Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it’s ok for my DD to walk school?

315 replies

alwaysgonnaloveyou · 07/03/2024 20:13

I have been offered a job but my 9 year old DD (soon to be 10) would need to walk to school alone. It is a mile away. I would need to leave the house at 7.30 to get to work but the out of hours club provided by school doesn’t open until 8. I am a single parent and do not know anyone who would be able to pick her up from our house and drop her off at school. I have a 14 year old DD also who is super sensible but goes to a different school so she would be looking after him until he has to walk to school. Her school is in the opposite direction so she can’t walk her halfway or anything.

OP posts:
Wilkolampshade · 08/03/2024 14:07

Yes, I think this is fine personally, although obviously it depends on the child/the environment etc. Mine played out and walked to/from friends houses after school younger than this and enjoyed the independence it gave them.

LittleOwl153 · 08/03/2024 14:02

I read this thinking 9yr old year 4... then I read 10 in May... so Yr 5...

My 10yr old Yr 5 will be walking the 0.8 mile to school after Easter by himself. Likely picking up his mates on route. They have it all planned. We have been trailing them for weeks initially pointing out daft things. But they are getting less and less. I have no reason for him to do this as I am at home and currently walk him. But he wants to. And I think he's capable.

I'd be more concerned about leaving the 2 of them (I also have a 14yr old) are you sure he will listen to her - not wind up the situation? As we are talking a few days in reality as your parents will do 4/5 I'd let him do it. 🤷‍♀️

lizzowhiz · 08/03/2024 13:27

@millymoo1202 yes of course walking is an option too, as many have pointed out. But if for whatever reason the OP decides against it, a taxi is a simple solution.

I can't believe the OP has actually made it into a difficult situation! She has the opportunity to go from earning 25k to 40k overnight and she just needs to sort the journey to school once a week! Walk or taxi. Sorted.

Hankunamatata · 08/03/2024 13:25

I think it's fine. My 10 year old has been walking for the last year.
Dc can leave the same time as you as probably take them 20 plus mins to walk.
Practise the walk a few times if you can. Make sure they aren't walking on their phones or with both earbuds in.

millymoo1202 · 08/03/2024 13:20

What has happened in the past 10 years since mine were that age that a 10 year old can’t walk to school? I’m in NE Scotland and it was the norm maybe not now but I despair, a taxi! Take the job

WitchesWithKnivesInTheirFeet · 08/03/2024 13:15

Honestly, if you are happy with the route and with DCs ability to manage it, then I would say it's fine. Does he have a phone in his bag so he can text you when he sets off and arrives? But you know your area and you know your DC. The responses you get on here will be based on other poster's own lives and area, not on yours. Where I live it's normal for kids to be walking alone in Y5 and Y6, and many start walking alone in Y4. So I would say that if your DC is leaving at the same time as everyone else to get there for normal start time, and there are likely to be other kids and parents around, then what you are proposing is absolutely fine. Other people who live in much busier areas - maybe where the traffic is more dangerous - might well have the opposite view. If you are happy with your DCs ability to manage this, and you can practice the walk for a while, then go for it (by practice, I mean you walk him most of the way, walking with him less and less each day over a few weeks, until he's walking it all on his own).

I've always believed that walking to and from school at normal times (so when there are other friends/parents around) is the best way to start learning independent travel. As a parent of a younger child, I kept an eye on solo older kids, and I'm sure others would too. Good luck!

YouG0GlenCoco · 08/03/2024 12:57

Could you not ask any of her friends parents if they could give her a lift, or if they also walk arrange a meeting point so she's not doing the full walk alone? As it's only one morning a week it's not too much of an ask, maybe you could offer help with an afternoon pick up or something else in exchange?

K0OLA1D · 08/03/2024 12:49

Josette77 · 08/03/2024 11:34

Op is a teacher!!! She can't change her hours.

Too much responsibility for a 14 yo??? Did no one on here have jobs at 14? People paid me to look after their young children.

I'm shocked anyone thinks 14 is too young to look after a 10 yo?!!!

Responsibilities are important to raising confident kids.

It's a nice thing to have your older dd do this. And the walk will be for the younger one as well. They will be proud of themselves.

By the time winter comes she'll be 10.5 It's ok for kids to walk in the cold and rain. It's ok for things to be uncomfortable sometimes.

This.

My 12 and 10 year olds get themselves ready and breakfasted alone for 3 days a week! My parents then come at just past 8 to lock up and take them to school, but by the time they are both in High school, so another 18 months, they'd be doing it as well as getting themselves to school

Ariona · 08/03/2024 12:45

I also think way too young. In fact our school would take a dim view of this.
Do both your parents need to look after your dh kids? Can one of them help for just that one day?
Can you get someone and pay them extra for just 2 hours?

lizzowhiz · 08/03/2024 12:44

So you're in the fortunate position of having grandparents to drive her 4 days a week; surely the obvious thing is to book a taxi for the one day they can't cover?!

Kalevala · 08/03/2024 12:42

Parentofeanda · 08/03/2024 09:02

Personally I wouldnt be letting my child walk until at least 13 or 14 as I just hate how much danger there is out there, so unless in a big group its teenage years for me

There's no childcare at secondary schools. Have you found a childminder who will drop off and pick up from secondary school? What about walking into town or the park or a friend's house, or catching public transport? Your child will be left behind socially.

goodkidsmaadhouse · 08/03/2024 12:27

SpongeBobSquarePantaloons · 08/03/2024 08:47

I don’t think it's so much that the attitude is different here but that kids in Scotland go to the school nearest their house, whereas in England they often don’t. So it's generally a shorter walk for our children, and everyone in the area will be walking there too.

