Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely sick of the ‘natural menopause is good’ narrative!

159 replies

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 05:45

This article was all over the media yeaterday:
https://unherd.com/2024/03/has-hrt-propaganda-misled-women/

It makes me so angry! Why is it that suddenly seeking treatment for symptoms in menopause being framed like this? In no other area of health is it considered acceptable to not seek treatment if you have debilitating symptoms. It’s utter misogyny.

Its ok for men in mid life to get treatment for their erectile dysfunction but women, ‘battle on through with some yoga and vitamins and stop complaining’

It reminds me a bit of the slightly toxic NCT ‘natural births and breastfeeding’ are the best way making any women who had a medical birth and couldn’t breastfeed an utter failure.

How is this narrative acceptable for women’s Heath? Menopause is absolutely fucking awful for some women - if you sail through with no symptoms, all power to you, but HRT is a lifesaver for many women.

Has HRT propaganda misled women?

https://unherd.com/2024/03/has-hrt-propaganda-misled-women/

OP posts:
Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 08:02

@flippertyjibbets ex chancellor. Still doesn’t mean it’s everyone either.

OP posts:
swayingpalmtree · 08/03/2024 08:00

However, I see women thinking taking HRT obviates the need to exercise, manage their diet or address other endocrine issues that are more prevalent in middle-age

Not the case for me- I run pretty much every day, eat lots of oily fish, am gluten free, perfect BMI etc still had horrific peri symptoms

HRTQueen · 08/03/2024 07:59

I thought the article was interesting

HRT as with all medication needs to be monitored especially as our bodies are going through changes this really doesn’t happen for most women

I know for women the change has been huge for many just eased symptoms so they were bearable others it hasn’t helped at all but we still need to make changes to our lives and that takes effort I am really struggling with this bit

I accept my body and how I feel has changed forever I think some women really struggle with this part of accepting and HRT doesn’t solve that we are not meant to have the energy levels we did earlier in life it’s crap but I’m still here

EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2024 07:59

The analogy of the headache is if you have symptoms for anything that can be treated then help should be offered.

Of course.

And part of treatment may be non-medical. My GP took a full list of symptoms, prescribed HRT, and 3 months later, reviewed the symptoms with me. It was amazing to hear all my very debilitating symptoms and how HRT had, thankfully, alleviated them.

However, I see women thinking taking HRT obviates the need to exercise, manage their diet or address other endocrine issues that are more prevalent in middle-age.

flippertyjibbets · 08/03/2024 07:58

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:56

@EarringsandLipstick I’m tired of how staff were portrayed as a bunch of bullies as a collective whole. It’s not true.

this is from your own bloody chancellor:

www.sussex.ac.uk/broadcast/read/56597

ineedsun · 08/03/2024 07:58

EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2024 07:39

Well, you might not. Some people will prefer to drink water, rest,get fresh air - which might work for them.

It's all to do with the symptoms & the severity.

No medication is free from side-effects, and good GPs will consider several options.

I would add the cause to this. Taking paracetamol and continuing to not drink enough / not get fresh air / not wear glasses / sit in a chair which causes bad posture etc etc is pointless

swayingpalmtree · 08/03/2024 07:57

I agree with you OP. GPs are not equipped to know about menopause or peri menopause either.

When I started peri, I had some awful symptoms. Went to my GP and he insisted I went on anti depressants. I told him I didnt need them- I wasn't depressed but the only thing he'd give me was citalopram, which has other side effects so hardly "natural" by any means.

I didnt take it, went to see a private doctor and got bio identical hormones. It fixed the issue within 2 months. If I hadn't gone out and done my own research I'd still be on citalopram wondering why I still felt so rubbish. It wasn't just my mood either, I was having flooding every month.

It makes me so angry that doctors seem to have no clue about this and seem so unwilling to help or to explore other options. My GP never suggests anything natural anyway like relaxation or meditation- he's obsessed with just putting everyone on an anti depressant.

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:56

@EarringsandLipstick I’m tired of how staff were portrayed as a bunch of bullies as a collective whole. It’s not true.

