends and I are in our mid to late 40s and it seems like every illness we get is put down to menopause and the vast majority want HRT and are put on it.

I'm actually coping perfectly well with crazy periods, down to about 2 a year now so hopefully nearly there, a few aches and pains, a bit forgetful and hot flushes. The doctor has told me if I don't want HRT, which he is happy to prescribe then to make sure I lift weights to maintain bone strength.

I'm sure menopause is debilitating for some women, but it's OK for me. My mum had an easy time with it too so maybe it's genetic.

I think it's important that women know there is a choice but one view shouldn't be pushed over another.

Battytwatty · 08/03/2024 07:10

@Lightsideofthemoon Stock was hounded out of her job at your institution. And I think her article in Unherd was spot on and very well written.

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:05

@Divebar2021 I think it’s because I follow a lot of menopause people on ‘menopause Twitter’ it was being widely debated by both camps. I started following them because I was repeatedly fobbed off for 5 years by the doctor and it was desperation in the end to get information. It’s that too that winds me up- a lot of the influencers that the article refers to have been a lifeline for women like me, repeatedly fobbed off and not able to understand what was wrong with me! It’s about health education too - not propaganda as the article calls it!

OP posts:
Divebar2021 · 08/03/2024 07:04

I liked this comment.

To be absolutely sick of the ‘natural menopause is good’ narrative!
Whenwillitgetwarm · 08/03/2024 07:03

And why is that anything ‘natural’ has a picture of Gwyneth Paltrow’ to promote it?

She has ample free time to do yoga, pay for nutritionists, have duvet days in her massive room with a sea view in California where she can work on maintaining her lovely tan.

She’s not under any stress that means if she can’t perform she risks losing her job and house. Plus she smokes and has a troubling relationship with food (see her promotion of Bone Broth as an appetite suppressant).

Divebar2021 · 08/03/2024 07:00

I read most of the article - written by a GP and someone else with medical qualifications ( whatever that means) - perhaps that explains the repeated mention of hot flushes with little mention of the myriad of other symptoms like insomnia / low mood/ joint pain / brain fog. My GP was also only really interested in physical symptoms and since I wasn’t experiencing hot flushes all my other symptoms seem to be swept aside. That article was making claims that were not especially balanced or supported by evidence - cherry picking. The suggestion that women are taking their health advice from “ influencers” is rather patronising. It’s not like we have opportunity to discuss this much with our own GPS in our 5/10 minutes appointments so where are we supposed to go for our impartial information?
I’m not sure if a natural menopause is being pushed in the media or not because of one article like that though. I doubt I would have seen it if the OP hadn’t posted it

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 06:55

@SuperstarDeejay no, I am saying that there has been a narrative shift. I believe that women should get proper healthcare support and this recent ‘get some CBT for your hot flushes’ narrative takes the emphasis away from getting the proper treatment women need.

OP posts:
SuperstarDeejay · 08/03/2024 06:53

My take on the article is that not every physical and mental ailment women suffer from after 40 is menopause related or will be cured by HRT. It questions whether the benefits of HRT are being oversold. If HRT is working for you and your symptoms then the article isn't about you... don't know why you would get offended or discount it completely? You're kind of showing that unquestioning HRT fangirl vibe that the article is expressing caution about.

Reallybadidea · 08/03/2024 06:53

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 06:46

@jeaux90 yea, I work at the institution Kathleen stock left. I don’t like her views in that article. I don’t think she is a feminist.

Are you going to explain why?

DappledThings · 08/03/2024 06:52

I'm not seeing the prevailing narrative as you are OP. It seems to me very much that a horrendous time during menopause is inevitable and every woman should be on HRT.

I've not looked into it much yet and if I feel worse and need HRT later I'm happy to go along with it but "natural is best" is really not the message I hear anywhere.

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 06:51

I think the problem is though that women weren’t getting a balanced approach. My doc never diagnosed PMDD, never believed that the fact I felt suicidal for 5 days of the month might be hormones! Never made the link. Never suggested HRT. Just kind of suggested I might be a bit mad. It’s awful!

OP posts:
Oakstreet · 08/03/2024 06:49

Wenttomowameadow · 08/03/2024 06:28

I think a balanced approach is good. Obviously provide access to hrt but recognise there are other management pathways.