I think there is a different attitude. It’s not just in walking to school but things like playing out, responsibility for teens. I’m really shocked by a lot of the threads on here that seem to think children and teens are utterly incapable of managing really quite simple and statistically not dangerous tasks.

Besides, a lot of kids in England do go to their nearest school - depends really on what’s available, whether you live in a village/town/city , etc. I mentioned my DD10 upthread - she actually doesn’t go to our catchment school so there’s no other kids walking the same way as her, but she’s more than fine walking the mile by herself.

SlipperyFish11 · 08/03/2024 12:04

I would ask to change your hours by half an hour, or reduce your lunch. Either that or decline the job.
I wouldn't be leaving a 9yo.

theclimbingsloth · 08/03/2024 12:00

I think for one day a week it would be fine as long as you are confident that they are sensible, likely to leave on time and not kill each other. It would be a shame to miss out on an opportunity to improve your family’s situation for the sake of half an hour.

I’d make sure they have a clear plan about what they need to do, times to leave, and what to do if there’s a problem. At least to begin with I would work out a way for them to let you know they got to school ok and maybe ask another school parent to keep an eye out for them at school.

It really depends on the child at this age. With my oldest - not a chance, he would realise he was late at about 2 o’clock and then wonder if he should still go to school or not!
With my youngest who is not yet 9, it wouldn’t be a problem as long as there were consequences for him messing around or being late. He would relish the independence and learning new skills and would likely keep his sibling on track.

However, I would be careful with who I told though. I’d check to see if there was a school policy about kids arriving/leaving on their own. And also be aware of anyone who might think it was unacceptable and stick their nose in. In some ways this is what would put me off doing it with my youngest in a year or two which is actually quite annoying!!

Would dropping off at grandparents make any difference with how far they’d have to walk from there?

MyNameIsFine · 08/03/2024 11:58

alwaysgonnaloveyou · 07/03/2024 20:16

No local childminders unfortunately.

Do you need a fully qualified childminder? This sounds like a job for a sixth former/student who would look after your children from 7.30 and walk youngest to school. Try advertising for a babysitter locally.

goodkidsmaadhouse · 08/03/2024 11:36

nevergetusedtoit · 08/03/2024 07:40

This.

It’s easy to see why there is such an obesity problem in the UK, after reading this thread.

Yep!

And it’s not just about children’s physical health.
We are doing their mental health no favours if we assume they cannot cope with these extremely ordinary scenarios (9yo walking 20 minutes; 14yo locking a front door).

Josette77 · 08/03/2024 11:34

Op is a teacher!!! She can't change her hours.

Too much responsibility for a 14 yo??? Did no one on here have jobs at 14? People paid me to look after their young children.

I'm shocked anyone thinks 14 is too young to look after a 10 yo?!!!

Responsibilities are important to raising confident kids.

It's a nice thing to have your older dd do this. And the walk will be for the younger one as well. They will be proud of themselves.

By the time winter comes she'll be 10.5 It's ok for kids to walk in the cold and rain. It's ok for things to be uncomfortable sometimes.

SD1978 · 08/03/2024 11:32

I'd probably organise a taxi, she has her older sister there, and then in a few months, or next year, walking herself. You're going to double your income, I'd say it's a reasonable expense to be able to manage that

Iloveshoes123 · 08/03/2024 11:23

I'm amazed by all the 9is far too young commentary. Our school (and any others I know of) allows children to walk home from year 5 i.e. when they are 9 and plenty of kids do it.

Iloveshoes123 · 08/03/2024 11:21

Op, I think people are really overreacting here. It's one day a week, you can talk to her on the phone during the journey and it is a 20 minute walk. She is in year 5, you are really not being unreasonable.

Bin85 · 08/03/2024 11:19

I walked that far at 4 going on 5 years old!
Of course this was years ago.
I was meant to be with the neighbour's children but they ran off most of the time.The roads were much quieter but it included a main road.
Can she have a phone so you can track her?

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/03/2024 11:10

It's a no from me. Too young I'm afraid and unfair on the 14 year old too.

Mel2023 · 08/03/2024 11:01

9 is far too young. How would you feel if something happened en route and you couldn’t get to her? In the winter it may well be dark as she’s walking as well. As you say there’s no childminders, could you arrange for a taxi with a local firm to pick your daughter up that one morning and drive her to school. Wouldn’t cost too much if it’s only a mile once a week. Your elder DD can make sure she gets in the taxi, and if you tell the school the arrangement they can make sure she arrives safely. Make sure she has your number and the number for the school so if for whatever reason the taxi was late/didn’t arrive she can call and explain and you can arrange another one, rather than her feel pressured to walk by herself to avoid being late.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 08/03/2024 10:52

Haven't RTFT but all the kids walk to school where I live from 9. I think it's too young for there not to be an adult in the house to see them off though.

littlefireseverywhere · 08/03/2024 10:49

Mine walked themselves to school at nine. we only live 10 minutes walk away from the school. However they wanted to and they were both able to do it I’d let them. Make sure she’s confident on the route and knows how to cross the roads and things