OP posts:
Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/03/2024 07:56

14% of women take HRT. The idea that women are flocking yo their GP to get HRT & it’s handed over without a query is just nonsense

its interesting that with 86% of women not taking HRT, there still apparently needs to be a narrative telling us it isn’t a panacea (obvs with us being daft wims who only listen to celebrities we need to be told this)

AgnesX · 08/03/2024 07:55

TheHardyStork · 08/03/2024 07:49

The problem is, just like not all headaches need painkillers, not all menopause symptoms need HRT.

So for me.
Would I take painkillers for a bit of a tension headache - no I'd have a glass of water and a bit of fresh air, maybe a snooze.
Would I take painkillers for a sinus headache, a hormone headache or a migraine - absolutely.

Do I take HRT for my hot flushes, aches and pains and forgetfulness - no.
Would I take HRT if I had debilitating physical symptoms and depression- yes.

Everyone is different. The analogy of the headache is if you have symptoms for anything that can be treated then help should be offered.

People's (women's) symptoms shouldn't be dismissed - it's a terrible place to be in regardless of the condition.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2024 07:52

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:48

@flippertyjibbets i’m not derailing this thread talking about her. I used her article because it’s a good example of some of the stuff on Unherd but why should I have to justify anything. The whole thing was an absolute nightmare at work for a lot of people who work there - toxic in the extreme and hugely stressful and like many people who work there - it’s a decent place with decent people who are tired of it all.

'Tired of it all'?

What's 'it all'?

I work in a university. I agree the internal dynamics aren't always clear to the wider world.

But by their own admission what Sussex did to Kathleen Stock fell far short of acceptable treatment of an employee, at its most basic.

It's shocking you can even indirectly support that.

JaninaDuszejko · 08/03/2024 07:52

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:44

@JaninaDuszejko my best mate went through menopause at 39. Again, proper education is needed.

And I have said early onset menopause has health issues associated with it and should be treated appropriately which in most cases would require HRT.

The average age of menopause is 51 with a range of 45-55.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 08/03/2024 07:51

HRT was off the table for me due to high incidence of female cancers (breast / ovarian) in my close family.

My personal approach to health is that a holistic approach should be taken. Some women suffer terribly with menopause, some don't but there seems to be a bit of a narrative that women are rocking up to GPS to ask for a magic bullet for every little thing when I don't think it's true.

Every individual is pretty much physiologically unique yet a wholesale approach seems to be taken with women because "hormones".

Medical advances keep happening and we are more and more informed about how to "take responsibility" for our health so we can function optimally largely to ensure we meet our responsibilities not necessarily for our own well-being, so I agree with the OP that it's frustrating that something that has helped countless women is being questioned in this manner.

Early menopause runs in my family. When I was in my mid 30s I started getting all the weirdness of what I now know is peri-menopause. Bizarrely it started with generalised foot pain, then other aches and pains, then extra scattiness. I don't often go to the doctors but checked it out and was given a "diagnosis" of fibromyalgia and a disinterested shrug. At that appointment I was asked what was going on in my life which admittedly was stressful and I was then offered antidepressants. Which I declined.

In my early 40s when the night sweats turned into day monsoons, my new partner insisted I went to the GP again. By then I'd had the skinny from my Mum and knew what it was. But to reassure him off I trotted. The GP was dismissive. Despite telling him my family pattern, he said I was too young. I pressed for the blood test - I couldn't help but be a little "told you so" when the numbers confirmed i was deep in the process. I crashed through and was done and dusted by 50. It wasn't fun. If I could have taken HRT I would have.

I suppose the rambly point I'm trying to make is that women's health is still overly conflated with their emotions. This kind of article may have some merit but I get where the OP is coming from in that there is a subtle implication that when women are feeling crap and ask for help, it's some sort of moral failing or attention seeking. If HRT hadn't been "invented" we'd all be struggling through - but it has so if it helps and is suitable for the women who need it, why turn it into an issue?

It's part of the health paradox - one should be alert for anomalous symptoms to catch nasties like cancer quickly, but chances are your GP will roll their eyes because you've been googling too much.

Which is ironic, as my late Mum went two years dicking about with the Fodmap diet with symptoms indicating ovarian cancer. In the end her GP decided to try her on HRT (in her 70s) to help her tiredness. The required blood test showed up her Stage 4 cancer. So I'm pretty jaded about attitudes to women's health overall to be fair.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2024 07:49

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:43

@flippertyjibbets no, I am not an ‘awful bully’ and I can assure you she isn’t a fucking saint.