I do worry that every single health issue over 38 is now being categorised as 'peri'. I think this does women's health a huge disservice.

I totally agree. There are many different culture's that through diet alone and natural remedies health get through it better then the westerners. Far east is one, Japan especially. People should do what feels right to them, but every little headache and heart palpitations is peri. By the way I would get checked out for heart palpitations and not bank on it being peri.

ineedsun · 08/03/2024 06:48

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 06:40

@ineedsun is it propaganda though? Or a campaign to make sure women are getting the access to the treatments they need rather than being fobbed off with antidepressants and CBT. Women in menopause ended up in mental health units less than a generation ago- do we really need to be heading back that way? We have modern medicine.

I am very healthy, don’t drink, normal blood pressure, exercise, normal weight etc. I still ended up a total wreck thanks to hormones & HRT has helped. It’s kept me in my job.

As I said, it’s great for you and the thousands of people who it has helped.

The issue is that now, as soon as you hit a certain age you’re bombarded with well meaning advice and infographics from non-scientific sources suggesting that as soon as you experience any of the 356 symptoms of menopause you should ask for HRT and if you don’t get it it’s because the Doctor is negligent and the world is misogynistic.

I’ve had endometriosis for about 35 years so I know what it’s like to be fobbed off etc, I’m not dismissing the experience of many many women who struggled and weren’t heard. All I’m saying is that balance is important. And that anti-depressants and CBT might actually be what some people need.

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 06:46

@jeaux90 yea, I work at the institution Kathleen stock left. I don’t like her views in that article. I don’t think she is a feminist.

OP posts:
Kikisweb · 08/03/2024 06:43

My mum had a reverse experience, was pushed to HRT then ignored and told she just had to get through it when the HRT made her suicidal. She then had the same with Tamoxifen after breast cancer but male doctors simply didn't take her seriously and were dismissive and labelled her unwilling to accept treatment rather than listening to how mentally unwell the meds had made her. She stopped both fairly quick and has used more natural methods.

jeaux90 · 08/03/2024 06:42

@Lightsideofthemoon Kathleen Stock is a philosopher and the article is about ageing, feminism, surgical intervention and the way society looks at ageing women. I thought it was well written.

I agree women should be able to age however they like.

At first I also fell for the "natural" menopause and it almost destroyed my career so it's damaging and unrealistic.

As I said up the thread, HRT saved me.

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 06:40

@ineedsun is it propaganda though? Or a campaign to make sure women are getting the access to the treatments they need rather than being fobbed off with antidepressants and CBT. Women in menopause ended up in mental health units less than a generation ago- do we really need to be heading back that way? We have modern medicine.

I am very healthy, don’t drink, normal blood pressure, exercise, normal weight etc. I still ended up a total wreck thanks to hormones & HRT has helped. It’s kept me in my job.

OP posts:
Anameisaname · 08/03/2024 06:40

The point is always that we need to be given sufficient information to make an informed decision.
There's no single answer and I personally value HRT not just for symptoms but also for the longer term health benefits associated with oestrogen.
For years women were scared off with breast cancer risk due to a flawed study that never really got properly explained in the media. Now natural menopause is a thing.
I don't get why media feel the need to opine on this so much.

WandaWonder · 08/03/2024 06:36

Sure blame men for everything that will fix things, I take it that hrt is good for people who need it is not to be treated like sweets

ineedsun · 08/03/2024 06:34

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 06:28

@ineedsun I think it’s part of a wider narrative shift - you see it all over social media - get CBT for hot flushes when there is also a shortage of HRT. I actually don’t think the article is very balanced - even the title is intimating that there is propaganda around HRT use!

There is though, well intentioned though it may be.

The increased profile is clearly a good thing but as others have already pointed out a more balanced approach is important.

Im really pleased that HRT helped you, and thousands of others. All I think - and it’s what this article is saying - is that it’s not a panacea.

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 06:33

Women should be allowed to age however the fuck they want!

OP posts:
OP posts:
Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 06:30

@Whenwillitgetwarm yea, Unherd is a shocker too. The nasty article about Kylie a while back by Kathleen Stock too was a particular horror

OP posts: