Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely sick of the ‘natural menopause is good’ narrative!

159 replies

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 05:45

This article was all over the media yeaterday:
https://unherd.com/2024/03/has-hrt-propaganda-misled-women/

It makes me so angry! Why is it that suddenly seeking treatment for symptoms in menopause being framed like this? In no other area of health is it considered acceptable to not seek treatment if you have debilitating symptoms. It’s utter misogyny.

Its ok for men in mid life to get treatment for their erectile dysfunction but women, ‘battle on through with some yoga and vitamins and stop complaining’

It reminds me a bit of the slightly toxic NCT ‘natural births and breastfeeding’ are the best way making any women who had a medical birth and couldn’t breastfeed an utter failure.

How is this narrative acceptable for women’s Heath? Menopause is absolutely fucking awful for some women - if you sail through with no symptoms, all power to you, but HRT is a lifesaver for many women.

Has HRT propaganda misled women?

https://unherd.com/2024/03/has-hrt-propaganda-misled-women/

OP posts:
Pigeonqueen · 08/03/2024 08:24

I think it’s actually quite a balanced article and I’m relieved to see it’s written by women.

I am one of the women who really doesn’t get on with HRT. I’ve been a patient of Newson clinic, I’ve been under the NHS for it. I wanted to give it a go. I’m 43 and have multiple autoimmune issues including lupus and Addisons which meant I went into early menopause aged 37. I was prescribed Oestrogel, utrogestan and the mini pill. Gradually I just had issue after issue, huge clots, persistent bleeding, mood changes etc etc. Newson just kept increasing the oestrogel which made things worse and ignoring my concerns. NHS gynaecologist reduced my dose back down but this caused other issues. In the end after years of this I just got so fed up with it all I’ve just completely stopped it. There is definitely a narrative of pushing all women to take it and a really thing about the long term dangers of not taking it - but for many women like me with complex issues it just makes things worse in so many ways.

I also think the most high profile menopause specialists - ie Louise Newson, Newson clinic etc etc are businesses at their core. If they were genuinely seeking to change women’s health they wouldn’t link to so many articles behind pay walls / subscriptions etc which if you follow them on instagram you’ll see this all the time. I wanted to read the article you’ve linked to and interestingly you don’t have to subscribe to anything to do this in comparison. And yes before someone leaps on me I do realise there are free factsheets on the balance website. But not all the information is free or easy to access.

I spent £600 with the menopause clinic. I would have kept spending £200 ish every few months if I hadn’t just stepped back and said it really wasn’t working for me.

Merrymouse · 08/03/2024 08:23

I think the lack of information and research is a big problem.

From the media, you would think that every woman hitting 39 is demanding HRT for peri menopause, regardless of symptoms.

That clearly isn’t true, but if you try to seek out information from your GP it’s a lottery, and reputable sources like NHS Direct are too vague to be helpful.

There seems to be a difference between advice you would get on the NHS and privately, but which is correct?

Davina MCall gets flack for being a celebrity menopause campaigner, but where do you go for the non celebrity advice?

swayingpalmtree · 08/03/2024 08:21

Honestly, I am sick to death of this narrative that everyone on HRT is just after an easy life

yeah, I don't really get that either. I don't know of a single person who wasn't desperate for some relief when they finally got HRT. Of course, changing your lifestyle can be helpful for some and it's never a bad idea to look at your daily routines and how you can incorporate self care practices to help. But ultimately, if someone is in pain, suffering with anxiety and sleep deprivation and horrible periods, why the heck shouldn't they want some relief?

Since when have women ever had an "easy life"?- the idea of that is just laughable from a health perspective when you think of all the things women go through regarding childbirth, BCP, periods, menopause, smear tests, mammograms etc and thats not even starting on health inequalities!

I'm sorry you had such an awful time btw x

flippertyjibbets · 08/03/2024 08:21

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 08:10

@EarringsandLipstick i am not implying that at all. What I am saying is that there was more to it - she wasn’t always a particularly kind person in her dealings with others either.

what now? Women who are being threatened, intimidated and bullied on a daily basis need to be kind? Woah.

Mercurial123 · 08/03/2024 08:16

A well written and balanced article. It's definitely not misogynistic. As someone who was diagnosed with breast cancer in my 30s and with two gene mutations, HRT was never going to be an option.

I've managed Menopause with diet, yoga, exercise and meditation.

If HRT works for you, great, but it's not the only option.