You know if you are going to throw out vague assertions, about someone who has definitely been horrendously treated (it's on record), then back them up.

As those of us who work in universities like to do.

TheHardyStork · 08/03/2024 07:49

AgnesX · 08/03/2024 07:37

I really don't understand the attitude. You have a headache you take a painkiller. Why is HRT any different.

The problem is, just like not all headaches need painkillers, not all menopause symptoms need HRT.

So for me.
Would I take painkillers for a bit of a tension headache - no I'd have a glass of water and a bit of fresh air, maybe a snooze.
Would I take painkillers for a sinus headache, a hormone headache or a migraine - absolutely.

Do I take HRT for my hot flushes, aches and pains and forgetfulness - no.
Would I take HRT if I had debilitating physical symptoms and depression- yes.

flippertyjibbets · 08/03/2024 07:49

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:48

@flippertyjibbets i’m not derailing this thread talking about her. I used her article because it’s a good example of some of the stuff on Unherd but why should I have to justify anything. The whole thing was an absolute nightmare at work for a lot of people who work there - toxic in the extreme and hugely stressful and like many people who work there - it’s a decent place with decent people who are tired of it all.

you derailed your own thread.

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:48

@flippertyjibbets i’m not derailing this thread talking about her. I used her article because it’s a good example of some of the stuff on Unherd but why should I have to justify anything. The whole thing was an absolute nightmare at work for a lot of people who work there - toxic in the extreme and hugely stressful and like many people who work there - it’s a decent place with decent people who are tired of it all.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2024 07:48

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:42

@EarringsandLipstick jesus. I think the point here though is the lack of good gps providing a balanced view. I can assure you that rest, a glass of water and some fresh air didn’t stop me feeling suicidal. And actually- i wasn’t sleeping because of my hormones and was getting panic attacks in the middle of the night.

🙄

That was to the poster who used the analogy of taking a pill for a headache. I was countering her analogy. Not suggesting fresh air for menopause symptoms.

I'm on HRT. I too had very dark, bleak days & horrendous symptoms.

I'm simply saying I have not seen the narrative you suggest; but I have noticed HRT being touted as a panacea for every rig or other issues not being investgafed, and that's also wrong.

flippertyjibbets · 08/03/2024 07:45

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:43

@flippertyjibbets no, I am not an ‘awful bully’ and I can assure you she isn’t a fucking saint.

being deliberately vague because you can't justify your comments about her because
you're a no debater?

flippertyjibbets · 08/03/2024 07:45

EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2024 07:41

@Lightsideofthemoon

Are you going to elaborate on your vague comments about Kathleen Stock?

There's clearly always more than what we see in the public discourse, but by any measure, the very obvious harassment and intimidation faced by Kathleen Stock, at her institution, which is on record, was appalling.

100 percent this.
It was horrific, deliberate intimidation by people who hadn't even read her book for the most part and think feminism is about empowering males to use female
spaces and colonise female sport. Fuck that shit.
If you supported the intimidation of Kathleen Stock op,
shame on you.

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:44

@JaninaDuszejko my best mate went through menopause at 39. Again, proper education is needed.

OP posts:
Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:43

@flippertyjibbets no, I am not an ‘awful bully’ and I can assure you she isn’t a fucking saint.

OP posts:
Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:42

@EarringsandLipstick jesus. I think the point here though is the lack of good gps providing a balanced view. I can assure you that rest, a glass of water and some fresh air didn’t stop me feeling suicidal. And actually- i wasn’t sleeping because of my hormones and was getting panic attacks in the middle of the night.

OP posts:
JaninaDuszejko · 08/03/2024 07:42

There was a thread the other week about preparing to turn 40 and reading up on HRT, which was a depressing example of the current obsession with this topic.

Yeah, I saw that one. When I was 40 I had a 4 year old, a 2 year old and DS wasn't even conceived yet. There's a lot of people in their very early 40s talking about the menopause when most of them won't go through the menopause for another 10 years.

flippertyjibbets · 08/03/2024 07:41

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 06:46

@jeaux90 yea, I work at the institution Kathleen stock left. I don’t like her views in that article. I don’t think she is a feminist.

I hope you weren't one of the awful bullies who harangued her and treated her like
utter crap for having very commonplace,
mainstream views shared by most people?