AlisonDonut · 08/03/2024 08:16

swayingpalmtree · 08/03/2024 08:00

However, I see women thinking taking HRT obviates the need to exercise, manage their diet or address other endocrine issues that are more prevalent in middle-age

Not the case for me- I run pretty much every day, eat lots of oily fish, am gluten free, perfect BMI etc still had horrific peri symptoms

I got the menopause at 42.

I was slowly getting osteoporosis because my female GP didn't feel I was old enough to be tested for the menopause, what with being 42.

I dropped incrementally every day, until I could no longer walk up the stairs at the end of the day. I was in agony the whole day, trying to do my job taking more and more painkillers to get through it.

I was Head Gardener at a city farm at the time. I walked thousands upon thousands of steps. I only got HRT at 49 after a year's worth of fitbit proof that I was doing exercise and getting no sleep.

The male doctor who prescribed HRT to me, got me the FSH tests which were 95, when the agreed level of 'hitting menopause' is 30. I think it was 25 at the time.

And he sent me for an urgent DEXA scan, which showed osteoporosis. After 3 years on HRT I had dropped back into healthy bone levels. I'm going to fight having access to it to my dying breath.

Honestly, I am sick to death of this narrative that everyone on HRT is just after an easy life.

Deliadidit · 08/03/2024 08:13

flippertyjibbets · 08/03/2024 07:49

you derailed your own thread.

Absolutely!

Samlewis96 · 08/03/2024 08:10

TheHardyStork · 08/03/2024 07:11

I think that the idea not everyone needs or wants HRT seems to have been lost recently.
There has been a massive push on it (HRT as a cure all) my friends and I are in our mid to late 40s and it seems like every illness we get is put down to menopause and the vast majority want HRT and are put on it.

I'm actually coping perfectly well with crazy periods, down to about 2 a year now so hopefully nearly there, a few aches and pains, a bit forgetful and hot flushes. The doctor has told me if I don't want HRT, which he is happy to prescribe then to make sure I lift weights to maintain bone strength.

I'm sure menopause is debilitating for some women, but it's OK for me. My mum had an easy time with it too so maybe it's genetic.

I think it's important that women know there is a choice but one view shouldn't be pushed over another.

Edited

And there are quite a few of us who can't take HRT. I had a radical hysterectomy for cervical cancer. This removes ovaries as well. There was never any talk of giving me HRT. Fortunately! (in a way) I didn't get too many issues with menopause and was mainly through it by time I was diagnosed but many other women aren't and seems only the much younger ones ( under 40) are given HRT. Believe it's considered high risk for something

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 08:10

@EarringsandLipstick i am not implying that at all. What I am saying is that there was more to it - she wasn’t always a particularly kind person in her dealings with others either.

OP posts:
Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/03/2024 08:09

The point is @sorrynotathome is that is a very low % of women who take HRT. Now whether that’s through choice or because they can’t access it or they’re not having debilitating symptoms, its still a low a % and yet even with these low numbers, we apparently still need to be told that it’s not the answer as if a massively high % took it and we needed to reduce its usage

swayingpalmtree · 08/03/2024 08:09

Yes exactly - and yet still there are numerous articles telling us HRT isn’t a panacea as if 90% of women were on it

Exactly. I even agree that it's not a panacea, as there could be multiple reasons for someone experiencing anxiety for example. But, when you get sudden anxiety for no reason, sleeping difficulties, feeling exhausted, combined with sudden heavy flooding periods every month, it's utter madness to suggest a fcking anti depressant for that.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2024 08:09

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 08:02

@flippertyjibbets ex chancellor. Still doesn’t mean it’s everyone either.

It doesn't have to be every single person

It's the institutional whole

You've implied that Kathleen Stock was not unfairly treated, and there's another side - but given no facts or not backed up your point. That's disgraceful.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 08/03/2024 08:09

ineedsun · 08/03/2024 06:23

I don’t think I’ve ever heard a ‘natural menopause is good’ message. For the last five years or so I’ve just had (in varying levels of intensity) non-medical people trying to shove HRT down my throat.

Medical staff seem to be more balanced but friends and family of a similar age, as soon as I mention a symptom will start sending infographics, links to articles or literally telling me to go and get HRT. Even those who are struggling like fuck on it. And if I point out that the symptom is related to something else, some of them get a little bit stroppy, almost taking it personally that I’m not struggling with menopause at the moment. It feels like a cult.

That article seemed pretty balanced to me, saying it’s there and it’s great for some people but there are other options. Surely that’s a good thing? They certainly don’t seem to be pushing a natural menopause is best narrative.

This.

I have been having mild hot flushes and exploring natural remedies (dietary changes, sage pills) and have been taken aback by the passion with which other women and medical practitioners have been pushing hrt at me. I know it’s been a lifesaver for many women with severe symptoms and am delighted they have been helped, but people seem to forget or deny there are other options.

flippertyjibbets · 08/03/2024 08:07

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 08:02

@flippertyjibbets ex chancellor. Still doesn’t mean it’s everyone either.

oh, they had the good sense to
leave? Well done them!

sorrynotathome · 08/03/2024 08:07

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/03/2024 07:56

14% of women take HRT. The idea that women are flocking yo their GP to get HRT & it’s handed over without a query is just nonsense

its interesting that with 86% of women not taking HRT, there still apparently needs to be a narrative telling us it isn’t a panacea (obvs with us being daft wims who only listen to celebrities we need to be told this)

Your figures don’t mean much if you don’t put them in the context of women who might be going through menopause, or women who might be experiencing symptoms. Presumably you wouldn’t expect 100% of women to be taking HRT?

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/03/2024 08:06

ineedsun · 08/03/2024 08:02

14% of all women or 14% of those who are experiencing menopause? Because the statistical significance of that is very different depending on the answer

14% of women in menopause

Merrymouse · 08/03/2024 08:06

ineedsun · 08/03/2024 08:02

14% of all women or 14% of those who are experiencing menopause? Because the statistical significance of that is very different depending on the answer

It’s 14% of women aged 45-64

EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2024 08:06

@flippertyjibbets

I keep cross posting with you - but yes! Re the Chancellor's statement - how much more clear does @Lightsideofthemoon want it to be? 🤨

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/03/2024 08:06

swayingpalmtree · 08/03/2024 08:04

14% of women take HRT. The idea that women are flocking yo their GP to get HRT & it’s handed over without a query is just nonsense

That could be because GPs won't give it to you. Mine wouldnt- he kept going on about anti depressants. My friend had exactly the same experience- asked multiple times for HRT, 6 months later is still waiting for a referral to the "menopause clinic". Its not that easy for us to get access to it- obv depends on your GP but not everyone can afford to go private

Yes exactly - and yet still there are numerous articles telling us HRT isn’t a panacea as if 90% of women were on it

swayingpalmtree · 08/03/2024 08:04

14% of women take HRT. The idea that women are flocking yo their GP to get HRT & it’s handed over without a query is just nonsense

That could be because GPs won't give it to you. Mine wouldnt- he kept going on about anti depressants. My friend had exactly the same experience- asked multiple times for HRT, 6 months later is still waiting for a referral to the "menopause clinic". Its not that easy for us to get access to it- obv depends on your GP but not everyone can afford to go private

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 08:04

@sorrynotathome I agree that more research is needed. The failed HRT study from years ago is still being quoted in a lot of places

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 08/03/2024 08:03

Lightsideofthemoon · 08/03/2024 07:56

@EarringsandLipstick I’m tired of how staff were portrayed as a bunch of bullies as a collective whole. It’s not true.

I'm sure it's not. Uni of Sussex has, what, 3,000 + staff? I do not believe each one bullied KS.

But you are being disingenuous.

As an institution, it failed to accord KS protection and her employment rights, or her academic freedom of expression, and it actively enabled harassment and intimidation of her.

I'm well-aware that most people are not perfect and no-one will do everything right.

But it's shameful you can start a thread advocating for women, and not stand up for a woman who by any standards, including admissions by the University itself, was shockingly treated, culminating in her having to leave her job.

Whycantiwinmillionsandsquillions · 08/03/2024 08:03

Agree with you op.
I was refused HRT.
I carried on until I felt suicidal and at my wits end.
Saw a different gp who prescribed it immediately.
Its only females who are treated in this way.
Men would not be told to “Practise breathing techniques and take multi vitamins.”

ineedsun · 08/03/2024 08:02

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/03/2024 07:56

14% of women take HRT. The idea that women are flocking yo their GP to get HRT & it’s handed over without a query is just nonsense

its interesting that with 86% of women not taking HRT, there still apparently needs to be a narrative telling us it isn’t a panacea (obvs with us being daft wims who only listen to celebrities we need to be told this)

14% of all women or 14% of those who are experiencing menopause? Because the statistical significance of that is very different depending on the answer

sorrynotathome · 08/03/2024 08:02

A problem I see with the current HRT obsession is that it is being promoted as prevention for a range of things from osteoporosis to heart disease to dementia. Women may therefore think they should take it, even if they have no/mild symptoms. Extensive clinical research shows the only thing it can help prevent is osteoporosis, in women at high risk (those with known risks and those who don’t exercise).